Fool me, this is real good shit ! [the VR thread]
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Working a bit with CV1 makes me realise I've been spoiled a bit by the PSVR which is way more confortable to wear and has a lot less screen door. Also the colours in the cv1 are dark compared to the same scene on the PSVR and there appears to be no easy way to fiddle with the gamma.
also what the fuck is all that crap you see if there's any white on screen? how on earth was the thing released with that happening? Nothing at all like that in the PSVR thank goat.
also what the fuck is all that crap you see if there's any white on screen? how on earth was the thing released with that happening? Nothing at all like that in the PSVR thank goat.
Justified and Ancient.
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
The so called 'god-rays' are worse the further from the screen you are so....
1) Take off glasses.
2) Remove the face foam padding (unclips)
3) Wear CV1 much closer to face.
4) Marvell at the practically no existent 'god-rays'
5) Take off the CV1 and see the deep lines embeded in your face by the CV1 casing
6) Put eveything back and say 'Shit Oculus what did you do'....
It really does appear they have done nothing but degrade the CV1 experience with every so called 'update'. The last two being the worst. The original as I received it was really good with deep blacks, very limited visible 'god-rays' and a slick motion experience. Now they've changed the SPUD and mesed with the colours so it is lighter. Deep blacks look just off black and now it is just 'ok'. I can fully understand if this is anyones first experience of a CV1 how they would think it is average at best, because thanks to whatever they've done it now is.
1) Take off glasses.
2) Remove the face foam padding (unclips)
3) Wear CV1 much closer to face.
4) Marvell at the practically no existent 'god-rays'
5) Take off the CV1 and see the deep lines embeded in your face by the CV1 casing
6) Put eveything back and say 'Shit Oculus what did you do'....
It really does appear they have done nothing but degrade the CV1 experience with every so called 'update'. The last two being the worst. The original as I received it was really good with deep blacks, very limited visible 'god-rays' and a slick motion experience. Now they've changed the SPUD and mesed with the colours so it is lighter. Deep blacks look just off black and now it is just 'ok'. I can fully understand if this is anyones first experience of a CV1 how they would think it is average at best, because thanks to whatever they've done it now is.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
I have "really weird problems" ..
So I got the point I have a shader between "my rendering and the last stage of CV1 processing" and I was thinking "sure with a bit of luma/contrast/gamma" I am going to get the colours "looking like on the PSVR".
HELL NO!
Any time I touch something "something improves a bit and something gets worse".
WTF is with all that TREMENDOUS match banding that seems to appear "on low colours".
So far "the kinda best" that KINDA looks almost could be PSVR is setting the final RT instead of SRGB to "Linear" ( RGB_UNORM ) BUT everything get quite washed out.
So I did try with :
- a bit of contrast/luma adjustment .. -> NOT REALLY
- messing up with "gamma" from 0.something to 2.something .. -> kinda, no, yes, no , you get weird banding on some colours
- strange "I think maybe this no for that no maybe" functions .. -> nada
Problem is I really don't know "what is the nature of the problem" it's like the CV1 has some "non linear colour profile" that who the heck knows but APPEARS it's not exactly SRGB or dunno.
All textures/things/rts/colour defs/whatever in the thing are _SRGB .. so wtf ?
I have to things "side by side" I yet can't make them look "similar" something is "weird" somewhere but what/where ?
Those God's rays are "God's ABSURDITY" even a very small not even full white thing surrounded by a bit of black seems to be "nightmare" even if the rest of the scene is quite bright/etc.
Fact is they DO NOT EXIST on DK2, DK2 definitely looks "very grainy" compared to CV1 but CV1 really "makes you ALMOST think it's worse than DK2".
But the colours now are making me nuts and "why I can't easily balance them ?" .. I wonder if that thing is handling SRGB properly and/or there's "something else" in the middle (?).
It's making me quite a bit bananas, sure you could re-touch/re-design all colours/everything but the question remains WHAT IS THE PROBLEM YOU SEE ??
Mah ...
OR "support" is not that much "supportive" ...
So I got the point I have a shader between "my rendering and the last stage of CV1 processing" and I was thinking "sure with a bit of luma/contrast/gamma" I am going to get the colours "looking like on the PSVR".
HELL NO!
Any time I touch something "something improves a bit and something gets worse".
WTF is with all that TREMENDOUS match banding that seems to appear "on low colours".
