SPACE
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
Well yes. They could not even find someone semi-competent to do the renders.
While searching for videos of weather balloons (found lots of ones featuring GoPros lifted into or nearly into space but they don’t capture the actual balloon) I found this:
I think it illustrates the issues very well. The amount of helium balloon needed to lift just one man. And the perils of doing it when there’s any sort of weather. And that’s just one man getting barely off the ground. Not rocket ships, space planes and all the infrastructure needed to land them 20km up.
While searching for videos of weather balloons (found lots of ones featuring GoPros lifted into or nearly into space but they don’t capture the actual balloon) I found this:
I think it illustrates the issues very well. The amount of helium balloon needed to lift just one man. And the perils of doing it when there’s any sort of weather. And that’s just one man getting barely off the ground. Not rocket ships, space planes and all the infrastructure needed to land them 20km up.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
Yes, a geostationary orbit.defsdoor wrote:If something is tethered to the earth and raised high enough, is there a point where the centrifugal force (it will be spinning with the earth) can counter the gravitational pull ?
CBATG
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geostationary_orbit
35,786 km up. Space elevators have been “designed” that would put something in such an orbit, an asteroid maybe, then run a cable from it to the point below it on the Earth. The problem is there is no material we know of that could stretch so far without breaking. Even if we found one such a long cable would be incredibly fragile, open to collisions from satellites, meteors, damage from weather and cosmic rays. And even if we solved that 35,786 km is a heck of a long way, we have no experience making anything similar even 1/1000 the length.
Re: SPACE
I spent a bit of time looking at blimps on wikipedia, and realised just how small they are. Those little wee planes and rockets on the top of that picture? That's probably about the size of a Goodyear blimp, which can lift about ten to twelve tonnes including itself (mostly itself).
I figure one of those drums might be about 60Mm³, which is about 60000 tonnes of lift at sea level and still close to 4500 tonnes at 20km up. Per drum.
Presumably you'd have to do it Hindenburg style and use hydrogen, because where the fuck would you get all that helium? Making that nearer 5000t lift.
Wikipedia tells me a Soyuz-U is a mere 300t (plus fuel, which I can't find right now).
But I don't imagine the objective is to hold the payload up by buoyancy. I expect the objective is to synthesise a nearly light-as-air building material so that you can build up 20km without the fundamental problem of collapsing under your own weight.
But over that length you must have enormous lateral forces to deal with, which I would say implies active compensation (and they mention that in their news announcement) but that flies in the face of wind energy generation, which they also mention.
Still think it's crazy, mind you.
I figure one of those drums might be about 60Mm³, which is about 60000 tonnes of lift at sea level and still close to 4500 tonnes at 20km up. Per drum.
Presumably you'd have to do it Hindenburg style and use hydrogen, because where the fuck would you get all that helium? Making that nearer 5000t lift.
Wikipedia tells me a Soyuz-U is a mere 300t (plus fuel, which I can't find right now).
But I don't imagine the objective is to hold the payload up by buoyancy. I expect the objective is to synthesise a nearly light-as-air building material so that you can build up 20km without the fundamental problem of collapsing under your own weight.
But over that length you must have enormous lateral forces to deal with, which I would say implies active compensation (and they mention that in their news announcement) but that flies in the face of wind energy generation, which they also mention.
Still think it's crazy, mind you.
Re: SPACE
I suspect no-one is going to ever suggest using hydrogen, ever again. I remember watching a programme once where they tried to create some Ye Olde airship design to see if it would actually work, and they were planning to be really authentic with hydrogen, a tar covered fabric envelope etc. They got an expert in to hear this plan, and what he said was "Okay... " but what his face said was "You do that. Meanwhile, I'll be in this blast-proof bunker ready with a brush to sweep up your remains."...
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: SPACE
Hydrogen has a terrible reputation for obvious reasons, but that's an effect of media attention as much as anything.
If you can keep it away from oxygen, and other combustibles, it's a lot less menacing. It still has commercial applications.
And it's not like astronauts have any acute fear of hydrogen.
If you can keep it away from oxygen, and other combustibles, it's a lot less menacing. It still has commercial applications.
And it's not like astronauts have any acute fear of hydrogen.
Re: SPACE
Of course, instead of hydrogen or helium, you could use absolutely nothing.
A vacuum balloon would have even more lift than these lighter-than-air gases, as it literally has no weight at all.
The grand problem with vacuum balloons, though, is maintaining their structural integrity. There is nothing inside it to resist the outside air pressure, so it would instantly collapse without reinforcement... and, generally, the reinforcements required to do that kind of job end up weighing more than the vacuum could lift, so negating its potential for buoyancy in air.
Which is why vacuum balloons are not used to build airships (though, if you could solve that problem, they would be the superior choice - more lift (indeed, the maximum ever possible from this principle of air displacement), no risk of ignition, no "supply" problems, etc.)
But, well, we're talking about a tower that's kilometres in height here. You're already demanding a material with uncannily impossible strength from the off with this design.
So, on the presumption that such a material could exist and be used, it might well be also able to withstand the external pressures of allowing you to create a vacuum inside the tower and, thus, within the already twisted logic of this tower concept in the first place, maybe the most logical choice for its internals is, in fact, absolutely nothing whatsoever.
A vacuum balloon would have even more lift than these lighter-than-air gases, as it literally has no weight at all.
The grand problem with vacuum balloons, though, is maintaining their structural integrity. There is nothing inside it to resist the outside air pressure, so it would instantly collapse without reinforcement... and, generally, the reinforcements required to do that kind of job end up weighing more than the vacuum could lift, so negating its potential for buoyancy in air.
Which is why vacuum balloons are not used to build airships (though, if you could solve that problem, they would be the superior choice - more lift (indeed, the maximum ever possible from this principle of air displacement), no risk of ignition, no "supply" problems, etc.)
But, well, we're talking about a tower that's kilometres in height here. You're already demanding a material with uncannily impossible strength from the off with this design.
So, on the presumption that such a material could exist and be used, it might well be also able to withstand the external pressures of allowing you to create a vacuum inside the tower and, thus, within the already twisted logic of this tower concept in the first place, maybe the most logical choice for its internals is, in fact, absolutely nothing whatsoever.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
That would be a very perverse way of doing it, when you can just fill it with helium and do away with all the structural reinforcements. We have no problem creating vacuums, whether small ones in a vacuum flask or larger ones in a lab or specialised facility. But always the containment is many times heavier than the weight saved, and I don’t think that would decrease with size and scale.
Plus with vacuum you are always in fear of catastrophic failure, if it were to collapse under air pressure due to a miscalculation, or leak air in and so lose buoyancy. Neither is a problem with helium. It could still leak but more slowly as there’s not the great difference in pressure as with a vacuum.
Plus with vacuum you are always in fear of catastrophic failure, if it were to collapse under air pressure due to a miscalculation, or leak air in and so lose buoyancy. Neither is a problem with helium. It could still leak but more slowly as there’s not the great difference in pressure as with a vacuum.
Re: SPACE
It's a lot of helium!
with r=125m, it's 9.817e8 cubic meters. Almost three billion dollars in todays money.
Except I did that wrong. You'll need only a tenth (do all gases expand the same way? Can I do that?) of the gas at the top. Start at $300M and work your way up as you work your way down. I don't know the curve.
(WTF, by the way. 1000 cubic feet is formally denoted "Mcf", which is a thousandth of what it looks like it should be.)
But I do wonder if a vacuum at 20km could be easy enough to maintain that it's not a bad idea. And for a touch of extra buoyancy you could always use the maximum pressure differential you can safely manage, even if it's not absolute it may still be more than zero.
Partial differential with hydrogen would be suicidal, though.
with r=125m, it's 9.817e8 cubic meters. Almost three billion dollars in todays money.
