RiK pats Harlequin on the back :
Let's have a closer look shall we?RiK wrote:Well put Harly.Harlequin wrote:I agree that members often have a tendency to gang up on posters who rub enough of us up the wrong way. I do not think that (o)(o) is a nasty person and most of us are prone to cuntishness now and then. After a year and a half of posting here I suspect unsaid personal reasons for his current behaviour. That written, the line between playing and trolling is very thin, if not one being a superset of the other. If he is aware that he has difficulty empathizing (FTFY) with those whom are irritated or angered by his games/tongue-in-cheekness then perhaps he should take note of the negative feedback it has produced and moderate his posts in response.
1. Agreement noted between Harly and a moderator that posters here "gang up" on a person to give them a "kicking". That nothing was done about gratuitous insults when a complaint was raised (I let the first few ride, note), not only suggests this is "accepted practice", but furthermore that admin/mods are far removed from impartiality and will totally ignore the (unambiguous) Forum Guidelines on a whim.Harlequin wrote:I agree that members often have a tendency to gang up on posters who rub enough of us up the wrong way.
2. There may be a thin line between playing and trolling, but neither are against forum guidelines. [Not that I trolled, I did say early on I push a few buttons].Harlequin wrote:"..the line between playing and trolling is very thin, if not one being a superset of the other.
Here is the relevant section :
However people may judge my posts, you would be hard pushed to find an example of me using gratuitous abuse or personal insults, because I don't do that. *Mutual Respect
The Yakyak forum is an open community. Every user is entitled to their own personal opinions, however, mutual respect is expected and though we encourage frank and open discussion, abuse or personal insults directed towards another user will not be tolerated.
3. I have noted that a few individuals have been angered by some of my posts, but that does not make me responsible for their subsequent actions. It's not a case of me having to moderate my posts, Harlequin, because they are and have always been "moderate". What you are actually saying here is that if a few people decide to gang up on a person (in this case.. (o)(o)) then that person should accept their kicking and act submissively. In other words, "mob rule" is the order of the day, and conformity is not only expected, it may be enforced.Harlequin wrote:If he is aware that he has difficulty empathizing (FTFY) with those whom are irritated or angered by his games/tongue-in-cheekness then perhaps he should take note of the negative feedback it has produced and moderate his posts in response.
"sack" on the other hand was not moderate in his behaviour, he was abusive. The third time this happened, I drew his attention to the fact he was being abusive. He repeated the abuse. Now some posters may have acclimatized themselves to being called cunts, but I'm new here, I don't know "sack".. I might take that from a 'mate'.. but he's not a 'mate'.. and I find that sort of abuse from a stranger totally unacceptable. That is why I put in a complaint.
The problem for YakYak is that, as a man of integrity, I will not tolerate bullying, and I have a legitimate complaint.
As I said before :
YakYak disclaimer : "Llamasoft/the forum admin team... reserve the right to delete or edit posts which are deemed innapropriate or to prevent posting to the forum in the event of failure to comply with the forum code of conduct.""This place claims to have guidelines and policies. It has a moderation system in place. The purpose of moderation is to moderate behaviour which breaches those guidelines and policies severely."
Forum guidelines : "..abuse or personal insults directed towards another user will not be tolerated.... Swearing is allowed, but not at other members."
I have asked RiK or Jedburgh to 1) delete the offending posts or 2) produce an apology from "sack", in accordance with their own code of conduct. A third option might be to alter the Forum Guidelines to reflect actual practice, ie. ".. personal insults directed towards another user will be tolerated" and "Swearing is allowed, including toward other members." So far, both parties have refused to even communicate.
Here's the deal, guys. Either the moderators/admin take action in accordance with their own code of conduct, or I want my account inactivated. Consider carefully, because the decision has wider implications than just getting rid of this "booby" nuisance. To be perfectly clear, I'm not trolling, nor am I holding anyone to ransom. I'm not even upset. I simply refuse to be bullied in a moderated forum, and expect the mods to intervene when that happens.
So, do your job please, Llamasoft and/or delegates: either deal with my complaint appropriately, or inactivate this account (leaving this post in place of course - there are no grounds to delete it).
PS No formal complaint has been made about me, and naturally, moderators should ignore "retaliatory" complaints. Sorry to have to preempt that, but as an experienced moderator myself...
* Harlequin seems to have taken offense that I suggested he was conniving. Whilst no harm was intended ("tacit winking".. come on!), H says that these comments caused him to become "emotionally involved". For that reason, as a gesture of goodwill, I hereby retract those comments, and issue an apology to Harlequin.






