
Celebrity Big Brother
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
You're from Bristol, I'm from Hertfordshire. If you were over my neck of the woods and I told you to 'fuck off back to Bristol', would that be racist?zip accident wrote:Yes. Irish jokes have become non-PC for that very reason.offyoutoddle wrote:
or an Irishman is rude to someone, would 'fuck off back home' have the same allegations of racism thrown in?
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
If I had been born in Bristol it might almost be. If you remember Lorna Doone, allegedly back then the Devonshire men and the Somerset men (or was it Cornishmen?) didn't get on at all.Tmuk wrote:
You're from Bristol, I'm from Hertfordshire. If you were over my neck of the woods and I told you to 'fuck off back to Bristol', would that be racist?
Usually, racism is divisive. You might say you and I are the same race, so it can't be racist for you to tell me to go home. Races are groups of people who don't interbreed, before the motor car and moving about the country to go where the jobs are, that would have applied to most members of most local communities, with respect to other communities.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
I think the housemates accused of racism are going to be absolutely shocked when they get out. I feel very sorry for them, because I don't think they are racist at all. Shilpa is annoying. She's condescending, pompous and shows no real warmth to anyone.
Quite a lot of the time when people fall out it's due to cultural differences of one kind or another. People who can't get along with people they consider 'chavs' are a very good example. It doesn't make either party bad people, or racists. If Jade et al. had deliberately excluded Shilpa from the start because she was Indian, and repeatedly attacked her over her race and nothing else, that would be racism. But what has actually happened is that Shilpa has been slowly excluded because she's done quite a lot to wind up the others, and never explains herself or apologises. In a perfect world Jade et al. would realise that how Shilpa behaves is due to how she was brought up and how she lives - extremely privileged. Sadly they're just not that smart - but they're certainly not racist.
Quite a lot of the time when people fall out it's due to cultural differences of one kind or another. People who can't get along with people they consider 'chavs' are a very good example. It doesn't make either party bad people, or racists. If Jade et al. had deliberately excluded Shilpa from the start because she was Indian, and repeatedly attacked her over her race and nothing else, that would be racism. But what has actually happened is that Shilpa has been slowly excluded because she's done quite a lot to wind up the others, and never explains herself or apologises. In a perfect world Jade et al. would realise that how Shilpa behaves is due to how she was brought up and how she lives - extremely privileged. Sadly they're just not that smart - but they're certainly not racist.
I'm with C4's statement on this, the ructions are a result of class rather than race clash. I've not heard anything overtly racist, the closest is Danielle's "go back home" comment which can be interpreted in many ways, the decider whether or not it is racist being the intention with which it was said, something we'll never know.
I don't like Jade and co's behavior but I'm not that keen on Shilpa's passive / aggressive act as well. The way in which she's carried herself has been impeccable though the content of what she's actually said pretty much the same that's been said about her.
Jade may have hit on some thing about Shilpa being disingenuous, her and her family are currently involved in an investigation about their links to the Mumbai mafia and during that investigation Shilpa's made quite a few contradictory statements.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shilpa_Shetty#Mafia_links
The trial's still to come and though the investigation doesn't prove anything in itself it does reaffirm a gut feeling that her little girl lost act is exactly that, a role she's playing.
As I said I'm not saying Jade & Co's behavior is acceptable, they're acting like unsophisticated fuckwits. I just think Shilpa's behavior is a more sophisticated version of the same sort of fuckwittery that stems from the same drives, insecurity and a need to be in control.
But yeah, when any of those 3 girls come out they're going to face an absolute shit storm and I reckon one that's disproportionate to anything that's been said or done.
I don't like Jade and co's behavior but I'm not that keen on Shilpa's passive / aggressive act as well. The way in which she's carried herself has been impeccable though the content of what she's actually said pretty much the same that's been said about her.
Jade may have hit on some thing about Shilpa being disingenuous, her and her family are currently involved in an investigation about their links to the Mumbai mafia and during that investigation Shilpa's made quite a few contradictory statements.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shilpa_Shetty#Mafia_links
The trial's still to come and though the investigation doesn't prove anything in itself it does reaffirm a gut feeling that her little girl lost act is exactly that, a role she's playing.
As I said I'm not saying Jade & Co's behavior is acceptable, they're acting like unsophisticated fuckwits. I just think Shilpa's behavior is a more sophisticated version of the same sort of fuckwittery that stems from the same drives, insecurity and a need to be in control.
But yeah, when any of those 3 girls come out they're going to face an absolute shit storm and I reckon one that's disproportionate to anything that's been said or done.
They ought to get a decent hardcore racist in there, like one of those people from a Christian Identity group, and then you'd see what racism and religious intolerance is. Even the BNP are bunch of sneery amateurs compared to the nastiness elevated into a terrorist artform that these people embody.
"Observation is the path to understanding. Self-observation is the path to self-understanding."
The unfortunate truth is that it depends on where the people come from and also the environment/circumstances in which it is said. Frankly, tellng someone to go from one county to another wouldn't be racism, it is just an extension of telling someone to fuck off. When in Scotland, despite having one Scottish parent, I am treated as an Englishman due to my accent. I have been told to "fuck off back to England" which, to most Scots wouldn't be seen as racism but to me I certainly felt it was.Tmuk wrote: You're from Bristol, I'm from Hertfordshire. If you were over my neck of the woods and I told you to 'fuck off back to Bristol', would that be racist?
