Here you have to pay to get photos from a certified machine (you could get them elsewhere, but they have to be acceptable size and brightness and sharpness, and a professional photographer would charge more than the machine). You can't wear glasses in photos for your passport (even if you always do), nor can you smile in your passport photo, and your hair must not cover your face. Then you have to have the big birth certificate that kids all have that gives your parents names and DOB, then you need to send one of your photos to the person who is saying they approve you, they have to write exact words including date on the back, then you send in the filled in form, 2 photos including the one with the writing on the back, and if it takes you too long or the words on the back of the photo aren't exactly right you have to do it all again. I did make mistakes, but I think most people would have trouble doing it in three months (there is doubtless someone (somewhere in Britain) who could do it in two weeks), and six isn't totally unreasonable.gilesgoat wrote:6 months ... ... CRIPEY .. "you are beating Italy with red tape" ... does NOT take more than 4 weeks .. in certain circumstances you may even have one in 2 weeks ..zip accident wrote: It also takes a long time to get a passport, and to get a passport you need a big new style birth certificate, which also takes time and costs money. Six months to get a passport (not a renewal of one that's just gone out of date) is not totally ridiculous, I don't remember how long it took me, but I think it was longer than that, I made mistakes, and it took a long time.
You got to Carbinieri, you apply, you pay, they take there the pics and fingerprints, it's all done there, you don't need to "where do I take the pics or such", and then they even phone when it's ready and/or they give you an appointment to come and pick it up.
Actually IIRC ( was over 5 years ago ) I think there's not even "a pic" they say "look here" and it's all done digitally, they get biometric data of your face as well and part of it is in the electronic passport ( that's why it works with those machines ).
Now with Covid could be more difficult ( or easier, could be part of it you can do it online ) .. ID card is a breeze to obtain, the first time ever I cannot really remember how it was done because it was over 40 years ago, to renew it it's really easy, you give in the old one, you pay the amount, it's done there "on the fly", the place usually has the thing to take photos too.
Now the ID card is electronic as well, probably the photo is digital now as well.
Anyway it's really NOT difficult/that long at all.
Politics Thread!
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Politics Thread!
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Politics Thread!
The photos rules are "similar" in Italy as well, but I THINK nowadays they actually WANT the glasses on if you wear them. Those "certified machines" are ALL certified in Italy now since "aeons", fundamentally it was all about the standard size, as 99.99% of times people needed those machines PRECISELY to get photos for IDs/passports.zip accident wrote:Here you have to pay to get photos from a certified machine (you could get them elsewhere, but they have to be acceptable size and brightness and sharpness, and a professional photographer would charge more than the machine). You can't wear glasses in photos for your passport (even if you always do), nor can you smile in your passport photo, and your hair must not cover your face. Then you have to have the big birth certificate that kids all have that gives your parents names and DOB, then you need to send one of your photos to the person who is saying they approve you, they have to write exact words including date on the back, then you send in the filled in form, 2 photos including the one with the writing on the back, and if it takes you too long or the words on the back of the photo aren't exactly right you have to do it all again. I did make mistakes, but I think most people would have trouble doing it in three months (there is doubtless someone (somewhere in Britain) who could do it in two weeks), and six isn't totally unreasonable.gilesgoat wrote:6 months ... ... CRIPEY .. "you are beating Italy with red tape" ... does NOT take more than 4 weeks .. in certain circumstances you may even have one in 2 weeks ..zip accident wrote: It also takes a long time to get a passport, and to get a passport you need a big new style birth certificate, which also takes time and costs money. Six months to get a passport (not a renewal of one that's just gone out of date) is not totally ridiculous, I don't remember how long it took me, but I think it was longer than that, I made mistakes, and it took a long time.
You got to Carbinieri, you apply, you pay, they take there the pics and fingerprints, it's all done there, you don't need to "where do I take the pics or such", and then they even phone when it's ready and/or they give you an appointment to come and pick it up.
Actually IIRC ( was over 5 years ago ) I think there's not even "a pic" they say "look here" and it's all done digitally, they get biometric data of your face as well and part of it is in the electronic passport ( that's why it works with those machines ).
Now with Covid could be more difficult ( or easier, could be part of it you can do it online ) .. ID card is a breeze to obtain, the first time ever I cannot really remember how it was done because it was over 40 years ago, to renew it it's really easy, you give in the old one, you pay the amount, it's done there "on the fly", the place usually has the thing to take photos too.
Now the ID card is electronic as well, probably the photo is digital now as well.
Anyway it's really NOT difficult/that long at all.
Normally there was, in the past, at least one machine like that "almost in every train station", I wonder if the one in my local train station is still there, it probably is all replaced by digital cameras and they take your pic ( and probably biometric scan as well ) in the place.
Taking a pic for passport / ID I remember was "1000 Italian lire" and a 5 mins job, usually people were spending 2000 lire because they were not satisfied of the first shot and wanted "a better one"
Also "Italy being Italy" I KNOW of people "taking a week before to take such pics" to go to the hair stylist, find new clothes, spend 1 hour on make up and sometime even getting a new pair of glasses because they did not like what they were wearing.
Ah yes the SUPER old machines were doing "4 photos in one shot" ( because normally you needed >1 photo ) but pretty soon they were doing 4 individual shots so people could chose "the better ones"
THIS IS ANCIENT but as you can see "even in those ancient times" it says "FOTOTESSERA" i.e. "Photo for ID" .. that's why we had those machines back in the 1970's ..

Getting a birth certificate in Italy is no big deal, that's the kind of thing the "anagrafe registar" is for, you go to the town hall of your residence city (i.e. I suppose here let's say would be "Carmarthen" ) and you ask for it.
Now in truth the fact is "I don't know how you really do from 'complete 0' " because MOST LIKELY when I go there they ask me "ok give me your ID card", that's more than sufficien to say "ok sign here and pay this and get the paper you need" ( that's why the ID card is SO useful and SO fundamental in Italy ).
But in Italy "it's practically impossible" to start "totally from 0 nothing" because "there's something of you since you are born".
Now I was telling a story to a friend some hours ago while chatting about this thread .. now .. "IDs and such" .. YOU HAVE NEVER HAD TO DO WITH ITALIAN CARABINIERI ( VERY LUCKY YOU ) ...
So ... too long to explain the full story, the place that sold me the 85 eur "special passport duty stamp" made a small mistake .. besides, I NEVER been into the NEW Carabinieri station in Monfalcone before .. so "they should not know me" .. .. telephone rings ..
"I AM THE CHIEF OF THE CARABINIERI STATION, THERE'S A PROBLEM WITH YOUR PASSPORT, CAN YOU COME HERE ?!"
Which actually means "COME HERE OR ELSE !" ...
( shaking voice ) ".. yes .. sure .. I come as soon as I can .. " ( which actually wasn't that soon )
So I get there after about 40 mins .. I open the door .. BIG new station .. there's a sort of reception with one person in .. I have a quick look around , NO IDEA where to go, I am JUST ABOUT to open my mouth and ask "I am looking for .. " .. I can't make a single word I hear someone SHOUTING "MR IVAN ! COME HERE !"
It was the chief .. NEVER met him or anyone there before in my life .. "they already knew all of me"
Well .. that's Carabinieri .. "they really already knew all" ..
Anyway despite the tone they were really professional and helpful .. but with them "you may never know" also OFTEN they are "pretty friendly" when they actually are doing so to extract even more info with you ( and then seriously fuck you up ).
Fundamentally "there's no worst place in Italy you could end up than a Carabinieri station" ( apart a prison / cell ), but this time "it was ok" ..
But anyway yeah "no big deal to get a passport" .. well "assuming you don't have weird law problems or such", you get the module, you fill up the module, you pay the stuff, the only thing you have to buy separately is "the 85 eur duty stamp" that is sold in ANY authorized shop in Italy ( and there are plenty, normally same places selling you tobacco ) .
Now if you want to see "something Italian really WEIRD" that is *MUCH WEIRDER* than obtaining a passport/ID you should see the declaration THAT I HAVE TO RE-DO EVERY YEAR to say "I don't own any TV equipment in Italy therefore I don't have to pay TV license".
You would *NEVER* believe what they came out with ..
Even if it's in Italy "I have to send a letter to the TV license office with a certain 3 pages module that seems to change every year" plus some copies of some other documents with it.
BUT BUT .. "Italy came out with a fantastic invention" .. "you sent a letter" .. HOW COULD YOU BE SURE that SOMEONE did NOT open YOUR letter, took your papers aways, replaced them with something else and sent another letter to the same address again ?
How can you be sure of that ?
.. Italy invented a WEIRD way for that .. that NOBODY BUT "the TV license office" uses and will NOT accept any other letters or stuff .. ( unless you do it online but the story gets even MORE complicated ) ..
