Cost of games is "crazy", says EA Montreal boss

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

lordP wrote:Gears of war $10 million, not including the unreal engine but including outsourcing to China 8O

http://www.gamesindustry.biz/content_page.php?aid=20176
You see .. outsourcing basically proves "the sad reality" that individual
labour cost (and cost of life) is so high that it's what makes quite up
the price.

You would make the same thing entierely in US or UK and it's probably
going to lift up costs 4x or 3x (if not more) just because what is considered
"normal average income for that kind of job" is lot higher.

That's one of the problems of our western societies "high standards of
life but at high costs", of course because quality is Quality there's always
a point where costs can't be reduced further without affecting it.

So basically we are "victims" of our own high standards and life models
of course.

The only thing that can be done here is to increase technology at max
but that anyway means "reduce the number of people employed"
and/or try to make the people "ultra efficient" but all this means raise up
lot expectations and complexity of the whole system.

And stress people loads.

And create a lot of problems.

Stop changing cell phones every month for a new model and buy all those anti-wrinkles
creams they show on TV and listening to all those loan/remortgaging
stuff and throw your CC in the bin, forget to use it and cut your balls
if you go overdraft.

And don't abuse student loans that you'll never be able to return back.

And smoke less, cigs are fucking expensive :wink:

Consumerism .. the curse of western world ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »



Stop changing cell phones every month for a new model and buy all those anti-wrinkles
creams they show on TV and listening to all those loan/remortgaging
stuff and throw your CC in the bin, forget to use it and cut your balls
if you go overdraft.

And don't abuse student loans that you'll never be able to return back.
I do all that and dont smoke, and still my Games are too expensive :lol:


The only solution I see is increaseing the amount of people playing games.
If everyone that watched movies, also played games, it would help costs a lot.
---
Technology can help with some things though....or purhapes it will one day become standard for every company that makes a real product to release a 3D version of it for game use. Which then could be just dumped into any games that need it. Free advertising for them, no-cost 3D models for developers.
Still, that only works for realistic games.


i remember reading an opinion piece that said the demands of the next gen consoles also pushes the price up each time, since more polygons etc are needed, & i suppose for the big companies each is trying to outdo the other technically so the bar is also raised in that way...
Of course.
Look at Too Human:
It was due to be released as an 80 Hour PS1 game.
Its now split into 3 Xbox360 games.

So,effectively, to pay for a vastely better graphics, they had to break the game down smaller, and hopefully, get 3 lots of cash back on the investiment.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Darkflame wrote:


Stop changing cell phones every month for a new model and buy all those anti-wrinkles
creams they show on TV and listening to all those loan/remortgaging
stuff and throw your CC in the bin, forget to use it and cut your balls
if you go overdraft.

And don't abuse student loans that you'll never be able to return back.
I do all that and dont smoke, and still my Games are too expensive :lol:


The only solution I see is increaseing the amount of people playing games.
If everyone that watched movies, also played games, it would help costs a lot.



i remember reading an opinion piece that said the demands of the next gen consoles also pushes the price up each time, since more polygons etc are needed, & i suppose for the big companies each is trying to outdo the other technically so the bar is also raised in that way...
Of course.
Look at Too Human:
It was due to be released as an 80 Hour PS1 game.
Its now split into 3 Xbox360 games.

So,effectively, to pay for a vastely better graphics, they had to break the game down smaller, and hopefully, get 3 lots of cash back on the investiment.
You can't ...

"Let's increase the sales volume" is not really the best solution.

You can't pretend more and more to buy stuff so hoping to cut costs
increasing the sales volume, you can't "push people" in buying more
and more and spread your stuff like a virus.

This is what consumer society tries to do, make everyone buy everything
the more and more possible because they can't further pull one side
they try to pull at max the other.

On the other side, people are silly too, wanting more and more pretending
to pay it less and less, this is NOT possible as well.

It's a "wrong dream" from both sides, it's a wrong dream to think you'll
increase someway the sales volume it's a wrong dream to think you'll
get stuff always getting cheaper or more quality paying it the same amount.

It can work that way up to a certain limit extent and in doing that it
introduces new more troubles.

If they are still "too expensive" then .. then there's something wrong
in your "production stage" and/or you have to face the fact you have to
target a different market.

