Almost, but with heavy disclaimers. A true handheld like the 3DS can go with me wherever I travel; toss it in a case and it comes along with me out into the world. The Switch doesn't seem like that would be a good idea at all. It's a home system, just one I don't need to plug into a tv. Technically it's portable, but portable within the home. The thing is, that limitation is a feature rather than drawback, in a weird Nintendo-ish way. I just don't see the detriment to function at all, and the performance is pretty much what I'd expect from a Nintendo system at this point.fog wrote:So you're likely to use the Switch exclusively as a handeld, which is exactly the point I was making.Jamesac wrote:Me, very much. The performance is fine, I've got no problems there, and being able to lie on the couch playing a proper console-sized game (Zelda for now, Toad Treasure Tracker 2 if I'm really lucky) while my wife watches tv sounds just about perfect. My PS4 has Dragon Quest Builders in it, which is a game I'd love to put a huge amount of time into, but it's really hard to find the time. I'm honestly not sure I'll be plugging in the Switch's dock at all.fog wrote:The Switch being able to be both a console and a handheld sounds really cool, but how many people really want that at the detriment to function and performance.
Nintendo Switch
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Seems just as portable to me, apart from the lack of clamshell design means you'd need a case to protect the screen and analogue sticks... Also, it's bigger, of course.
I made a deviantart page.
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
'....The baron is a gay old rogue with an eye for the ladies....'
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Here's my report from the hands-on event in London yesterday.
The device itself is smaller than you think it will be. This is a blessing and a curse, as it makes it more portable, but also makes it less practical when used in "table top" mode - especially on two player games. It'll do for some casual ad-hoc playing on a long flight, but when you're taking it round to the family for after dinner games at Christmas, you'll want to take the whole dock.
I should note that I wasn't able to spend any time looking at the hardware in any detail. There were no demo units available to just check out the physical features in terms of attaching the controllers or (un)docking it. All the units were already set up to play specific games, so I also didn't get to see anything of the underlying OS. Every un-docked Joy Con was already hooked up to a wrist strap, so I also can't comment on how comfortable they feel without the additional rounded edges and protruding L & R buttons that provides.
The Joy Cons are certainly versatile controllers, and are the real secret of the system. The "HD rumble" is a definite improvement over simple vibration: one minigame in 1-2-Switch has you moving the controller to try to determine how many marbles are in a box based on their movement, and it definitely conveyed the feeling of something rolling from end to end and side to side. Another had you trying to crack a safe by turning the control until you felt a "detent" in the dial on the safe, which also worked well. The cow milking minigame, on the other hand, just felt like traditional rumble to me. That said, I was *really* bad at it, and almost everyone I heard talking about that minigame thought it was one of the highlights, so perhaps I was just getting some "you're doing it wrong" rumble whilst everyone else could feel milk squirting from a cow!
The Joy Cons were a little small: fine for my medium sized hands when held as "normal" joypad controllers, but even I found them a bit fiddly for holding comfortably as motion controls. The milking game had you holding it vertically in one hand and pressing the L & R buttons in sequence as you pulled the Joy Con down. I found it tricky to get a comfortable grip that let me press the buttons easily. Because of their shape, for some games you really have to have one player that holds the left one in a left hand and the other player holds the right one in a right hand - so if you have two righties (or two southpaws) in your house you might find that you need at least one more Joy Con if you both want to play some minigames (such as the Quick Draw one) with your preferred hand.
For more traditional gaming, the Joy Con grip was comfortable enough. I didn't use the pro controller or the plastic steering wheel, so can't comment on those. Using the device in tablet mode, with a Joy Con on each side, also worked okay - though I found it a little wide and thin for my tastes. I prefer a more chunky grip, like the Wii U controller. It's something I would get used to, though, and didn't stop me getting second place in 8 player Mario Kart
I wasn't able to play Zelda or Splatoon, due to the length of the queues (e.g. a two hour wait for a 20 min demo on Zelda). I did play Arms, which is really just a fun twist on Wii Sports Boxing, but not the sort of game I would return to with any frequency. For a different take on beat-em-ups, though, it's worth considering if you like the genre.
Other than that, I played an F-Zero like racer which took a nod from Ikaruga with a colour-changing game mechanic that let you switch vehicle between blue and orange modes to get boosts or be slowed down. We also played Bomberman R, which was... well Bomberman, but on a small screen (tabletop mode). Finally we played Snipperclips, which is an interesting cooperative puzzle game that will probably result in anything but cooperation ("no, rotate it to your OTHER left!"). None of those used any of the Joy Con's capabilities beyond the basics of normal controls, so didn't really do much to sell the system other than make it look like there were a few more games on their way.
My feeling is that it could be a great system that sells well to casual gamers in the same way that the Wii did, but only if Nintendo sort out their marketing message. I fear they won't manage that. They need to push the many ways of using the Joy Cons, and the HD rumble - but I reckon they'll try to sell it too heavily on the portable/dockable aspect of the system, which I don't think has the appeal they think it has. The peripherals are painfully expensive, so hopefully they'll at least drop the price of the base system before too long, once they've finished reaming the early adopters.