Anyway "I know the trick" now, takes me only 1 hour to do it
But no I can tell you and been asking again to other people in Italy, it normally takes 1 month to get it, often less and you can sort it all out in 1 day ( the module and the pics ) , unless of course you have some really odd/weird law/citizenship situation.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Politics Thread!
Some bollocks here I'm afraid:zip accident wrote:Here you have to pay to get photos from a certified machine (you could get them elsewhere, but they have to be acceptable size and brightness and sharpness, and a professional photographer would charge more than the machine).
- Home-taken digital photos have been acceptable for about five years, my last passport was renewed using a selfie from my phone. (Well, actually, I got the 9-year-old to take it, which is why I have the facial expression of someone just about to say "OK, that's fine, I'll do it myself...").
- My previous one was taken in a photo shop at the local supermarket for a couple of quid.
- Print shop prints of digital photos been acceptable since digital cameras got into the megapixel range
- For the lad's passport when he was a baby in 2008 I took a photo and printed it on my own printer.
They also do most of the photo / identity verification digitally nowadays too. I was surprised how efficient it was. The UK government web services in general seem pretty solid nowadays.
It is a common misconception though. My mum was concerned about the faff of renewing her passport until I told her I'd done mine online and demonstrated she could get the right result against the plain wall in the kitchen.
Re: Politics Thread!
There’s evidence that strict voter ID rules in the USA disproportionately disadvantage already marginalised groups and there's no evidence that voter fraud in the UK has any significant effect on the outcomes of elections.tufty wrote:Nah, that was a joke, and a back reference to http://www.yakyak.org/viewtopic.php?f=2 ... 0#p1707296Rhythm wrote:So for being suspicious of the Tories we're now all as bad as holocaust deniers or "Covid was a hoax to keep us locked in" folks? Classy move, fella
I'm suspicious of a tory government's motivations to do anything, but as "blatant voter suppression" this simply doesn't meet the mark. They'd be suppressing their own voters, and while individual tories might be stupid cunts, as a whole they are far from stupid. There's certainly some motive to it, and it may well be evil, but I simply don't buy it as what it's being purported to be here. It could even be a disposable cover for some more subtly evil fucking scheme that's being slipped in whilst everyone gets their tits in a twist about this. After all, it's a not law, it's a plan, and whilst it's in the Queen's speech, it can still be thrown away or allowed to be amended into nothingness.
As for your 11 million voters, the right wing press are suggesting 2.1 million as the plan stands today.
You're right that this might not make it onto the statute books but the intention is to shift voting demographics.
They've done really stupid shit for similar motives in the past. Remember the poll tax?
Re: Politics Thread!
This is all true, but with the exception of the disabled and the homeless, there's also evidence that those who do not hold photo ID fall mainly into groups that are pro-Tory, being mostly some combination of "older", "white" and "of lower socio-economic status".gravy wrote:There’s evidence that strict voter ID rules in the USA disproportionately disadvantage already marginalised groups and there's no evidence that voter fraud in the UK has any significant effect on the outcomes of elections.
So either it's targeted at some very non-obvious group who manage to outweigh the electoral advantage the tories have in the above, or, more likely in my opinion, it's a decoy whilst something more effective is being slipped in behind it. Gerrymandering is highly effective, standard Tory policy, and it barely raises an eyebrow, why would they bother with something that's obviously going to take flak from all sides including their own?
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: Politics Thread!
This piece is where we differ. Where are you getting this data from? And why would "lower socio-economic status" mean someone is a Tory voter? Everything I've seen has pointed to the bulk of "no ID" being LSES/BAME and that they'd traditionally vote "not Tory"tufty wrote: This is all true, but with the exception of the disabled and the homeless, there's also evidence that those who do not hold photo ID fall mainly into groups that are pro-Tory, being mostly some combination of "older", "white" and "of lower socio-economic status".
Steam: SteelyDamn
Re: Politics Thread!
It's targeting low-income BAME, in inner cities IMHO. They want some Tory mayors. And I'm not sure that you're right about the photo ID demo. The UK has one of the highest proportion of passport holders, 76% in the last censustufty wrote:This is all true, but with the exception of the disabled and the homeless, there's also evidence that those who do not hold photo ID fall mainly into groups that are pro-Tory, being mostly some combination of "older", "white" and "of lower socio-economic status".gravy wrote:There’s evidence that strict voter ID rules in the USA disproportionately disadvantage already marginalised groups and there's no evidence that voter fraud in the UK has any significant effect on the outcomes of elections.
So either it's targeted at some very non-obvious group who manage to outweigh the electoral advantage the tories have in the above, or, more likely in my opinion, it's a decoy whilst something more effective is being slipped in behind it. Gerrymandering is highly effective, standard Tory policy, and it barely raises an eyebrow, why would they bother with something that's obviously going to take flak from all sides including their own?
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Politics Thread!
I think here Tufty we have/are seeing a bit of "political/cultural clash/bias", let me explain for all.
"From an European point of view" and in this case REALLY "NOT from an UK point of view" the fact not to have an ID card/use it for voting is "ABSOLUTELY CONCEPTUALLY ABSURD" ( especially in Italy ).
But "in Europe AND NOT UK, we have really much different realities", "in Europe" obtaining an ID card is relatively simple/inexpensive and considered really "one of the MUST HAVE documents or you REALLY ARE NO ONE in EVERY SENSE" ( so you are not even "poor" or "BAME" or "LSES" or whatver, you really 'someone that should not even exist/be here' - not even a refugee/immigrant that came with a boat, they are identified and listed as soon as they step in ).
But it's "such a paramount thing" that "no one will ever think not to have/get one", you always have it, it's used "anytime, everywhere for whatever it may be needed".
In Italy in particular we are EXTREMELY USED to the fact "you could be asked an ID/document/whatever" it's just how it works, it's SO COMMON that people don't even think about it.
If you tell me "you need an ultra mega weird paper to vote", in Italy, even in that case I would NOT think immediately "ah this is a way to not make certain people vote", I would immediately think "OH they changed rules again ? How much money they want this time ?" because "that's the sort of stuff that happens in Italy all time".
The second thing you MAY think in that case would be "Oh has Berlusconi ran out of money for his bunga bunga parties ?" .. because in the end of the day "when anything like that happens" is that "ultimately the government ran out of money somewhere and they need some more".
However I have to say/think that in Italy, "if really someone would try someway to limit the voting people" there would be "tremendous uproar" from all the other parties/things and possibly even within the same party, that would not pass easily and/or unnoticed.
I never seen to be honest in Italy "attempts not to have other pepole vote" but I see all the time "all sorts of things to make people vote what they want you to vote", they want your votes, as many as they can get, but only what they want ..
But yeah "the stories of IDs in general" in Italy "is such a trivial thing with many different options" that you would not think for a second that "asking for an ID is a way to limit people" .. well .. OF COURSE if you REALLY have NO ID and if you REALLY can't get one then, in Italy, there's REALLY SOMETHING VERY ODD with you ! Something truly "out of the normal".
Also there are "fuckton of very legitimate reasons" in Italy to have documents I would never be happy NOT to have at least one where "I can prove something if asked to" and in Italy that "asked to" happens LOT more frequently than what you think may be.
There's Carabinieri doing a road block, checking cars, "hello good morning please give me your driving license" ( OBLIGATORY to carry with you all time you drive ) ... you don't have any ? "Step out the car you can't drive ! Follow me in the Carabinieri station we have to fine you for driving without a license !" .. or "who are those passengers with you ?" .. "Please give me your IDs .. " .. you don't have any ? "Follow me in the Carabinieri station for checking .. " ..
You say "how many times Carabinieri do a road block in Italy?" .. well I live in border region, can happen "any time".
How many times Carabinieri are around the cities/etc. can stop people and ask for documents ?
"Always", they are always around somewhere .. can happen .. it's not impossible or "never happens" actually does happen.
Why ? "Because we are Italy, that's how it works".
So I think "we see things quite a bit different" about IDs in general and how/why they are used.
Anyway IF you'll ever come to Italy *BE STRAFUCKING SURE* to HAVE SOME ID with YOU ! DON'T GO WITHOUT ONE !!
"From an European point of view" and in this case REALLY "NOT from an UK point of view" the fact not to have an ID card/use it for voting is "ABSOLUTELY CONCEPTUALLY ABSURD" ( especially in Italy ).
But "in Europe AND NOT UK, we have really much different realities", "in Europe" obtaining an ID card is relatively simple/inexpensive and considered really "one of the MUST HAVE documents or you REALLY ARE NO ONE in EVERY SENSE" ( so you are not even "poor" or "BAME" or "LSES" or whatver, you really 'someone that should not even exist/be here' - not even a refugee/immigrant that came with a boat, they are identified and listed as soon as they step in ).
But it's "such a paramount thing" that "no one will ever think not to have/get one", you always have it, it's used "anytime, everywhere for whatever it may be needed".
In Italy in particular we are EXTREMELY USED to the fact "you could be asked an ID/document/whatever" it's just how it works, it's SO COMMON that people don't even think about it.
If you tell me "you need an ultra mega weird paper to vote", in Italy, even in that case I would NOT think immediately "ah this is a way to not make certain people vote", I would immediately think "OH they changed rules again ? How much money they want this time ?" because "that's the sort of stuff that happens in Italy all time".
The second thing you MAY think in that case would be "Oh has Berlusconi ran out of money for his bunga bunga parties ?" .. because in the end of the day "when anything like that happens" is that "ultimately the government ran out of money somewhere and they need some more".
However I have to say/think that in Italy, "if really someone would try someway to limit the voting people" there would be "tremendous uproar" from all the other parties/things and possibly even within the same party, that would not pass easily and/or unnoticed.
I never seen to be honest in Italy "attempts not to have other pepole vote" but I see all the time "all sorts of things to make people vote what they want you to vote", they want your votes, as many as they can get, but only what they want ..
But yeah "the stories of IDs in general" in Italy "is such a trivial thing with many different options" that you would not think for a second that "asking for an ID is a way to limit people" .. well .. OF COURSE if you REALLY have NO ID and if you REALLY can't get one then, in Italy, there's REALLY SOMETHING VERY ODD with you ! Something truly "out of the normal".
Also there are "fuckton of very legitimate reasons" in Italy to have documents I would never be happy NOT to have at least one where "I can prove something if asked to" and in Italy that "asked to" happens LOT more frequently than what you think may be.
There's Carabinieri doing a road block, checking cars, "hello good morning please give me your driving license" ( OBLIGATORY to carry with you all time you drive ) ... you don't have any ? "Step out the car you can't drive ! Follow me in the Carabinieri station we have to fine you for driving without a license !" .. or "who are those passengers with you ?" .. "Please give me your IDs .. " .. you don't have any ? "Follow me in the Carabinieri station for checking .. " ..
You say "how many times Carabinieri do a road block in Italy?" .. well I live in border region, can happen "any time".
How many times Carabinieri are around the cities/etc. can stop people and ask for documents ?
"Always", they are always around somewhere .. can happen .. it's not impossible or "never happens" actually does happen.
Why ? "Because we are Italy, that's how it works".
So I think "we see things quite a bit different" about IDs in general and how/why they are used.
Anyway IF you'll ever come to Italy *BE STRAFUCKING SURE* to HAVE SOME ID with YOU ! DON'T GO WITHOUT ONE !!
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Politics Thread!
From the study linked in the guardian article I linked yesterday, there's this :Rhythm wrote:Everything I've seen has pointed to the bulk of "no ID" being LSES/BAME and that they'd traditionally vote "not Tory"
There are other plenty of studies showing much the same thing, new ones appear every time the whole ID card thing comes up.Age
Younger people were more likely than the general population to hold a form of photo ID. Ninety-nine per cent of those aged 18-29 held a form of photo ID, slightly higher than either those aged 30-69 (98%) or 70+ (98%). Additionally, those aged 85+ were less likely to hold photo ID that was recognisable. Nine in ten (91%) did so, compared to well over nine in ten (95-98%) of younger age groups.
Ethnicity
Individuals from the White group were less likely to hold any form of photo ID than those in an ethnic minority group (98% vs. 99%), although there were no significant differences in the proportions with recognisable photo ID (96% and 97% respectively). Those in the Asian / Asian British group were more likely to hold any form of ID than the rest of the population (100% vs. 98%), and looking within that group those of Indian ethnicity were more likely to hold photo ID than the overall population (100% vs. 98%).
…
Employment: Employed (99%) vs. not in work (98%) vs. unemployed (92%);
Qualifications: Those with qualifications (97-100% across all the qualification types, with those with a degree or higher being most likely) vs. those without qualifications (94%);
As far as traditional voting patterns go, there's not much tradition left. Whilst BMAE voters do largely vote against the Tories (for example), the overall voting pattern for LSES is very much pro-Tory and overwhelmingly right wing. This has some nice graphs and easily digestible figures.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: Politics Thread!
OK, thanks for that, Tufty. Runs counter to stuff that I've seen and even what the FT is publishing, but makes sense.
Rather handily, the FT article republished the YouGov chart I'd seen previously, which is why my first suspicion is that it's a vote rigging thing.

So we're still left with the reasons being:
Money
Power
Some unknown reason
I'm still inclined to think it's one of the former. The Money angle will be manifested by Tory donor mates who'll magically get the contracts to build the ID verification system. Even if there's a promise for "free" ID cards someone will be paying for those, and the Tories absolutely have a track record of siphoning public funds into the pockets of their mates.
Power.... even if this isn't a direct vote rigging project, there's still the argument that this could be an exercise in controlling votes. Whilst the system is being declared as being open to everyone, who's to say that this won't develop further into a "who can/can't vote" exercise down the line? (I realise this enters the tinfoil hat area so I'll not put too much weight on this)
Rather handily, the FT article republished the YouGov chart I'd seen previously, which is why my first suspicion is that it's a vote rigging thing.

So we're still left with the reasons being:
Money
Power
Some unknown reason
I'm still inclined to think it's one of the former. The Money angle will be manifested by Tory donor mates who'll magically get the contracts to build the ID verification system. Even if there's a promise for "free" ID cards someone will be paying for those, and the Tories absolutely have a track record of siphoning public funds into the pockets of their mates.
Power.... even if this isn't a direct vote rigging project, there's still the argument that this could be an exercise in controlling votes. Whilst the system is being declared as being open to everyone, who's to say that this won't develop further into a "who can/can't vote" exercise down the line? (I realise this enters the tinfoil hat area so I'll not put too much weight on this)
Steam: SteelyDamn
Re: Politics Thread!
Money? Pure venal greed? The Tories? Shome mishtake, shurely?
Yeah, that fits.
Yeah, that fits.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Politics Thread!
I dare to say that the real problem here is not about what Tories are doing/trying to do, is about the fact that Labour seems "not to be able to counter-act anything" and come out with some real strong statements/candidates ...
( and/or they are not convincing enough people ).
( and/or they are not convincing enough people ).
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Politics Thread!
Labour have divided their own base* and are basically circling the drain.gilesgoat wrote:I dare to say that the real problem here is not about what Tories are doing/trying to do, is about the fact that Labour seems "not to be able to counter-act anything" and come out with some real strong statements/candidates ...
( and/or they are not convincing enough people ).
*Since the 70s they've been moving progressively further to the right. When Corbyn got voted in as a result of the Labour base saying "no, we want actual left-wing policies" the centrist, Blairite contingent started shitting the bed. Back-biting, belittling, refusing to follow the new direction, rumour-mongering, leaks.... It's basically made Labour an entirely unviable party. (They've been that way ever since Blair got in, but that's another thing altogether).
What they should have done (but didn't because it would "split the vote") when it became apparent that they were having problems, was split the party. They could have broken out into a Centrist Labour and a Left Labour. That way we'd have been able to get a true view on how many people wanted which flavour of "Labour".
As it stands, a vote for Labour now can't be read as representing anything, really. They had woolly positions on Brexit, they have differing internal opinions on immigration, social policies, policing, the full lot. Is a Labour voter supporting Starmer? Or are they hoping the party will swing further Left again? Basically, by insisting everyone knows that they're a centrist party rather than a Left-wing one, they've started digging their own grave.
And we've seen this reflected in the local elections, where the only truly "Left" national party, the Greens, made comparatively huge gains. Corbyn made me consider voting for Labour for the first time in my life as it indicated a rollback of all the shite that Labour pulled in the 90s and 00s. But party refused to listen to what their voter/member base were asking for and instead are intent on ripping themselves apart.
Steam: SteelyDamn
Re: Politics Thread!
And a 150 seat Tory majority.Rhythm wrote:That way we'd have been able to get a true view on how many people wanted which flavour of "Labour".
Maybe more given the two Labour factions would likely have spent most of their time eviscerating each other, and that both would be tarred with the "Vote for either, get a coalition with the other" brush.
Re: Politics Thread!
No, you're right, the way they actually handled it has been much better for everyone.Dio wrote: And a 150 seat Tory majority.
Labour have been pushing more and more people away from them for decades. As I said, the first time I'd ever considered voting was when Corbyn was leader. But their refusal to read the room has meant it's been insanely easy for the media, with the help of the monied, to mop the floor with them. Starmer has done fuck all to turn that around in 18 months. They need to fully step back, take a long hard look at themselves and pick a direction to move in, because at the moment they're falling to pieces.
Steam: SteelyDamn
