I would like to recommend
Tesis, the first feature film by Abre Los Ojos director Alejandro Amenábar. It is a very suspenseful and critically acclaimed thriller about a female student who investigates snuff videos.
I would also like to recommend Guillermo del Toros Spanish/Mexican movies
The Devil's Backbone, a beautiful and original ghost story set in a remote orphanage in the 1930s, and
Cronos, a fun and well-made twist on the vampire myth.
If you like your films a bit strange then check out something by Julio Medem. My favourite is probably
Tierra, a beautiful drama about a bug exterminator with mental and romantic problems.