FOOTBALL: Season 2006/07 Discussion Thread
Hey I need something to be happy about. I have been reading on various footy forums how delighted people are that Leeds are down. Well as much as everyone hates Leeds I hate the Blunts too so I need to take some joy from this season.amanset wrote:Says the man with the Leeds avatarMat T wrote:Blades down.
They didn't need the goal to stay up, they were fine with a draw as it happens.GeeZa wrote:I cannot believe West Ham stayed up and it was especially predictable it would be a Tevez goal. It makes me wonder if this is going to still cause some kind of stink with legal action forthcoming.
-------------------------
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
No they didn't need the goal, but they've sure needed Tevez and him scoring just underlines that. He's been their best player and it's not just his goals, his work-rate is phenomenal. He's one of the very best players in the world playing for a club that he obviously shouldn't be playing for. The point still stands about what exactly will happen wrt legal advice because I think a few clubs will feel that the FA (well, the Premier League really) have let West Ham completely off the hook and subsequently condemned at least one club to the disaster of relegation.Rib wrote:They didn't need the goal to stay up, they were fine with a draw as it happens.GeeZa wrote:I cannot believe West Ham stayed up and it was especially predictable it would be a Tevez goal. It makes me wonder if this is going to still cause some kind of stink with legal action forthcoming.
I'm a bit late on this, and have read a heap about the contract mess, but why shouldn't he be playing there? I understand the contract was illegal, but has been sorted out now to the FA's satisfaction. That's why they copped the big fine. Yes, he's a terrific player, but how does an illegal 3rd party contract that some damn fool at WHUFC head office approved cause so much grief? If it was so bad, why didn't the FA just rip up the contract or bar him from playing or something?He's one of the very best players in the world playing for a club that he obviously shouldn't be playing for.
I'm not shit-stirring here. Genuinely interested in an answer as a long time hammers fan.
I really hope the Tevez deal isn't settled in court. For my money, the FA took a gamble that West Ham would be relegated anyway and they could avoid legal action by just giving them a fine they could easily pay. A brilliant run of results (and all credit to them) has caused this to backfire sensationally.
What has happened clearly illustrates double stanbdards in the Prem, but at the same time, surely you can't retrospectively relegate a team from court? It would set an even more dangerous precedent than the failure to dock West Ham!
I really hope Sheff U see sense, and that Warnock cools it a bit. His comments today haven't done him or his club any favours. I know a lot of fans here and they're absolutley shell shocked, but overall they just want to get on with it. Going to court will just prolong the agony.
(edited because I can't spell 'shell shocked'. Although being 'shell socked' is also an interesting condition)
What has happened clearly illustrates double stanbdards in the Prem, but at the same time, surely you can't retrospectively relegate a team from court? It would set an even more dangerous precedent than the failure to dock West Ham!
I really hope Sheff U see sense, and that Warnock cools it a bit. His comments today haven't done him or his club any favours. I know a lot of fans here and they're absolutley shell shocked, but overall they just want to get on with it. Going to court will just prolong the agony.
(edited because I can't spell 'shell shocked'. Although being 'shell socked' is also an interesting condition)
Last edited by seibu on Mon May 14, 2007 12:01 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
- Acronym
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3982
- Joined: Wed Feb 19, 2003 8:18 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: andrew_walkingshaw
- Contact:
The problem is that typically what happens when a player plays under an illegal registration is that the side in question are deemed to have lost every game he's played in. That didn't happen here, and people are (understandably) furious. Look at what happened to AFC Wimbledon earlier this year.shimeril wrote:If it was so bad, why didn't the FA just rip up the contract or bar him from playing or something?
There's also confusion as to when, or whether, he moved from an invalid registration to a valid one - and whether he could (ie, was it within the transfer window?)
It's all going to end up in court. I *like* West Ham, but I think the other sides at the bottom have been hard done by. There really isn't a good answer.
The logic of the decision is absolutely baffling as well. The reason no points were docked was because it was deemed not to be fair as it might affect the relegation battle. Er, isn't that the point?
Middlesbrough are miffed at this because of our own experience; however, that was a different kettle of fish (FA, not Premier League), although both cases highlight the ineptitude of the two bodies to get any consistancy on punishments (In the case of 'boro missing the match, they asked the PL on the morning what the punishment would be - the fax came back to say it'd be a fine but not a loss of points, which turned out to be incorrect and not their place to say).
It's a mess: to relegate someone on a points fine would be pretty crappy (as it was for us); but to leave this mess hanging over the end of the season is a lot worse. I'm hoping for a speedy resolution - unfortunately the speediest would be the gang of 2/4/6 to drop everything and be good sportsmen: that's unlikely to happen.
Middlesbrough are miffed at this because of our own experience; however, that was a different kettle of fish (FA, not Premier League), although both cases highlight the ineptitude of the two bodies to get any consistancy on punishments (In the case of 'boro missing the match, they asked the PL on the morning what the punishment would be - the fax came back to say it'd be a fine but not a loss of points, which turned out to be incorrect and not their place to say).
It's a mess: to relegate someone on a points fine would be pretty crappy (as it was for us); but to leave this mess hanging over the end of the season is a lot worse. I'm hoping for a speedy resolution - unfortunately the speediest would be the gang of 2/4/6 to drop everything and be good sportsmen: that's unlikely to happen.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Brian Clough managed Leeds once. That should be plenty of happiness, right thereMat T wrote:Hey I need something to be happy about.
No, you can't hate the Blunts as much as everyone else hates Leeds.... it's too much hate for one man to match. I'm sad they got relegated though (Sheffield Utd) because if we win the playoffs (ha!) we'll have to play the timewasting hoof monkeys again next season.I have been reading on various footy forums how delighted people are that Leeds are down. Well as much as everyone hates Leeds I hate the Blunts too so I need to take some joy from this season.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Whether West Ham should have been deducted points or not is largely irelevent. The fact remains that all Sheffield Utd had to do yesterday was draw or win against another relegation threatened side. The fact that they couldn't do that means they deserve to go down, end of story.
There's no point in moaning afterwards about points deduction and Liverpool/Man Utd fielding weakened teams. Avoiding relegation was in their hands and they weren't good enough to take advantage.
Warnock is a dick if you ask me for some of the things he's saying today.
There's no point in moaning afterwards about points deduction and Liverpool/Man Utd fielding weakened teams. Avoiding relegation was in their hands and they weren't good enough to take advantage.
Warnock is a dick if you ask me for some of the things he's saying today.







