Hiroshima anniversary yesterday

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
ElfQrin
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4384
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2003 12:55 pm 0
Location: Italy
Contact:

Post by ElfQrin »

DutchLlama wrote: Don't we forget that both Germany and Japan (and Italy for that matter) attacked and occupied their neighbours? Or should we ignore that so we can go on with our hobby of mindless America bashing? :roll:
Ah, so the secret is that you don't have to invade your neighbours... which means as long as USA doesn't invade Canada or Mexico everything is fine?

Then why they had to lie to invade Iraq? They could just have said "They're not our neighbours".

:roll:
Last edited by ElfQrin on Sun Aug 07, 2005 3:16 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Post by gravy »

Gorecki wrote:My knowledge of WW2 history is fairly basic so could somebody answer some questions for me.

What was the reasons for bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Were they important military/industrial centres or was it just a case of terrorising the Japanese into surrendering? And if it was the latter, what was the reason behind dropping the second bomb, surely the first would have been enough?

How close was Japan to surrendering anyway? I've heard several left-wingers argue that Japan were on the brink of surrendering (some have even claimed that they actually did try to surrender but it was rejected by the US) and that dropping a nuclear bomb was just Americas way of showing off to the Russians.


There's a lot of talk about how nuclear weapons ended WW2 early but this is always stated as fact and rarely questioned or fully explained. A bit of background knowledge would be nice.
My understanding is that the Japanese hugh command was try to negeotiate a conditional surrender via the Russians which would let them keep their emperor.

Truman wanted unconditional surrender, ordered the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki and then gave the Japanese the conditional surrender they were angling for in the first place.

I think the real reason the bombings went ahead despite there not neccessarily being a need for them to happen were that US had invested too much time and money into their development for them not to be used.

It also made an incredibly strong statement to the Soviet Union about how things would be post war.

It's pretty bad but could have been a lot worst. There a further 15 atomic bombings planned after Nagasaki.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Post by zip accident »

Gorecki wrote:

How close was Japan to surrendering anyway?
Dunno. It's been argued both ways. There was a two week delay between the first and second bombs, so presumably the Japanese had time to surrender after the first. The second, could be taken to imply a production line, though in fact they were different designs, and a third would perhaps have required months.
I've heard several left-wingers argue that Japan were on the brink of surrendering (some have even claimed that they actually did try to surrender but it was rejected by the US) and that dropping a nuclear bomb was just Americas way of showing off to the Russians.
I've heard that one. Uncle Joe was a pretty scary guy. The Russian tanks beat the panzers. So a continuation of the war in Europe might have been on the cards, without allied bombing capability, and the A bombs. Then again, maybe not. Who can tell? Stalin's dead and can't tell us what he'd have done. Equally, Trueman is dead, and he decided that the A bomb should be dropped.
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Post by gravy »

A nice lot of info here

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bom ... d_Nagasaki

The US military's post bombing assesment of whether the use of nuclear weapons was justified is pretty damning.
User avatar
Perkunas
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2058
Joined: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Tokyo
Contact:

Post by Perkunas »

Gorecki wrote:My knowledge of WW2 history is fairly basic so could somebody answer some questions for me.

What was the reasons for bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Were they important military/industrial centres or was it just a case of terrorising the Japanese into surrendering? And if it was the latter, what was the reason behind dropping the second bomb, surely the first would have been enough?

How close was Japan to surrendering anyway? I've heard several left-wingers argue that Japan were on the brink of surrendering (some have even claimed that they actually did try to surrender but it was rejected by the US) and that dropping a nuclear bomb was just Americas way of showing off to the Russians.

There's a lot of talk about how nuclear weapons ended WW2 early but this is always stated as fact and rarely questioned or fully explained. A bit of background knowledge would be nice.
There was a nice documentary (three parts) on television this week in Belgium (Canvas) about this topic.

There were several reasons for the use of the atom bombs on Japan.

First of all, the United States had invested an insane amount of resources on the Manhattan project (100.000 people, $200 billion budget IIRC). They only tested one atom bomb in New Mexico, so they knew little/nothing about radio-active fallout and such. Japan was both a target (force Japan to surrender) as a 'testing ground' (what is the impact on an urban enviroment?) for two types of nuclear weapons: an A-Bomb and a Hydrogen bomb.

Secondly, the Americans feared the Japanese just wouldn't surrender at all, which would mean a battle like Okinawa on a scale of the size of Japan. Intelligence knew the Imperial Army was moving a large number of army divisions to the coasts of Kyushu (the most southern part of Japan) at an alarming rate, which would mean a massacre as the Allied wanted to invade that part of Japan (they predicted a 1:3 kill rate), in order to attack the main island later in 1946.

