Um, what?KlaxonCow wrote:Every Timelord - not just the Doctor - has regenerated as the same gender.


Um, what?KlaxonCow wrote:Every Timelord - not just the Doctor - has regenerated as the same gender.




Nope. After the funeral pyre the ring was used to resurrect the Master and he returned in the same male body as before, albeit blonder.KlaxonCow wrote:…
Now, I know what's coming. "What about Missy?".
Well, simply, that wasn't a regeneration. The Master died. His body was burnt on a funeral pyre. But he stored his "soul" - for want of a better word - inside a ring that we see a woman pick up.
The Master's gender swap has narrative explanation. He did not regenerate, as his previous Timelord body no longer exists. It was burnt. It's gone. He rather stole someone else's body - who happened to be a woman - and, well, Missy has since commented that, once in possession of a female body, she now much prefers it.
…
"Fantastic bloke. He had that snake as a tattoo in every regeneration. Didn’t feel like himself unless he had that tattoo. Or herself a couple of times. Oo hoo! She was a bad girl!"F-ZeroOne wrote:Theres also the "Corsair", who I believe was female when they died but its been implied that they'd been around for a while and may not have been the same gender all the time.


Oh, DW is possibly uniquely free in its ability to continually reinvent itself with no more than token regard for previous 'canon'. I am mostly countering proposed objections to that freedom.Governmentyard wrote:There's plenty of nerd argument to be had over this. I don't really care for much of it because they clearly make up the rules as they go along. Because contemporary folk tale. I do know that growing up there were very, very few male role models in the media that I was able to identify with but The Doctor certainly was. I accept that I'm probably in a minority saying that, and obviously we've room for plenty of extra female role models on top of what we've got. Heaven knows I've had my rants about weak female characterisation in sci/fantasy films on here recently. But this character is uniquely important to me, and his gender is part of why.
The Doctor gender debate is happening because this change in any main character of anything always causes it. It quickly becomes a technical or semantic debate because people are partaking to shore up their self-image by winning. All of which ignores my point above - the fact that a character is or is not the same gender as oneself can define your attachment to them and people are perfectly entitled to feel disenfranchised when that changes. And to say so without being brigaded by rabid folks from either end of the political spectrum.
Which none of them seem to realise is actually a circle.



I have just read that Chibnall's scripts, along with Whithouse's and Gatiss's, did not require as much rewriting from Moffat as those from other writers.I wrote:… those previous episodes seem to me to have been mostly written to order rather than displaying much style of his own, although both Davis and Moffat could rewrite scripts quite heavily, with Davis apparently making Moffat's mostly an exception.
