tufty wrote:There's an awful lot of overanalysing.
In fairness, Dave Pianos is a music theory channel, so it's all about analysing time signatures, chord sequences, etc. to understand the music theory.
Indeed, his favourite band is the Beatles, and he's very clear that the Beatles did not know music theory - at least not to the neurotic levels that he analyses things - but that doesn't mean you can't still analyse the underlying music theory of stuff that was composed instinctively and by ear.
It's not implied that they're consciously composing things because of music theory, and maybe it's all just "by ear" instinctive improvisation. But it's a music theory channel, so he analyses why it works, in terms of music theory, whether the bands intended it or not.
Like, a cricket bowler is likely not thinking about the physics of their throw. But that doesn't mean you can't work out those physics, understand why it's a brilliant technique and then be even more awed by the fact that they're not working it all out with maths, but just instinctively found the perfect way of throwing the ball.
I know some people feel that applying "theory" to artistic performance somehow "steals away" the instinct and intuition. I had a mate, who played guitar in my childhood band, who was all "never learn theory, it'll spoil your performance". But I just disagree.
Knowing that stars are nuclear fusion reactors, fusing hydrogen into helium, doesn't - at least for me - steal an inch of beauty from the photos.
Knowing that "the pillars of creation" - as this nebula is called - is dust and that there are stars forming inside them (hence "of creation") doesn't steal the beauty of the image away for me. It doesn't stop it looking like a claw reaching upwards. Knowing that they've used "false colours" - as is often the case for astronomical photos, as visible light is often the worst way to see things - only adds to it.
At least for me, the child-like wonder at the beauty of the universe ain't diminished an inch by actually learning the science of what you're looking at. In fact, it's additional layers on top. It brings more to that beauty - to realise it doesn't just look good, but it's functional as well.
I'm a coder and I know what goes on behind the curtain, but this doesn't stop me enjoying playing games. If anything, it can add more - as I realise how bloody clever someone's being to wring out some mad performance from a C64 that shouldn't be possible.
I remember, when I was in university, talking with a Muslim who I shared a student house with, and after a long philosophical conversation, he remarked "you think too much". And my response remains the same: "is that even possible?". I don't think it is.
Whether you want to consciously do the maths or not, music is maths.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes