I understand what you mean, and the Doctor did explain that his title was more a statement of intent. I could consider it rather as I count my ex-boyfriends, which I usually number as four (Tim the hippioid, Alan the biker, Alan the Hat and Meow). There was someone else who I believed myself to be in a requited romantic relationship with, with whom I lived for some time in what grew to be a state of terror induced by mental and physical abuse. I suppose he would be #1.5; I cannot bring myself to consider him the true #2. Is that disassociation still not a form of denial, though? I can think of no definition of 'boyfriend' or 'romantic partner' that fits the four but does not fit him. I just want to shut him out of my emotional history by refusing to acknowledge him despite him, like the others, having been a major influence on who I am today. I have struck him out so forcefully that I have even forgotten about him when psychiatrists have asked me about previous relationships and past abuse.Darkflame wrote:The dialogue also basically said "thats me...but it isnt the Doctor". I don't think he is denighing its part of him, merely denighing its a part worthy of the title.
It also gets around counting issues a bit. If he doesn't count as a doctor, the numbering remains the same where-ever he goes in the order.
(still counts as a regeneration though)
So, perhaps Hurt's is incarnation 8.5. Perhaps also, however, it does the Doctor no good to continue to pretend that he wasn't objectively the true 9th, just as my Paul was objectively my 2nd.