So far "the kinda best" that KINDA looks almost could be PSVR is setting the final RT instead of SRGB to "Linear" ( RGB_UNORM ) BUT everything get quite washed out.
So I did try with :
- a bit of contrast/luma adjustment .. -> NOT REALLY
- messing up with "gamma" from 0.something to 2.something .. -> kinda, no, yes, no , you get weird banding on some colours
- strange "I think maybe this no for that no maybe" functions .. -> nada
Problem is I really don't know "what is the nature of the problem" it's like the CV1 has some "non linear colour profile" that who the heck knows but APPEARS it's not exactly SRGB or dunno.
All textures/things/rts/colour defs/whatever in the thing are _SRGB .. so wtf ?
I have to things "side by side" I yet can't make them look "similar" something is "weird" somewhere but what/where ?
Those God's rays are "God's ABSURDITY" even a very small not even full white thing surrounded by a bit of black seems to be "nightmare" even if the rest of the scene is quite bright/etc.
Fact is they DO NOT EXIST on DK2, DK2 definitely looks "very grainy" compared to CV1 but CV1 really "makes you ALMOST think it's worse than DK2".
But the colours now are making me nuts and "why I can't easily balance them ?" .. I wonder if that thing is handling SRGB properly and/or there's "something else" in the middle (?).
It's making me quite a bit bananas, sure you could re-touch/re-design all colours/everything but the question remains WHAT IS THE PROBLEM YOU SEE ??
Mah ...
OR "support" is not that much "supportive" ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
If an all black screen looks grey then you have a faulty unit.
You may have trouble with colour banding or an '8-bit' look to the colours? Sometimes affects one side only (reported more on the left screen IRC)
Again, this will be a faulty unit.
If the colours in general look a little odd, I've heard re-installing Nvidia drivers and selecting the little check box 'clean install' can sometimes re-set the RGB range and get rid of 'colour banding' , 'black crush' and other such issues (not worked for me).
Check the Oculus cinema app and choose the 'moon' screen to watch on. Look up and right at the image of the earth. What does the black sky look like around there?
Edit: Another possibility if you are seeing really light colours as if a thin veil is over everything is the tracking. If you cover the CV! with your habds and block of the sensor everything goes lighter. Check your sensor is working ok (it still tracks about when you move your head so that is no indication).
You may have trouble with colour banding or an '8-bit' look to the colours? Sometimes affects one side only (reported more on the left screen IRC)
Again, this will be a faulty unit.
If the colours in general look a little odd, I've heard re-installing Nvidia drivers and selecting the little check box 'clean install' can sometimes re-set the RGB range and get rid of 'colour banding' , 'black crush' and other such issues (not worked for me).
Check the Oculus cinema app and choose the 'moon' screen to watch on. Look up and right at the image of the earth. What does the black sky look like around there?
Edit: Another possibility if you are seeing really light colours as if a thin veil is over everything is the tracking. If you cover the CV! with your habds and block of the sensor everything goes lighter. Check your sensor is working ok (it still tracks about when you move your head so that is no indication).
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
The problem here all you say sounds " a little bit like voodoo" ..
I think there's some "issue with probably a simple explanation" what "pisses me off" is it seem so far I cannot get a clear answer/reply about what it is from Oculus.
IMHO there's some "non linear curve/thing" that if you don't match things "right" something goes odd.
Whatever is going inside the CV1 is not linear, we'll try to make some "ad hoc fix" in time for the exhibition but the story is strange, must be said the CV1 documentation is one of the poorest I ever seen, I don't even know if they consider some people are actually coding for it and/or are just using Unity and/or some other engine
There's a part in the docs, few lines, where they mention something about sRGB and such and then go " .. but this is too complicated to be properly explained here is out the scope of this thing .. " .. and nothing more is said about it.
I tried my best to study all the (3) code samples I can't see really much difference/stuff in what I am doing, yet "side by side comparision" difference between what I get on PSVR and what I get on CV1 in terms of colours/luminance is quite a thing.
Have no fucking clue about what's going on "in theory" there are only 2 ways this thing can go, but in practice none of the 2 gives the correct result so "where's the problem ??".
DK2 had some stuff like "overdrive" mode, I had the feeling that "something a bit odd" maybe is done in the PSVR too, I vaguely remember some prototypes where it was still possible to change some "things" where showing changing of colours from one "mode" to "another".