Ferrari are "too expensive" but they are not for anyone nor they are
intended to be.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
piku
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20960
Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2002 10:44 am 0
Website: Http://Www.ncot.uk
Location: Wakefield
Contact:

Post by piku »

Darkflame wrote:Id like to see a scheme that lets people pay upfront for games....where the gamers effectively are pysdo-commisioning a game to be made.
Yes, Im completely crazy.
(but id pay for many things years in advance if it meant them being made...)
Giving money to software companies before they've even thought about making something? Yes, you're a bit mad ;)

And six years too late. That's what happened with the .COM people.
return (0);
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

Not quite.
I was preposing, officialy and with contract, people could pay up front for a game to be made.
If the right threshold of "employing public" is reached, it goes ahead to be created. If not, the money is refunded in all.
It would be a legal nightmare, for sure.
But still, Id put money on the table now for certain games....LBA3, MonkeyIsland5 (with Ron), Beyond Good and Evil 2. Im sure everyone has there own little collection of "game wishs".
You can't ...

"Let's increase the sales volume" is not really the best solution.

You can't pretend more and more to buy stuff so hoping to cut costs
increasing the sales volume, you can't "push people" in buying more
and more and spread your stuff like a virus.
I agree with most of what you said, but it is a simple fact that other entertainment media has its cost load spread over a larger volume of people.
Film, Music, TV, ect

I see nothing fundimental about games that it will forever be only a tiny subset of the population in comparison to those mediums.
I know no one that dosnt watch films.
I know no one that dosnt enjoy music.
I know no one that dosnt watch tv.
One day, I hope there will be no one that dosnt enjoy games ;)
adam
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4418
Joined: Sat Jun 24, 2006 9:15 pm 0

Post by adam »

Darkflame wrote:Id like to see a scheme that lets people pay upfront for games....where the gamers effectively are pysdo-commisioning a game to be made.
Yes, Im completely crazy.
(but id pay for many things years in advance if it meant them being made...)

i think Einstürzende Neubauten did something like that... they were recording an album & people could vote on the direction it took... don't think there was upfront money involved though...
User avatar
Roobarb
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1451
Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2005 2:37 pm 0
Location: Blighty

Post by Roobarb »

Darkflame wrote:I agree with most of what you said, but it is a simple fact that other entertainment media has its cost load spread over a larger volume of people.
Film, Music, TV, ect

I see nothing fundimental about games that it will forever be only a tiny subset of the population in comparison to those mediums.
I know no one that dosnt watch films.
I know no one that dosnt enjoy music.
I know no one that dosnt watch tv.
One day, I hope there will be no one that dosnt enjoy games ;)
They do enjoy games, but not necessarily video games :wink:

The worldwide games industry is estimated at ~$30billion at the moment, and the films industry (or more specifically, Hollywood) is around $45billion, so video games do not have infinite room for expansion market-wise.

For more people to buy games consoles and play games, the prices are going to have to come down, not go up. There's only a finite amount of money people can spend, so video games will have to offer something more compelling and at a better price than other forms of entertainment.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Darkflame wrote:Not quite.
I was preposing, officialy and with contract, people could pay up front for a game to be made.
If the right threshold of "employing public" is reached, it goes ahead to be created. If not, the money is refunded in all.
It would be a legal nightmare, for sure.
You can't ...

"Let's increase the sales volume" is not really the best solution.

You can't pretend more and more to buy stuff so hoping to cut costs
increasing the sales volume, you can't "push people" in buying more
and more and spread your stuff like a virus.
I agree with most of what you said, but it is a simple fact that other entertainment media has its cost load spread over a larger volume of people.
Film, Music, TV, ect

I see nothing fundimental about games that it will forever be only a tiny subset of the population in comparison to those mediums.
I know no one that dosnt watch films.
I know no one that dosnt enjoy music.
I know no one that dosnt watch tv.
One day, I hope there will be no one that dosnt enjoy games i ;)
This already happends, there are quite some companies interested and
willing to give you money in advance for production of things.

But of course, as they are giving you in advance stuff you can't at all
manage to find out by yourself they have the right to claim some
stuff from you.

All this, of course, is done on the trustness of your skills and capabilities
to produce "something good" that will meet "everybody's expectations" in
this business agreement.

If you do it well .. fine .. if you do it wrong .. it will be lot more difficult
someone else will advance you money again a second time ...

Personally it's a work scheme I don't want to be in and I don't really think
"it's always necessary", it's necessary only if you really don't have any other choiche.

It's "always the same" and it can't work much differently, if let's say I
give you 100K $ to make <whatever> and we agree that after X months
that <whatever> has to be ready I'd be expecting that:

a) you won't ask me more than those 100K $, if that has to happen you
must have very convincing and valid reasons for that to be

b) your budget plan has to be accurate

c) after the X months time the <whatever> is ready, if there are delays
there must be valid reasons we both agree are valid for that to happen

d) you keep me informed all time and whenever I ask you about how
things are going and what you are doing

e) I may have a word or two in what you are doing as I am paying it all
in advance and there won't be any return until the thing is not out for sale

f) supposely, those 100K will have all to return back to me plus the rest
we'll make at a % we both agreeded in advance

g) if we don't make at least 100K back (and/or all we spent) we declare
this project "failed" and this of course has to be a "lesson" for what
else eventually we'll do next and how

h) the project has a begin date and an end date, if the thing goes over
the "max time limit" we both agreeded in advance you cover all the costs
by your own and/or we may have an option to resolve the contract

i) in any time, there may be reasons and situations that could make
us decide that "this project has to be stopped"

That's how it works usually .. it's not impossible to get money in advance, not at all.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Post by gilesgoat »

Roobarb wrote:
Darkflame wrote:I agree with most of what you said, but it is a simple fact that other entertainment media has its cost load spread over a larger volume of people.
Film, Music, TV, ect

I see nothing fundimental about games that it will forever be only a tiny subset of the population in comparison to those mediums.
I know no one that dosnt watch films.
I know no one that dosnt enjoy music.
I know no one that dosnt watch tv.
One day, I hope there will be no one that dosnt enjoy games ;)
They do enjoy games, but not necessarily video games :wink:

The worldwide games industry is estimated at ~$30billion at the moment, and the films industry (or more specifically, Hollywood) is around $45billion, so video games do not have infinite room for expansion market-wise.

For more people to buy games consoles and play games, the prices are going to have to come down, not go up. There's only a finite amount of money people can spend, so video games will have to offer something more compelling and at a better price than other forms of entertainment.
Yes but I personally think thats someway "idiot" as well because:

a) it's not possible to make tech cost less and less and less giving "more"
b) same about games
c) the people want "absurd things"

I think a lot can be done on "ideas" you don't need "super ultra tech" to
make stuff that make people happy, but on another side those people that
want the increase in super ultra tech they must be ready to pay the cost for it
and if they can't afford it, they can't simply buy it.

If I am happy to ride with my bycicle around and breath fresh air and
walk different new roads I can still enjoy and do it and have lot of fun.

If I am into "I want the engine of my Ferrari even more pumped and
now I want 500 Mph after I already have 450 Mph" then you pay all is
necessary to pay for it, full stop.

You can still do lot with the 450 Mph and you can have lot of things and
variations you could do on it without necessarely having to pump it up more
but if what you want is to pump it up more .. take out the wallet ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
SunDiver
Posts: 17
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 12:15 pm 0
Location: UK

Post by SunDiver »

It's a lot more than a million quid - first generation last-gen (PS2/XB1) titles cost that much. A typical multi-platform next-gen title these days with a team of 60-80 people will run anywhere between 4-8 million sterling over a typical two year development cycle.
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »


For more people to buy games consoles and play games, the prices are going to have to come down, not go up. There's only a finite amount of money people can spend, so video games will have to offer something more compelling and at a better price than other forms of entertainment.
People arnt not buying games because they are too expensive, the reason most people dont play games is *because they are not interested*

Its a sad but true fact.
There already IS plenty of cheap games around.
Theres hundreds of budget titles, lots of second hand machines, all sorts of "plug and play" things.

And yet still more people go for other mediums by an order of magatude.

Of course, lowering the costs of entry, will encourage a few more to expirement, and existing games might try out games they wouldnt otherwise.

But overall, I think its absolutely crazy to say there isnt shitloads more potential gamers out there.

I dont see how comparing the value of the markets counts against games in any way.
Hollywood has reached $45billion and has pretty much reached the limit of the viewer population.
Games are on $30billion and are appealing to a vastely smaller fraction of the population. The existing, smaller, demographic of gamers values the entertainment more.

But that dosnt mean in any way that demographic has to stay a minority.




That's how it works usually .. it's not impossible to get money in advance, not at all.
Yes, but you dont get the full crazyness of plan. ;)
My "mad scheme" was for the end-gamer to effectively buy the game in advance. Rather then at the moment, when we buy a game we are paying in many ways for the -next game- to be madeas chosen by the publisher.

