pogo wrote:The water and atmosphere that was there is mostly gone, yes, but it took a very long time judging by the carvings made in the landscape.
Ah, but Mars was tectonically active at the time - as Olympus Mons, the Solar System's largest mountain / extinct volcano, testifies.
But it isn't anymore.
The significance of the tectonic activity is that, here on Earth, our molten iron core generates a magnetic field and this "magnetosphere" surrounding the planet acts as a shield deflecting the Solar Wind away from the planet.
Being smaller - and Mars is quite significantly smaller than the Earth, as the image above shows - then it really doesn't have enough gravity to hold onto an Earth-like atmosphere and, lacking that all-important magnetosphere, that atmosphere is also going to be stripped off by the perpetual bombardment of the Solar Wind.
It's not just unable to hold onto it anyway, but it's actively got the Solar Wind constantly stripping it off too (something that it possibly wouldn't have had to contend with in the past, if Mars had had a magnetosphere to protect it back then, as the Earth does, from its now-extinct geological activity).
Also, lacking a magnetosphere is, unto itself, a good reason to discount terraforming Mars anyway. Without such protection, any life on the surface would be living under a perpetual rain of the solar wind and stray cosmic rays and other nasty shit like that.
Indeed, if you listen to Martian scientists, it's mostly this influence of being continuously baked in a radioactive shower of shit from space that makes them lean towards believing that there's most likely no life currently on Mars. But as this state of affairs wasn't always so - as Mars certainly has extinct volcanoes and the remnants of what looks like lava flows, then it used to be volcanically active and that could well have meant that it did have a magnetosphere once, but has subsequently lost it when the internals of Mars cooled down and ceased being geologically active - then they still believe it's worth looking for signs of previous life, back when Mars was a slightly more hospitable place in its past.
After all, the problem isn't a lack of oxygen. Plants - which compromises a far, far larger chunk of "life on Earth" than us mere animals - don't breathe oxygen. Indeed, our planet didn't originally have any oxygen in its atmosphere either. It was all the plants - processing carbon dioxide, as they photosynthesised - which put it all there in the first place, to make this planet even capable of supporting oxygen-breathing animal life.
(This is also why, when examining exoplanets, the scientists are going to be looking for signs of oxygen in the atmosphere of these exoplanets as a big indicator for possible alien life. Because, for any aliens looking back at the Earth from elsewhere, the oxygen in our atmosphere only came about because life got going on the planet, so it's rather major "indicator" that we're down here on the surface.)
But, in the end, it boils down to the size of Mars.
This doesn't just mean less gravity, it also meant that its internal fires died off too soon. Being smaller means less radioactive materials and also less pressures to keep those internals hot.
And the heat matters because it's the movement of its molten internals that gives a planet a magnetic field and, therefore, the protection of a magnetosphere.
(What's interesting is that the current theory is that it might have been Jupiter's massive gravitational "interference" that stopped Mars getting to Earth / Venus size - as Earth and Venus really are very similar in size and Venus is often called "the evil twin" of Earth because of this. Jupiter's gravity stealing away accretion disc material that otherwise would have gone into forming Mars - and also that pesky Jovian gravity possibly denying it many an asteroid collision that would have added more material to the planet as well, post-formation.)
Also, one has to ask that if you're technologically able to make a planet's mass much bigger, in order to give it more gravity, and deliver insane amounts of water and oxygen to it, without issue, and are somehow re-triggering its extinct volcanic activity back into action once more, then you're basically already in "planet building" territory there.
If you can do all that with your sufficiently advanced technology, it really wouldn't be that much harder again to just build a brand new planet from scratch instead.
(But, yes, I know. It's a hypothetical question and that's not the point.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes