The ghost of raids past wrote:Thats one of the saddest sights. Man giving up leaving the gravity well.
The fact the Shuttle couldn't really leave Earth's gravity well is the main reason it is in a museum. It did after all orbit, by definitioning remaining within the gravitational hold of the planet. That and the unsafe design of attaching it to the side of a foam shedding tank.
Lots of new tech is on the way, and its all capsule based, as that is all we currently know we can return to Earth safely after a high speed escape from the planet's gravity.
I believe we are two years away from manned flights for the Dragon capsule (holding a crew of 6), and I think four or so for the Boeing capsule, which will be the one used with the next SLS.
Firefox wrote:I like the way they've chosen to display it banked over like that.
I don't. In the atmosphere her normal orientation was level.
Well, it did bank in real life, but I meant that it was a clever way of displaying it so that people can get a good view of it from lots of different angles.
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."
axel000 wrote:The fact the Shuttle couldn't really leave Earth's gravity well is the main reason it is in a museum. It did after all orbit, by definitioning remaining within the gravitational hold of the planet. That and the unsafe design of attaching it to the side of a foam shedding tank.
There's nothing specific in the design of the Shuttle that was the problem. It was the whole underlying principle of throwing complicated technology at the problem, and priding themselves upon it, and ignoring the obvious flaws in the concept, most notably that it cannot be made safe, cheap or reliable.
The fundamental underlying principles of going into space are not particularly complicated - turn a load of chemical energy into kinetic energy - and any solution that is (relatively) safe, cheap and reliable will therefore also probably not be complicated. Hence why the Russian space program is more successful than NASAs in these respects - the Russians didn't have the money to do anything complicated, so they did simple stuff well.
Id still rather we invested in new stuff even if it doesn't work at first. Capsules might be known methods, but they really don't seem great long term. We might just get stuck without growing new tech.
Figure out the cheapest way to get humans and payloads in orbit (possibly via separate methods). That should be a goal. Not more one-off missions were most of the tech gets thrown away.
Given theres a lot of moves now to start moving/mining asteroids, that really opens up possible construction in space itself - saving a lot of lifting from earth needed. Orbital construction infrastructure would let us explore easier.
axel000 wrote:The fact the Shuttle couldn't really leave Earth's gravity well is the main reason it is in a museum. It did after all orbit, by definitioning remaining within the gravitational hold of the planet. That and the unsafe design of attaching it to the side of a foam shedding tank.
There's nothing specific in the design of the Shuttle that was the problem.
The structure and ceramic heat tiles could not withstand the forces and heat of a non-LEO atmospheric re-entry. Coming back from say a Lunar transit would have ripped it apart.
But that still completely misses the point, which is that the shuttle was the wrong solution for almost any task you care to name of it, partly because it's original design was massively compromised by a US military requirement which was never put into use, but at least equally because of NASA's obsession with staying on the bleeding edge.
(There's far more obvious reasons the shuttle would be an idiotic solution to a lunar mission than the heat protection system.)
, but at least equally because of NASA's obsession with staying on the bleeding edge.
Time it was made.
What would the shuttle have been like if Nasa really had kept it cutting edge? did it have much scope for improvements if the design went though iterations over the decades? So rather then a few clones, there was various versions?
I know the expensive of having the fabrication Felicity running - but I still think that inferstructures would have paid of longterm
I don't know about their lunar lander, but they certainly had problems with their Saturn-V equivalent - I think thats the one that blew up on the launchpad, killing a number of Russian generals that had gone to see the launch in one of the worst rocket-related disasters of all time. There was also the "no-one remembers the guy who came second" problem...
Orava wrote:I suppose going to the Moon will be seen by future generations like building the pyramids. Magnificent as they are, they are ultimately pointless.
Except to show what can be done. Of course, no modern building is actually as tall as the pyramids.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Dio wrote:Even more expensive, even less reliable, and even less safe.
By that logic, why arn't we all in Ford Model T cars then
If your arguing the shuttle was the pinnacle of mankind's designs in that area, you need to cit what limits it was pushing up against which newer designs couldn't have improved upon.