Problems with the patch.
Re: Problems with the patch.
Ahhh, hybrid graphics.
Have you updated to the latest Windows 10 by any chance? They made some big changes to the way hybrid graphics is handled over the last couple of versions of Windows - the OS has taken over from the graphics drivers in choosing which GPU that a given application runs on. It's possible that the patch changed which GPU it chose, or that Windows 10 has also updated and made some changes.
If you want some deeper reading on the complexities of this, try https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/ie/dn932812(v=vs.94)
As to solutions: first of all, I recommend you get onto the latest Win10 and latest drivers for both integrated and discrete chipsets, and see how that affects it. Updating your graphics driver is critical because the app will only get enabled if the dGPU IHV (i.e. nvidia in your case) adds T4K to the list of discrete-enabled apps. If it's not on the list, you need to ping nvidia's support service and ask them to add it in.
If it was AMD I could check it out for you but for nv you're on your own!
Whiteball - top piece of psychic debugging there. I hadn't thought of that at all!
Have you updated to the latest Windows 10 by any chance? They made some big changes to the way hybrid graphics is handled over the last couple of versions of Windows - the OS has taken over from the graphics drivers in choosing which GPU that a given application runs on. It's possible that the patch changed which GPU it chose, or that Windows 10 has also updated and made some changes.
If you want some deeper reading on the complexities of this, try https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/ie/dn932812(v=vs.94)
As to solutions: first of all, I recommend you get onto the latest Win10 and latest drivers for both integrated and discrete chipsets, and see how that affects it. Updating your graphics driver is critical because the app will only get enabled if the dGPU IHV (i.e. nvidia in your case) adds T4K to the list of discrete-enabled apps. If it's not on the list, you need to ping nvidia's support service and ask them to add it in.
If it was AMD I could check it out for you but for nv you're on your own!
Whiteball - top piece of psychic debugging there. I hadn't thought of that at all!
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Problems with the patch.
WHAT ?Dio wrote:Ahhh, hybrid graphics.
Have you updated to the latest Windows 10 by any chance? They made some big changes to the way hybrid graphics is handled over the last couple of versions of Windows - the OS has taken over from the graphics drivers in choosing which GPU that a given application runs on. It's possible that the patch changed which GPU it chose, or that Windows 10 has also updated and made some changes.
If you want some deeper reading on the complexities of this, try https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/ie/dn932812(v=vs.94)
As to solutions: first of all, I recommend you get onto the latest Win10 and latest drivers for both integrated and discrete chipsets, and see how that affects it. Updating your graphics driver is critical because the app will only get enabled if the dGPU IHV (i.e. nvidia in your case) adds T4K to the list of discrete-enabled apps. If it's not on the list, you need to ping nvidia's support service and ask them to add it in.
If it was AMD I could check it out for you but for nv you're on your own!
Whiteball - top piece of psychic debugging there. I hadn't thought of that at all!
Hybrid graphics ?
Discrete enabled apps ?
Ask NVIDIA to add ?
... what amount of SHIT are "you" ( GPU manufacturers - or is it Windows ? or is it the laptop manufacturers ? ) coming out with ?
.. I always said it, I'll say it again " I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptops, I hate laptop .. "
I think at some point I am going to build a replica of the Y-MP ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Problems with the patch.
In the olden days - i.e. up to about 2016 - what we did to do hybrid was:
- Install the Intel graphics driver
- Install our driver over this. We would actually hide the Intel driver away, and make it think it was still the only graphics driver on the system
- As well as installing our main driver, we then insert a thin layer that can redirect work to one or both drivers depending on the workload
This was particularly entertaining when it came to managing GPU-accessible system memory, since Windows had no idea which driver was actually asking for what.
Eventually Microsoft got cheesed off at all the shenanigans and took over the layer. It's a little more predictable now, but it also means there are more people in the mix when something is broken.
AMD+AMD hybrid was even more complicated since it could migrate apps between the two on a dynamic basis for power reasons. Or even run the same app on both GPUs at the same time in some configurations.
- Install the Intel graphics driver
- Install our driver over this. We would actually hide the Intel driver away, and make it think it was still the only graphics driver on the system
- As well as installing our main driver, we then insert a thin layer that can redirect work to one or both drivers depending on the workload
This was particularly entertaining when it came to managing GPU-accessible system memory, since Windows had no idea which driver was actually asking for what.
