Zoot wrote:
However - to attribute that marvelous success to the tactical ability of Benitez is wrong, IMHO.
No sir, it is you who's wrong!!
Benitez is no fluke in Europe, I think he's very much at home in that style of football. His accomplishment of winning the UEFA Cup and CL in successive seasons is testament to this, which has only been achieved by the great Paisley and not so great Mourinho.
What? You are telling me that after AC Milan totally played LFC of the park in one of the most epic displays of football ever seen in the first half in Istanbul, that it was Benitez who encouraged his players to come out and do what they did with his outstanding tactical awareness?
Nah - it was British heart and soul, mate.........
It was a mixture of a few things: Harry Kewell coming off, Steven Gerrard spurring 'em on, Milan relaxing, little bit of luck (penalty miss/rebound score), Dudek having the night of his life, terrific support... Rafa's role was probably limited, but I'm sure he must have put a rocket up 'em at half time.
Aaaaaand while we're on this - as ever - touchy subject. Zoot - surely you're not suggesting that Man Utd's Bayern Munich win was down to Ferguson's tactical brilliance and not, say, Munich utterly outplaying Utd for most of the game and then switching off for two corners/jammily bundled-in goals?
Sickboy wrote:Aaaaaand while we're on this - as ever - touchy subject. Zoot - surely you're not suggesting that Man Utd's Bayern Munich win was down to Ferguson's tactical brilliance and not, say, Munich utterly outplaying Utd for most of the game and then switching off for two corners/jammily bundled-in goals?
I think that we can both agree that it's the result that counts, innit?
Sickboy wrote:Aaaaaand while we're on this - as ever - touchy subject. Zoot - surely you're not suggesting that Man Utd's Bayern Munich win was down to Ferguson's tactical brilliance and not, say, Munich utterly outplaying Utd for most of the game and then switching off for two corners/jammily bundled-in goals?
I think that we can both agree that it's the result that counts, innit?
But Utd didn't win the one that really mattered that season, the Carling Cup.
-------------------------
Good rule of thumb - if the Rev hates it, it's ace - Yak
Sickboy wrote:Aaaaaand while we're on this - as ever - touchy subject. Zoot - surely you're not suggesting that Man Utd's Bayern Munich win was down to Ferguson's tactical brilliance and not, say, Munich utterly outplaying Utd for most of the game and then switching off for two corners/jammily bundled-in goals?
I think that we can both agree that it's the result that counts, innit?
But Utd didn't win the one that really mattered that season, the Carling Cup.
Sickboy wrote:Aaaaaand while we're on this - as ever - touchy subject. Zoot - surely you're not suggesting that Man Utd's Bayern Munich win was down to Ferguson's tactical brilliance and not, say, Munich utterly outplaying Utd for most of the game and then switching off for two corners/jammily bundled-in goals?
I think that we can both agree that it's the result that counts, innit?
Well, yeah. Cups are cups - even the Carling one. (Didn't see Utd not trying to win it in the 2003 final).
Zoot wrote:
However - to attribute that marvelous success to the tactical ability of Benitez is wrong, IMHO.
No sir, it is you who's wrong!!
Benitez is no fluke in Europe, I think he's very much at home in that style of football. His accomplishment of winning the UEFA Cup and CL in successive seasons is testament to this, which has only been achieved by the great Paisley and not so great Mourinho.
What? You are telling me that after AC Milan totally played LFC of the park in one of the most epic displays of football ever seen in the first half in Istanbul, that it was Benitez who encouraged his players to come out and do what they did with his outstanding tactical awareness?
Nah - it was British heart and soul, mate.........
Very true. A lot of people use the Champions League success as proof of Rafa's abilities but if anything it proves the total opposite. It was Rafa's first choice tactics and lineup that led to Liverpool being 3 down and it was only when he discarded everything he believes in that Liverpool made a comeback.
Are Liverpool really any better now than they have been for years under several previous managers?
fog wrote:Are Liverpool really any better now than they have been for years under several previous managers?
I think we are - but only just. The Champion's League win has flattered the reality.
The question really is, how much has Rafa moved us forward after breaking up Houllier's team post-Istanbul? On the evidence of last night, not all that much, really.
fog wrote:Are Liverpool really any better now than they have been for years under several previous managers?
I think we are - but only just. The Champion's League win has flattered the reality.
The question really is, how much has Rafa moved us forward after breaking up Houllier's team post-Istanbul? On the evidence of last night, not all that much, really.
Don't get too depressed, mate. At least you didn't lose to West Ham (again).
Zoot wrote:
At least you didn't lose to West Ham (again).
Yes, I bet you almost choked on your prawn sandwich in the Library of Dreams at that result.
Bill Shankly:
"I was the best manager in Britain because I was never devious or cheated anyone. I'd break my wife's legs if I played against her, but I'd never cheat her."
fog wrote:Are Liverpool really any better now than they have been for years under several previous managers?
I think we are - but only just. The Champion's League win has flattered the reality.
The question really is, how much has Rafa moved us forward after breaking up Houllier's team post-Istanbul? On the evidence of last night, not all that much, really.
You have a better squad now but I'm not convinced previous managers wouldn't have made better use of it.
Flabio wrote:Let the third round commence. Chasetown are gone, unsurprisingly, but Cambridge are beating Wolves and Huddersfield are beating Birmingham.
Come on, lots of upsets please
I've a worrying feeling we might be involved in one of those upsets tomorrow.
Blackburn getting thrashed at home by Coventry, Birmingham, Everton, Bolton all losing and only 4 goals so far in the Spurs v Reading game? Bizarre.
At least Sunderland are bringing some normality to the afternoon. 0-3 down at home to Wigan. Roy Keane will be happy
Blackburn, Bolton, and Chelsea all put out sub-standard teams and with Kitson from Reading saying he doesn't give a shit about the FA Cup, it just feels like the magic is fading. Which is a shame.
This all kicked off when Man Utd pulled out of the FA Cup to play in that retarded World Club Championship.
Mat T wrote:Is it me or is the FA Cup going a bit downhill?
Blackburn, Bolton, and Chelsea all put out sub-standard teams and with Kitson from Reading saying he doesn't give a shit about the FA Cup, it just feels like the magic is fading. Which is a shame.
This all kicked off when Man Utd pulled out of the FA Cup to play in that retarded World Club Championship.
Yeah, Man Utd are responsible for all things bad in football - probably including Leeds Utd being in Division 1