Really I wish they'd released two related cheaper systems: a handheld version with no dock, and a console version with no screen. Each buyer could then decide which mode they want most, but still switch cartridges and controllers to the other version if they later buy that.
I'll definitely pick one up at some point, but the system is too expensive (once you factor in a few near-essential peripherals, plus at least one game), and the launch line-up too sparse, to make it a day-one purchase.
The device itself is smaller than you think it will be. This is a blessing and a curse, as it makes it more portable, but also makes it less practical when used in "table top" mode - especially on two player games. It'll do for some casual ad-hoc playing on a long flight, but when you're taking it round to the family for after dinner games at Christmas, you'll want to take the whole dock.
I should note that I wasn't able to spend any time looking at the hardware in any detail. There were no demo units available to just check out the physical features in terms of attaching the controllers or (un)docking it. All the units were already set up to play specific games, so I also didn't get to see anything of the underlying OS. Every un-docked Joy Con was already hooked up to a wrist strap, so I also can't comment on how comfortable they feel without the additional rounded edges and protruding L & R buttons that provides.
The Joy Cons are certainly versatile controllers, and are the real secret of the system. The "HD rumble" is a definite improvement over simple vibration: one minigame in 1-2-Switch has you moving the controller to try to determine how many marbles are in a box based on their movement, and it definitely conveyed the feeling of something rolling from end to end and side to side. Another had you trying to crack a safe by turning the control until you felt a "detent" in the dial on the safe, which also worked well. The cow milking minigame, on the other hand, just felt like traditional rumble to me. That said, I was *really* bad at it, and almost everyone I heard talking about that minigame thought it was one of the highlights, so perhaps I was just getting some "you're doing it wrong" rumble whilst everyone else could feel milk squirting from a cow!
The Joy Cons were a little small: fine for my medium sized hands when held as "normal" joypad controllers, but even I found them a bit fiddly for holding comfortably as motion controls. The milking game had you holding it vertically in one hand and pressing the L & R buttons in sequence as you pulled the Joy Con down. I found it tricky to get a comfortable grip that let me press the buttons easily. Because of their shape, for some games you really have to have one player that holds the left one in a left hand and the other player holds the right one in a right hand - so if you have two righties (or two southpaws) in your house you might find that you need at least one more Joy Con if you both want to play some minigames (such as the Quick Draw one) with your preferred hand.
For more traditional gaming, the Joy Con grip was comfortable enough. I didn't use the pro controller or the plastic steering wheel, so can't comment on those. Using the device in tablet mode, with a Joy Con on each side, also worked okay - though I found it a little wide and thin for my tastes. I prefer a more chunky grip, like the Wii U controller. It's something I would get used to, though, and didn't stop me getting second place in 8 player Mario Kart
I wasn't able to play Zelda or Splatoon, due to the length of the queues (e.g. a two hour wait for a 20 min demo on Zelda). I did play Arms, which is really just a fun twist on Wii Sports Boxing, but not the sort of game I would return to with any frequency. For a different take on beat-em-ups, though, it's worth considering if you like the genre.
Other than that, I played an F-Zero like racer which took a nod from Ikaruga with a colour-changing game mechanic that let you switch vehicle between blue and orange modes to get boosts or be slowed down. We also played Bomberman R, which was... well Bomberman, but on a small screen (tabletop mode). Finally we played Snipperclips, which is an interesting cooperative puzzle game that will probably result in anything but cooperation ("no, rotate it to your OTHER left!"). None of those used any of the Joy Con's capabilities beyond the basics of normal controls, so didn't really do much to sell the system other than make it look like there were a few more games on their way.
My feeling is that it could be a great system that sells well to casual gamers in the same way that the Wii did, but only if Nintendo sort out their marketing message. I fear they won't manage that. They need to push the many ways of using the Joy Cons, and the HD rumble - but I reckon they'll try to sell it too heavily on the portable/dockable aspect of the system, which I don't think has the appeal they think it has. The peripherals are painfully expensive, so hopefully they'll at least drop the price of the base system before too long, once they've finished reaming the early adopters.
Really I wish they'd released two related cheaper systems: a handheld version with no dock, and a console version with no screen. Each buyer could then decide which mode they want most, but still switch cartridges and controllers to the other version if they later buy that.
I'll definitely pick one up at some point, but the system is too expensive (once you factor in a few near-essential peripherals, plus at least one game), and the launch line-up too sparse, to make it a day-one purchase.
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
The new zelda looks like it has the potential to be one of the best in a good while, looks so chilled, but I doubt I'll bite if the carts stick at £60! Very slim line up too, hope to see some good surprises from them this year.
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Xenoblade Chronicles 2 alone will last me a whole year
(although by "2017" they probably mean December)
(although by "2017" they probably mean December)
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Baggypants
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5328
- Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
- Location: Salford(UK);
- Contact:
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
I'm a bit surprised they're not doing Wii Sports again this generation.
"The eggs, get them!"
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Really great honest hands-on write up, thanks so much.
Can't disagree with any of your points.
The cost of peripherals is simply horrific. Saw an interesting graphic that showed the main unit is actually about $100 to buy seperately based on all the individual preorder costs. I think we all know that simply wouldn't be the case and it just points to massive mark up on everything else.
I mean an extra dock, around £80!! Come on. Its virtually an empty plastic box.
I really want the Switch to succeed as the thought of home games on a portable is amazing.
Let's hope Nintendo gets it shit together before now an launch and at least announces much more games for it as at the moment it's pretty thin.
Can't disagree with any of your points.
The cost of peripherals is simply horrific. Saw an interesting graphic that showed the main unit is actually about $100 to buy seperately based on all the individual preorder costs. I think we all know that simply wouldn't be the case and it just points to massive mark up on everything else.
I mean an extra dock, around £80!! Come on. Its virtually an empty plastic box.
I really want the Switch to succeed as the thought of home games on a portable is amazing.
Let's hope Nintendo gets it shit together before now an launch and at least announces much more games for it as at the moment it's pretty thin.
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
That was one of the things that came to mind when using the Joy Cons.Baggypants wrote:I'm a bit surprised they're not doing Wii Sports again this generation.
Given that Nintendo aren't going to compete on raw power, they have two practical target markets for their hardware: people who want Nintendo's IP, and casual gamers who aren't worried about power. And it's only the latter that will enable them to grow market share.
In that respect the hardware does a lot of things right, and it's arguably a better evolution of the Wii approach than the Wii U was. But aside from 1-2-Switch, Nintendo don't seem to be pushing any software that might appeal to casual players. They need a few casual titles that are (relatively) quick and easy to produce, but would have broader appeal. "Switch Sports" or a Switch version of "42 all-time classics" (with realistic HD rumble dice!) would help to do the job.
I have a theory about that: we all know about the "razor blade" approach to console sales - sell the hardware cheap and make up the shortfall in software sales. I think they're taking that a step further. They know that the main hardware will drop in price at some point, but peripherals tend to resist such dramatic price cuts, giving them a second type of "razor blade" to make a profit on.oxo wrote:The cost of peripherals is simply horrific.
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
I suspect ARMS is pretty accessible for everyone, being essentially a full game made from Wii Boxing.
Does depend how they market it though.
Does depend how they market it though.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
- Baggypants
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 5328
- Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
- Location: Salford(UK);
- Contact:
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Yeah, but, boxing. Out of the original Wii sports game our household played bowling and tennis together. I played golf on my own and boxing as a nod to doing exercise. (Baseball was shit. )Darkflame wrote:I suspect ARMS is pretty accessible for everyone, being essentially a full game made from Wii Boxing.
Does depend how they market it though.
"The eggs, get them!"
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Thanks for the write-up, xav! Always good to have a real person's perspective on a new gizmo (as opposed to a press release or hipster journo's whitterings).
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
- zbandito
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2916
- Joined: Sat May 18, 2002 10:00 pm 0
- Location: Portland, Oregon
- Contact:
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Well based on the price and availability of any remaining wii u stock, I'd say they timed this just about perfectly from an inventory standpoint. And given that both wii u and 3ds are hacked now, it makes even more sense from the perspective of platform security, something third parties are sure to take note of.
It's not a tablet though! Really? Is it honestly not going to connect to Netflix or YouTube? To be honest, this seems like a missed opportunity. They obviously don't want to fully promote or depend upon a third party platform, nor maintain their own PIM/Internet/productivity software but.. what are the chances it's not running android or *nix underneath anyway? The chipset is obviously capable of it. Personally I would rather it be able to suspend and reboot from an android environment back and forth to a dedicated gaming / performance environment with a minimal kernel/OS.
Can you imagine yak about now? Nnnnng, must finish Polybius.. But.. A cow milking sim!
It's not a tablet though! Really? Is it honestly not going to connect to Netflix or YouTube? To be honest, this seems like a missed opportunity. They obviously don't want to fully promote or depend upon a third party platform, nor maintain their own PIM/Internet/productivity software but.. what are the chances it's not running android or *nix underneath anyway? The chipset is obviously capable of it. Personally I would rather it be able to suspend and reboot from an android environment back and forth to a dedicated gaming / performance environment with a minimal kernel/OS.
Can you imagine yak about now? Nnnnng, must finish Polybius.. But.. A cow milking sim!
- zbandito
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2916
- Joined: Sat May 18, 2002 10:00 pm 0
- Location: Portland, Oregon
- Contact:
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
It does seem a bit of a shame they left PPC behind given all their legacy code, but they probably see ARM as having a better future.
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10749
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Nintendo Switch (NX)
Well I am stoked for this as just love portable play, playing Robotron (Mame) or Gauntlet (Mame) or Mario Kart on the bog has infinite appeal compared to solid hours sat in front of a tv with a home console . Possible this will get jb ?
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !


