Fil wrote:Pandering to bronies will ruin the show as much as turning it into the toy commercial it's meant to be.
The last thing I'd want is for it to target bronies actually, as they'd get it wrong and make it "darker" and such.. it'd then miss the point completely and be a classic case of "you're not the one I fell in love with". Some part (of many) of its appeal is in its innocence, uplifting cheerfulness etc that does - quite admittedly - come from the fact that it's aimed at kids.
Assuming they're still selling toys to kids successfully, the balance seems ok as it is. It's for them, but appealing to us weirdosolder folk in addition, not as a replacement.
As per YakYak, achievement unlocked: Massive Tangent Created (100G)
gravy wrote:In other news the original creator has quit the show.
She (Lauren Faust) hasn't quit, she's just stepped down from being Executive Producer to Consulting Producer due to other commitments and a lack of the same amount of time to devote to MLP for its second series. Given she was only responsible for writing three of the episodes in series one, then things I presume are still in good (and the same) hands as before...
Mayhem wrote:As per YakYak, achievement unlocked: Massive Tangent Created (100G)
gravy wrote:In other news the original creator has quit the show.
She (Lauren Faust) hasn't quit, she's just stepped down from being Executive Producer to Consulting Producer due to other commitments and a lack of the same amount of time to devote to MLP for its second series. Given she was only responsible for writing three of the episodes in series one, then things I presume are still in good (and the same) hands as before...
Well...
Lauren Faust wrote:And now I suppose it’s finally time for me to deliver some unfortunate news. I’ve been uncertain for a little while now about how, when and, to be honest, whether to announce the news at all. But here it is: I am no longer working on the show. Various circumstances with the production made it increasingly impossible for me to keep up the level of personal creative involvement and control that I had at the start of the series. I don’t think I can accurately express how difficult and painful the decision was and still is. When Season 2 begins, you will see my credit changed from Executive Producer to Consulting Producer. My involvement in Season 2 ultimately does* not reach far beyond story conception and scripts. A little more involved in the beginning, and a little less towards the end.
Mayhem wrote:Given she was only responsible for writing three of the episodes in series one, then things I presume are still in good (and the same) hands as before...
Maybe.
It's probably not unrelated to the fact that Hasbro's My Little Pony revenues have fallen in 2010*. Exactly the same time this allegedly franchise resurrecting cartoon launched. Quit or pushed? Either seems likely.
* Edit: as reported in Hasbro's SEC filing this year.
Mayhem wrote:Given she was only responsible for writing three of the episodes in series one, then things I presume are still in good (and the same) hands as before...
Maybe.
It's probably not unrelated to the fact that Hasbro's My Little Pony revenues have fallen in 2010*. Exactly the same time this allegedly franchise resurrecting cartoon launched. Quit or pushed? Either seems likely.
* Edit: as reported in Hasbro's SEC filing this year.
I must say I am impressed of your knowledge of Hasbro profits/investments/revenues/etc.
Mayhem wrote:Given she was only responsible for writing three of the episodes in series one, then things I presume are still in good (and the same) hands as before...
Maybe.
It's probably not unrelated to the fact that Hasbro's My Little Pony revenues have fallen in 2010*. Exactly the same time this allegedly franchise resurrecting cartoon launched. Quit or pushed? Either seems likely.
* Edit: as reported in Hasbro's SEC filing this year.
I must say I am impressed of your knowledge of Hasbro profits/investments/revenues/etc.
Yak wrote:One thing that's pretty certain is that the people most vocal with the HURR HURR HURR SIX YEAR OLD GIRLS comments about MLP haven't actually watched it.
It's ok, I'm not Voldemort, it's ok to say my name...
Yak wrote:haven't actually watched it.
Actually yes, I have. That's 30 minutes of my life I'll never get back.
And you think they look any different to anyone over the age of 8?
I've watched a lot of goofy stuff aimed below my age bracket, and I've got to agree with Rik completely on this one.
If you're looking for animated (because animation is always awesome to see) might I very strongly recommend Avatar: The Last Airbender? I'm re-watching the series for the second time with my girlfriend (first time for her) and we're both having a complete blast.
James
You may be surprised this new MLP ( FIM ) actually probably pleasures more people in their 30 .. 40 that maybe the original target it was intended for ( which at this point I am not really so sure about what it should have been ).
In my opinion stuff like "Last Airbender" is "nothing" compared to a thing like FIM, it's definitely not the kind of stuff I'd watch after a stressful day and also to me a thing like that is more targetted to teens than FIM is.
FIM is actually "an anomaly", a show not exactly aimed to teen/adults at all ( well not really ) but that ends up in being more appealing to adults than maybe an 8 years old.
Whole lot of snipping there, because I just want to clarify a point-
I actually plan to give MLP a shot, enough people like it that it seems more than fair. All I'm agreeing with Rik on is that, looking at the two shots in the original post side-by-side, there's not a lot to go on. Old MLP vs new, they both look really girly.
And much like Avatar, the thing that it looks like probably isn't the thing that it is. Avatar: The Last Airbender is excellent, and not the horrible cliche-fest that it sounds like on paper. If I trust you on MLP it's only fair you trust me on this one.
The left picture seems to have a lot more personality to me. Maybe it helps to already be fairly familiar with it though, kind of ruining the point of the pic.
Apart from episodes 1-2 and 3/26 there's no continuity so you can start anywhere BTW.
Good starting points would be:
If you like characters - "Dragonshy". Covers the personality of all the mane cast pretty well.
If you like action or Sonic-the-Hedgehog-like characters - "Sonic Rainboom". Rainbow Dash's finest hour.
If you like slightly darker (for a little girls show) but amusing - "Party of One".
If you like starting at the beginning or "defeating the big evil mwahaha" - Episode 1.
It is a bit contradictory though, given the last sentence of her statement was:
My involvement in Season 2 ultimately does* not reach far beyond story conception and scripts. A little more involved in the beginning, and a little less towards the end.
Which means she will be involved with the show in some capacity, albeit not that much. Doesn't exactly sound like completely quitting the show to me...
You are of course entitled to your own opinion about the show.
As are we all, and it is evident that some people do enjoy it.
So by advising that nobody should bother to judge it for themselves you are in fact doing a disservice to those who might actually enjoy it, but who would miss out if they took your stupid advice to heart.
I have seen the same attitude in some game reviews and it pisses me off; it's stupid in that context too.
It is a bit contradictory though, given the last sentence of her statement was:
My involvement in Season 2 ultimately does* not reach far beyond story conception and scripts. A little more involved in the beginning, and a little less towards the end.
Which means she will be involved with the show in some capacity, albeit not that much. Doesn't exactly sound like completely quitting the show to me...
She's no longer working on the show but did some work for Season 2 before quitting.
As well as writer of 3 episodes she was the developer, executive producer, storyboard artist and creative director for season 1. Her leaving will have an effect, it's just not clear what the effect will be yet.