Giles & Yak,
Just wanted to say that I hope everything works out for you. I'm sure it will do. You deserve to be successful. If there is ever anything I can do to help then just give me a shout.
Christian.
*HELP* (serious), positive vibes needed ..
- sack
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 7077
- Joined: Fri May 10, 2002 4:13 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: evilgopher
- PSN: sixFiveOhTwo
- Location: Rijswijk, The Netherlands
- Contact:
I think my problem with frogger is that I do like the gameplay but there were so many clones which were more competent. I grew up playing one or more of those and of couse being a 'frogger clone' frogger got the kudos. Usually a fair point - I prefer innovation over imitation - but this is the exception to the rule.Harlequin wrote:I do quite like Frogger myself. Indeed, it was the first game that I found myself unconsciously playing in real life.GeeZa wrote:Frogger is, and always has been, completely worthless and shit. I think some folks are so fixated on vintage or retro gaming that they don't see that most of it is utter garbage. I personally think Jeff has every right to feel more than mildly f*cked off that Frogger out-sold SG. One is a mindless and unrewarding game of moving between gaps in crappy sprites, the other is a sophisticated, innovative and immersive arcade shooter with killer audio-visual production values. It's just not even remotely fair.
Like I say - most of the clones are a bit smoother, better implemented, less clunky and irritating and I have memories of those so when I go back to the 'genuine article' I feel disappointed.
Wonder how many other people are in the same boat as me on this one?
- starshipcommand
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1726
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 7:27 pm 0
- Location: UK
It's not like I even hate Frogger that much. Bit of a lame old arcade game maybe, but hey, trawl through MAME - *most* of those old games don't survive the test of time that well.
It's just... well, look, there are two companies attempting to use XBLA. One of them has a well-established emulation engine, running for years, and a well-established XBLA framework, and they basically take a single MAME rom, plug it in, turn the "money" handle, it goes KA-CHING, they get half a million dollars in the first month, everybody there is happy.
Versus the other company which is basically two guys putting heart and soul and everything into a years' work and... we have no money handle, we have no KA-CHING. Someone has an easy ride here, someone doesn't. That's all I've been saying.
Am I wrong to believe that spending a year to create something new should be worth at least the equal of plugging an old ROM into a formula and turning the crank?
It's just... well, look, there are two companies attempting to use XBLA. One of them has a well-established emulation engine, running for years, and a well-established XBLA framework, and they basically take a single MAME rom, plug it in, turn the "money" handle, it goes KA-CHING, they get half a million dollars in the first month, everybody there is happy.
Versus the other company which is basically two guys putting heart and soul and everything into a years' work and... we have no money handle, we have no KA-CHING. Someone has an easy ride here, someone doesn't. That's all I've been saying.
Am I wrong to believe that spending a year to create something new should be worth at least the equal of plugging an old ROM into a formula and turning the crank?
Justified and Ancient.
No, you're not wrong. But sadly most ppl outside of Yakyak don't care what amount of work has been thrown into the title, they just see a preview-screen, maybe read one or two words and thats it mostly. If they remember it from their childhood the better. Yeah, i'm afraid it's that way...Yak wrote:Am I wrong to believe that spending a year to create something new should be worth at least the equal of plugging an old ROM into a formula and turning the crank?
Just have a look at the music biz. Lots of snippets and sampled stuff used or even full remakes of old hits. Yeah, there are entirely new productions, but the power of human memory is very very strong.
It's very rare that the *BEST* products win the biggest marketshare or earn the most, you also will know that or sure. It's sad but true.
But *PLEASE* don't give up. As giles already wrote don't worry too much about the past, you've done a enormous workload of wonderful stuff. Maybe adjust the next title a little towards the "non-hardcore"-gamer.
I just wish you the best, best health, happy sheepies, good code, good food, faith in development.
Hellyeah!
He probably meant two kinds of companies. MAME rom vs new, and the cheap cash-in of a crusty but known commodity is beating the living crap out of the new stuff in terms of sales, despite the new stuff being of much higher quality. I imagine It's more than a little discouraging to people who want to create new stuff in the old style.
James
James