There are just no hard and fast rules. Unfortunate but true.
On a lighter note, I downloaded some episodes and within five minutes Dirk has said both "bloody" and "bollocks". Has heen been spending some time in the UK of late (or in the past)?
Doone Valley is about 10 miles from me (it's a real place, and the book is based on real events - you can still see the bulletholes in the Chapel window to this day).zip accident wrote:If you remember Lorna Doone, allegedly back then the Devonshire men and the Somerset men (or was it Cornishmen?) didn't get on at all.
And it would have been the Somersetmen and the Devonmen hating each other in this instance - basically they were 2 extended families from neighbouring villages.
Sit down you little bastard
I think Danielle's reaction in the diary room was quite telling. No, saying someone should fuck off home isn't racist in itself, but she clearly reacted in a way that showed she knew she'd said something wrong. Then she said she didn't know what she'd meant by it. Really? Or did she just not want to say?
Why are you breaking my kayak?
I think "fuck off home" rather than "fuck off out the house", coupled with her Diary Room behaviour certainly seems to imply that what she really meant was "fuck off back to India". Still, at least she seemed to be a bit ashamed about having said it.
Ever since I started watching I've felt that Shilpa came across as a bit of a "princess", and it's true that she isn't entirely innocent, but my Goat she's semi-indinitely less irritating than the Coven of Morons
. Jade going off on one last night was simultaneously cringeworthy and hilariously funny. Watching stupid people getting angry can be pretty funny
.
Ever since I started watching I've felt that Shilpa came across as a bit of a "princess", and it's true that she isn't entirely innocent, but my Goat she's semi-indinitely less irritating than the Coven of Morons
Justified and Ancient.
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here
I read the diary room apology as driven by Danielle's shock realisation that everything she was saying was being picked up by the cameras. The dozy twunt. 
But yeah, that's a fair point, that diary room sequence are the strongest case for there being a racial element to the bullying but it's still a little weak IMHO.
I reckon the brouhaha is driven by a few slow news days, Brown currently being India and that cunt Keith Vaz tabling it in the commons (same bloke getting his profile up by slamming Bully in the house despite never having played or seen it)
I just hope this mess at least brings an important issue into public discussion: safe cooking times of chicken
But yeah, that's a fair point, that diary room sequence are the strongest case for there being a racial element to the bullying but it's still a little weak IMHO.
I reckon the brouhaha is driven by a few slow news days, Brown currently being India and that cunt Keith Vaz tabling it in the commons (same bloke getting his profile up by slamming Bully in the house despite never having played or seen it)
I just hope this mess at least brings an important issue into public discussion: safe cooking times of chicken
Last edited by gravy on Thu Jan 18, 2007 2:25 pm 0, edited 2 times in total.
- HippyDave
- Baaaa!

- Posts: 529
- Joined: Thu Jun 13, 2002 8:13 am 0
- Location: Worcestershire, UK
- Contact:
As far as I can see, any comments that Shilpa has made have been made in retort to worse from Goody and her witless, moronic posse. Occasionally she gets a really good one in, too: I was practically on my feet cheering when Shilpa made the "This is what you're famous for. Good luck!" comment. Why? Because, unlike virtually everything that Jade has said, it's actually true...
My other half is the BB fan, really, and I often don't pay much attention - this, however difficult it is to watch (I was biting my lip in fury last night, watching Shilpa being relentlessly bullied and victimised), is more compulsive. You sit there, just waiting for the three lobotomised losers to get their comeuppance. I hope they get pilloried; may their useless waste-of-space careers be well and truly over when this is over.
Dirk and Jermaine (and H, bless 'im) have come out of this looking pretty good, too. I was pleased to see Jermaine finally snap and intervene last night, even if it was just to stop Jade shouting incoherent abuse. Christ, my ears hurt and I was just watching it on telly!
Sadly, I think Jade's attitude is typical of many young folks in the UK. Not necessarily racist (I think the racist comments just come out because the bimbos can't come up with anything more intelligent to say), not certainly self-obsessed, jealous and bigoted. I work with a couple of girls in their mid-twenties and they all think Jade is the victim here.
I despair, I really do.
My other half is the BB fan, really, and I often don't pay much attention - this, however difficult it is to watch (I was biting my lip in fury last night, watching Shilpa being relentlessly bullied and victimised), is more compulsive. You sit there, just waiting for the three lobotomised losers to get their comeuppance. I hope they get pilloried; may their useless waste-of-space careers be well and truly over when this is over.
Dirk and Jermaine (and H, bless 'im) have come out of this looking pretty good, too. I was pleased to see Jermaine finally snap and intervene last night, even if it was just to stop Jade shouting incoherent abuse. Christ, my ears hurt and I was just watching it on telly!
Sadly, I think Jade's attitude is typical of many young folks in the UK. Not necessarily racist (I think the racist comments just come out because the bimbos can't come up with anything more intelligent to say), not certainly self-obsessed, jealous and bigoted. I work with a couple of girls in their mid-twenties and they all think Jade is the victim here.
I despair, I really do.
"...a chicken vindaloo, kamikaze hot, with a fire extinguisher on standby."
- Sir_LANs-a-lot
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 12143
- Joined: Mon Mar 10, 2003 1:00 am 0
- Location: Here





