Ukraine updates
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Ukraine updates
In my opinion, Russia hasn't really tried yet.
There have been prisoners, conscripts and mercenaries, but the professional russian army, they haven't been involved.
My previous thought was that the Russian leadership wanted Kaliningrad oblast gone, and was pushing the west to make them claim it in a peace deal (Trump? he loves free things, and if someone else is paying (Ukraine for example) so far as he's concerned it's free (Kaliningrad? Pugh, Pugh, Barney Mcgrew, Cuthbert, Dibble, Grubb)), now I think they're conceding it as gone, and just seeing how much they can get for it.
Rusty tanks may be the worst they could find, but I think it's easily possible they have better. Nato without the USA might have it's hands full.
There have been prisoners, conscripts and mercenaries, but the professional russian army, they haven't been involved.
My previous thought was that the Russian leadership wanted Kaliningrad oblast gone, and was pushing the west to make them claim it in a peace deal (Trump? he loves free things, and if someone else is paying (Ukraine for example) so far as he's concerned it's free (Kaliningrad? Pugh, Pugh, Barney Mcgrew, Cuthbert, Dibble, Grubb)), now I think they're conceding it as gone, and just seeing how much they can get for it.
Rusty tanks may be the worst they could find, but I think it's easily possible they have better. Nato without the USA might have it's hands full.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Ukraine updates
Just noticed in my original post I said there were three missiles on each wing, I meant three missiles total - which by itself is a slightly odd load out (usually the numbers would match, though thats not always the case).
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Ukraine updates
Living in the heart of London underneath the Thames flight corridor, I often see (well, hear first, from a long way off) a lone Chinook thwop-thwopping east-west or the other way.
Once or twice in the last 25 years I've seen two together - ceremonial fly-pasts, change-of-monarch, 7/7, that sort of thing.
Yesterday we had two overflights of triple Chinnys. I heard the first and thought "blimey he's low" because the NOISE was chest-throbbing, looked outside, and there's THREE in tight formation heading west. Then about 15 minutes later, another three. I have never seen three together, nor six on the same day.
European NATO without Trumpton might have its hands full, but it's getting ready to defend itself nonetheless.
Once or twice in the last 25 years I've seen two together - ceremonial fly-pasts, change-of-monarch, 7/7, that sort of thing.
Yesterday we had two overflights of triple Chinnys. I heard the first and thought "blimey he's low" because the NOISE was chest-throbbing, looked outside, and there's THREE in tight formation heading west. Then about 15 minutes later, another three. I have never seen three together, nor six on the same day.
European NATO without Trumpton might have its hands full, but it's getting ready to defend itself nonetheless.
Re: Ukraine updates
Another minor correction to my original post; I also said that the BBC initially illustrated their article with a picture of what I thought was a Su-27; turns out it was a MiG-29 (or development of), so they did at least get the manufacturer right...
(sorry, this is the sort of thing that keeps me awake at night if I don't correct myself...
).
Why NATO may not be going full Solo Wing Pixy on Russian aircraft incursions just yet (short version, gives Putin excuse for full mobilisation due to "NATO aggression"):
Why NATO may not be going full Solo Wing Pixy on Russian aircraft incursions just yet (short version, gives Putin excuse for full mobilisation due to "NATO aggression"):
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Ukraine updates
Su 27? I read it as MiG 27 and thought Wtf? You're right, I misread.
I am in no way saying Nato should back down. Maybe I should be, big wars kill too many heterosexuals, with the predictable consequence. But no, the consequences of a soviet atlantic wall would be too bad, it's better to fight.
Interestingly, the only tank I saw in that parade in the video was a T34-85, which was a WW2 tank. Sort of like our BoB flight perhaps?
I'm still saying at 80,000 ft and mach 2.8 they could easily have crossed all of Estonia, and there is no way anything on the ground could have reached them. Aircraft already at 60,000 ft AND on their flight path would have had trouble reaching them. 60 mph is one mile a minute, 12 minutes at mach 2.8 (which is a top standard speed for these particular aircraft) is a heck of a distance. They didn't spend 12 minutes dodging across the national sea borders.
If they were at 40,000 ft or less that's a different matter, though at 40,000 ft they'd probably still be fast enough to evade most pursuit.
The USA has flown SR 71s across Russia multiple tens of times, maybe hundreds of times (and got sternly worded warnings for every one no doubt), so this is hardly unusual let alone unfair.
I am in no way saying Nato should back down. Maybe I should be, big wars kill too many heterosexuals, with the predictable consequence. But no, the consequences of a soviet atlantic wall would be too bad, it's better to fight.
Interestingly, the only tank I saw in that parade in the video was a T34-85, which was a WW2 tank. Sort of like our BoB flight perhaps?
