Trump

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
gumboot
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7652
Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2007 3:42 am 0
Location: trumpstain!

Re: Trump

Post by gumboot »

Absolute_Zero wrote:With text that can be read in a variety of ways... the interpretation taken tells me things about my interlocutors they might not otherwise reveal.
You think that method has real credibility? Would it stand up to any scientific scrutiny?

Sounds like reading tealeaves to me, or forensics-drama science, or something like that.


(christ, we're going to look so primitive and superstitious a hundred years from now when people look at the archives of the television we watched and the adverts that were directed at us)
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Trump

Post by Cloudane »

venusian wrote:Putting aside the tits...

You're saying we should all become a little bit more fascist in order to gain traction with people who are already a bit more fascist. This, purely as a pragmatic reaction: we should all become quasi-fascists - a nation of calmly spoken appeasers.

That's certainly what it sounds like you're saying although reading actual things through your pseudo-encrypted prose is difficult. Liberals need to dump Corbyn, Farron, et al and embrace leaders who will reflect Farage's rhetoric on nationalism in the hope that UKIP voters will listen. Is that it?
Can't speak for him but I think (may be wrong) what he's trying to get at is the same as what I was trying (and failing) to get across. That in the real world, we have to compromise with people we disagree with. Even those who we see as fascists - I'd say beware of exaggeration. I'm no fan of Farage for example and he does display some worrying racial attitudes but he's that bloke down the pub who you'd make a wanker sign about when he leaves, not literally Hitler.

Not become more fascist, no. But maybe understanding how people become that way - which may include letting them speak - would help with eventually overcoming the problem?

What we have right now is what we have had IRL throughout history - no-compromise "I'm right and the enemy is wrong, is a lost cause and must be eliminated" kind of attitudes that have typically led to wars. They're just playing out a little differently. "We" may 'know' we're 'right' and opposing views may seem absolutely abhorrent and the people on that side may seem not to be worth pissing on if they were on fire, but until we can learn to at least tolerate each other and try to understand what in the world the other guy is thinking, we're never going to be any step further towards a peaceful world.
Though I suspect not everyone even wants a peaceful world, they just want to be right.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Trump

Post by Absolute_Zero »

gumboot wrote:
Absolute_Zero wrote:With text that can be read in a variety of ways... the interpretation taken tells me things about my interlocutors they might not otherwise reveal.
You think that method has real credibility? Would it stand up to any scientific scrutiny?
Though open to interpretation, less subjective than a Rorcharch test.

The sample feedback I gave Venusian [based on his reading of my part-inkblot text] fits. No surprise there as I was well aware of his political proclivities.
Sounds like reading tealeaves to me
'tis what it is... a canvas to cast upon.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Trump

Post by Absolute_Zero »

Cloudane wrote:
venusian wrote:Putting aside the tits...

You're saying we should all become a little bit more fascist in order to gain traction with people who are already a bit more fascist. This, purely as a pragmatic reaction: we should all become quasi-fascists - a nation of calmly spoken appeasers.

That's certainly what it sounds like you're saying although reading actual things through your pseudo-encrypted prose is difficult. Liberals need to dump Corbyn, Farron, et al and embrace leaders who will reflect Farage's rhetoric on nationalism in the hope that UKIP voters will listen. Is that it?
Can't speak for him but I think (may be wrong) what he's trying to get at is the same as what I was trying (and failing) to get across. That in the real world, we have to compromise with people we disagree with. Even those who we see as fascists - I'd say beware of exaggeration. I'm no fan of Farage for example and he does display some worrying racial attitudes but he's that bloke down the pub who you'd make a wanker sign about when he leaves, not literally Hitler.

Not become more fascist, no. But maybe underst, thouanding how people become that way - which may include letting them speak - would help with eventually overcoming the problem?

What we have right now is what we have had IRL throughout history - no-compromise "I'm right and the enemy is wrong, is a lost cause and must be eliminated" kind of attitudes that have typically led to wars. They're just playing out a little differently. "We" may 'know' we're 'right' and opposing views may seem absolutely abhorrent and the people on that side may seem not to be worth pissing on if they were on fire, but until we can learn to at least tolerate each other and try to understand what in the world the other guy is thinking, we're never going to be any step further towards a peaceful world.
Though I suspect not everyone even wants a peaceful world, they just want to be right.
More or less, though you're being too kind to the sinners posing with their strap-on wings, imo.

