Chibnall.... maintain quality.....
Christ, if he's struggling to maintain this soulless crap for 10 episodes, then there's no hope.
There's a lesson here about nepotism I think, if Jodie is going as well. Hire on acting and writing abilities, not on whether they're mates from Broadchurch.
If there's a genuine problem with the workload (and possibly there is; RTD was famously a workaholic and Moffat only managed 5 series in 7 years), the solution would be to split the workload, like in the old days - the showrunner shouldn't need to be doubling as script editor & writing half the episodes himself. But it is particularly galling, if true, that it's Chibnall complaining about it, as his writing feels like it's had less work put into it than Moffat's or Rusty's.
Ollie wrote:If there's a genuine problem with the workload (and possibly there is; RTD was famously a workaholic and Moffat only managed 5 series in 7 years), the solution would be to split the workload, like in the old days - the showrunner shouldn't need to be doubling as script editor & writing half the episodes himself. But it is particularly galling, if true, that it's Chibnall complaining about it, as his writing feels like it's had less work put into it than Moffat's or Rusty's.
Indeed, in the classic years script editors were forbidden from writing their own scripts (although workarounds were sometimes found, especially in periods of desperation).
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Ollie wrote:If there's a genuine problem with the workload (and possibly there is; RTD was famously a workaholic and Moffat only managed 5 series in 7 years), the solution would be to split the workload, like in the old days - the showrunner shouldn't need to be doubling as script editor & writing half the episodes himself. But it is particularly galling, if true, that it's Chibnall complaining about it, as his writing feels like it's had less work put into it than Moffat's or Rusty's.
Indeed, in the classic years script editors were forbidden from writing their own scripts (although workarounds were sometimes found, especially in periods of desperation).
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Those early years - effectively 25-minute episodes. Now they are nearly double that.
Even in McCoy's era there was three/four cameras at most. Now we have multiple cameras, special FX rigs, green screen and months in postproduction.
That order of ten episodes a year from the BBC is equivalent to making five feature films a year.
And behind the scenes has changed. Most TV series have the showrunner in charge, often the main creator/writer. They set the tone, so taking them out of the writing equation is difficult.
Disappointing if the rumours of them leaving are true.
merman wrote:Those early years - effectively 25-minute episodes. Now they are nearly double that.
Even in McCoy's era there was three/four cameras at most. Now we have multiple cameras, special FX rigs, green screen and months in postproduction.
I generally agree but there is usually only a single camera these days, resulting in far longer shoot times to film different angles.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Rather enjoyed that one. Great to see some Angry Doctor and some very good "pwn them with a powerful lecture" moments. Keeping the rest of the team busy instead of just having them standing around asking questions helped as well, though I feel the number of companions still dilutes the opportunities for character development too much.
King James hamming it up could have got annoying but they redeemed it with his character moments with the Doctor - who also got her own moments at the same time she was alone with him. Little disappointed with the "aliens trapped in prison accidentally let out" resolution, but then it is Doctor Who, what else was it going to be?!
It wasn't good. It wasn't bad, wasn't unwatchable, but wasn't good. They brought in King James as some sort of throwaway NPC that didn't matter to the campaign. There was zero character development and the story didn't go anywhere.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Zero character development is par for the course. Apparently these four non-Chibnall-written episodes (6-9) were designed to be interchangeable, so they could switch the order about if they wanted - so any furtherment of character arcs would have been a strict no-no.
Ollie wrote:Apparently these four non-Chibnall-written episodes (6-9) were designed to be interchangeable
Something I like, given how earlier seasons tried to be clever and came across as pretentious. It's a TV show and I appreciate good stories being contained to an episode or two. Being ~1 hour each allows plenty of room for that.
Ollie wrote:so any furtherment of character arcs would have been a strict no-no.
That's not so. "Demons in Punjab" is a direct example of how it can be done. The Simpsons has over 600 episodes that are all interchangeable but frequently had character driven stories.
"The Witchfinders" was just lazy. Something the series can't afford at this stage.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
Great guest appearance, but my major complaint was the way we got to the conclusion - it was very clumsily explained (with the "spark" off the ducking stool as the first inkling of the solution). "By the way, it's aliens" felt lazy when the rest of the characters were so strong.