Fool me, this is real good shit ! [the VR thread]
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
This is an interesting development.
http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2016/10/r ... ype/?amp=1
A lot more interesting take on what Occulus are looking at for the future in Michael Abrash's recent talk at their conference.
I'll hunt out a link when I get home.
http://arstechnica.com/gaming/2016/10/r ... ype/?amp=1
A lot more interesting take on what Occulus are looking at for the future in Michael Abrash's recent talk at their conference.
I'll hunt out a link when I get home.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
What Facebook have planned for VR.
Problem is I can’t imagine anyone choosing to do this, in preference to a regular phone call, or video call, or even multi-way video call, i.e. a video conference. The thing about all those is you don’t need any special hardware, just a modern phone. You also get to see people as they look, not avatars that have escaped from some uncanny valley.
What they are showing is not even theoretically possible with current hardware as it can’t do the gesture capture. It also requires I don’t know what for the live VR feed from his home. I.e. it’s all probably years in the future.
Problem is I can’t imagine anyone choosing to do this, in preference to a regular phone call, or video call, or even multi-way video call, i.e. a video conference. The thing about all those is you don’t need any special hardware, just a modern phone. You also get to see people as they look, not avatars that have escaped from some uncanny valley.
What they are showing is not even theoretically possible with current hardware as it can’t do the gesture capture. It also requires I don’t know what for the live VR feed from his home. I.e. it’s all probably years in the future.
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
My big worry about Oculus is that they are focusing (or at least diverting) some good talent into the wrong areas.
I think perfecting VR for gaming first is the big win all round. You get good solid hardware that solves some of the most difficult problems making it easier to go back and do other thing with it later.
You also get a good number of units sold and VR keeps going (and keeps in the media and minds of people). Social will only hold it back in terms of development and reach.
While the Gear VR is undoubtably good, I've always had the feeling that it gets a little to much of the R&D pie. I think Oculus want (as we all do) untethered and free headsets, but for different reasons. They think that is the path to a mass take up of VR for social.
I'd rather just use Skype or something.
Edit:
Thinking about it, a Skype window in AR (such as Microsofts Hololens) would actually be much better (like what they had at the end of that video but without all the other rubbish).
I think perfecting VR for gaming first is the big win all round. You get good solid hardware that solves some of the most difficult problems making it easier to go back and do other thing with it later.
You also get a good number of units sold and VR keeps going (and keeps in the media and minds of people). Social will only hold it back in terms of development and reach.
While the Gear VR is undoubtably good, I've always had the feeling that it gets a little to much of the R&D pie. I think Oculus want (as we all do) untethered and free headsets, but for different reasons. They think that is the path to a mass take up of VR for social.
I'd rather just use Skype or something.
Edit:
Thinking about it, a Skype window in AR (such as Microsofts Hololens) would actually be much better (like what they had at the end of that video but without all the other rubbish).
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
The connect controllers capture a number of gestures, the ones used in the video.pogo wrote:What they are showing is not even theoretically possible with current hardware as it can’t do the gesture capture. It also requires I don’t know what for the live VR feed from his home. I.e. it’s all probably years in the future.
Broadcasting VR is pretty easy compared to video, it's less technically demanding than a skype call
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Anyway.
Here's the Abrash talk, it's about what where he thinks VR technically needs to be 5 years from now. It's a good talk.
Here's the Abrash talk, it's about what where he thinks VR technically needs to be 5 years from now. It's a good talk.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
gravy wrote:The connect controllers capture a number of gestures, the ones used in the video.
Broadcasting VR is pretty easy compared to video, it's less technically demanding than a skype call
I didn’t think of that, largely as it’s a terrible way to do it. I got the impression from that that it’s somehow picking up actual expressions, for a more authentic experience. If it’s based on expressions you input, via a controller, then it’s all fake. Plus it would quickly become very tiresome pressing buttons for “smile”, “laugh”, ”frown”, and conversations would quickly descend into phone calls with blank avatars.
I would thought broadcasting VR would require more bandwidth. For Skype no matter the number of viewers you only need to send the data captured by the camera. For VR if there are multiple viewers you need to send different information for each viewer, depending where each is looking. Or you send all the data, all 360° of it, and let the viewers’ software and hardware determine what to show.
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Er... you were moaning about gestures and now it's now facial recognition?
You were fooled into thinking they were showing hand and facial recognition beyond the capability of modern technology AND it's terrible? Okay.
Those videos in the background are broadcast from FB to each headset. Each user is broadcasting model information that's overlaid.
But it's effective yeah?
You were fooled into thinking they were showing hand and facial recognition beyond the capability of modern technology AND it's terrible? Okay.
Those videos in the background are broadcast from FB to each headset. Each user is broadcasting model information that's overlaid.
But it's effective yeah?
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
That’s what I thought they were trying to show. There are ways to do it today. If someone can do live motion capture onto a 3D model in a game engine they can do it crudely onto an avatar. The other people in the conversation could e.g. be looking into a camera which does the capture, as we don’t see them and barely see Zuckerberg’s.gravy wrote:Er... you were moaning about gestures and now it's now facial recognition?
You were fooled into thinking they were showing hand and facial recognition beyond the capability of modern technology AND it's terrible? Okay.
But that’s incompatible with current headsets as they block your face. Pressing buttons on the controllers seems like a very poor substitute. It’s more like using smileys throughout your messaging to convey emotion. It makes sense sometimes in text, it makes no sense in a conversation when your voice conveys emotion. I’m sure people would quickly get bored of it and stop using it.
