disciple wrote:gravy wrote:This is kind of a facile point but sort of worth asking.
A lot of animals we eat wouldn't exist in the first place if we hadn't cultivated for food. Is it better for a pig to live and end up as sausages than not exist in the first place?
I'll just be honest here, though it may result in the discussion becoming a bit hairy.
Animals or breeds of animals?
The former, better to not have existed. I'm not sure anything is lost by something not being born is it. That to me feels like it's almost pushing towards religious territory.
The issue is more of what happens after, to make it a bit more extreme (I don't think it's a straw man). You couldn't really justify, say, a slave farm on the grounds that the slaves wouldn't have existed otherwise. "Well the animals wouldn't have existed so it's ok" seems a bit of a red-herring to me, in reality irrelevant to the discussion. A distraction.
The latter, well that's pretty complex isn't it.
As I say it's not so black and white, ending up as sausages isn't necessarily the issue.
Really depends from what angle you are talking.
Are we talking about...
1. Certain species/breed of animal only exists because we bred them?
2. The number of animals that are farmed and hence have short lives and die for our food production?
1. The animals would have existed anyway, maybe not exact breeds or types we eat sure OK. Wild boars would still exist even if apes hadn't got the spark of intelligence to become cavemen millions of years ago. There are also 2 metre high descendants of oxen too. Chickens and all other birds are dinosaurs. We eat them, and to help the process we farm them. But they do not only exist because we made them.
2. If the issue you want to discuss is 'is there already too many people on the planet' given in one century we went from 1.5 billion to 6 billion people. Higher population does equal higher cattle and therefore by definition more animals born specifically for the purpose of being slaughtered for food to feed the excessive population of this straining planet. It's never better to be born into the world to suffer and then be killed horribly, it's either the same as not being born or worse than not being born from the point of rational thinking. Definitely not for the better in any scenario whether religious beliefs are included in the debate or excluded completely.
We are at the top of the food chain and we're predators, this is how it turns out on every planet with intelligent life like ours I guarantee you. If Star Trek type utopian bollox was true then warp drive journeys between 50,000 light year distances would also be true.
Just pray Soylent Green does not come true in your lifetime
