The Dr Who thread

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

No more daft then "lets have the prime-minister blow up some aliens because she thinks she shouldn't have to relay on a correctly spilled cup of tea to save the day".

I wouldn't go as far as KlaxonCow's (well written) essay, but I think it is true we are supposed to see the doctor as being a bit obsessive compulsive wanting to "fix" people.
Oddly, it reminded me of ReBoot. The villian, on hearing that he is being re-written to be a better person mentions "ah, a fate worse then death". The idea of personal identity being stolen. Of "not being you" in conflict of, well, not being a bastard, is an interesting one.

On the other hand, I don't think there was supposed to be an easy solution for the doctor - after all, without the time travel, the technical solution wouldn't have been there either.
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Ollie »

Dio wrote:It was successfully fun for several series now (and, in the opinion of some of us, many more over the previous run) without the Bill & Ted stuff. Why is it necessary now?
Well he is a Time Lord, ffs, you can't really watch a series that's based on the premise of someone having a time machine and then get upset when there's timey-wimey stuff in it.
Why are you breaking my kayak?
User avatar
juice
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1942
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 9:37 pm 0
Location: Sheffield!
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by juice »

Dungeon-Dave wrote:
RiK wrote:
Dungeon-Dave wrote:This one is young and impetuous, Master.
Ha ha ha.... I'm 42 and proud of it ;)
Young Juice still has a decade to catch up to us Wise Old Ones...
Hey, I can be as curmungeonly and grumpy as anyone ;)
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

KlaxonCow wrote:Strange. Because as a bitter and jaded adult, I saw something completely different.
…
A wonderful analysis there. Thank you.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by pogo »

To me it was just a remarkably well written story.
Spoiler: show
First I don't worry too much about whether or not he abides by the Time Travellers' Prime Directive not to meddle, or whatever, as any such rule has been more observed in the breach in Dr Who, nor about whether it's realistic as they've never treated Time Travel realistically by establishing a set of plausible rules and sticking to them. And the Christmas Specials get more leeway as they have dual brief, to be festive and fun as well as serious Dr Who.

With all that in mind I think it worked very well. They established from the start that the Doctor would be meddling in a particular way and breaking the laws of causality in doing so, from which you could predict the ending very easily. Except having said how he's going to break the rules Moffat then goes to town surprising us with how he does so. The new memories. The love story. The fish (the shark that swallowed half the screwdriver made me think of another great plot device, the crocodile that swallowed an alarm clock in Peter Pan). Christmas at Abigail's family. Abigail's mortality. The way he interprets Dickens's Christmas Carol is especially effective.

He also puts in so many gags and touching moments it's a joy to watch. Card tricks, the psychic paper, using Abigail and young Kazran to highlight the age of old Kazran, Amy and Rory, Marilyn. Even the ending is a surprise: spending the whole episode getting Kazran willing to act he changes him too much to do so, so Abigail has to sing.
So very very good, one of the best episodes of Dr Who written by Moffat, whose writing is on another level from the other writers on new Dr Who so far.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

Ollie wrote:
Dio wrote:It was successfully fun for several series now (and, in the opinion of some of us, many more over the previous run) without the Bill & Ted stuff. Why is it necessary now?
Well he is a Time Lord, ffs, you can't really watch a series that's based on the premise of someone having a time machine and then get upset when there's timey-wimey stuff in it.
Odd that I've managed it for 35 years, isn't it?

OK, if you want the full thesis on this: Doctor Who has always had a semi-Pratchettian 'narrative causality' view of time - obviously, because of the restrictions that doing the filming in a linear time presents, but the result of this has been a framework which is both largely scientifically consistent, with a few leaps of faith, and ideally constructed for drama. I've never really watched Doctor Who and had the question "Why not just travel in time in order to fix dilemma X?" because it wasn't allowed and I knew it wasn't allowed, even though it's explicitly mentioned only a couple of times. The changes to the rules threaten to break both halves of this.