Take a hint from solid double-blind testing of groups of men graded by questionnaire for homophobic response. Attach strain-gauge to manhood, flash randomised pictures that includes some 'gay' images. Correlate strain-gauge response to imagery against questionnaire. Result: strong association between loudest-and-proudest homophobic attitudes and involuntary homosexual tumescence.

Another amusing sex-based example would be the number of TV-evangelists caught in flagrante delicto. I maintain this is a more general result than many will like.

People are often the very opposite of what they proclaim; even, or especially, to themselves. Look, look at him over there... meanwhile they're not looking at me.

It doesn't require a careful parsing of the political thread to discern a sizeable population with bile for brain juice. Wish fulfilment violence oozes between the words. Presumably those willing to admit to such emotions will argue it's a justified response to "them over there". Poison, allegedly defeats poison. No, it's a self-sustaining amplifier.

Yay, we get to hate and feel righteous about it... kill 'em all.
User avatar
gumboot
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7652
Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2007 3:42 am 0
Location: trumpstain!

Re: Trump

Post by gumboot »

I usually struggle to comprehend people's strong desire to make others think right.

The necessity became more apparent when the UK voted to leave the EU and Trump won the presidential election; but it still seems to me an utterly futile exercise.

Is it genuinely something people are really still bashing their heads against? Or is it just something they're having a laugh about because that's all there is to be done?
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: Trump

Post by Cloudane »

Absolute_Zero wrote:More or less, though you're being too kind to the sinners
Might I propose, with all due respect, that by failing to be kind we'd be doing exactly the same thing that we're seemingly bemoaning just with the "target" being the self righteous?
It all seems to be variations on the same theme!

Not sure what you mean on the homophobia test. As I understand it, implicit association tests are designed to make you aware of biases, not to demonise them. Knowledge is power, and knowing that you have biases helps with understanding them and looking at things from different angles - and presumably, with an open enough mind (I'd like them all to be), acceptance.

I've not to my knowledge been racist or homophobic (I'm bi, but I know that doesn't prevent one being homophobic) but have certainly been part of the "mob" - a social justice warrior I suppose you could say, and hopefully know something of the trap, and becoming the thing you don't actually like.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Trump

Post by Absolute_Zero »

Cloudane wrote:
Absolute_Zero wrote:Morree or less, though you're being too kind to the sinners
Might I propose, with all due respect, that by failing to be kind we'd be doing exactly the same thing that we're seemingly bemoaning just with the "target" being the self righteous?
It all seems to be variations on the same theme!
I'm teasing, not being unkind per se... a little provocation can be alluring. Too much and the reactionary shutters come down. It's a trade-off judgement.
Not sure what you mean on the homophobia test. As I understand it, implicit association tests are designed to make you aware of biases, not to demonise them. Knowledge is power, and knowing that you have biases helps with understanding them and looking at things from different angles - and presumably, with an open enough mind (I'd like them all to be), acceptance.
Hypothesis: for various reasons, people can be internally different to their external projection... up to 180. This class of postulate rarely elevates above "soft" science status, but because that being tested here involves involuntary response, measured by hardware, it becomes "hard" science. Puntastic.

When the results were first published, they came under sustained attack for obvious reasons. Nevertheless, despite the many motivated take-down attempts, the conclusions stand as solid. People can be their own anti-particle... proven.

And my subsidiary observation, drawn from the experiment and experience, is the louder and more seemingly earnest the declaration of whatever [in this case heterosexuality].............. as Shakespeare put it: the lady doth protest too much.

My bottom line here is that the conflict we're discussing excites deep and dark passions and that it would be wise not to trust people too much regards what they say as being internally consistent with what they are.

There are blatantly obvious parallels with religious-like conceptions of good vs evil... which I tend to deploy at the drop of hat to draw attention to the connection. So, we generally don't respect religion any more yet many of its characteristics continue on other stages. Politics, for some, has replaced religion.
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6651
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: Trump

Post by venusian »

Absolute_Zero wrote:
venusian wrote:Liberals need to dump Corbyn, Farron, et al and embrace leaders who will reflect Farage's rhetoric on nationalism in the hope that UKIP voters will listen. Is that it?
With text that can be read in a variety of ways... the interpretation taken tells me things about my interlocutors they might not otherwise reveal.
Absolute_Zero wrote:The sample feedback I gave Venusian [based on his reading of my part-inkblot text] fits. No surprise there as I was well aware of his political proclivities.
So, moving on to this thing I wouldn't reveal but of which you're well aware...
Absolute_Zero wrote:So, political pond dweller,
Yes, let's start with hypocrisy.
Absolute_Zero wrote:fascism is the problem...
A problem, yes. Along with nationalism they are particularly pernicious forms of tribalism.

