The Wonderful NHS in the UK
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
The complaint about TTIP is that it would let US companies sue the govt. But that's already possible. If you had any doubts then the actual case of Raython, a US defence contractor, successfully suing the govt. should convince you.
PFI started under Major, not Thatcher and has continued since. So both (or all three) parties are buried up to their necks in shameful behaviour over this? Then there's nothing to worry about as a future govt. isn't going to be cancelling contracts and triggering expensive law suits. There just isn't support among the major parties for large scale renationalisation for idealogical reasons.
PFI started under Major, not Thatcher and has continued since. So both (or all three) parties are buried up to their necks in shameful behaviour over this? Then there's nothing to worry about as a future govt. isn't going to be cancelling contracts and triggering expensive law suits. There just isn't support among the major parties for large scale renationalisation for idealogical reasons.
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
"Raytheon."
TTIP expands govt exposure to litigation because it gives US equal RIGHTS to BID and TENDER on EU markets - and if prevented from doing so sue via a secret court system.
The example above is completely different.
YES it was SNATCHER who SNATCHED the PFI idea from Australia.
YES we have had 30+ years of economic deviancy, regardless of which of the two horses whiskers crossed the line first.
Here's a little primer on ISDS you.
[youtube]spBdTcaY3_Q#t[/youtube]
TTIP expands govt exposure to litigation because it gives US equal RIGHTS to BID and TENDER on EU markets - and if prevented from doing so sue via a secret court system.
The example above is completely different.
YES it was SNATCHER who SNATCHED the PFI idea from Australia.
YES we have had 30+ years of economic deviancy, regardless of which of the two horses whiskers crossed the line first.
Here's a little primer on ISDS you.
[youtube]spBdTcaY3_Q#t[/youtube]
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
Always good to see what the other side are saying.
Some of this Forbes article is just
.
Love the framng of "ISDS enables foreign investors to circumvent domestic legal processes and sue host governments in third-party arbitration tribunals for unfair or discriminatory treatment " as a positive.
The fawning over "MNCs". "Multinational companies are among the most successful and sophisticated companies in the world!"
Speaking as if MNCs are poor wittle kittens...only pleasure they get in life is enhancing and emboldening US interests. Sniff... :
http://www.forbes.com/sites/danikenson/ ... greements/
Some of this Forbes article is just
Love the framng of "ISDS enables foreign investors to circumvent domestic legal processes and sue host governments in third-party arbitration tribunals for unfair or discriminatory treatment " as a positive.
The fawning over "MNCs". "Multinational companies are among the most successful and sophisticated companies in the world!"
Speaking as if MNCs are poor wittle kittens...only pleasure they get in life is enhancing and emboldening US interests. Sniff... :
http://www.forbes.com/sites/danikenson/ ... greements/
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
You still don't get it, despite the Raytheon case essentially proving my point. TTIP won't make it easier for multinationals to sue the govt. as they can already do so. They have the resources, the offices and lawyers in every country, the experience to take on governments and win. The laws are already in place to let them do so: contract law and the common law mostly.
The problem for small firms is they may not have the resources and experience for this. So doing business with governments in other countries is much more risky for them. If things go wrong they face a dilemma: spend large amounts of time and money suing the govt., using a legal system they have no experience of; or walk away. This puts the government in a much stronger position and the firm in a much weaker one, so far fewer small firms are able or willing to do these deals. It's left to multinationals who benefit from the lack of ISDS (which may be why Forbes is against it).
Another feature of ISDS is it should help EU, including British, firms especially. The US legal system is particularly expensive, and the government there is a particularly strong adversary. Having an alternative to the legal system for small EU firms will be of great benefit to them if they're doing business with bits of government in the US.
The problem for small firms is they may not have the resources and experience for this. So doing business with governments in other countries is much more risky for them. If things go wrong they face a dilemma: spend large amounts of time and money suing the govt., using a legal system they have no experience of; or walk away. This puts the government in a much stronger position and the firm in a much weaker one, so far fewer small firms are able or willing to do these deals. It's left to multinationals who benefit from the lack of ISDS (which may be why Forbes is against it).
Another feature of ISDS is it should help EU, including British, firms especially. The US legal system is particularly expensive, and the government there is a particularly strong adversary. Having an alternative to the legal system for small EU firms will be of great benefit to them if they're doing business with bits of government in the US.
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
It's not the ability to sue for breach of contract that worries people it's the idea they can sue for the loss of profits based on changes in law e.g. complete ban on cigarettes would entitle the cigarette companies to sue for loss of profit (illustration purposes only)pogo wrote:You still don't get it, despite the Raytheon case essentially proving my point. TTIP won't make it easier for multinationals to sue the govt. as they can already do so. They have the resources, the offices and lawyers in every country, the experience to take on governments and win. The laws are already in place to let them do so: contract law and the common law mostly.
The problem for small firms is they may not have the resources and experience for this. So doing business with governments in other countries is much more risky for them. If things go wrong they face a dilemma: spend large amounts of time and money suing the govt., using a legal system they have no experience of; or walk away. This puts the government in a much stronger position and the firm in a much weaker one, so far fewer small firms are able or willing to do these deals. It's left to multinationals who benefit from the lack of ISDS (which may be why Forbes is against it).
Another feature of ISDS is it should help EU, including British, firms especially. The US legal system is particularly expensive, and the government there is a particularly strong adversary. Having an alternative to the legal system for small EU firms will be of great benefit to them if they're doing business with bits of government in the US.
Not through a court but through investor state dispute settlement so the discussions are not open
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
But they couldn't. If the govt. decided to ban tobacco, or alcohol, or coffee, then firms would be able to do nothing except adapt. the govt. makes decisions like this all the time; it changes duty, changes regulations on packaging, on who can buy products and where, and firms have to put up with it. The recent big change to how tobacco's displayed in many stores (it isn't on display anymore) will have materially affected the profits of firms but there's nothing they can do. And it's only the latest in a long line of laws restricting tobacco products.
ISDS won't change this. Firms will still be subject to the law of the land, whatever the govt. decides it should be. ISDS just gives another venue for resolving disputes, cheaper and easier than the courts.
As I noted earlier it's even possible for a govt. to get around being sued, and so get around being taken to arbitration, by changing the law. They could change the law around a particular case such as the e-Borders one, or introduce a generic 'the govt. can't be sued' law. Perfectly possible, but no sane government would do it, as firms would suddenly be very reluctant to do business with the government, and the country would become one of those shunned by private firms and investors as too risky.
ISDS won't change this. Firms will still be subject to the law of the land, whatever the govt. decides it should be. ISDS just gives another venue for resolving disputes, cheaper and easier than the courts.
As I noted earlier it's even possible for a govt. to get around being sued, and so get around being taken to arbitration, by changing the law. They could change the law around a particular case such as the e-Borders one, or introduce a generic 'the govt. can't be sued' law. Perfectly possible, but no sane government would do it, as firms would suddenly be very reluctant to do business with the government, and the country would become one of those shunned by private firms and investors as too risky.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
This is interesting:
An American doctor experiences an NHS emergency room
An example of an American family taking advantage of our free healthcare. Their point is the NHS isn't the horror story it's made out to be in the US (see also this comment) but it's also notable that they aren't charged though they surely should be.
I suspect there are two reasons for this. One is it's her son that needs help. With our individualised health care system the child is the patient and you can't easily bill a child. Second it's an emergency, or at least urgent, health situation and the NHS is overwhelmingly set up to treat first, ask questions later.
And this is I think how it should be. Doing it any other way, so e.g. people are asked first about their right to free care and ability to pay, would be massively disruptive and a much worse experience for all. Designing urgent care so all your interactions can be tracked and billed would be an extra layer of bureaucracy and complexity we can do without.
Maybe the mother will be billed later, maybe not, but I don't think it matters much. The odd child falling ill on holiday is not going to bankrupt the NHS. People coming here with chronic illnesses are more of a problem, if it happens, but I've not seen any evidence of it.
An American doctor experiences an NHS emergency room
An example of an American family taking advantage of our free healthcare. Their point is the NHS isn't the horror story it's made out to be in the US (see also this comment) but it's also notable that they aren't charged though they surely should be.
I suspect there are two reasons for this. One is it's her son that needs help. With our individualised health care system the child is the patient and you can't easily bill a child. Second it's an emergency, or at least urgent, health situation and the NHS is overwhelmingly set up to treat first, ask questions later.
And this is I think how it should be. Doing it any other way, so e.g. people are asked first about their right to free care and ability to pay, would be massively disruptive and a much worse experience for all. Designing urgent care so all your interactions can be tracked and billed would be an extra layer of bureaucracy and complexity we can do without.
Maybe the mother will be billed later, maybe not, but I don't think it matters much. The odd child falling ill on holiday is not going to bankrupt the NHS. People coming here with chronic illnesses are more of a problem, if it happens, but I've not seen any evidence of it.
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
I don't think that's true. The proposal is to have similar terms to the treaty US has with other countries through NAFTA and that has been used to sue governments for regulatory change or the process in which regulatory change was made.pogo wrote:But they couldn't. If the govt. decided to ban tobacco, or alcohol, or coffee, then firms would be able to do nothing except adapt.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
There are cases of governments being sued/taken to arbitration for regulations that were discriminatory. E.g.