It's always shied away from discussing technology, living on the hand-wavy side of the Mohs Scale Of Science Fiction Hardness, but there have been enough bits of time travel information that you can pretty much describe the pre-3rd-new-series rules governing time travel:

- There is a vague concept of a 'time stream' in which an entity (physical object, sentient being etc.) exists
- It is nearly impossible to time travel within a time stream to modify that time stream.
- It specifically is possible, though: see the Three Doctors, where the Time Lords are able to expend a great amount of energy in order to violate the rule (specifically, the First Law Of Time). However, until the current time stream in which the entities are present is exited, entities so travelling are not aware of the existence of this alternate time stream. Hence why multiple Doctors can't remember what is about to happen in the future.
- Once inside a time stream, its effects on the universe become global. See "Pyramids of Mars" - once the Doctor has entered a time stream that previously was 'resolved' he cannot travel forward in time to escape the time stream without resolving the issue.
- Once a given time stream has been entered, it is hard to reenter at an earlier point, and there is a 'natural' point of re-entry. So 'modern Earth' ages at a constant rate, and the Doctor can jump back to the Earth timestream at any point after the one at which he left it, but it's 'hard' to jump back to it at an earlier point.
- Time streams may be absolutely linear (e.g. that of Gallifrey).

There's a few other minor rules I might discern, but not really relevant.

These served Doctor Who very well for years because it creates a solid framework for narrative causality and handwaving away the regular aging of Earth, etc., while being flexible enough to allow for arbitrary storytelling and a fair bit of close-to-Deus-Ex-Machina fixes when really really required.

Most important, it means that Time Travel Is Not The Easy Answer. Because if it becomes so more than really rather occasionally, then it surely becomes Time Travel Is Always The Very Easy Answer and the drama is gone.

The Tie Incident wobbled the rules pretty badly, and the last finale and this Special tore them up into tiny pieces. (River Song is clearly all over the shop with them as well, but that's easily handwaved away when they resolve it all if they so choose).

If anything, the Special is the worse offender; completely arbitrary modification of the time stream; at least the finale was only a massively re-entrant timestream (OK, and the Bill & Ted "future affecting the now", which is pretty bad for dramatic tension) and you could probably handwave it by saying the exploding TARDIS provided the energy to completely eliminate the First Law Of Time...
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

The Dr Who thread

Post by Cloudane »

To paraphrase Voyager's Captain Janeway: "You want my advice on understanding time travel? Don't even try."

That's how I like to see it, in fiction anyway. Otherwise you are just guaranteed to notice paradoxes and other shit that just doesn't make sense and ends up looking like a plot hole.

I guess the writers of DW have taken a similar approach: why try to write "good" time travel stuff (especially when Moffat himself puts it forth as a show *primarily* aimed at kids), just don't even try.
c64audio
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1657
Joined: Thu Apr 25, 2002 5:34 pm 0
Location: In the Mobile Sphere
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by c64audio »

For all we know, the next story arc will reveal that all this mucking about in time has triggered something which is trying to destroy the Tardis: i.e. that he's been breaking the laws of time willy-nilly and will have to pay. I'm sure Moffat has it in hand that the level of drama won't suffer from a ground-rule change.

Chris
Chris Abbott
Remixer and mobile thingywotsit.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by zip accident »

I did like KC's explanation. I sort of suspected there was something deeper going on. I always found Dickens tedious to read, even though I know he'd supposed to be a good guy.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Darkflame »

- It is nearly impossible to time travel within a time stream to modify that time stream.
So if the doctor can't modify the time stream, how are the invasions prevented?
- It specifically is possible, though: see the Three Doctors, where the Time Lords are able to expend a great amount of energy in order to violate the rule (specifically, the First Law Of Time).
I think that was more it was interfering with his own timestream that required the energy. (tempted to say that he isn't allowed normally to cross the streams...)

Also, what about the "time meddler" wasn't he messing with time, violating the rule?. (although in not so major ways)
Once a given time stream has been entered, it is hard to reenter at an earlier point, and there is a 'natural' point of re-entry. So 'modern Earth' ages at a constant rate, and the Doctor can jump back to the Earth timestream at any point after the one at which he left it, but it's 'hard' to jump back to it at an earlier point.
Thats nonsense, they have been jumping all over earths time from Season1.
It doesn't seem harder then anything else. You could argue that short precise jumps arn't seen much, its more often 100/1000's of years.

Unless you mean there isn't "a" earth timestream, but multiple. Not as in other universe's, but multiple timestreams as in "one after eachother", where landing in one would then restrict your movement within that one stream, but you could still jump forward to the next or past (which might be thousands of years apart)
Presumably where the timestreams join are the "fixed points in time", which cant be modified.
I could accept that. I think.
These served Doctor Who very well for years
oh, please, they were made up as they went. These rules you accept only because they predate whats here.

I'm all for as much consistency as possible, but these "rules" all popped up at different points, and are themselves not really that consistent.
Most important, it means that Time Travel Is Not The Easy Answer. Because if it becomes so more than really rather occasionally, then it surely becomes Time Travel Is Always The Very Easy Answer and the drama is gone.
This I absolutely agree with, however.

Arguably changing someones personality wasn't "easy" and didnt solve anything in this case, in this plots overall story.
It was more things like jumping forward to get the password that could get too easy. Then again, ye-old "separation from Tardis" is still possible to prevent this if needed.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Dio »

Darkflame wrote:
- It is nearly impossible to time travel within a time stream to modify that time stream.
So if the doctor can't modify the time stream, how are the invasions prevented?
Not sure to what you're referring here.
Once a given time stream has been entered, it is hard to reenter at an earlier point, and there is a 'natural' point of re-entry. So 'modern Earth' ages at a constant rate, and the Doctor can jump back to the Earth timestream at any point after the one at which he left it, but it's 'hard' to jump back to it at an earlier point.
Thats nonsense, they have been jumping all over earths time from Season1.
It doesn't seem harder then anything else. You could argue that short precise jumps arn't seen much, its more often 100/1000's of years.

Unless you mean there isn't "a" earth timestream, but multiple. Not as in other universe's, but multiple timestreams as in "one after eachother", where landing in one would then restrict your movement within that one stream, but you could still jump forward to the next or past (which might be thousands of years apart)
Presumably where the timestreams join are the "fixed points in time", which cant be modified.
I could accept that. I think.
Yeah, that's roughly what I think. Strips of time, something like that. Not a fan of the fixed points in time stuff though.
These served Doctor Who very well for years
oh, please, they were made up as they went. These rules you accept only because they predate whats here.

I'm all for as much consistency as possible, but these "rules" all popped up at different points, and are themselves not really that consistent.
I'll quote Pratchett again, from the introduction to the Map of Ankh-Morpork: he thought it was impossible to make one, because he'd made it all up as he went along, but was surprised to find that it worked.

There is certainly consistency in it all - the consistent notion that time travel should be shied away from in plotting because it makes the whole thing into a bloody great big mess, but used as much as possible in theming to add variety to the series. To be honest, I reckon that combination of basic principles inevitably leads to something akin to the rules described above :) .

Fair enough - for most of the old run they largely handwaved the whole problem away by having the Doctor's TARDIS-piloting accuracy, particularly the time part of it, being a bit dubious (except when it needed to be laser-guided, when it was) :D .

Arguably changing someones personality wasn't "easy" and didnt solve anything in this case, in this plots overall story.
I agree that this was quite a deliberate choice on the Doctor's part; if we're in a plot where there is no First Law, instead of the 'easy options' rescuing the ship by mucking about with the time stream, he chose a 'difficult' one because it would redeem the person involved, make the universe a happier place and be more fun in the process.

Almost all of the objections to this particular episode's abuse of time travel can be answered with that one - as I said in my first post on the episode a couple of days ago. But it still sets a dangerous precedent (and also potentially changes the character of the Doctor rather a lot, if you want to get more subtle).

Then again, ye-old "separation from Tardis" is still possible to prevent this if needed.
I have nightmares about this coming, since Kryptonite is the world's shittest plot device.

Even then, though, basic 'separation' doesn't seem likely to hold up under close scrutiny, since whenever he does get access to the TARDIS again he could go back in time and stop whatever it was that meant he couldn't and it all turns into a mess again. Much simpler just to keep causality, well, causal.
User avatar
Gorecki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5962
Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Gorecki »

I think the problem is, Dio that you're approaching this with the logic of a physicist rather than the logic of a storyteller. I think your argument that buggering about with time removes any drama has been blown out of the water by A Christmas Carol, where it was used to great dramatic effect.
Dio wrote:Why is it necessary now?
Well it very obviously isn't necessary but then CGI isn't necessary either. The reason for their exclusion previously were the same, the makers weren't capable of doing it. Messing about with time, plotting and story logic for dramatic and comedic effect is what Moffat is good at. Anybody who had the pleasure of watching Coupling knows that. So why shouldn't he do it?

The only reasons you've come up with so far are physical, causality reasons that simply don't apply to a decent storyteller.
Tang Sou!
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by pogo »

Gorecki wrote:Well it very obviously isn't necessary but then CGI isn't necessary either. The reason for their exclusion previously were the same, the makers weren't capable of doing it. Messing about with time, plotting and story logic for dramatic and comedic effect is what Moffat is good at. Anybody who had the pleasure of watching Coupling knows that. So why shouldn't he do it?

