Politics Thread!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
And politicians lie all the time, under those definitions. Not only is is common but the law allows it:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentary_privilege
Otherwise prisons would be full of politicians for what they said in parliament. Instead we let them make their statements, carry out their policies or not, then after five years we get to kick them all out at elections if we feel they are dishonest (and the other lot is more honest).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentary_privilege
Otherwise prisons would be full of politicians for what they said in parliament. Instead we let them make their statements, carry out their policies or not, then after five years we get to kick them all out at elections if we feel they are dishonest (and the other lot is more honest).
Re: Politics Thread!
Exactly why we need it.
Directors of publicly listed companies face jail if they make false or misleading statements on shares and assets.
Why wouldn't you want public servants to be accountable for intentionally false statements..
Directors of publicly listed companies face jail if they make false or misleading statements on shares and assets.
Why wouldn't you want public servants to be accountable for intentionally false statements..
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
That’s different though in two ways. First one important point of firms is auditing; preparing and publishing the accounts so the public, in particular the shareholders, know everything. As shareholding is widely dispersed the information has to be public. It has to be released to everyone at the same time, to stop someone gaining advanced knowledge and buying or selling based on it. Subverting this process, by leaking information, preparing false accounts, or otherwise deceiving shareholders, is a form of fraud and so illegal.
But those are very narrow and particular forms of fraud. Lying more generally in the course of business, to e.g. mislead your opponents about your plans, making a prediction that turns out to be wrong, or changing strategy by killing a product early, are not only common but accepted. And most politicians’ “lies” are more like that: changes to policies or plans based on changed circumstances, or changes to wrongfoot the opposition. Not fraud for personal advantage.
The other way it’s wrong is they way I wrote before. While managers at firms can be fired for doing badly politicians can’t. They can only be voted out. And they are voted out for individual policies but for their honesty, competence, fairness, as judged by voters. If they get caught lying they can lose the election because of it. Unless it’s for personal gain, such as embezzlement or taking cash for services, then it should be left up to the electorate.
But those are very narrow and particular forms of fraud. Lying more generally in the course of business, to e.g. mislead your opponents about your plans, making a prediction that turns out to be wrong, or changing strategy by killing a product early, are not only common but accepted. And most politicians’ “lies” are more like that: changes to policies or plans based on changed circumstances, or changes to wrongfoot the opposition. Not fraud for personal advantage.
The other way it’s wrong is they way I wrote before. While managers at firms can be fired for doing badly politicians can’t. They can only be voted out. And they are voted out for individual policies but for their honesty, competence, fairness, as judged by voters. If they get caught lying they can lose the election because of it. Unless it’s for personal gain, such as embezzlement or taking cash for services, then it should be left up to the electorate.
Re: Politics Thread!
Lying in a courtroom is another example - " perjury ".pogo wrote:Blah blah blah blah blah..
Much of the public support the idea of criminalising political lies.
They've made a start in America...
Trippy vibes...
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
http://soundcloud.com/two-gapper
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
I know all about perjury, which is another example of a very narrow circumstance in which lying can be illegal. It’s not just lying in a courtroom, but lying under oath. The person under oath, and it is only one person at once, should tell the truth. But even then they are allowed to defend themselves, or put forward their evidence. You can have two or more contradictory versions of the facts, one or more of which must be a lie, given under oath. But generally people do not get prosecuted unless there is further reason for it.
As for the USA their system is already badly broken. In many cases they have a system of deposition, where each side spends time looking for evidence. They can demand documents, call witnesses. Sometimes they find evidence they would not other have ben able to. But often, and this is often the point, they catch people out in a lie as they have long sessions of giving evidence, all recorded and under oath. If they trip up and contradict themselves, or are contradicted by other evidence, they can be prosecuted for perjury.
The classic example is Bill Clinton. He was investigated after getting a blow job in the Oval Office. That’s not by any stretch illegal. It may be grounds for divorce but that’s between a married couple. But he was investigated and eventually charged with not the act but lying about it: his “I did not have sexual relations with that woman” depending on a very tortured definition of sexual relations. The whole process was overtly political, and ended when the US Senate failed to convict him for his statement. But it shows how statements about something that’s not even remotely illegal can turn into charges.
As for the USA their system is already badly broken. In many cases they have a system of deposition, where each side spends time looking for evidence. They can demand documents, call witnesses. Sometimes they find evidence they would not other have ben able to. But often, and this is often the point, they catch people out in a lie as they have long sessions of giving evidence, all recorded and under oath. If they trip up and contradict themselves, or are contradicted by other evidence, they can be prosecuted for perjury.
The classic example is Bill Clinton. He was investigated after getting a blow job in the Oval Office. That’s not by any stretch illegal. It may be grounds for divorce but that’s between a married couple. But he was investigated and eventually charged with not the act but lying about it: his “I did not have sexual relations with that woman” depending on a very tortured definition of sexual relations. The whole process was overtly political, and ended when the US Senate failed to convict him for his statement. But it shows how statements about something that’s not even remotely illegal can turn into charges.
Re: Politics Thread!
You can get into some very serious shit in the US if you're a publicly traded company's representative and do any of those things, if those things could affect the percieved market value of the company. Deliberate misdirection is pretty much entirely illegal, and in the case of accidental misdirection you need to come clean immediately you understand that you made a mistake in prediction or have changed strategy, or you'll be accused of fraud by the SEC.pogo wrote:Lying more generally in the course of business, to e.g. mislead your opponents about your plans, making a prediction that turns out to be wrong, or changing strategy by killing a product early, are not only common but accepted.