Also, Japan still had a lot of airplanes (20.000 IIRC), which could be used as Kamikazes on the landing fleet. This meant the entire (costly) American pacific fleet was vulnerable. They didn't really know how far the Japanese would go, if they would break eventually, or if they would fight to their deaths and the annihilation of their homeland.

If they Japanese wouldn't have surrendered, one of the plans was to shell Kyushu with a handfull atom bombs (from ships), in order to wipe out most of the Japanese army. The invading American forces would've been killed through radiation as well, however...

Japan, however, had tried to negotiate with Moscow shortly before the Russians declared war on Japan (one of the reasons being they didn't want to have a war on two fronts, plus they feared Japan would become a communist state if the Russians were allowed to invade Japan). At one point the Japanese accepted an (near) unconditional surrender, on the condition that the emperor would retain both his symbolic as politic powers. But this was rejected.

The Japanese were close to surrendering to the Americans before the two atom bombs, but they wanted to make it seem as if Japan was unlikely to surrender/was still very strong, so they would have a stronger position in peace negotiations, in which they tried to 'force' the Americans (and vice versa of course).

Both Nagasaki and Hiroshima were of some importance (I believe Hiroshima housed a large Mitsubishi factory), but still smaller than cities like Tokyo or Osaka.


Next year I'll be studying Japanology at university, I am sure I'll be able to tell much more then. ;)
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

gravy wrote:A nice lot of info here

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bom ... d_Nagasaki

The US military's post bombing assesment of whether the use of nuclear weapons was justified is pretty damning.
Which was discovered after Japan had surrendered and people could
be interviewed. The same Japanese leadership that knew the game
was up also lead to things like this:
In addition, the Japanese had organized nearly all adult civilians into the Patriotic Citizens Fighting Corps to perform combat support, and ultimately combat jobs. Weapons and training were generally lacking, but they were expected to make do with what they had.
One mobilized high school girl, Yukiko Kasai, found herself issued an awl and told, "Even killing one American soldier will do. ... You must aim for the abdomen." (Richard B. Frank, Downfall)
Maybe it's just me but when you are planning on using schoolgirls
to fight your war it's time to look at other options. Particularly when
the choice might have been between US, Russian or Chinese
occupation.
User avatar
DutchLlama
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6038
Joined: Fri May 03, 2002 1:09 pm 0
Location: Fhloston Paradise with llovely Leeloo... Sweet! :)

Post by DutchLlama »

Well it was a terrifying and brutal war.

And to give the other side of the medal, please visit these Wikipedia sites too:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanjing_Massacre
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731

The US may have done evil things during WW2, but does that make them the greatest evil of the war?

If you listen to some diatribes on the left (e.g. from the International Socialists) the US was the agressor of WW2 with Japan as the victim. :roll:
Last edited by DutchLlama on Sun Aug 07, 2005 3:40 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Boy: "Have you met monsters before?" The Doctor: "Yes."
Boy: "Are you scared of them?" The Doctor: "No, they are scared of me!"
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Post by tufty »

It's a little offtopic, but my history teacher lived through the Dresden firebombings. Her descriptions thereof were graphic and uncompromising. Rather than shadows being left, she metioned things like corpses melted into the tar on the road. It takes a lot to reduce a class of 14-year-olds to tears, but she could manage it.

Fuck knows what it was like to live through the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings. I actually can't bear to think about it.

Simon
anon76235
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6712
Joined: Fri Jul 23, 2004 4:52 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: tyrwmuwyru,tyweiu,
PSN: r6wsmunwrtyurtmuwrty
Yahoo Messenger: 567.,uim576eiw65nuw6u
Location: rtumsrytu,sruyrtu,sytru

Post by anon76235 »

punkrulesok wrote:
Matrix wrote:bombs on this scale suck, nobody should have access to them, least of all America IMHO.
*Right* on! Unfortunately, man is not a peacefull entity, and I fear another world war will happen eventually, that will wipe out most of man kind.
theres always a war on.
User avatar
Kemper_Boyd
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 11967
Joined: Wed Jul 31, 2002 9:15 pm 0

Post by Kemper_Boyd »

Perkunas wrote:for two types of nuclear weapons: an A-Bomb and a Hydrogen bomb.
Not that it's particularly important but both bombs were A-Bombs (fission)
not Hydrogen (fusion). Little Boy (Hiroshima) was a uranium gun design,
Fat Man (Nagasaki) was a plutonium implosion design.
User avatar
DutchLlama
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6038
Joined: Fri May 03, 2002 1:09 pm 0
Location: Fhloston Paradise with llovely Leeloo... Sweet! :)

Post by DutchLlama »

ElfQrin wrote:
DutchLlama wrote: Don't we forget that both Germany and Japan (and Italy for that matter) attacked and occupied their neighbours? Or should we ignore that so we can go on with our hobby of mindless America bashing? :roll:
Ah, so the secret is that you don't have to invade your neighbours... which means as long as USA doesn't invade Canada or Mexico everything is fine?

Then why they had to lie to invade Iraq? They could just have said "They're not our neighbours".

:roll:
Well they could have stayed out of WWII altogether. Maybe we would have been much better off under the 'benevolent' rule of either Hitler or Stalin. :roll:
Boy: "Have you met monsters before?" The Doctor: "Yes."
Boy: "Are you scared of them?" The Doctor: "No, they are scared of me!"
User avatar
Perkunas
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2058
Joined: Tue Apr 13, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Tokyo
Contact:

Post by Perkunas »

Kemper_Boyd wrote:
Perkunas wrote:for two types of nuclear weapons: an A-Bomb and a Hydrogen bomb.
Not that it's particularly important but both bombs were A-Bombs (fission)
not Hydrogen (fusion). Little Boy (Hiroshima) was a uranium gun design,
Fat Man (Nagasaki) was a plutonium implosion design.
Oh right, I thought something else because the second bomb used (Nagasaki) packed a lot more force. I do know a fusion bomb consists of a fission bomb and a fusion bomb (the former being used to build up the necessairy heat for a more powerfull fusion).
User avatar
Gorecki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5962
Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer

Post by Gorecki »

Cheers for the info everyone. The Wikipedia links were particularly interesting, if still a million miles away from being conclusive. There's so much conflivting evidence and points of view that it seems impossible to have a definitive opinion on the morality of the bombings, especially when you take into account the millions of lives at stake on all sides. It's just too big to judge.
Tang Sou!
User avatar
Rev. Stuart Campbell
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3995
Joined: Sun Jan 05, 2003 4:38 pm 0
Location: From Heck

Post by Rev. Stuart Campbell »

DutchLlama wrote: Well they could have stayed out of WWII altogether. Maybe we would have been much better off under the 'benevolent' rule of either Hitler or Stalin. :roll:
The USA tried everything it could to stay out of WW2. Not until its hand was forced by Germany and Japan declaring war on it did the US take an active part. Which is one of the reasons it's so contemptible that so many Americans go on about how they saved Europe from the Nazis. Their contribution to the Allied war effort was by far the least of all the major participants.

I get annoyed by all the after-the-fact criticism of the dropping of the bombs, though. It's easy with hindsight to know what Japan would and wouldn't have done. There were more than enough grounds for the belief that they'd have fought to the bitter end, given how savagely they'd defended every last rock in the Pacific on the way to the home islands.

Secondly, Truman was under no obligation whatsoever to consider Japanese casualties. He was the leader of a nation which had been attacked without provocation by a murderous, empire-building enemy. If taking 100,000 Japanese lives with an A-bomb would have saved a single US soldier, it was not only Truman's right but his duty to his own people to use it.

Thirdly, it's very easy to construct a case that says without Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the terror of atomic destruction that ultimately kept the Cold War from turning into a hot one wouldn't have existed. Blowing up a desert test ground is interesting in theory, but only on seeing what the A-bomb did to real cities and real people could everyone have truly understood the apocalyptic horror that lay in wait in a subsequent world war. My own view is that Hiroshima and Nagasaki kept the peace in a world of incredible ideological and political tensions for five decades, and if the innocent victims have a legacy, surely it must be that.
http://wosland.podgamer.com
"You are a fucking bastard smeghead that continues
to prove people and pretend is doing nothing."
User avatar
Aglaranna
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 471
Joined: Sat Jul 16, 2005 1:07 pm 0
Location: Elvandar

Post by Aglaranna »

I was talking about this a little in work on Friday. My boss had found something on the web that said that about 45% of the people who survived the bombs were still alive today. How healthy they were, I don't remember. I think it was in New Scientist. He has a subscription.
http://www.newscientist.com/article.ns? ... 725115.900

I always remember a photograph in one of the Physics text books I used to use, of the back of a woman who had been burned in the bombings. She'd been wearing a check dress, and her burns had been in the same pattern - worse where the dark check had been.
Commit acts of random kindness and senseless beauty.
Avatar: Autumn Magic
http://www.amybrownart.com/
Post Reply