The WTO Appellate Body Outlaws Discrimination in U.S. Flavored Cigarette Ban
The US had banned flavoured cigarettes except menthol and tobacco (so unflavoured I guess). But this discriminated against clove tobacco from Indonesia, who sued and won at the WTO. Countries can write regulations like this but they can't do so in a way that favours a domestic product (menthol cigarettes) over a foreign one (clove cigarettes).
This seems to come up quite a lot: regulations whether by design or accident end up discriminating against particular, usually foreign, firms and products and so breach the rules of bodies such as the WTO. Regulations have to be based on good policy reasons, and not discriminate against particular firms or products. If the US had banned all artificial flavours they probably would have been OK.
The WTO Appellate Body Outlaws Discrimination in U.S. Flavored Cigarette Ban
The US had banned flavoured cigarettes except menthol and tobacco (so unflavoured I guess). But this discriminated against clove tobacco from Indonesia, who sued and won at the WTO. Countries can write regulations like this but they can't do so in a way that favours a domestic product (menthol cigarettes) over a foreign one (clove cigarettes).
This seems to come up quite a lot: regulations whether by design or accident end up discriminating against particular, usually foreign, firms and products and so breach the rules of bodies such as the WTO. Regulations have to be based on good policy reasons, and not discriminate against particular firms or products. If the US had banned all artificial flavours they probably would have been OK.
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
pogo wrote:But they couldn't. If the govt. decided to ban tobacco, or alcohol, or coffee, then firms would be able to do nothing except adapt. the govt. makes decisions like this all the time; it changes duty, changes regulations on packaging, on who can buy products and where, and firms have to put up with it. The recent big change to how tobacco's displayed in many stores (it isn't on display anymore) will have materially affected the profits of firms but there's nothing they can do. And it's only the latest in a long line of laws restricting tobacco products.
ISDS won't change this. Firms will still be subject to the law of the land, whatever the govt. decides it should be. ISDS just gives another venue for resolving disputes, cheaper and easier than the courts.
As I noted earlier it's even possible for a govt. to get around being sued, and so get around being taken to arbitration, by changing the law. They could change the law around a particular case such as the e-Borders one, or introduce a generic 'the govt. can't be sued' law. Perfectly possible, but no sane government would do it, as firms would suddenly be very reluctant to do business with the government, and the country would become one of those shunned by private firms and investors as too risky.
If a government decides for health and safety reasons to ban something they can be sued under free trade agreements where businesses have invested in doing things prior to their banning. ISDS are secret and therefore not open to scrutiny by the public so we won't know what's going on. So changing the law is no longer a simple act of parliament if there are potential losses they could be sued for.
Arbitration is about resolving a contractual dispute a potential avenue to be pursued before resorting to the courts. It is not necessarily binding unless both parties agree and the company still has the right to sue if they feel the arbitration result is not satisfactory.
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
Not come across that one before but it's an example of what I just wrote: governments can enact legislation but not in a arbitrary way that discriminates against particular firms or countries.
Canadian government to be sued over Quebec fracking ban
I.e. they're not objecting to the Quebec govt. introducing a bill banning fracking everywhere, or banning it in some places based on scientific evidence. They're objecting to the govt. banning fracking just where Lone Pine planned to do it, before a study has been done. Whether this means the government was 'arbitrary, capricious' or not will be for the arbitrators to decide.
Canadian government to be sued over Quebec fracking ban
Due to public pressure and scientific studies linking USGE to pollution of air, soils and water, the Quebec Government introduced Bill 18 into the Quebec National Assembly, which revoked all permits related to oil and gas under the St. Lawrence River.
The Bill received Royal Assent and a further document, Bill 37 placed a moratorium on the USGE project in June 2011, which was then expanded to autumn 2012. The moratorium banned drilling under the St. Lawrence river until an environmental evaluation of the potential effects of USGE on the environment were in place.
...
“[we] submit this arbitration on bahalf of the Enterprise under Article 1117 of the NAFTA, for the arbitrary, capricious, and illegal revocation of the Enterprise’s valuable right to mine for oil and gas under the St. Lawrence River by the Government of Quebec without due process, without compensation, and with no cognizable public purpose. The Government of Canada is responsible for Quebec’s acts under the NAFTA and applicable principles of international law.”
I.e. they're not objecting to the Quebec govt. introducing a bill banning fracking everywhere, or banning it in some places based on scientific evidence. They're objecting to the govt. banning fracking just where Lone Pine planned to do it, before a study has been done. Whether this means the government was 'arbitrary, capricious' or not will be for the arbitrators to decide.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
The question in the end comes down to Joe Stalin's alleged:VNVObit wrote:pogo wrote:But they couldn't. If the govt. decided to ban tobacco, or alcohol, or coffee, then firms would be able to do nothing except adapt. the govt. makes decisions like this all the time; it changes duty, changes regulations on packaging, on who can buy products and where, and firms have to put up with it. The recent big change to how tobacco's displayed in many stores (it isn't on display anymore) will have materially affected the profits of firms but there's nothing they can do. And it's only the latest in a long line of laws restricting tobacco products.
ISDS won't change this. Firms will still be subject to the law of the land, whatever the govt. decides it should be. ISDS just gives another venue for resolving disputes, cheaper and easier than the courts.
As I noted earlier it's even possible for a govt. to get around being sued, and so get around being taken to arbitration, by changing the law. They could change the law around a particular case such as the e-Borders one, or introduce a generic 'the govt. can't be sued' law. Perfectly possible, but no sane government would do it, as firms would suddenly be very reluctant to do business with the government, and the country would become one of those shunned by private firms and investors as too risky.
If a government decides for health and safety reasons to ban something they can be sued under free trade agreements where businesses have invested in doing things prior to their banning. ISDS are secret and therefore not open to scrutiny by the public so we won't know what's going on. So changing the law is no longer a simple act of parliament if there are potential losses they could be sued for.
Arbitration is about resolving a contractual dispute a potential avenue to be pursued before resorting to the courts. It is not necessarily binding unless both parties agree and the company still has the right to sue if they feel the arbitration result is not satisfactory.
If the USA goes tits up, this treaty isn't worth the price of the paper it's not written on.How many divisions do the IMF have?
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
pogo wrote:Not come across that one before but it's an example of what I just wrote: governments can enact legislation but not in a arbitrary way that discriminates against particular firms or countries.
Canadian government to be sued over Quebec fracking ban
Due to public pressure and scientific studies linking USGE to pollution of air, soils and water, the Quebec Government introduced Bill 18 into the Quebec National Assembly, which revoked all permits related to oil and gas under the St. Lawrence River.
The Bill received Royal Assent and a further document, Bill 37 placed a moratorium on the USGE project in June 2011, which was then expanded to autumn 2012. The moratorium banned drilling under the St. Lawrence river until an environmental evaluation of the potential effects of USGE on the environment were in place.
...
“[we] submit this arbitration on bahalf of the Enterprise under Article 1117 of the NAFTA, for the arbitrary, capricious, and illegal revocation of the Enterprise’s valuable right to mine for oil and gas under the St. Lawrence River by the Government of Quebec without due process, without compensation, and with no cognizable public purpose. The Government of Canada is responsible for Quebec’s acts under the NAFTA and applicable principles of international law.”
I.e. they're not objecting to the Quebec govt. introducing a bill banning fracking everywhere, or banning it in some places based on scientific evidence. They're objecting to the govt. banning fracking just where Lone Pine planned to do it, before a study has been done. Whether this means the government was 'arbitrary, capricious' or not will be for the arbitrators to decide.
Actually banning it until a study has been completed based on public pressure (remember governments are supposed to enact the will of the people - albeit rarely these days) and scientific studies. So they were in effect ensuring nothing potentially detrimental to people's health could be carried out prior to completion of environmental impact assessment. Perfectly reasonable and sensible decision.
regardless it sounds like the company took a high risk gamble (it would be foolish to invest millions if you didn't consider potential risks), profits are not materialising so they are filing for arbitration to recover their "profits"
It's effectively Chapter 11 of NAFTA where foreign companies have in effect greater rights to sue governments than the citizens of that country. The concern is TTIP effectively restates this
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
Governments are meant to act in the interest of the whole population, not just local special interests. Its precisely that sort of government that's given the UK a broken housing market, as it's been shaped far too much by local nimbys vetoing or at least severely limiting much needed development up and down the country. Government's job is very often to go against local interests when an overriding national interest is at stake. Such as having a coherent, workable energy policy.VNVObit wrote:Actually banning it until a study has been completed based on public pressure (remember governments are supposed to enact the will of the people - albeit rarely these days) and scientific studies. So they were in effect ensuring nothing potentially detrimental to people's health could be carried out prior to completion of environmental impact assessment. Perfectly reasonable and sensible decision.
- VNVObit
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4072
- Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
- PSN: VNV_Obit
- Location: London
Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK
pogo wrote:
Governments are meant to act in the interest of the whole population, not just local special interests. Its precisely that sort of government that's given the UK a broken housing market, as it's been shaped far too much by local nimbys vetoing or at least severely limiting much needed development up and down the country. Government's job is very often to go against local interests when an overriding national interest is at stake. Such as having a coherent, workable energy policy.
the quote you provided said due to public pressure not due to a pressure group so bemused how that's suddenly pandering to local interests
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
Tony Wakeford
My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single
"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