There has been a rise in the prevalence of fascistic and nationalistic ideas espoused by political figures in recent years, particularly the last six months. They are all harmful to the sum of human happiness. The rise is harmful to actual people on a daily basis. It's a problem. Not "the".

But let's be clear, as much as you'd like there to be a team of mad dictator worshiping loons on one side being driven on by mad dictator worshiping loons on the other, with you sitting Buddha-like in the middle, this simply isn't the case.

Fascism doesn't define a group of people. There are fascist ideas which are sometimes manifest as actions. There isn't even a group of ideas which define fascism. But sometimes there are groups of people who identify strongly enough with some subset of broadly fascist ideas that they're prepared to self-identify as fascists. That's not where we are today in this country.

Opposing fascist ideas does not mean opposing people. It means saying that some ideas are bad ideas. It only becomes about "us" and "them" when people like you start putting yourself in the "centre" and gesticulating about the people "over there".

Leave voters are not fascists. Leave voters are not racists. Racists didn't vote leave. Fascists didn't vote leave. Internationalists didn't vote remain. SJWs didn't vote Remain. None of these exist as groups.
Absolute_Zero wrote:BTW, I usually vote LibDem - not so much for policy positions, rather as equidistant triangulation between the symbiotic lunatics on each wing.
That tells us everything we need to know about the sophistication of your political stance.
Absolute_Zero wrote:Perhaps it would be illustrative of how you and yours fuel team fascist [and vice versa],
There you go again with your implicit tribalism...
Absolute_Zero wrote:if I mention a real-world locale. Rochdale and notably similar are a part result of an aggressively anti-racist mindset...
...and your conflation of fascism and racism.
Absolute_Zero wrote:So no, "that" isn't it. As per the doctor in my previous post: don't do that. Don't do that which in opposing the enemy, witlessly strengthens the enemy... even if in turn that strengthens you.
And again. That there's an "enemy" at all.
Cloudane wrote:Can't speak for him but I think (may be wrong) what he's trying to get at is the same as what I was trying (and failing) to get across. That in the real world, we have to compromise with people we disagree with.
Yes and no. Actions require compromise because otherwise nothing could be done. It's not necessary to agree that it's sometimes okay to be needlessly racist.
Cloudane wrote:Even those who we see as fascists - I'd say beware of exaggeration. I'm no fan of Farage for example and he does display some worrying racial attitudes but he's that bloke down the pub who you'd make a wanker sign about when he leaves, not literally Hitler.
Who said he was? I described him as nationalistic.
Cloudane wrote:Not become more fascist, no. But maybe underst, thouanding how people become that way - which may include letting them speak - would help with eventually overcoming the problem?
Obviously. Who said not to do this?
Absolute_Zero wrote:It doesn't require a careful parsing of the political thread to discern a sizeable population with bile for brain juice. Wish fulfilment violence oozes between the words. Presumably those willing to admit to such emotions will argue it's a justified response to "them over there".
And now we're back to ink-blot tests.
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6651
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: Trump

Post by venusian »

Absolute_Zero wrote:Hypothesis: for various reasons, people can be internally different to their external projection... up to 180. This class of postulate rarely elevates above "soft" science status, but because that being tested here involves involuntary response, measured by hardware, it becomes "hard" science.

When the results were first published, they came under sustained attack for obvious reasons. Nevertheless, despite the many motivated take-down attempts, the conclusions stand as solid. People can be their own anti-particle... proven.
Equating innate high-speed associations with the whole person is stretching "science" to the point where it's invisible.

