The Dr Who thread
Well, I am probably in a minority by actually liking Catherine Tate (and yes, Steve, she does have nice tits
), and I like Tennant, and I liked teh whole episode. It's Christmas, people, it's the time when teh guests on quiz shows are celebrities trying to entertain us and win money for charity. It's the time when we feast on fine food, sip eggnog and lie back on the sofa witha smile on our faces.
We don't need to think about it, we just need to get into the chill zone. Big ups from me to RTD, because this did just that (although I cheated and only watched it last night
)
We don't need to think about it, we just need to get into the chill zone. Big ups from me to RTD, because this did just that (although I cheated and only watched it last night
- PVB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 32542
- Joined: Mon Apr 22, 2002 10:16 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: PVBuk
- PSN: PVBuk
- Location: Medway, U.K.
I (for onceZoot wrote:Well, I am probably in a minority by actually liking Catherine Tate (and yes, Steve, she does have nice tits![]()
), and I like Tennant, and I liked teh whole episode. It's Christmas, people, it's the time when teh guests on quiz shows are celebrities trying to entertain us and win money for charity. It's the time when we feast on fine food, sip eggnog and lie back on the sofa witha smile on our faces.
We don't need to think about it, we just need to get into the chill zone. Big ups from me to RTD, because this did just that (although I cheated and only watched it last night)
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
Dungeon_Dave wrote:After the age of 13, spodlike qualities suddenly became respected and desired (though not to the opposite sex), and when making my way into exams at 16 there were many peers envious of my mathematical/computational abilities[1] who made joking reference with "you can do this shite 'cos you understand Dr Who and all that...".
Chester G. Edwards wrote:Let’s face the obvious: yesterday we were nerds, today we’re the cognitive elite. Let’s conquer.
I empathise fully by the way, Dave - I've stopped going anywhere near the remnants of my family because they feel it necessary to still point at the geeky younger sprog and his funny hobby. Hold on. Just gonna stop typing while that wave of rage passes. Okay.
*koff* Yeah.
I actually quite enjoyed the Special. The TARDIS can fly in n-space, we've seen it before dozens of times - recently, with being missiled by Dalek motherships and smashing into dumpsters. It got paid for, though, so all good and well.
Not having seen any of Catherine Tate's other stuff obviously put me in a better position to enjoy this, as it seems a lot of folk have had enough of her before she even stepped on screen - this made her a potentially dodgy choice, but is it possible that the people commissioning actors for the show just didn't know how marmitey she was, and how many people were sick of her? It's entirely possible. TV Studio Execs are not - as a subgroup of humanity - widely known for paying attention and absorbing actual facts.
Plot holes? Well come on - it's Dr. Who! If it was meant to make perfect sense, then it wouldn't be anywhere near as much fun. Come to that, remember what attempting to cleave unto Canon did to Enterprise - it couldn't go one way, and it couldn't go another. Therefore, it imploded.
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
I don't think any casting exec can claim ignorance of how disliked Catherine Tate is in some areas of TV viewership. I personally hate her comedy show with a great passion. Her playing Donna I liked a lot however. Even my mum said by the end that she should be the new companion.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
I stopped watching Dr Who around the time Peter Kay was guesting. I was getting a bit fed up of it being set in bloody Walthamstow every week, Rose's fucking mum, politically correct new age emotional man Mickey & council houses/flats it was like watching an episode of fucking Eastenders, not cutting edge British sci-fi!! The adding in of the 'celebrities' thing was the last straw.
Anyway caught the Christmas episode and really enjoyed it, nothing really bad to say about it. I didn't really watch it with a critical eye, on watching again maybe I would have criticisms. I thought Catherine Tate's character was brilliant in it, bags of character and humour.