Except I did that wrong. You'll need only a tenth (do all gases expand the same way? Can I do that?) of the gas at the top. Start at $300M and work your way up as you work your way down. I don't know the curve.
(WTF, by the way. 1000 cubic feet is formally denoted "Mcf", which is a thousandth of what it looks like it should be.)
But I do wonder if a vacuum at 20km could be easy enough to maintain that it's not a bad idea. And for a touch of extra buoyancy you could always use the maximum pressure differential you can safely manage, even if it's not absolute it may still be more than zero.
Partial differential with hydrogen would be suicidal, though.
Re: SPACE
Where the fuck from?pogo wrote:when you can just fill it with helium
Helium is in short supply. Because, you know, any that's not been trapped underground has long since floated off into space.
And, unlike hydrogen, it's unreactive and doesn't bond with anything. We do have plenty of hydrogen because it usefully bonds with other things to become heavier than air - such as, of course, oxygen in that stuff we call "water" - and that keeps it from all flying off into space. But helium stubbornly refuses to bond with anything.
And we have much more practical uses for all that helium. It's an excellent coolant. Needed for things like MRI scanners.
It's already bad enough that something so desperately precious as that is regularly pissed away on party balloons, for pity's sake.
Whilst explosive hydrogen is just fine?!pogo wrote:Plus with vacuum you are always in fear of catastrophic failure
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: SPACE
I seem to remember reading an article a year or 2 ago questioning whether or not party balloons should be filled with it.KlaxonCow wrote:Helium is in short supply. Because, you know, any that's not been trapped underground has long since floated off into space.
Hydrogen instead would make for more fun at parties & should make your voice go even squeakier
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: SPACE
Hydrogen no, helium yes. In theory hydrogen is lighter but I imagine within the atmosphere where it very combustible it will always require stringent safety conditions, which will mean complexity, cost, weight. Helium is inert. It’s even safer than heated air as stuff just can’t burn in it. A safe helium balloon just consists of a layer of latex.
A bit of chemistry. It’s not the atomic number or atomic weight that’s important but the molecular weight.
Hydrogen has atomic number and weight 1, but forms molecules consisting of two atoms so has molecular weight 2.
Helium has atomic weight 4, but does not form compounds so exits as single atoms. It has molecular weight 4.
Nitrogen is 80% of air, has atomic weight 14 but also forms diatomic molecules, so has molecular weight 28.
Oxygen is the other 20%, has atomic weight 16, molecular weight 32.
Basically hydrogen is 26 lighter than air, helium is 24, a minimal difference. You would in theory need around 10% more helium than hydrogen (by volume) to lift the same weight, but given the much greater difficulty handling hydrogen helium probably has the advantage. Or put it this way, if hydrogen were at all useable for balloons don’t you think we would use it, if not at fairgrounds than in blimps etc.?
A bit of chemistry. It’s not the atomic number or atomic weight that’s important but the molecular weight.
Hydrogen has atomic number and weight 1, but forms molecules consisting of two atoms so has molecular weight 2.
Helium has atomic weight 4, but does not form compounds so exits as single atoms. It has molecular weight 4.
Nitrogen is 80% of air, has atomic weight 14 but also forms diatomic molecules, so has molecular weight 28.
Oxygen is the other 20%, has atomic weight 16, molecular weight 32.
Basically hydrogen is 26 lighter than air, helium is 24, a minimal difference. You would in theory need around 10% more helium than hydrogen (by volume) to lift the same weight, but given the much greater difficulty handling hydrogen helium probably has the advantage. Or put it this way, if hydrogen were at all useable for balloons don’t you think we would use it, if not at fairgrounds than in blimps etc.?
Re: SPACE
Just Sellotape two hydrogen atoms together and you've basically got helium.
"I am a very considerate person. If I want to go out all night on my miniature golf course and shoot lizards, well, no reason to keep the neighbours awake..."