Your only two options are to tell the truth or say nothing under trade secret rules (and even then, your financial predictions still have to be accurate and take account of expected revenues / losses from any secrets). Falsehoods will land you with enormous fines and jail time very presto.
The UK is marginally more relaxed, but not that much.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
There is a “quiet period” around certain events such as the announcement of results, the announcement of a merger or sell off. But mostly the point it to ensure all shareholders hear about it at the same time, so it is only announced when results are final, or the merger is certain, not before, and the announcement can be done in a standard way so everyone who wants hears it.Dio wrote:You can get into some very serious shit in the US if you're a publicly traded company's representative and do any of those things, if those things could affect the percieved market value of the company.pogo wrote:Lying more generally in the course of business, to e.g. mislead your opponents about your plans, making a prediction that turns out to be wrong, or changing strategy by killing a product early, are not only common but accepted.
Apart from that companies regularly do things that impact their share price, including things that some might find deceptive. Apple disparaged large screen phones and styluses for tablets, implying they would never do them, before producing their own versions of each. Media companies regularly leak plot points and other details, even incorrect ones to throw fans off the trail. Many firms do viral, deceptive marketing that has little to do with the product. Release dates are announced then changed, products are announced then canned or scrapped.
Re: Politics Thread!
... and if you do most of those things intentionally, you bet your backside you'll be in trouble.
See Tom Hanks on this week's Graham Norton, who after accidentally announcing Toy Story 4 by saying he was working on it had Disney lawyers on the phone to him within ten minutes.
Trust me. I've had the training on this one, as a senior staff member who has an interest in the company's share price. I am extraordinarily restricted in what I can say as much for legal reasons as for avoiding-getting-fired reasons. Dishonestly representing the company's position on almost anything financial or greatly finance affecting is a huge DO NOT DO IT, whether it's for deception purposes or not.
I'm sure if you review some of the examples you mention, you'll find they're couched in much more ambiguous language than you remember, or at a much greater distance from the future changes. And others clearly don't affect the share price in an obvious way, or are just simply marketing, such as plot point leaks.
See Tom Hanks on this week's Graham Norton, who after accidentally announcing Toy Story 4 by saying he was working on it had Disney lawyers on the phone to him within ten minutes.
Trust me. I've had the training on this one, as a senior staff member who has an interest in the company's share price. I am extraordinarily restricted in what I can say as much for legal reasons as for avoiding-getting-fired reasons. Dishonestly representing the company's position on almost anything financial or greatly finance affecting is a huge DO NOT DO IT, whether it's for deception purposes or not.
I'm sure if you review some of the examples you mention, you'll find they're couched in much more ambiguous language than you remember, or at a much greater distance from the future changes. And others clearly don't affect the share price in an obvious way, or are just simply marketing, such as plot point leaks.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
All very interesting, but do you know what the most popular article on the Guardian is right now?
Labour leadership in turmoil over vote on UK military action in Syria
It hardly matters what the Tories do at the moment, as the opposition make them look like paragons of professionalism. Corbyn looks less and less like someone fit to run the country by the day.
Labour leadership in turmoil over vote on UK military action in Syria
It hardly matters what the Tories do at the moment, as the opposition make them look like paragons of professionalism. Corbyn looks less and less like someone fit to run the country by the day.
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
Re: Politics Thread!
Because to run the country you have to like bombing?
As Michael Rosen tweeted today "I prefer Labour arguing over whether to bomb than a near unanimous Labour Party bombing with gusto".
As Michael Rosen tweeted today "I prefer Labour arguing over whether to bomb than a near unanimous Labour Party bombing with gusto".
Re: Politics Thread!
Call me back when you think of somewhere where just bombing actually / would have improved matters.pogo wrote:It hardly matters what the Tories do at the moment, as the opposition make them look like paragons of professionalism. Corbyn looks less and less like someone fit to run the country by the day.
Apart from Slough, obviously.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
Re: Politics Thread!
And this would be just bombing a country where everyone on the ground is already being just bombed by one or more of Russia and the US. What on earth is the point of us joining in?
Cameron outlined seven points which need to be met before bombing starts, and two of them were laughably far away: effective ground forces to finish the job in ISIS territory (how can any of them be effective when if they're Assad the US will bomb them and if they're not the Russians will) and a credible post-conflict strategy (so that would involve being able to accurately specify who will run the country afterwards, which he surely obviously can't).
So Cameron's even failing his own tests, if he's intellectually honest about his interpretations.
Cameron outlined seven points which need to be met before bombing starts, and two of them were laughably far away: effective ground forces to finish the job in ISIS territory (how can any of them be effective when if they're Assad the US will bomb them and if they're not the Russians will) and a credible post-conflict strategy (so that would involve being able to accurately specify who will run the country afterwards, which he surely obviously can't).
So Cameron's even failing his own tests, if he's intellectually honest about his interpretations.
- phattslagg
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 3578
- Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
- Location: Worcester, England
Re: Politics Thread!
And anyway, pongo, there will be many of us who think that by showing the strength *not* to just walk into the fucking obvious trap that ISIS have set for us, he is better suited to leadership than Cameron.
Re: Politics Thread!
This whole voting business is all getting a bit "have you stopped beating your wife?", isn't it.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
Trap? The main reason ISIS bombed Paris was to try and scare off the French, or anyone else who might consider joining in. The UK stepping up its response therefore is exactly the opposite of what they wanted. Corbyn, if he votes against bombing in Syria, is doing exactly what ISIS wants. If anyone is falling into their trap it is him.phattslagg wrote:And anyway, pongo, there will be many of us who think that by showing the strength *not* to just walk into the fucking obvious trap that ISIS have set for us, he is better suited to leadership than Cameron.