I'll have to do some much deeper tests, in the end I'll have to write a "module" for colour display/calibration with greyscales and such because otherwise "no fucking clue to try to understand better what's going on".
Mah ...
I think there's some "issue with probably a simple explanation" what "pisses me off" is it seem so far I cannot get a clear answer/reply about what it is from Oculus.
IMHO there's some "non linear curve/thing" that if you don't match things "right" something goes odd.
Whatever is going inside the CV1 is not linear, we'll try to make some "ad hoc fix" in time for the exhibition but the story is strange, must be said the CV1 documentation is one of the poorest I ever seen, I don't even know if they consider some people are actually coding for it and/or are just using Unity and/or some other engine
There's a part in the docs, few lines, where they mention something about sRGB and such and then go " .. but this is too complicated to be properly explained here is out the scope of this thing .. " .. and nothing more is said about it.
I tried my best to study all the (3) code samples I can't see really much difference/stuff in what I am doing, yet "side by side comparision" difference between what I get on PSVR and what I get on CV1 in terms of colours/luminance is quite a thing.
Have no fucking clue about what's going on "in theory" there are only 2 ways this thing can go, but in practice none of the 2 gives the correct result so "where's the problem ??".
DK2 had some stuff like "overdrive" mode, I had the feeling that "something a bit odd" maybe is done in the PSVR too, I vaguely remember some prototypes where it was still possible to change some "things" where showing changing of colours from one "mode" to "another".
I'll have to do some much deeper tests, in the end I'll have to write a "module" for colour display/calibration with greyscales and such because otherwise "no fucking clue to try to understand better what's going on".
Mah ...
Whiteball wrote:If an all black screen looks grey then you have a faulty unit.
You may have trouble with colour banding or an '8-bit' look to the colours? Sometimes affects one side only (reported more on the left screen IRC)
Again, this will be a faulty unit.
If the colours in general look a little odd, I've heard re-installing Nvidia drivers and selecting the little check box 'clean install' can sometimes re-set the RGB range and get rid of 'colour banding' , 'black crush' and other such issues (not worked for me).
Check the Oculus cinema app and choose the 'moon' screen to watch on. Look up and right at the image of the earth. What does the black sky look like around there?
Edit: Another possibility if you are seeing really light colours as if a thin veil is over everything is the tracking. If you cover the CV! with your habds and block of the sensor everything goes lighter. Check your sensor is working ok (it still tracks about when you move your head so that is no indication).
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Perhaps you could make yourself a simple "test card" image with linear gradients, stepped gradients, different colours, etc. so that you can map out the colour space and try to work out what's going on?
You know, if you have a few linear gradients of primary colours and greys - 0 to 255 - across the screen in the image but it doesn't look linear when you look at it through the CV1 then it'll give you an idea of how the colour space is being distorted. And, of course, you can view the "test card" on the PSVR too, to gauge a comparison, because it's a "known image" so how they differ is how the displays differ.
You know, if you have a few linear gradients of primary colours and greys - 0 to 255 - across the screen in the image but it doesn't look linear when you look at it through the CV1 then it'll give you an idea of how the colour space is being distorted. And, of course, you can view the "test card" on the PSVR too, to gauge a comparison, because it's a "known image" so how they differ is how the displays differ.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
I have been directed from the OR guys to this article I yet have to digest :KlaxonCow wrote:Perhaps you could make yourself a simple "test card" image with linear gradients, stepped gradients, different colours, etc. so that you can map out the colour space and try to work out what's going on?
You know, if you have a few linear gradients of primary colours and greys - 0 to 255 - across the screen in the image but it doesn't look linear when you look at it through the CV1 then it'll give you an idea of how the colour space is being distorted. And, of course, you can view the "test card" on the PSVR too, to gauge a comparison, because it's a "known image" so how they differ is how the displays differ.
https://gamedevdaily.io/the-srgb-learni ... 3b7f68cf7a
One of the guys at OR gave me a "brief description" about what the "Compositor" ( the final thing that does all the correction/layering/etc. for the OR ) does and it's like "I still don't quite fully get it" .. goes around lines of "yes is linear but no it's not linear but no that linear you think it's linear it's not really linear and that non-linear is linear but not quite, it's called OVR_RGB_LINEAR_SOMETHING but no it's not linear because ..." ..
"What you talkin' about Willis ?"
Anyway two things "big QDOS" to OR .. those headphones have "quite a sound response" not bad for the simil-shit they seems to be they are.
I think "the biggest unnamed qdos" that goes to OR is "how the fuck they manage(d) to process tracking that well" .. given I know "the despairs and problems" you may ( I did ) ran into PS4 "to be sure things are like they should be perfectly in synch" doing that on the PC must be "nightmares at the highest possible levels" .. and yet someway it works ..
BUT I am still getting nuts with those colours and a the god rays vaffanculo, thankfully not really that visible at all in our that.
Said that, which are good things, I can tell you that SADLY "on the PC the thing we done will NEVER be/look the way it does on PSVR".
The difference is striking, yes the game is there, yes the action is there, yes it feels good and plays good .. BUT .. TWO things "no frikin' way" ..
The "Brilliance and Depth" of the colours of the PSVR are "one notch above OR" BUT THE BIGGEST THING, yes I did criticize that thing quite a bit "before" ( before I understood what you really NEED to do to make things look right ) but now I can see "Sony you've done a MIRACLE with that" that "thing" ( that they did not want to tell me what it is or how it works ) they put in to remove screendoor .. works as perfect as it could be.
Even the CV1 "it's still a bit grainy" .. and not even "that little" .. yes LESS than before but "still present, still pretty visible" ..
You put PSVR on , 10 seconds "and you are in another world where everything looks the way you'd expect it to see" ..
Image quality ? There's only ONE winner here, is PSVR, full stop, I've seen the Vive .. "it's still not the same" we'll see one day when we'll get one what I can take out from it but .. tch .. those 120 FPS ... they done it really so right with those choices ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
I'm still really happy with my GearVR. The only complaint I have is that in darker scenes colours tend to "swim" a bit but it's not really noticeable unless you look at it. Very little to no screen-door effect, and really comfy to wear.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Gear VR is "a small jewel", the only problems with it are :Barney wrote:I'm still really happy with my GearVR. The only complaint I have is that in darker scenes colours tend to "swim" a bit but it's not really noticeable unless you look at it. Very little to no screen-door effect, and really comfy to wear.
1. costs of the phone
2. is a phone not a "mega powerful" PC or such
Yet it's a very cute thingy.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
*BLEURGH*
.. Jeff is playing "Assetto Corsa" with an Habarth car .. "looks nice" ..
I ask Jeff "can I try a lap" so he gets me in, gives me the controls ..
I say "oh well I can just try it here no need to move the chair/all" ..
First bend .. second bend .. third .. "oh dear I feel a bit nauseated" .. ..
NGH .. URGH ..
Quickly removes off the headset ...
Almost goes in the bath to puke out ...
"OK" ...
.. Jeff is playing "Assetto Corsa" with an Habarth car .. "looks nice" ..
I ask Jeff "can I try a lap" so he gets me in, gives me the controls ..
I say "oh well I can just try it here no need to move the chair/all" ..
First bend .. second bend .. third .. "oh dear I feel a bit nauseated" .. ..
NGH .. URGH ..
Quickly removes off the headset ...
Almost goes in the bath to puke out ...
"OK" ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Did you ever get to try Polynomial 2? The developer is a Llamasoft fan and sent a code your way. It's super-pretty, and does six-degrees-of-freedom movement in a way that I found gave me no motion sickness at all. Impressive, plus you can either go full shooty or just tool around the universe and chill. 
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Ok I must be hard at understanding .. but I still don't get it .. I read that article ..makes me think "but I am doing the right things then" .. OR .. "ok I am doing the wrong things then" ..
But then "if I do wrong, then doing that should do right" .. then or I am doing a double wrong that does not do one right or the heck what ..
"If I say it's linear, it belives it's linear and it's wrong" "ok" .. but then if I apply the correction they say it should be not linear any more I should see it "like I am seeing it now" .. .. NO ..
"Ah no then it must be thinking that what I input is not this but that" .. and then if apply this it should come back as they say .. .. NO ..
So if it's not like then it MUST be like this because there's nothing "else" to do .. .. NO ...
But . but .. if that is that and me is this then if I "encode" like this I should see .. NO ..
.. what the fuck is that ? ... WTF IS THAT ??!!
At this point I am starting to think that "maybe the problem is somewhere else" .. I'll start checking there's not maybe any problem in some alpha blending op or some other weird thing.. the amount of shit and confusion that can come out from "one tiny little difference" is PHENOMENAL ...