One thing though, as I say I haven't seen many of the episodes in with the new Doctor whatshisname in it. But judging from the Christmas episode Dr Who seems to be more about people and characters and emotion than sci-fi. What science there is in there seem to be quickly brushed over and never really explained in any depth. Any science seems to be quickly pulled from a hat then just as quickly discarded. Not sure if this is a good thing or not, maybe it's intentional on the part of the writer, maybe it hints at why they seem to very rarely leave the East end of London.
Anyway caught the Christmas episode and really enjoyed it, nothing really bad to say about it. I didn't really watch it with a critical eye, on watching again maybe I would have criticisms. I thought Catherine Tate's character was brilliant in it, bags of character and humour.
One thing though, as I say I haven't seen many of the episodes in with the new Doctor whatshisname in it. But judging from the Christmas episode Dr Who seems to be more about people and characters and emotion than sci-fi. What science there is in there seem to be quickly brushed over and never really explained in any depth. Any science seems to be quickly pulled from a hat then just as quickly discarded. Not sure if this is a good thing or not, maybe it's intentional on the part of the writer, maybe it hints at why they seem to very rarely leave the East end of London.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Too bloody right. Remember the very first Ecclestone episode with "anti-plastic"? ANTI-PLASTIC.Bog wrote: Plot holes? Well come on - it's Dr. Who! If it was meant to make perfect sense, then it wouldn't be anywhere near as much fun. Come to that, remember what attempting to cleave unto Canon did to Enterprise - it couldn't go one way, and it couldn't go another. Therefore, it imploded.
We don't need no anal explanations of every bloody thing. Star Trek this ain't.
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
You've hit my two main complaints, Disciple.
Time and Relative Dimensions in London and Cardiff (TARDILAC!)
Not much actual science fiction.
The two kinda go together, really - if you're always binging around council estates or flood barriers, then you're only going to get a very narrow slice of what's Out There. The Great Spectrum of Possibilities that is Sci-Fi can only get so much exercise if all you're doing is checking out the Auton Invasion of Stepney, to be honest.
Hell, even with my ultra-sensitive Yank-Bashing detectors, I'd be happy to see an ep set in the US with lots of Stereotypical Thicky Rednecks going "Whut? There wuz a invashun? Wheyen?" and stuff, just to have a fucking change. Well, no, not really. I'd get the arse good and proper, and we all know it
But that's about how desperate I'm getting for a change of scene.
That said, the good is still mainly outweighing the bad - maybe someone somewhere needs to lower their expectations of what the viewers demand from the insides of a spaceship. Some of the earlier sets re-dressed would do fine for ships, stations, outposts and colony sites. Maybe someone thinks we need a whole, new pristine set each time?
Time and Relative Dimensions in London and Cardiff (TARDILAC!)
Not much actual science fiction.
The two kinda go together, really - if you're always binging around council estates or flood barriers, then you're only going to get a very narrow slice of what's Out There. The Great Spectrum of Possibilities that is Sci-Fi can only get so much exercise if all you're doing is checking out the Auton Invasion of Stepney, to be honest.
Hell, even with my ultra-sensitive Yank-Bashing detectors, I'd be happy to see an ep set in the US with lots of Stereotypical Thicky Rednecks going "Whut? There wuz a invashun? Wheyen?" and stuff, just to have a fucking change. Well, no, not really. I'd get the arse good and proper, and we all know it
That said, the good is still mainly outweighing the bad - maybe someone somewhere needs to lower their expectations of what the viewers demand from the insides of a spaceship. Some of the earlier sets re-dressed would do fine for ships, stations, outposts and colony sites. Maybe someone thinks we need a whole, new pristine set each time?
Equally, Catherine Tate is one of the BBC's major stars. I daresay BBC execs don't care if Catherine Tate is hated by a small group of minority interest fans... I'm sure she brought in more people than she lost.HGFB wrote:I don't think any casting exec can claim ignorance of how disliked Catherine Tate is in some areas of TV viewership. I personally hate her comedy show with a great passion.
The BBC execs are almost certainly not bovvered.