Eventually Microsoft got cheesed off at all the shenanigans and took over the layer. It's a little more predictable now, but it also means there are more people in the mix when something is broken.
AMD+AMD hybrid was even more complicated since it could migrate apps between the two on a dynamic basis for power reasons. Or even run the same app on both GPUs at the same time in some configurations.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Problems with the patch.
I must have missed the lesson .. what the heck is 'hybrid' ???Dio wrote:In the olden days - i.e. up to about 2016 - what we did to do hybrid was:
- Install the Intel graphics driver
- Install our driver over this. We would actually hide the Intel driver away, and make it think it was still the only graphics driver on the system
- As well as installing our main driver, we then insert a thin layer that can redirect work to one or both drivers depending on the workload
This was particularly entertaining when it came to managing GPU-accessible system memory, since Windows had no idea which driver was actually asking for what.
Eventually Microsoft got cheesed off at all the shenanigans and took over the layer. It's a little more predictable now, but it also means there are more people in the mix when something is broken.
AMD+AMD hybrid was even more complicated since it could migrate apps between the two on a dynamic basis for power reasons. Or even run the same app on both GPUs at the same time in some configurations.
Why can you not just REPLACE the Intel driver with yours and make it work ?
You mean your driver does an 'emulation' of something over the Intel driver that is crap or sorta ????
Why not just make the GPU run 'native' with a 'proper' driver ??
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Problems with the patch.
Discrete GPUs use a lot more power than integrated ones. So you want to turn it off when you're not playing 3D-intensive games. That's hybrid.
Very simple strategies like "Always use discrete on mains power" are available, but I don't know what nvidia's policies are.
Very simple strategies like "Always use discrete on mains power" are available, but I don't know what nvidia's policies are.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Problems with the patch.
Should not be a user menu somewhere and/or being able to select BY YOURSELF on an app/mood basis "how you want to run an app" ??Dio wrote:Discrete GPUs use a lot more power than integrated ones. So you want to turn it off when you're not playing 3D-intensive games. That's hybrid.
Very simple strategies like "Always use discrete on mains power" are available, but I don't know what nvidia's policies are.
Reminds me thing like .. SnapDragon CAN, with some limitations, run VR at full speed at "max clock profile" .. for 20 mins .. then the battery is totally consumed
I remember I managed to have Minotaur Rescue VR going on "clock level 3" reasonable ok .. for about 1 hour ... and that was the best you can get ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
-
Lurker of Stars
- Posts: 14
- Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2018 2:45 pm 0
Re: Problems with the patch.
There is, it's just that it isn't obvious. Nvidia Control Panel, anyone?gilesgoat wrote:Should not be a user menu somewhere and/or being able to select BY YOURSELF on an app/mood basis "how you want to run an app" ??Dio wrote:Discrete GPUs use a lot more power than integrated ones. So you want to turn it off when you're not playing 3D-intensive games. That's hybrid.
Very simple strategies like "Always use discrete on mains power" are available, but I don't know what nvidia's policies are.
Reminds me thing like .. SnapDragon CAN, with some limitations, run VR at full speed at "max clock profile" .. for 20 mins .. then the battery is totally consumed![]()
I remember I managed to have Minotaur Rescue VR going on "clock level 3" reasonable ok .. for about 1 hour ... and that was the best you can get ...
Re: Problems with the patch.
Yeah, that might work. Not sure if we have a control for it in our panel or not.
Re: Problems with the patch.
Heres a random video from you tube that might help as it talks about how to check/set which graphics chip is used for what and when.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Problems with the patch.
Why there's not an "API call" in some device driver and/or at this point should be "something in Windows and/or DirectX" to say "this app requires high performance mode", full stop ????Dio wrote:Yeah, that might work. Not sure if we have a control for it in our panel or not.
[edit] as far as I remember, at least on the Samsung Gear VR there was a thing like that, you could have chosen the "Clock Profile" and go from "MAX" to "super conservative" ..
Note that "MAX" would have TOTALLY DRAINED your phone in about 20 mins and making it piping hot but you had VR as good as a PC with "proper VR" .. it's amazing, those Snapdragon chips CAN do 'impressive stuff' IF 'on power'.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Problems with the patch.
Such things have a great and terrible history. The app doesn't necessarily have enough information to make the judgement call. For example, in 2009 Diablo 2 would undoubtedly have set such a flag, but people are still playing that game ten years on and would probably prefer it to run on the integrated graphics nowadays.gilesgoat wrote:Why there's not an "API call" in some device driver and/or at this point should be "something in Windows and/or DirectX" to say "this app requires high performance mode", full stop ????
Not that the driver always does either.
Trying to find the best solution to a lack-of-information problem is one of my hot topics of research.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Problems with the patch.
I'd suggest you add a new topic to your research and/or make a different one about "Applications/OSes/stuff/SW in general that wants to be too much smart for its own good".Dio wrote:Such things have a great and terrible history. The app doesn't necessarily have enough information to make the judgement call. For example, in 2009 Diablo 2 would undoubtedly have set such a flag, but people are still playing that game ten years on and would probably prefer it to run on the integrated graphics nowadays.gilesgoat wrote:Why there's not an "API call" in some device driver and/or at this point should be "something in Windows and/or DirectX" to say "this app requires high performance mode", full stop ????
Not that the driver always does either.
Trying to find the best solution to a lack-of-information problem is one of my hot topics of research.
I mean "ok" I don't know what your GPU/machine IS BUT I do know what my app wants to do "go at high performance, keep frame rate at max, all smooth and nice".
Now unless you do a thing like "run this app for X time, measure, hits the FPS target ? No ? Increase Y, Yes ? Ok maybe try to decrease Y as long as FPS == refresh rate" .. you can't do anything.
There's only "so much" an app could TRY to tell "your driver" about "what's trying to do" and even less "the app does not know a shit what HW it's running on" and/or if in 20 years time it's still running on some "uberumulation virtual GPU whatever".
ERGO : 'simplest solution' ? "Let the user have a simple control to say MIN/MAX" not something "super weird" that user have no control about.
Overall, we are talking about "using less power" .. and 'taking this or that out or slowing/raising that clock" or shit like that .. let the user choose, in a simple way.
DO NOT MAKE APPS TRYING TO BE TOO MUCH CLEVER !
Because "what is clever today, could be shit tomorrow" and the simplest solution like "let me choose" could be really the simplest fix.
I am tired of SW 'doing all shit behind the scenes' twisting completely 'what one had in mind' for 'some weird attempt of .. '
DO NOT MAKE THINGS MORE COMPLEX, MAKE THEM SIMPLER
And not "all automagically happens" IS NOT SIMPLER !
Some ( me ) developers are FRAKING ANNOYED/FRUSTRATED of "things that should automagically work/black boxes/etc."
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Problems with the patch.
It's not that simple. Max perf all the time is not the correct goal for all users. For example, consider cybercafes in China, where electricity costs may be 50%+ of their budget. A reduction of 30% in machine power usage (and that's easily available - 80% is possible in some scenarios!) is a reduction of 15% in their running costs.
Purely giving the choice to the user is much worse. The average user simply can't make an informed decision. They don't have enough information.
Therefore, what you have to do is put in place sensible defaults, guess user intent where you can. Leaving the user the option of an override is usually done, but not always, because where that option exists telemetry will generally indicate that they make the wrong choice as often as the right choice (because the number of uninformed users vastly exceeds the number of informed users and, worst of all, Dunning-Kruger makes many users who are not that smart believe they know everything), and that adding user options increases support costs because uninformed users do stupid things.
There are no right and wrong answers here. There is a complex multivariable equation and you have to try to find a place of minimum pain. That's really the best you can do.
Purely giving the choice to the user is much worse. The average user simply can't make an informed decision. They don't have enough information.
Therefore, what you have to do is put in place sensible defaults, guess user intent where you can. Leaving the user the option of an override is usually done, but not always, because where that option exists telemetry will generally indicate that they make the wrong choice as often as the right choice (because the number of uninformed users vastly exceeds the number of informed users and, worst of all, Dunning-Kruger makes many users who are not that smart believe they know everything), and that adding user options increases support costs because uninformed users do stupid things.