I got the point "I don't understand a shit what's going on with those colours" .. at this point only a true test card can shed some light, maybe.
[edit] - and I must be said that or my brain is completely exploded, that COULD be, or "someone too should write better documentation/articles" because I read some stuff and it's like "Yes, KINDA, I still don't get what you are saying".
They should say "input this to get that" or "if you do this you'll get that, if you do that you'll get this", it should not be "rocket science" but to me the way I read this still have a bit the vibe of "voodoo" / not sure what I am saying / reading.
But then "if I do wrong, then doing that should do right" .. then or I am doing a double wrong that does not do one right or the heck what ..
"If I say it's linear, it belives it's linear and it's wrong" "ok" .. but then if I apply the correction they say it should be not linear any more I should see it "like I am seeing it now" .. .. NO ..
"Ah no then it must be thinking that what I input is not this but that" .. and then if apply this it should come back as they say .. .. NO ..
So if it's not like then it MUST be like this because there's nothing "else" to do .. .. NO ...
But . but .. if that is that and me is this then if I "encode" like this I should see .. NO ..
.. what the fuck is that ? ... WTF IS THAT ??!!
At this point I am starting to think that "maybe the problem is somewhere else" .. I'll start checking there's not maybe any problem in some alpha blending op or some other weird thing.. the amount of shit and confusion that can come out from "one tiny little difference" is PHENOMENAL ...
I got the point "I don't understand a shit what's going on with those colours" .. at this point only a true test card can shed some light, maybe.
[edit] - and I must be said that or my brain is completely exploded, that COULD be, or "someone too should write better documentation/articles" because I read some stuff and it's like "Yes, KINDA, I still don't get what you are saying".
They should say "input this to get that" or "if you do this you'll get that, if you do that you'll get this", it should not be "rocket science" but to me the way I read this still have a bit the vibe of "voodoo" / not sure what I am saying / reading.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Just how bad are the colours?
Are you sure you haven't got a faulty unit?
Are you sure you haven't got a faulty unit?
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
I am sure the unit is fine, they are not "bad" they are all 'too dark' but when switched to "linear" they get all too washed out.Whiteball wrote:Just how bad are the colours?
Are you sure you haven't got a faulty unit?
"I head a rumour/problem" that certain NVIDIA cards/drivers can see the HDMI output not as a TV output but as a MONITOR output and go on with a wrong gamma profile.
But I am not sure how to verify or modify it given that OR does not appear anywhere as a "standard monitor" ( another weird thing ).
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
I finally sorted it out .. "the fucking colours" ...
This is a case of "studying some sample code, think you understood it 'most you need to', steal and modify some bits of code replicating some stuff thinking "if they do that in the example it should be the right thing to do" ..
Not FULLY understanding ( and I still don't ) what the example does in that particular case.
So at some point there is a swap texture chain declared as OVR_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM_SRGB, this calls a function that does "a number of things" some lines below you see an rtdv.Format = DXGI_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM ...
Likewise at some point I "ripped" some lines of code for doing and MSAA thing, again they were using that DXGI_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM in both creation and "resolve" but as all this stuff gets stuffed into the "OR Compositor" with all those stories with typeless/not typeless/linear yes/no/etc. and seeing that all samples where doing something like that "has to be the right thing to do ?" ..
Not in my case .. I needed to specify DXGI_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM_SRGB in all parts .. suddenly all starts to look very similar to PSVR ...
Mah .. anyway it works ..
This is a case of "studying some sample code, think you understood it 'most you need to', steal and modify some bits of code replicating some stuff thinking "if they do that in the example it should be the right thing to do" ..
Not FULLY understanding ( and I still don't ) what the example does in that particular case.
So at some point there is a swap texture chain declared as OVR_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM_SRGB, this calls a function that does "a number of things" some lines below you see an rtdv.Format = DXGI_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM ...
Likewise at some point I "ripped" some lines of code for doing and MSAA thing, again they were using that DXGI_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM in both creation and "resolve" but as all this stuff gets stuffed into the "OR Compositor" with all those stories with typeless/not typeless/linear yes/no/etc. and seeing that all samples where doing something like that "has to be the right thing to do ?" ..
Not in my case .. I needed to specify DXGI_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM_SRGB in all parts .. suddenly all starts to look very similar to PSVR ...
Mah .. anyway it works ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"