/coat
Simon
"Who put the 'ram' in the 'ram-a-lam-a-ding-dong'?"
I wonder if keeping it on Earth is an exercise of cost-cutting? This was also done back in Pertwee's days. Although saying that, I like Tennant's Doctor better but Pertwee had UNIT instead of Torchwood.Bog wrote:You've hit my two main complaints, Disciple.
Time and Relative Dimensions in London and Cardiff (TARDILAC!)
Not much actual science fiction.
The two kinda go together, really - if you're always binging around council estates or flood barriers, then you're only going to get a very narrow slice of what's Out There. The Great Spectrum of Possibilities that is Sci-Fi can only get so much exercise if all you're doing is checking out the Auton Invasion of Stepney, to be honest.
Hell, even with my ultra-sensitive Yank-Bashing detectors, I'd be happy to see an ep set in the US with lots of Stereotypical Thicky Rednecks going "Whut? There wuz a invashun? Wheyen?" and stuff, just to have a fucking change. Well, no, not really. I'd get the arse good and proper, and we all know itBut that's about how desperate I'm getting for a change of scene.
That said, the good is still mainly outweighing the bad - maybe someone somewhere needs to lower their expectations of what the viewers demand from the insides of a spaceship. Some of the earlier sets re-dressed would do fine for ships, stations, outposts and colony sites. Maybe someone thinks we need a whole, new pristine set each time?
There's something reassuring to my mind when the Brigadier gets involved.
Sealed with a curse as sharp as a knife. Doomed is your soul and damned is your life.
- HGFB
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 23575
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 8:51 pm 0
- Location: At my desk. Tap tap tapping.
Would 1930s New York do? Just throwing *completely* random dates and locations into the air you understandBog wrote:Hell, even with my ultra-sensitive Yank-Bashing detectors, I'd be happy to see an ep set in the US with lots of Stereotypical Thicky Rednecks going "Whut? There wuz a invashun? Wheyen?" and stuff, just to have a fucking change. Well, no, not really. I'd get the arse good and proper, and we all know itBut that's about how desperate I'm getting for a change of scene.
My bag is called Mr Shitface
-
Bog
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 15767
- Joined: Mon Jun 24, 2002 2:01 pm 0
- Location: Los Angeles, California, Sol 3
"You. Carstairs. Chap with the wings - five rounds rapid."Driller wrote:There's something reassuring to my mind when the Brigadier gets involved.
Somehow I very much doubt we'll see Brigadier Leithbridge-Stewart's ilk again - that'd go with the Modern Army like a cavalry bugle on a Challenger tank.*
Besides, nobody pays attention to the UN anymore, and UNIT sank without a trace under the amount of paperwork and clearances required to operate independant nuclear power sources back in '88. Very sad.
IIRC, UNIT turned up briefly in Ecclestone's reign, and turned out to be exactly the over-buraucratised, emasculated, overconfident and ineffectual pile of crap that we expected. No - wait - it was last year's Christmas Invasion while Tenant was in his jim-jams wasn't it?
Shame that.
*Incredibly cool but you'd be told off for it and made to take it down from the cupola before you're gotten into second gear
:edit:
Yes, as long as we also have a couple of outer-space eps, too.The Bringer of Joy wrote:Would 1930s New York do? Just throwing *completely* random dates and locations into the air you understand
TBH, I quite miss the old format of having a whole season as a story-arc.
You sure she was playing Donna? Looked and sounded like she was playing Lauren to meHGFB wrote:I don't think any casting exec can claim ignorance of how disliked Catherine Tate is in some areas of TV viewership. I personally hate her comedy show with a great passion. Her playing Donna I liked a lot however. Even my mum said by the end that she should be the new companion.
- limb_clock
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 8186
- Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2003 9:46 am 0
- XBL Gamertag: LimbClock
- Location: Winland a.k.a. Finland
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK



