Peter Molyneux: Loved up
- benedictw
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6012
- Joined: Thu Mar 25, 2004 3:44 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: CoderBen
- Location: Poole, UK
- Contact:
I thought B&W was wonderful - or at least the creature side of it was amazing, the game levels side of things didn't quite fit. To a degree all of Lionheads games seem to have been 'sandbox' games but with game stuff ontop.
Yeah. I'll look forward to Fable 2 - no more Bloody Huds!
Yeah. I'll look forward to Fable 2 - no more Bloody Huds!
Gamertag\PSN: CoderBen
Sorry, but it's the Black & White trauma that still haunts me.Flabio wrote:Prejudice sucks.
I was prepared to love my "pet" in B&W. I trained him. I fed him. I showed him how to do things properly. I spent hours and hours on him. And all he did was eat his own shit. He would collect a small mountain of shit, sit down beside it and eat. I beat him senseless for this over and over, but he didn't care.
And when I advanced to the next map, he suddenly went berserk and fireballed every villager in sight. I never taught him how to cast fireball.
Love, my ass.
- PVB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 32542
- Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 10:16 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: PVBuk
- PSN: PVBuk
- Location: Medway, U.K.
I don't agree.punkrulesok wrote:yeah i agree with that.Flabio wrote: <snip>
Prejudice sucks.
i think maybe the reason why comments like the above are seen is because the don't realise that people from that company are here.
if something new from llamasoft was shown here, even if they thought it was "a bit crap" they would'nt say that because they know this is the llamasoft forum.
If someone doesn't like a Llamasoft game and can give constructive criticism for that, then that's fine.
For example, I don't like Tempest 3000.
I've played it several times and found that the graphics weren't good enough (high enough resolution, etc.) to show what killed me sometimes.
I seem to hit a 'wall' in the game, where pulsars or such arrive on the web, I can't see them for all the pretties going on and get zapped.
Yak called me a cunt and said that he did what he could within the limitations of the machine, but others (e.g. Jedburgh) could get much further into the game, so maybe it was more my fault than the game.
The fact that (back in the day) I managed to get through all the levels of T2K (to unlock Beastly Mode) gave me some sway in validating my comment, which is why I'm still allowed on here.
Short Answer:Flabio wrote:It's really frustrating how when your peers see something about what you're working on, their first reaction is 'thats a bit crap'.
Pretty much everyone else on here that works in the industry gets praised whenever something they're doing is shown, but there's always so much hate for us
We're pretty bloody pleased with what we showed at GDC.
Prejudice sucks.
Lionhead are in an enviable position - able to make the games they want to. Pete has promised gamers the moon on a stick a few times - and often only delivered the stick. Frustration at wasted opportunities / jealousy make Lionhead an easy target.
Long Answer:
The guy is obviously really passionate about what he does, and the core ideas he announces are often great and really appealing. People genuinely want to like the games Lionhead make - they really do. However, when the games come out it's almost like he missed his own point (or at least the thing that he'd told everyone else was the point).
Black and White is the best example - the pet should have been the game. When I played it I enjoyed teaching him to kick livestock around - something he was very good at (I didn't think that through properly, because it made it quite hard to keep him fed). I enjoyed trying to teach him to throw his own shit at villagers (he never quite got the hang of that, but it was fun trying). But all of that was me making up my own games. The actual game generally involved micro-managing whinging villagers and solving little puzzles, and the creature even got in the way from time to time. This really wasn't why I bought it. I spent more time playing with my pet on the first level making up my own fun than I ever spent in the rest of the game, simply because it just didn't interest me. Perhaps there was a great game in there, but it wasn't the one I was looking for, and wasn't the one I believe I'd been told to expect.
A friend summed it up perfectly for me. He suggested that a great way to make a hit game would be to listen to a Peter Molyneux announcement, and then make the game that you think he's just described. Because sadly he probably won't. It's a real shame. This is my major issue with his games - they don't lack in quality or polish; they're just not quite the game I was expecting, and often seem to underuse the brilliant idea that got me excited in the first place. If he can sort that out, then he'll get less flak IMO.
I think the dog announcement was probably a step in the right direction. He's drawn flak for this one because it's so low key compared to previous announcements - but at least it's deliverable. All he has to do is live up to his own self-created hype (or cut the hype) and he'll get much less stick. That and deliver great games, obviously.
I hope he gets it right. The industry needs charismatic figureheads, and as I mentioned before he obviously loves what he does, and genuinely wants to make great games. It's just he's not quite delivering what he's led people to expect.
I'd prefer a cat btw.