I'm still saying at 80,000 ft and mach 2.8 they could easily have crossed all of Estonia, and there is no way anything on the ground could have reached them. Aircraft already at 60,000 ft AND on their flight path would have had trouble reaching them. 60 mph is one mile a minute, 12 minutes at mach 2.8 (which is a top standard speed for these particular aircraft) is a heck of a distance. They didn't spend 12 minutes dodging across the national sea borders.
If they were at 40,000 ft or less that's a different matter, though at 40,000 ft they'd probably still be fast enough to evade most pursuit.
The USA has flown SR 71s across Russia multiple tens of times, maybe hundreds of times (and got sternly worded warnings for every one no doubt), so this is hardly unusual let alone unfair.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Ukraine updates
Sorry to everyone else for turning this into an aviation thread.
A quick search, as usual, comes up with varying results regards a MiG-31s performance. The absolute best case seems to be sustained Mach 2.8 for at least several minutes at 80,000 feet. Heat stress of the airframe and burning through engine service life would be a possible issue though.
More reasonable is probably sustained Mach 2.35 at around 62,000 feet. Thats still pretty formidable and as you say, is a challenge.
One of the workarounds to this, of course, is not to play to your opponents strengths but your own. You get them before they get where they want to be and ideally, before they even know you're there; or even better, before they're even in the air. This is, naturally, easier said than done.
The T-34-85s are indeed "heritage". For some reason, there aren't as many more modern Russian tanks to go around. I might be misremembering this, but I seem to recall someone saying that somewhat ironically they are all post-war examples bought from another nation.
A quick search, as usual, comes up with varying results regards a MiG-31s performance. The absolute best case seems to be sustained Mach 2.8 for at least several minutes at 80,000 feet. Heat stress of the airframe and burning through engine service life would be a possible issue though.
More reasonable is probably sustained Mach 2.35 at around 62,000 feet. Thats still pretty formidable and as you say, is a challenge.
One of the workarounds to this, of course, is not to play to your opponents strengths but your own. You get them before they get where they want to be and ideally, before they even know you're there; or even better, before they're even in the air. This is, naturally, easier said than done.
The T-34-85s are indeed "heritage". For some reason, there aren't as many more modern Russian tanks to go around. I might be misremembering this, but I seem to recall someone saying that somewhat ironically they are all post-war examples bought from another nation.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Ukraine updates
Aviation? Warfare tech more like.F-ZeroOne wrote:Sorry to everyone else for turning this into an aviation thread.
3.2 mach burns out the engines entirely. These are old aircraft and they have a lot of them still flying, losing some flying hours for a publicity stunt wouldn't be a big ask.A quick search, as usual, comes up with varying results regards a MiG-31s performance. The absolute best case seems to be sustained Mach 2.8 for at least several minutes at 80,000 feet. Heat stress of the airframe and burning through engine service life would be a possible issue though.
Make it 70,000 ft and you're on.More reasonable is probably sustained Mach 2.35 at around 62,000 feet. Thats still pretty formidable and as you say, is a challenge.
In "Kelly's Heros" a T34 plays the part of a Tiger 1 (look at the tracks/wheels). There were a *lot* of T34s built, even more than Shermans. The Soviets built a lot of tanks, if they weren't scrapped for steel (possible but not that likely, they seem to have had a lot of iron ore), they are probably still around.One of the workarounds to this, of course, is not to play to your opponents strengths but your own. You get them before they get where they want to be and ideally, before they even know you're there; or even better, before they're even in the air. This is, naturally, easier said than done.
,,,
The T-34-85s are indeed "heritage". For some reason, there aren't as many more modern Russian tanks to go around. I might be misremembering this, but I seem to recall someone saying that somewhat ironically they are all post-war examples bought from another nation.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Ukraine updates
You're talking to someone, who while very much not infallible when it comes to this sort of thing, annoyed a relative recently when watching "All Quiet On The Western Front" (the version on Netflix) by pointing out that the tracks on the tanks weren't quite right and probably from a more modern vehicle. I very much noticed the T-Tiger.
(admittedly not the very first time I saw it, because I didn't know quite as much then as I do now).
The ceremonial T-34s were apparently Czech-manufactured (so technically Soviet) post-war, exported to Laos and then re-imported back to Russia. So they may have seen actual tigers but not Tigers... [1]
[1] Okay, tigers, stripey growling cat kind do live in certain areas of Russia.
The ceremonial T-34s were apparently Czech-manufactured (so technically Soviet) post-war, exported to Laos and then re-imported back to Russia. So they may have seen actual tigers but not Tigers... [1]
[1] Okay, tigers, stripey growling cat kind do live in certain areas of Russia.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Ukraine updates
I make a lot of mistakes, several of my recent posts had as many as six edits (I did have to be quick) and even so there are frequently mistakes that get by.F-ZeroOne wrote:You're talking to someone, who while very much not infallible when it comes to this sort of thing, annoyed a relative recently when watching "All Quiet On The Western Front" (the version on Netflix) by pointing out that the tracks on the tanks weren't quite right and probably from a more modern vehicle. I very much noticed the T-Tiger.(admittedly not the very first time I saw it, because I didn't know quite as much then as I do now).
For a T34 that Tiger is excellent, there was apparently at least one other in a film in at about that period, I wonder whether it was the same vehicle?
There is something in Wikipedia about some of the last Tiger 2s being destroyed by T34-85s, which I'd have expected to be severely outmatched.The ceremonial T-34s were apparently Czech-manufactured (so technically Soviet) post-war, exported to Laos and then re-imported back to Russia. So they may have seen actual tigers but not Tigers... [1]
[1] Okay, tigers, stripey growling cat kind do live in certain areas of Russia.
Rust on a tank doesn't do that much, there are Shermans off Cornwall? Devon? that have been there since WW2. You don't get rustier than bathed in salt water for 80 years, but so far as I know they're still there.
The soviet union built a huge number of tanks, the nuclear option was left open because while western tanks where arguably better (Amx series excepted) they weren't believed to be fully enough better to cope with the numbers. It's hard work to scrap a tank, so I'm expecting some are still around somewhere, without any evidence whatever.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Ukraine updates
Talking of mistakes... I was grasping for the right word. I meant "suspension", not chassis.
Theres a story of a M3 light tank (or possibly an armoured car) taking out a Tiger [1] by racing round to its back and hitting it in its more vulnerable rear. Not sure how true that is, though I've heard it from various sources more than once. Its not too hard to imagine T-34-85s getting lucky, or taking advantage of known weak points etc.
I think the point with the ceremonial ones is not how long they've lasted, or how good a tank it was etc; its more that Russia uses them as a symbol of the great victory over the fascists by the heroic Russian (or Soviet) people etc when the tanks being paraded weren't built until afterwards, by a country Putin probably would like back one day, and had to be re-imported from another country because Russia didn't have any of its own in suitable condition and they're being used by some commentators to highlight the difference between the impression Russia likes to project to the world and the paper mache behind it.
Speaking of Ukraine, good grief, was it only February...?
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/202 ... -un-speech
[1] Well, in the story. Some later variants of the Panzer IV could bear a resemblance and I wouldn't be the first to point out that not every Tiger in a war-related Tiger story may actually have been a Tiger.
Theres a story of a M3 light tank (or possibly an armoured car) taking out a Tiger [1] by racing round to its back and hitting it in its more vulnerable rear. Not sure how true that is, though I've heard it from various sources more than once. Its not too hard to imagine T-34-85s getting lucky, or taking advantage of known weak points etc.
I think the point with the ceremonial ones is not how long they've lasted, or how good a tank it was etc; its more that Russia uses them as a symbol of the great victory over the fascists by the heroic Russian (or Soviet) people etc when the tanks being paraded weren't built until afterwards, by a country Putin probably would like back one day, and had to be re-imported from another country because Russia didn't have any of its own in suitable condition and they're being used by some commentators to highlight the difference between the impression Russia likes to project to the world and the paper mache behind it.
Speaking of Ukraine, good grief, was it only February...?
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/202 ... -un-speech
[1] Well, in the story. Some later variants of the Panzer IV could bear a resemblance and I wouldn't be the first to point out that not every Tiger in a war-related Tiger story may actually have been a Tiger.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Ukraine updates
A drone has struck a Turkish-flagged tanker in a Romanian port; Romania is a NATO member.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/worl ... wtab-en-gb
This follows an apparent act of sabotage on the Polish rail network.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/worl ... wtab-en-gb
This follows an apparent act of sabotage on the Polish rail network.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Ukraine updates
"Comrade! The Kerch bridge is now a tilt bridge!"
"Excellent! Another triumph of superior Russian engineering!"
"Er... thats not quite what I meant, comrade... "
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckx27v6dpjz0o
(okay, at this stage the extent of the damage isn't known for sure but there are reports that one of the arches over the section that allows ships through has a 15 degree tilt... )
"Excellent! Another triumph of superior Russian engineering!"
"Er... thats not quite what I meant, comrade... "
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckx27v6dpjz0o
(okay, at this stage the extent of the damage isn't known for sure but there are reports that one of the arches over the section that allows ships through has a 15 degree tilt... )
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Ukraine updates
Now appears to be confirmed that the road span section of the bridge is down, after Ukraine hit it a second time with weapons including a “man in the loop” guided Flamingo missile (essentially like the missiles from “StarGlider”… ).
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.