Purhapes it could be:
a) If the game isnt made for that cost, the developer takes responsability. (they would be the ones setting the cost and budget to start with, else it wont go ahead at all).

b) If the game is made on the budget of the investment, the advanced-buyers get a free copy of the game and the return of any money they paid over that.

c) If it sales more, the investor/buyers get an agreed percentage back.

This could work for eppisodic or smaller, or less popular games.
but, as I said, its a mad scheme, and would still need pretty much all the points you said.

I guess in some ways you could view it as buying a shares in a specific game.
All this, of course, is done on the trustness of your skills and capabilities
to produce "something good" that will meet "everybody's expectations" in
this business agreement.
Yes, it would highly be dependant on trust.
Id pay Ron Gilbert, or Fredric Raynal money in advance based on previous proformance and reputation.
But that would vary from buyer to buyer who they trusted.
User avatar
Roobarb
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1451
Joined: Mon Nov 14, 2005 2:37 pm 0
Location: Blighty

Post by Roobarb »

Darkflame wrote:People arnt not buying games because they are too expensive, the reason most people dont play games is *because they are not interested*

Its a sad but true fact.
There already IS plenty of cheap games around.
Theres hundreds of budget titles, lots of second hand machines, all sorts of "plug and play" things.

And yet still more people go for other mediums by an order of magatude.

Of course, lowering the costs of entry, will encourage a few more to expirement, and existing games might try out games they wouldnt otherwise.

But overall, I think its absolutely crazy to say there isnt shitloads more potential gamers out there.

I dont see how comparing the value of the markets counts against games in any way.
Hollywood has reached $45billion and has pretty much reached the limit of the viewer population.
Games are on $30billion and are appealing to a vastely smaller fraction of the population. The existing, smaller, demographic of gamers values the entertainment more.

But that dosnt mean in any way that demographic has to stay a minority.
Not sure how you figure games console sales are a minority thing. For example:
US standalone DVD player sales since 2000: a little over 100million
US (portable and home) games console sales since 2000: a little over 100 million (of which ~40% are handheld)

There are just over 100 million households in the US. I believe the average US household has some 40-50 DVDs, making ~4-5billion DVDs sold vs ~750million games sales. The difference in price between new DVDs and games is probably around 4or5:1.

The difference between DVD and games sales looks very much like it conforms to price elasticity of demand to me.
User avatar
teamonkey
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12082
Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
PSN: teamonkey_ca
Contact:

Post by teamonkey »

Darkflame wrote:How much of those 85 are actualy working though?
I bet less then half.
Why say you that?
User avatar
Darkflame
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18236
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2003 11:06 am 0
Location: Not the UK

Post by Darkflame »

Nah, ignore that comment.
Was Just my cynical attitude to most work place environments.

1 person working, 2 people telling him what to do, and 1 person about to change their minds over what needs to be done ;)
Roobarb wrote: Not sure how you figure games console sales are a minority thing. For example:
US standalone DVD player sales since 2000: a little over 100million
US (portable and home) games console sales since 2000: a little over 100 million (of which ~40% are handheld)

There are just over 100 million households in the US. I believe the average US household has some 40-50 DVDs, making ~4-5billion DVDs sold vs ~750million games sales. The difference in price between new DVDs and games is probably around 4or5:1.

The difference between DVD and games sales looks very much like it conforms to price elasticity of demand to me.
Game *playing* is a minority thing.

The people that *play* games are in the minority.

The statistics are talking of at best households, certainly not people and are also ignoring the overlap between console and portable buyers, for one thing.
For another, you forget that DVD's are just one of many sources for that entertainment medium to come on. (Cinema, tv and dvd...making money each time)

Look, its this simple:
There are huge numbers of people out there that dont play video games at all. Not merely not play it much, but not play it at all.

Compared to a basically zero number that don't watch movies, or listen to music.

Look, are you honestly saying everyone you know plays video games?
Are you honestly saying, that out of everyone you know, that theres just as many games players as people that enjoy any other form of entertainment?

Of course, games take longer to play, so I'm not talking about equal time.
I'm just talking about people playing them *at all*.
The majority of people I know don't.
My parents don't.
My grandparents don't.
At least two thirds of the females I know don't.

Yet they all enjoy movies.
Post Reply