Like most white people I seem to have an innate response to favour other white people. I also know I'm going to die but it doesn't stop me trying not to. I am (and by association others (because I'm not in the habit of dividing the the world into two groups: me and the idiots)) not defined by my involuntary response biases.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Trump

Post by Absolute_Zero »

venusian wrote:
Absolute_Zero wrote:
venusian wrote:Liberals need to dump Corbyn, Farron, et al and embrace leaders who will reflect Farage's rhetoric on nationalism in the hope that UKIP voters will listen. Is that it?
With text that can be read in a variety of ways... the interpretation taken tells me things about my interlocutors they might not otherwise reveal.
Absolute_Zero wrote:The sample feedback I gave Venusian [based on his reading of my part-inkblot text] fits. No surprise there as I was well aware of his political proclivities.
So, moving on to this thing I wouldn't reveal but of which you're well aware...
It wasn't aimed at you... by "fits" I mean the locus of your concern is political. It's just a "sample" of how "interpretation taken" might be applied. I can't know in advance who will respond.
Absolute_Zero wrote:So, political pond dweller,
Yes, let's start with hypocrisy.
See above.
Absolute_Zero wrote:fascism is the problem...
A problem, yes. Along with nationalism they are particularly pernicious forms of tribalism.

There has been a rise in the prevalence of fascistic and nationalistic ideas espoused by political figures in recent years, particularly the last six months. They are all harmful to the sum of human happiness. The rise is harmful to actual people on a daily basis. It's a problem. Not "the".

But let's be clear, as much as you'd like there to be a team of mad dictator worshiping loons on one side being driven on by mad dictator worshiping loons on the other, with you sitting Buddha-like in the middle, this simply isn't the case.

Fascism doesn't define a group of people. There are fascist ideas which are sometimes manifest as actions. There isn't even a group of ideas which define fascism. But sometimes there are groups of people who identify strongly enough with some subset of broadly fascist ideas that they're prepared to self-identify as fascists. That's not where we are today in this country.

Opposing fascist ideas does not mean opposing people. It means saying that some ideas are bad ideas. It only becomes about "us" and "them" when people like you start putting yourself in the "centre" and gesticulating about the people "over there".

Leave voters are not fascists. Leave voters are not racists. Racists didn't vote leave. Fascists didn't vote leave. Internationalists didn't vote remain. SJWs didn't vote Remain. None of these exist as groups.
Sorry to be unresponsive to the text but you're playing with a ball that wasn't in play. The interpretation you've taken is literal and ad-hom... which is informative.
Absolute_Zero wrote:BTW, I usually vote LibDem - not so much for policy positions, rather as equidistant triangulation between the symbiotic lunatics on each wing.
That tells us everything we need to know about the sophistication of your political stance.
Who is this "us" that you speak for? :)

I made mention merely because you invoked Farron as someone Liberals need to dump... as a posited interpretation of my earlier pseudo-encrypted prose.

Yet again, what you take, given a multiplicity of possibilities nascent in my word salad, is interesting. That I vote LibDem isn't news.
Absolute_Zero wrote:Perhaps it would be illustrative of how you and yours fuel team fascist [and vice versa],
There you go again with your implicit tribalism...
Well duh, that is the central focus of my argument. Quod Erat Demonstrandum... for those with the ears to hear it*. A better strategy for those that don't.

[*] How did you manage to miss that I'm opposing tribalism? It's not is if I haven't railed against such in other, earlier threads.
Absolute_Zero wrote:if I mention a real-world locale. Rochdale and notably similar are a part result of an aggressively anti-racist mindset...
...and your conflation of fascism and racism.
All isms deserve some conflation into the bucket of implicit tribalism.
Absolute_Zero wrote:So no, "that" isn't it. As per the doctor in my previous post: don't do that. Don't do that which in opposing the enemy, witlessly strengthens the enemy... even if in turn that strengthens you.
And again. That there's an "enemy" at all.
Using the animus of tribalism to mock it. Whoosh.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Trump

Post by Absolute_Zero »

venusian wrote:
Absolute_Zero wrote:Hypothesis: for various reasons, people can be internally different to their external projection... up to 180. This class of postulate rarely elevates above "soft" science status, but because that being tested here involves involuntary response, measured by hardware, it becomes "hard" science.

When the results were first published, they came under sustained attack for obvious reasons. Nevertheless, despite the many motivated take-down attempts, the conclusions stand as solid. People can be their own anti-particle... proven.
Equating innate high-speed associations with the whole person is stretching "science" to the point where it's invisible.

Like most white people I seem to have an innate response to favour other white people. I also know I'm going to die but it doesn't stop me trying not to. I am (and by association others (because I'm not in the habit of dividing the the world into two groups: me and the idiots)) not defined by my involuntary response biases.
The default assumption seems to be [approximately] that we tend to form our opinions/responses based on the perceived "facts" as we experience them in the more "formative" years. More likely [imo] we find the "facts" that support up-welling subconscious [for the want of a better word] instincts, modulated by experience. IOW, mostly post hoc rationalisation.

In support of which I'd cite birth-separated identical twin research. Sparse but striking.
User avatar
Barney
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2131
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 7:59 pm 0
Location: UK, Broughton, Brigg

Re: Trump

Post by Barney »

Surely the answer is to not be a dick? Forcing one's beliefs and prejudices on another is surely the worst form of dickish-ness there is, so don't do that, as your doctor said.

Hang about online (or IRL) with like-minded non-dicks (in your opinion) but maintain a healthy awareness of what the dicks are up to. Don't ask your non-dick friends what the dicks are doing though - find somewhere the dicks are on display and go watch what they do for yourself.

There hasn't been enough time yet for our tribalism to fade, and until it does there's not a lot you can do, personally. Attacking others because they're wrong is not on - and I'm as guilty of that as anyone, at times - so surely the best we can hope for is for as many people as possible to just try to be nice.

As for racism, sexism, homophobia etc - that's pretty much hardwired at present. Most mammals, when presented with a child that smells wrong, looks wrong due to defects or whatever will kill the offspring. At a level we cannot articulate, we are afraid of things that don't fit - if someone is a different race, has a disability, whatever, our instinct is to dislike it. It's a survival mechanism. We are different from other mammals in that we have the tools available to suppress those feelings and behave nicely towards eachother but make no mistake, it's a conscious effort - at least for now. Evolution being what it is, it's going to be a long, long time before those reactions are bred out of us.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
User avatar
gumboot
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7652
Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2007 3:42 am 0
Location: trumpstain!

Re: Trump

Post by gumboot »

http://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/01/07/us ... oters.html

What's the big deal? Well, it wasn't a big deal last year. It seems to me it only became a big deal after Trump denied it over and over and over and over.

The impossibility of getting anything to sink in to Trump's thick head is making news here really monotonous.
User avatar
phattslagg
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3578
Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
Location: Worcester, England

Re: Trump

Post by phattslagg »

Barney wrote: As for racism, sexism, homophobia etc - that's pretty much hardwired at present. Most mammals, when presented with a child that smells wrong, looks wrong due to defects or whatever will kill the offspring. At a level we cannot articulate, we are afraid of things that don't fit - if someone is a different race, has a disability, whatever, our instinct is to dislike it. It's a survival mechanism. We are different from other mammals in that we have the tools available to suppress those feelings and behave nicely towards eachother but make no mistake, it's a conscious effort - at least for now. Evolution being what it is, it's going to be a long, long time before those reactions are bred out of us.
As any such things are unlikely to ever affect anyone's ability to reproduce before death, it'll take more than just time, anyway. On the face of it, I agree with what you wrote, and have argued similarly. However, I disagree that "sexism, racism and homophobia" are themselves hardwired, and would argue that it is merely "suspicion of the different" that is. What our adult selves come to perceive as sufficiently "different" depends very much on our upbringing and environment, and these can change over the course of a couple of generations.

An interesting case in point: yesterday I was trying to explain the concept of the "Irishman joke" to my 14yr old daughter, and found it surprisingly difficult to convey to her - especially as I can't remember any decent examples. It had occurred to me that her generation don't even really tell jokes anymore - it's all memes now. And the idea that "the Irish are inherently stupid" that was implicit in all such jokes has all but died by now.

The problem facing us is we have, on the one hand, a movement that sees increasing integration of cultures as inevitable and fine, and on the other, we have those who see this as a threat to their very sense of existence. This is unlikely to resolve anytime soon, but ultimately tolerance has to be encouraged if we are to enjoy a relatively peaceful future.
User avatar
Absolute_Zero
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3564
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.

Re: Trump

Post by Absolute_Zero »

In Ireland they make *men jokes about those from Cork/Kerry. Who the target becomes in those counties, I couldn't say. My favourite was...

How do you confuse a Kerryman?
Present him with a fork and a spade and ask him to take his pick.

Essex girls as Northside [Dublin] girls.

How do you know when a Northside girl has achieved orgasm?
She drops her bag of chips.
Post Reply