There are no right and wrong answers here. There is a complex multivariable equation and you have to try to find a place of minimum pain. That's really the best you can do.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Problems with the patch.
<Sarcasm>Dio wrote:*SNIP* For example, consider cybercafes in China, where electricity costs ... *SNIP*
.. but but ... they surf 10% of the Internet given the remaining 90% is censored with 95% hacked SW so this is already a 95% save in money and ... ... ...
</Sarcasm>
Ok but I already spent 'X hundreds of pounds too many' in a video card where I paid "fuckload" to get what I want to get can I have a thing where I say "I want to run this damned SW the way I want it NOT YOU ! ..
Do I have to start wearing a ninja suit and have two swords and call upon Richard Stallman and join the church of St iGNUtius to have an SW and computer that does what I want it to do ?
Do I have to add AMD as well in the list of "evil corporations willing to control the world ?" ..
<Shoe in the head> IS THAT WHAT YOU WANT ? </Shoe in the head>
I don't like this trend .. seriously .. wtf ?
I am starting to feel "things are going a bit too far", we already have "nanny states" we don't need "nanny corporations".
"Give me that damned switch or I am not going to buy AMD ever again !" .. seriously ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
-
Lurker of Stars
- Posts: 14
- Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2018 2:45 pm 0
Re: Problems with the patch.
I know rants are one of your chatacter traits, but I think you're a bit confused here. Generally, desktop HW doesn't use as aggressive power/thermal management compared laptops, so problems like this shouldn't happen on there. On laptops, the big problem is that they aren't always hooked up to mains, because people generally don't want to carry arround a AC adapter brick everywhere just to browse the web or (more relevent to the topic at hand) play an old game like Diablo 2, or something a good bit newer like Space Giraffe for more than an hour or 2. Games devs aren't oracles, after all! Anyway, you can make a game profile to set power settings for NVIDIA (you can set it globally for AMD), you can continue to that for the indefinite future, and pretty much no user (even D-K ones) would do it unless they were troubleshooting perf. problems. Also, I think if you wanted to look into getting your game (or future games) working on NVIDIA laptops without these perf hitches, you might ask in their dev forums what to do, and some soul might respond. (HINT: It might involve NVIDIA's NVAPI [it's a driver specific thing], but I'm not an expert in these kinds of things). As you know well, most indie devs use Unity or UE4, which are tested for all kinds of PC configs and are probably driver optimized as well, and the rest is 2D stuff. Personally, I see it as Atari's fault for not having their QA company test for HW configs that you don't have but are common in the "real world" and making up for your lack of having a (NVIDIA) dGPU laptop. For Polybius, I'd repeat the MA:V1 prerelease (send hardware config and I will consider giving you beta access) thing, but post it on more mainstream places like the /r/pcgaming subreddit (and maybe the mild mess known as the PCMR subreddit if the mods give the greenlight)as well to get a wider range of HW configs (to a reasonable extent, considering that you're a couple of guys). In a ideal world, all this shit wouldn't be needed, but this isn't one. Anyway, that concludes my civil venting written before I went to bed.gilesgoat wrote:<Sarcasm>Dio wrote:*SNIP* For example, consider cybercafes in China, where electricity costs ... *SNIP*
.. but but ... they surf 10% of the Internet given the remaining 90% is censored with 95% hacked SW so this is already a 95% save in money and ... ... ...
</Sarcasm>
Ok but I already spent 'X hundreds of pounds too many' in a video card where I paid "fuckload" to get what I want to get can I have a thing where I say "I want to run this damned SW the way I want it NOT YOU ! ..
Do I have to start wearing a ninja suit and have two swords and call upon Richard Stallman and join the church of St iGNUtius to have an SW and computer that does what I want it to do ?
Do I have to add AMD as well in the list of "evil corporations willing to control the world ?" ..
<Shoe in the head> IS THAT WHAT YOU WANT ? </Shoe in the head>
I don't like this trend .. seriously .. wtf ?
I am starting to feel "things are going a bit too far", we already have "nanny states" we don't need "nanny corporations".
"Give me that damned switch or I am not going to buy AMD ever again !" .. seriously ..
