gilesgoat wrote:gravy wrote:gilesgoat wrote:
If they were/are there by their own the problem should be solved naturally as when there's no much food the extra number will eventually die of starvation or such.
Are you really saying it's preferable that animals starve to death than be culled?
This is an interesting debate ( but that I'd like on a separate thread )
I think this is an entirely relevant place to raise awareness .. I assume those who profess admiration of fictional dayglo cartoon ponies with tramp stamps might have
some interest, however shallow, in the plight of real, living, breathing, fully conscious ponies? There is also the relationship of Hasbro toward education to consider.. and the ignorance which they may foster. Children, perhaps even adults, may conclude in the absence of being informed that ponies live fullfiling lives like those in the cartoon.. they may be ignorant to the alleged carcinogenic properties of Hasbro products or the exploitation of foriegn workers and so forth. All relevant to MLBs. Case in point ... MLP has given some viewers pause to thought regarding issues such as eating meat :
http://www.mlparena.com/Forums/viewtopi ... art=0.html
Or shall we say, here and now, that "MLP is my My Little Fantasy.. I as a Brony wish to indulge in the world of fantasy ponies without being bothered by the plight of real ponies.."
gilesgoat wrote:The real problem is here it's man-made mess not a nature mess.
Quick answer, unless predators, in nature nobody culls you you die by your own.
Fact is this looks like a monetary speculation that ran out of control, before to come to measures like culling there is such a thing like birth/population control, you have to prevent things happening before they happen not put patches when it's too late and even if you cull you still don't solve the problem if you do not put preventive measures in places.
A superficial analysis of the situation would be a disservice to those ponies who roam on the moors (not just Dartmoor
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mountain_a ... ony_breeds). The situation is complex. However, in a nutshell, the main issue is clarified in the youtube clip i presented.. there are those who have an interest in welfare, but the 'unnatural' influence of humans is calculable : there are irresponsible people who overbreed, neglect, then cull, with little respect for life, while claiming these actions are sustainable.
gilesgoat wrote:Said that, horse meat is also very popular in certain markets, in Italy you can buy horse meat
Indeed, the majority of ponies from Dartmoor, up to 80% according to some sources, are shipped live to Italy and likewise places (rather than being slaughtered at home), where they are then slaughtered for meat, or to be made into fancy handbags. Many are foals, or to use emotive language, "babies and children".
gilesgoat wrote:If I for myself I'd have to choose between a bullet or dying of starvation I am not sure what I would choose at that moment but whatever I am going to choose it has to be only ME doing that choice and I would never accept the one made by anyone else in my place nor I could ever be convinced that whatever coiche is made is ever going to be exactly "the right one".
I suspect ponies are not given the option to choose? One must rely on humans who control the environment and manage wild breeds to make responsible choices. When welfare is ignored, that then becomes a topic of concern, an awareness raising issue, which is what I am doing here, what swep.org.uk among others do, and those who desperately seek to home "worthless" animals destined for slaughter.
Personally speaking, I would take the bullet to the head rather than starvation every time, as the latter is no doubt a protracted, painful, sorrowful affair. May I point out however that many of the ponies on Dartmoor and other places firstly starve, typically enduring harsh weather conditions first (not all hardy pure breeds!),
then get the bullet to the head... alternatively, they may first be starved,
then endure the stress of being seperated from their families and transported (these are semi-wild animals note) to such places such as Italy, and then
finally after all that, getting a bullet in the head.
gilesgoat wrote:The fact is you do not own the life of anyone so in essence is hard to define "what is more right" or "what is less".
Anyway even if you cull you need then measures in place otherwise the problem is going to be there again given X time again and over and over.
Exactly the point of the youtube clip (as this is a problem which is being allowed to repeat) to raise awareness of these issues, which are generally ignored and, as the lady says, are a "grim secret", which tourists and MLP viewers may be oblivious to. Here is some further information, which may or may not involve biases..
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b00zgwhl ...
http://www.swep.org.uk/press-release-east-moor-bodmin/ ....
http://www.swep.org.uk/wp-content/uploa ... 302111.pdf..