This probably makes more sense long term. They are already looking at a wireless headset, which is one part of what’s needed for VR to become mainstream, untethered VR. The other thing is AR: something like Hololens or Google Glass that does not completely cover your face, so you can wear the devices out in public, or at least around the office/house without killing yourself.
The potential is that such wearable devices could on day replace the phone. The screen is an AR device, with integrated mic and headphones. Discrete cameras and sensors could pick up gestures and expressions.
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Watch the Abrash video before pontificating. It's a clear outline of what they have now and where they're going.
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Not even a camera,with a AR device you could just look at mirror to have a videocall.pogo wrote:That’s what I thought they were trying to show. There are ways to do it today. If someone can do live motion capture onto a 3D model in a game engine they can do it crudely onto an avatar. The other people in the conversation could e.g. be looking into a camera which does the capture, as we don’t see them and barely see Zuckerberg’s.gravy wrote:Er... you were moaning about gestures and now it's now facial recognition?
You were fooled into thinking they were showing hand and facial recognition beyond the capability of modern technology AND it's terrible? Okay.
But that’s incompatible with current headsets as they block your face. Pressing buttons on the controllers seems like a very poor substitute. It’s more like using smileys throughout your messaging to convey emotion. It makes sense sometimes in text, it makes no sense in a conversation when your voice conveys emotion. I’m sure people would quickly get bored of it and stop using it.
This probably makes more sense long term. They are already looking at a wireless headset, which is one part of what’s needed for VR to become mainstream, untethered VR. The other thing is AR: something like Hololens or Google Glass that does not completely cover your face, so you can wear the devices out in public, or at least around the office/house without killing yourself.
The potential is that such wearable devices could on day replace the phone. The screen is an AR device, with integrated mic and headphones. Discrete cameras and sensors could pick up gestures and expressions.
https://darkflame.co.uk/EverythingEvery ... tual-world
Regarding avatars, maybe something like;
http://store.steampowered.com/app/274920/
Could work with just the lower face with blocked face guessed at?
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Anyone else pre-order the Occy touch?
Bit expensive I know, but I couldn't resist.
Bit expensive I know, but I couldn't resist.
I may have no control over the length of my life, but the depth & width is entirely up to me.
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Yes, I have.
I'm really interested to see how the sense of immersion improves with them.
I don't really care if it's better or worse than the control methods of Vive or PSVR, but now at least a lot of games and experiences have the ability to be ported assuming the developers are equiped and willing.
I'm really interested to see how the sense of immersion improves with them.
I don't really care if it's better or worse than the control methods of Vive or PSVR, but now at least a lot of games and experiences have the ability to be ported assuming the developers are equiped and willing.
I know nothing about Konix.
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
I'm still out at the moment on whether I need (want) these or not.
I think that if used well they can certainly add a lot and there has been instances when new experiences make you want to reach out and touch things you see in the virtual world - but how long will that sense of wonder last?
Will they just become like the Wii and devs get lazy and it all ends up being gimicky stuff they are used for after a while?
And lastly, waving arms and hands about may get tiresome. Small natural movements now and then? maybe ok.
Decisions, decisions....
I think that if used well they can certainly add a lot and there has been instances when new experiences make you want to reach out and touch things you see in the virtual world - but how long will that sense of wonder last?
Will they just become like the Wii and devs get lazy and it all ends up being gimicky stuff they are used for after a while?
And lastly, waving arms and hands about may get tiresome. Small natural movements now and then? maybe ok.
Decisions, decisions....
Re: Fool me, this is real good shit ! [Oculus Rift]
Just to make those decisions even more complicated, step forth OSVR!
What's interesting about this one - besides the "open source" nature of it all - is that one of its backers is Leap Motion, who're working on a visor face plate that includes their technology.
And if they pull that off well, then this system could end up with the best VR controller of them all - your own hands. I can imagine that not only would this be the most natural and precise input method, as it's the one you already use in actual reality, but the sense of presence in having virtual hands that exactly match your real hands is going to be mind-blowing.
Also, fascinatingly enough, it's cheaper. And the version in the video is made by Razer, not known for being a cheap-and-cheerful manufacturer but a "premium gaming" manufacturer that you pay little extra for higher quality, so that's very intriguing regards wondering why the others cost so much more. Hmm.
Another nice optional touch is the supplied belt box. Run the cables down to a small box that you can clip on your belt and from there to your PC. A bit of real-world cable management.
We'll see. But, yeah, here's yet another competitor entering the ring to further confound your purchasing decisions.
(Once he's tested it out and posted up a review, I'll come back with that video.)
What's interesting about this one - besides the "open source" nature of it all - is that one of its backers is Leap Motion, who're working on a visor face plate that includes their technology.
And if they pull that off well, then this system could end up with the best VR controller of them all - your own hands. I can imagine that not only would this be the most natural and precise input method, as it's the one you already use in actual reality, but the sense of presence in having virtual hands that exactly match your real hands is going to be mind-blowing.
Also, fascinatingly enough, it's cheaper. And the version in the video is made by Razer, not known for being a cheap-and-cheerful manufacturer but a "premium gaming" manufacturer that you pay little extra for higher quality, so that's very intriguing regards wondering why the others cost so much more. Hmm.
Another nice optional touch is the supplied belt box. Run the cables down to a small box that you can clip on your belt and from there to your PC. A bit of real-world cable management.
We'll see. But, yeah, here's yet another competitor entering the ring to further confound your purchasing decisions.
(Once he's tested it out and posted up a review, I'll come back with that video.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes


