pogo wrote:Complete nonsense of course: we know now how intrinsically chaotic many things are, from the weather and so natural disasters to who is born when. And it's the people that live or die who make history. It's Christianity, or Buddhism, because of Jesus Christ or the Buddha. And the major religions lie behind many of the civilisations in our history. Or much the modern history of the Middle East follows from the establishment of Israel, which itself happened because of the Holocaust, inspired and masterminded by one man. What if Christ, or Buddha, or Hitler had not been born? Would not history be completely different for all time?
For that matter, would Hitler have been born if a couple of amino acids hooked up seconds earlier or later 3.5 billion years ago? Destiny is a perception people naturally develop when looking back on the past and everything seems to click together, because things always seem to click together. Which could include the meddling of a time-traveller as they are part of those events clicking together to an observer. The mechanics of the universe could imply pre-destination and that free will is just an illusion or destiny unfolding at that moment. After all, who's going to give Hitler's parents contraception at the right time when Hitler was never born?
Chaotic systems lead to behaviour emerging. Instead of asserting destiny is nonsense you could just as easily assert true chaos is nonsense.
This is heading towards Terminator 2 territory where John Conner stops the development of Skynet so Judgment day never happens and Terminators are never made, meaning one isn't sent back in time to kill Sarah and John's dad isn't sent back to sire John...
They needed a protagonist protecting paradox plot-device in that franchise.
Philip K. Dick's Minority Report tackles the topic really well, where the protagonist using conscious free-will fulfils the precognition and proves all reports (including the minority report) to be accurate. Destiny can encompass choices you will make using free-will - such as Captain Adelaide Brooke choosing to shoot herself in Waters Of Mars.