Personally, I'd have to disagree. I hated the whole idea of the creature. It might have made a pleasant distraction if it were implemented to such a degree where I could feel confident that I was making any sort of impact whatsoever, but I was too busy power-levelling my (lame) godliness to care. The best level in B&W was the level where [lbhe perngher trgf pncgherq].Black and White is the best example - the pet should have been the game. When I played it I enjoyed teaching him to kick livestock around - something he was very good at (I didn't think that through properly, because it made it quite hard to keep him fed). I enjoyed trying to teach him to throw his own shit at villagers (he never quite got the hang of that, but it was fun trying). But all of that was me making up my own games. The actual game generally involved micro-managing whinging villagers and solving little puzzles, and the creature even got in the way from time to time. This really wasn't why I bought it. I spent more time playing with my pet on the first level making up my own fun than I ever spent in the rest of the game, simply because it just didn't interest me. Perhaps there was a great game in there, but it wasn't the one I was looking for, and wasn't the one I believe I'd been told to expect.
Cats are ace.
Last edited by Kamineko on Sun Mar 11, 2007 2:27 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
- Viscount Charles
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2008
- Joined: Tue Sep 17, 2002 5:34 pm 0
The problem is that the PM-lead hype always evaporates about 2-3 hours into the game.gravy wrote:I'm sorry, but Molyneux's recent history is plagued by lofty promises followed by games that are okay but galling in the context of claims such as "Fable with be the best RPG ever made!"
Take B&W - sublime, brilliant, funny - for 2-3 hours. After that point, when all the little quirky humour had been used up and the game had only its core mechanisms to keep us occupied, we realised that it sucked. Untrainable creature, micro-management - whatever the problems were with the game, it meant that the fun vanished along with the entertainment. And that's not what the hype had promised.
Same with all the rest of the PM games of the last 5-10 years to be honest. Long on hype, great while the content sustained it through the first few hours, then a huge let-down when the game turns out to be an ordinary god-game or Tycoon variant (or whatever).
PM went from being not simply genre-defining, but genre-creating, to the purveyor of smoke and mirrors.
"Put me back on my bike!"
- teamonkey
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12082
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 1:07 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: itsthetaste
- PSN: teamonkey_ca
- Contact:
Fuck 'em, what you've done there is great. This sort of thing will be very important for the long term and it will seep into other games. I was reminded a bit of Argo the horse in Shadow of the Colossus and he was one of the key bits that made that game great. I had a real attachment to that horse, he had personality.Flabio wrote:It's really frustrating how when your peers see something about what you're working on, their first reaction is 'thats a bit crap'.
Pretty much everyone else on here that works in the industry gets praised whenever something they're doing is shown, but there's always so much hate for us
We're pretty bloody pleased with what we showed at GDC.
Prejudice sucks.
Mark Ecko said that gamers were the biggest bunch of whining ungrateful bastards around (I'm paraphrasing here). Getting Up was pretty poor, true, and he does seem like a bit of a twat, but his point was that with films or books people generally acknowledge that people have different tastes, which doesn't seem to be the case in the gaming community in general. They lambast anything that doesn't suit them with all their soul, regardless of quality. Mainstream gaming tastes are so narrow at the moment, there's no room for anything else it seems, yet people complain about a lack of originality. There's so much more to gaming than just "fun". There aren't many studios that will do something exciting and completely different.
</rant>
I wonder if videogames are the ideal outlet for PM's ideas and creativity. A lot of what he tries to achieve is commendable, but his highbrow concepts often translate into a burden or dogsbody work in the context of a game. Maybe he'd be able to realise his vision better if he was an author or script writer.
-
Toastontoast
- Baaa!

- Posts: 112
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2006 6:59 pm 0
Who gives a crap about Mark Ecko?teamonkey wrote:Fuck 'em, what you've done there is great. This sort of thing will be very important for the long term and it will seep into other games. I was reminded a bit of Argo the horse in Shadow of the Colossus and he was one of the key bits that made that game great. I had a real attachment to that horse, he had personality.Flabio wrote:It's really frustrating how when your peers see something about what you're working on, their first reaction is 'thats a bit crap'.
Pretty much everyone else on here that works in the industry gets praised whenever something they're doing is shown, but there's always so much hate for us
We're pretty bloody pleased with what we showed at GDC.
Prejudice sucks.
Mark Ecko said that gamers were the biggest bunch of whining ungrateful bastards around (I'm paraphrasing here). Getting Up was pretty poor, true, and he does seem like a bit of a twat, but his point was that with films or books people generally acknowledge that people have different tastes, which doesn't seem to be the case in the gaming community in general. They lambast anything that doesn't suit them with all their soul, regardless of quality. Mainstream gaming tastes are so narrow at the moment, there's no room for anything else it seems, yet people complain about a lack of originality. There's so much more to gaming than just "fun". There aren't many studios that will do something exciting and completely different.
</rant>
But, but, but... did you actually know you were going to get Sim Village when you bought the game? Because I was expecting some kind of cross between Tamagotchi and Rampage - and that's the problem. If I'd known it was going to be Sim Village I wouldn't have been disappointed, but everything I'd read had led me to expect Super Tamagotchi Rampage, and the version of that I'd been playing in my head was the better game.Kamineko wrote:Personally, I'd have to disagree. I hated the whole idea of the creature.Black and White is the best example - the pet should have been the game. When I played it I enjoyed teaching him to kick livestock around - something he was very good at (I didn't think that through properly, because it made it quite hard to keep him fed). I enjoyed trying to teach him to throw his own shit at villagers (he never quite got the hang of that, but it was fun trying). But all of that was me making up my own games. The actual game generally involved micro-managing whinging villagers and solving little puzzles, and the creature even got in the way from time to time. This really wasn't why I bought it. I spent more time playing with my pet on the first level making up my own fun than I ever spent in the rest of the game, simply because it just didn't interest me. Perhaps there was a great game in there, but it wasn't the one I was looking for, and wasn't the one I believe I'd been told to expect.
It's the same with The Movies. The high concept of that was brilliant, and I was really looking forward to it, but by the time the game started telling me to place litter bins and benches and stuff I'd lost all enthusiasm for it.
The problem seems to be that the truly innovative bits are being hamstrung by some very traditional gameplay. The meat of the game - the thing I need to do to progress - is often not the cool thing that I bought the game for, but the same kind of gameplay that exists in a hundred other games. I want to do the cool thing. If I buy a game based on Superman I'm really not expecting to spend most of the game as Clark Kent.
Oh, well, the level I was talking about is the first level I saw round at my friends house, so I was expecting all of the houses/mana/influence stuff.
My first reaction upon seeing the creature from far off was 'What's that grotesque blob in the distance doing with all the lightning? Is that supposed to be the enemy god?'
(My next reaction is 'Where's the raise/lower land tool?')
My first reaction upon seeing the creature from far off was 'What's that grotesque blob in the distance doing with all the lightning? Is that supposed to be the enemy god?'
(My next reaction is 'Where's the raise/lower land tool?')
Fantastic stuff there! It's strange that when Team Ico did this with Agro in Shadow of the Colossus, everybody was all over it, but when Lionhead does it, it's suddenly a shit idea.
I love how rule #1 was, "don't let the dog aggravate the player" ... good to see someone is trying to do this correctly, and throughout the demo, it really showed. To me it seemed like the dog was always around you without ever getting in your way ... even when he was close by, he almost "circled" the player at such a distance that you'd never run into him.
The context sensitive combat stuff was fucking ingenious! I was asking myself, "how the hell are they gonna pull this off?", just as Molyneux asked the question (how do we do this with no buttons?) and that's a seriously elegant solution.
The dog==minimap was cool too ... he said that the dog would be "a part" of the minimap, but I hope we have the option to not use the minimap at all ... I like my UIs uncluttered.
SiN
I love how rule #1 was, "don't let the dog aggravate the player" ... good to see someone is trying to do this correctly, and throughout the demo, it really showed. To me it seemed like the dog was always around you without ever getting in your way ... even when he was close by, he almost "circled" the player at such a distance that you'd never run into him.
The context sensitive combat stuff was fucking ingenious! I was asking myself, "how the hell are they gonna pull this off?", just as Molyneux asked the question (how do we do this with no buttons?) and that's a seriously elegant solution.
The dog==minimap was cool too ... he said that the dog would be "a part" of the minimap, but I hope we have the option to not use the minimap at all ... I like my UIs uncluttered.
SiN
- betamax
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10520
- Joined: Thu May 01, 2003 11:36 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Betamax_W
- Location: Coalition Anxiety
- Contact:
Just to turn back the hands of time and maybe frame this in a way seasoned gamers may appreciate: is there anyone here who didn't become slightly attached to Dogmeat (The random canine companion from the original Fallout game)? I know I did.
He sucked, he died too quickly and he was a liability in combat, but I just couldn't let him die. I just reloaded my last save and tried to figure out how to get him through in one piece even if I only just scraped through myself. It was kind of a subgame I made for myself within the main meat of Fallout. But I never went to the length of caring after the game was done.
Love though? People aren't even sure what the hell love actually is, if it exists at all. Now, not only has PM identified this most elusive of human features, he's going to catch it in a butterfly net and squeeze it into a game. Love? Nah. A transient intellectual concern that ends when you exit game more likely.
I liked B&W. I had a tortoise called Frank. He had tattoos.
He sucked, he died too quickly and he was a liability in combat, but I just couldn't let him die. I just reloaded my last save and tried to figure out how to get him through in one piece even if I only just scraped through myself. It was kind of a subgame I made for myself within the main meat of Fallout. But I never went to the length of caring after the game was done.
Love though? People aren't even sure what the hell love actually is, if it exists at all. Now, not only has PM identified this most elusive of human features, he's going to catch it in a butterfly net and squeeze it into a game. Love? Nah. A transient intellectual concern that ends when you exit game more likely.
I liked B&W. I had a tortoise called Frank. He had tattoos.
"Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Shouting lager, lager, lager, lager. Is just one of the reasons you're not welcome at Claridges any more". -Psychic Bob
The Movies was yet another example of a good idea turned into a bore.It's the same with The Movies. The high concept of that was brilliant, and I was really looking forward to it, but by the time the game started telling me to place litter bins and benches and stuff I'd lost all enthusiasm for it.
Does this guy even play his own game before it goes out ?



