The Apollo command module wasn't reused, it was just a way of getting the astronaughts back at that point, and maybe a museum piece, corrosion was irrelevant.pogo wrote:Parachutes ! and inflatable floats for landing on water. If they can safely land a return module with a crew of 3 + life support + heat shield returning from the moon they can surely land an empty rocket stage from much lower. Then be ready to pick it up, rinse it and dry it quickly. Again like with people returning from space.gumboot wrote:Water really isn't all that soft for any meaningful drop.
SPACE
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: SPACE
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
Apollo 14 command module (in a museum):

Looks discoloured from the heating on the way down but otherwise sound. Corrosion takes time: if you’ve ever dropped something electrical in water, or poured a drink on it, you know to quickly rinse it and dry it thoroughly, disassembling it if necessary, and it has a good chance of working again.
You might want to build it differently if it has to splash down in water. Add some sealing to stop water getting in to electronics for example. But the bulk of it, being made mostly of large bits of metal, will be fine dipped in water for a short time. It will probably just need a wash to get off any salt and other material it picked up from the water.
Looks discoloured from the heating on the way down but otherwise sound. Corrosion takes time: if you’ve ever dropped something electrical in water, or poured a drink on it, you know to quickly rinse it and dry it thoroughly, disassembling it if necessary, and it has a good chance of working again.
You might want to build it differently if it has to splash down in water. Add some sealing to stop water getting in to electronics for example. But the bulk of it, being made mostly of large bits of metal, will be fine dipped in water for a short time. It will probably just need a wash to get off any salt and other material it picked up from the water.
- axel000
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 2905
- Joined: Thu Sep 29, 2005 4:02 am 0
- PSN: huckwee
- Location: Philadelphia, USA
Re: SPACE
The solid rocket boosters already made parachuted descents into the sea, the water impact still damaged them, hence the need for the powered landing Space X is perfecting.
Also, the wave action can do buckle and break apart the rocket sections. You'd have to add a lot of support structure and mass to prevent that from happening in strong seas.
Also, the wave action can do buckle and break apart the rocket sections. You'd have to add a lot of support structure and mass to prevent that from happening in strong seas.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gamertags:
[Steam] scottish_usa
[PSN] huckwee
[Star Citizen] Zander9
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Gamertags:
[Steam] scottish_usa
[PSN] huckwee
[Star Citizen] Zander9
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: SPACE
I don't think that discolouration is from heating. The heating would have been to the base of the craft where the ablative shield was, the heating would have been less toward the top of the craft. The discolouration is far too uniform to be heat related in my opinion. It might be corrosion, but it's more likely to be a laquer applied in the museum to limit the effects of dust and corrosion from fingers.pogo wrote:Apollo 14 command module (in a museum):
Looks discoloured from the heating on the way down but otherwise sound. Corrosion takes time: if you’ve ever dropped something electrical in water, or poured a drink on it, you know to quickly rinse it and dry it thoroughly, disassembling it if necessary, and it has a good chance of working again.
You might want to build it differently if it has to splash down in water. Add some sealing to stop water getting in to electronics for example. But the bulk of it, being made mostly of large bits of metal, will be fine dipped in water for a short time. It will probably just need a wash to get off any salt and other material it picked up from the water.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: SPACE
Well, pogo was proposing the parachutes.axel000 wrote:The solid rocket boosters already made parachuted descents into the sea, the water impact still damaged them, hence the need for the powered landing Space X is perfecting.
I was thinking more of a half-way house thing. Still the powered landing - but into water, not onto land. We can see in the footage that they can slow it right down to almost a stand still already with the technology they've got. I'm just thinking of those last few metres and using the water to cushion the landing. So things don't explode spectacularly, just because it lost its balance and toppled over.
As I was saying, it's not that a water landing is soft, per se. But just that it's softer than solid ground. More margin for error, so more likely chance of success, one hopes.
(And, indeed, if you were going to attempt it, then you would necessarily need to redesign the rocket. Because you've got to make sure it's buoyant in water, most importantly, but also watertight and sealed / coated to prevent corrosion and such. I realise that it wouldn't be a case of just taking what they've got there now and removing the landing platform to drop it in water. That's not what I was proposing. But maybe future rockets could be designed this way to make the powered landing thing easier and safer.
Plus, of course, no, I'm not a rocket scientist. I could be completely wrong. Just a passing thought I had while looking at the footage, really.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: SPACE
Well, I don't deny that rockets go through a whole heck of a lot of stress during take-off, but My supposition is that a sharp jolt from a water landing (as soft as that might be compared to clay) would force the things through a very extensive inspection process to ensure that there was no minor or progressive damage that could jeopardise future uses.KlaxonCow wrote:But it's softer than solid ground.gumboot wrote:Water really isn't all that soft for any meaningful drop.
When I said "soft landing" I entirely meant it in relative terms, of course, not that it'd be like landing gently like a feather on soft fluffy pillows or anything like that.
Soft's probably the wrong word, granted. But you know what I mean.
And more inspection still for the risk of residual water damage. I mean, you've been using your engine just a fraction of a second prior to get a reasonable splash-down speed. Just how do you plan to seal that hole before any water gets in? Once it's in, how do you ensure that you've got all of it back out again? Along with the minerals that it contains.
I think it's probably a situation well worth avoiding.
But I'm filled with unlimited hope for foam.
Re: SPACE
That was certainly true for the Shuttle SRBs. They needed extensive reworking to make them round again after their splashdown-under-parachute.
In the insurance industry, any car that's been immersed in salt water is automatically written off. You can usually manage to put them back on the road, but a year or two down the line they just disintegrate in short order.
For the Falcon, I reckon you'd have to completely strip down the engines and rebuild them from scratch, and that's the old-fashioned NASA kind of thinking that Musk is trying to prevent. He wants reusable rockets, not ones that can be reconditioned into usability.
In the insurance industry, any car that's been immersed in salt water is automatically written off. You can usually manage to put them back on the road, but a year or two down the line they just disintegrate in short order.
For the Falcon, I reckon you'd have to completely strip down the engines and rebuild them from scratch, and that's the old-fashioned NASA kind of thinking that Musk is trying to prevent. He wants reusable rockets, not ones that can be reconditioned into usability.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
Dawn is back at Ceres. It shot past it about a month ago taking a few photos but its momentum made it overshoot onto Ceres’s dark side as Ceres’s gravity was not enough to catch it. Since then it has been using its ion drive to slowly come back and put itself in orbit, and is now taking photos again:
Spoiler: show
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: SPACE
Craters, craters everywhere, and nary a drop to drink.pogo wrote:Dawn is back at Ceres. It shot past it about a month ago taking a few photos but its momentum made it overshoot onto Ceres’s dark side as Ceres’s gravity was not enough to catch it. Since then it has been using its ion drive to slowly come back and put itself in orbit, and is now taking photos again:
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- Absolute_Zero
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3564
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 4:11 pm 0
- Location: Hilbert Hotel, Heisenberg.
Re: SPACE
I think its amusing that even with something as potentially incredible as the EM Drive results the press still change it to "Nasa invents warp drive!"
Sort of like if the medical community curing all cancers and the press going "All deceases cured and we are immortal now!"
The reality is never enough, no matter how amazing to start with.
Sort of like if the medical community curing all cancers and the press going "All deceases cured and we are immortal now!"
The reality is never enough, no matter how amazing to start with.
-
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
want to read eye-wateringly bad stories? No? Ok.
Re: SPACE
Not a Daily Mail reader, I take it?Darkflame wrote:
Sort of like if the medical community curing all cancers and the press going "All deceases cured and we are immortal now!"
In other news: WHAM!
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-32510911
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
Last image from Messenger, about 1km wide/tall.

On the EM drive, lets wait until the effect has been reported and measured by someone other than NASA who have an interest in anything that they can use to justify a budget. Conservation of momentum is a pretty fundamental law in physics, one that’s stood up well even as physics was revolutionised first by relativity then by quantum mechanics. I find it hard to believe someone has invented a drive that lets us get around it now.

On the EM drive, lets wait until the effect has been reported and measured by someone other than NASA who have an interest in anything that they can use to justify a budget. Conservation of momentum is a pretty fundamental law in physics, one that’s stood up well even as physics was revolutionised first by relativity then by quantum mechanics. I find it hard to believe someone has invented a drive that lets us get around it now.