The only reasons you've come up with so far are physical, causality reasons that simply don't apply to a decent storyteller.
Agree. For a non-Who example look at Star Trek. The recent film used time travel to reboot the universe so they could restart the franchise with new, young actors. But they did it with such style, and paid due respect to the history of the show, that they got away with it. Earlier Trek though has been on far shakier ground because of far ropier writing: destroy Voyager then do some timey wimey stuff so it never happened for example.

For me time travel is always nonsense, and anything written about it is fantasy. You can write whatever rules you like but they only exist to serve the plot and so are simply plot devices. If a better, or even just different, writer comes along and treats the rules differently there's no iron law they can't. Another more obscure example: Alan Moore on taking over Swamp Thing completely changed the character's basis. He got away with it as he's such a good writer, and the changes made sense for the stories he went on to tell.
User avatar
juice
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1942
Joined: Thu Feb 03, 2005 9:37 pm 0
Location: Sheffield!
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by juice »

Gorecki wrote:I think the problem is, Dio that you're approaching this with the logic of a physicist rather than the logic of a storyteller. I think your argument that buggering about with time removes any drama has been blown out of the water by A Christmas Carol, where it was used to great dramatic effect.
I'm not sure I agree with that - the final twist was nicely dramatic, but the main thing that "time buggering" was used for in ACC was for the comedy Christmas jaunts. Hey look, the Doctor's wearing a fez again!

Time buggering also renders the entire plot moot. The Doctor has always been free to meddle with other people's timelines, but in ACC, the Doctor is essentially changing his own past (i.e. all the time he spent with "current" Kazran): if he can do it now, why didn't he do it before the disaster? What stopped him from simply jumping onto the ship two hours earlier and dealing with the problem then?

(as KC argues, you could make the case that the Doctor was interested in "saving" Kazran - but surely he could have rescued the ship and then undertaken this task *without* risking several thousand lives? The Doctor would have to be a psychopathic egomaniac to be willing to gamble that much!)

This isn't something which was allowed in the past - in the original DW, it took serious amounts of effort from the timelords to allow this (e.g. Genesis of the Daleks, the Three timelords) and even RTD generally adhered to this rule, even if he was keen on timeline-resetting deus-ex-machinas.
Dio wrote:Why is it necessary now?
Well it very obviously isn't necessary but then CGI isn't necessary either.
...
The only reasons you've come up with so far are physical, causality reasons that simply don't apply to a decent storyteller.[/quote]
A decent storyteller doesn't have to break canon to write a good story - nor does he write a story filled with so many blatant plotholes. For instance, Issac Asimov spent years figuring out ways to write interesting stories based around the three laws of robotics *without* ever breaking them.

There *has* to be rules and limits, as otherwise writers have nothing to work with. Superman is a perfect example: without Kryptonite and lead, there's virtually nothing he can't do. Where's the dramatic tension in writing stories for someone who can solve any problem with super-speed, super-strength and laser-eye vision? Conversely, limits often provide a hook to hang a script off. E4's Misfits is a perfect example - who would have thought having the ability to control cheese and milk would make someone a perfect assassin?

(interestingly, if you look on Wikipedia, there's been a pitched battle throughout Dr Who's entire timeline to limit it's use "On the basis that a device that could help in any situation was very limiting for the script")

There's also a further issue with overusing a plot device: once the extraordinary becomes ordinary and familiar, it's no longer interesting - and it may also become ridiculed and viewed as a cliche, further diminishing it's effectiveness.

So, to my mind, giving the Doctor the ability to freely manipulate events in his own timeline was *not* necessary, neither was it desirable and nor is it good in the long term for the show as a whole. It could well be that Moffat is doing something clever - he's already at least partly broken away from "Doctor Who = The Messiah" theme that RTD loved so much, but we'll have to wait until the end of the second season to see if he's capable of maintaining the show in the long term...
http://www.caffeinated.org.uk/spectrum/ - Spectrum reviews with animated screenshots!
http://www.xboxindiegames.co.uk/ - Xbox Indie Game reviews - 1050 and counting!
c64audio
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1657
Joined: Thu Apr 25, 2002 5:34 pm 0
Location: In the Mobile Sphere
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by c64audio »

> Doctor Who = The Messiah

Haha! I see what Moffat is doing now:

"He's not the Messiah. He's a very naughty boy!"
Chris Abbott
Remixer and mobile thingywotsit.
Post Reply