This is what I'm so dubious and sceptical about:
https://yougov.co.uk/topics/internation ... ived-safet
As YouGov are acknowledging and measuring here, there was an effective reputational attack mounted on the AstraZeneca vaccine in the EU.
Let us remember the German newspaper, Handelsblatt, with their article claiming that an anonymous German government source told them that the vaccine was only 8% effective in over-65s.
When I suggested, on this thread, that this didn't seem at all right, the response was that this was a respected German newspaper and it would not risk its reputation. This was further reinforced when the newspaper doubled down on the claims.
The thing is, as we now know, that 8% claim is wrong. Horridly wrong. Absurdly wrong.
It's seemingly backing up Macron's reputation-destroying claims that the vaccine is "quasi-ineffective for over-65s".
And it was not just France who was saying these things. Indeed, France backed own to approve the AZ vaccine in over-65s, before the German government did.
There was a disinformation campaign against the AstraZeneca vaccine in the EU - and it has succeeded, looking at the YouGov poll, in putting off an awful lot of people from getting vaccinated with it.
Stocks of the vaccine, not just in France but also Germany and other EU countries, are simply not being fully utilised.
This was the connection I was getting at. The EU is demanding the vaccine and even confiscating it, yet is then not actually fully utilising it.
The tragedy that I'm concerned with is that they stop 400K doses going to Australia - who, indeed, need the vaccines, as their bet on a home-grown vaccine unfortunately failed, so they need that 400K doses and would use up every last bit of it - and then it ends up not being fully utilised.
This is the real damage of the political games being played here. 400K human beings - Australians - could have happily used up every last dose, while the EU wants it all - and then isn't delivering enough doses, and apparently can't do so, as Europeans have been scared off it.
Scared off it by those newspaper claims of only being 8% effective for over-65s, that were seemingly backed up by Macron's "quasi-ineffective" claims.
And the thing is that these claims aren't just wrong, they're wildly wrong. 8% efficacy suggests it's not worth bothering with at all - which, yeah, contrasts sharply with the EU's threats and bullying of AZ to get every single last dose they can, but why would they bother if it was genuinely that bad? And that calls into question whether they did know that these 8% claims were bogus? - but, actually, the data that's come out places it as roughly an equal to the other vaccines.
You see, if the real figures were, say, 80% and the claims had been 70%, then you could say that this was an honest mistake. A margin of error. But claiming 8% efficacy?!?
And one has to ask why, indeed, a newspaper like Handelsblatt would stake its reputation on this article, and then double down on it in a subsequent article?
Perhaps because they absolutely ain't remotely lying that they got this data from an anonymous German government source. We don't know who that is, but the paper would know and they likely did all their due diligence to check that this person really was from the German government and all the rest of it.
But, of course, what they can't verify ahead of publication is whether their source - from the German government, Handelsblatt was totally assured by, to stand by their article - was just lying to them about the data.
Handelsblatt would have stood by the article and the claims
if they knew for a fact that their source really was from the German government and was someone who would absolutely know and have access to this data. They'd believe it and double-down on it, if they, for example, got to see the data on actual official German government paper and so on and so forth.
Handelsblatt stuck by it because, from their perspective, everything they were reporting was true. But, of course, there's a subtle but important difference between the claim that the vaccine is only 8% effective in over-65s, and faithfully reporting that someone told you that the vaccine is only 8% effective in over-65s.
Like, I can absolutely faithfully report that the bloke down the pub told me that he'd flown to Mars on a SpaceX rocket. I'm not lying. That is what the bloke down the pub said. My reporting is totally accurate and faithful to what I've been told. What's a complete load of shit, though, is what the bloke down the pub is actually saying. He never did fly to Mars on a SpaceX rocket. He's a big fat liar.
And the thing is, what would give Handelsblatt the confidence to publish that article and then double-down on it, staking their reputation? I'm thinking it would that, yes, a German government official - in a position where they should know - really did "leak" to this newpaper that the vaccine was only 8% effective in over-65s.
And then, on cue, Macron backs that up with his "quasi-ineffective" comment. Which then adds much more weight to these claims, because now you've got two different countries seemingly saying the same thing, and a newspaper standing its ground that, yes, we absolutely stand by our journalistic integrity on this, we absolutely were told by a German government source (though we can't name who, as we must protect our sources).
This reminds me of that photo that Piers Morgan published, during the height of the Iraq war, which showed criminal shit going on inside a British army vehicle. Thinking he had a scoop - something to back up his anti-war stance - he rushed to publication.
Then it came out that, actually, the army vehicle in the photo is not one that's on active duty in Iraq. It couldn't be real. So, duped into this, Piers Morgan lost his job running the paper (although, hey, he's doing alright on TV these days instead), because of how he'd failed to do due diligence in checking that the photo must be real.
But, come on, this was a stitch up. Because, okay, it's not a vehicle that the military have deployed in Iraq. But it is a British army vehicle - so who would have access to it, to stage this fake photo? Who, in fact, would be so clever as to create a fake photo, but leave this nerdy little fact in there - which only a really nerdy military buff would even notice, that the vehicle is very slightly different and this gives the game away that it's all fake - so that you could convince Piers to publish, but then wreck his reputation afterwards for wrongly publishing it?
Someone who, ooh, would be annoyed by his anti-Iraq stance and would have access to British army vehicles, in the UK, to stage this fake photo. Catch my drift?
Yes, the photo was fake and Piers was played for a fool - being given what was seemingly a "smoking gun" that he rushed to publish, impatient to be shown he was right all along, without getting his own military buffs in to verify its veracity - but there's still that absolutely massive question hanging there: Who the fuck faked that photo? Who had the motivation to do so? Who had access to British army resources to be able to do it?
Piers was je-baited, as the Twitch kids would say. He was, indeed, an idiot to fall for it and disregard standard journalistic integrity, in his excitement to have this "scoop", to get your boys to go over the evidence with a fine-toothed comb. But you can totally see why.
Faking such a photo is quite a tall order - why, only someone like the British government would have the motivation and resource to pull it off, really - and, as this destroys the government "case for war", then you mentally rule out the idea that it was a fake by the British government, by why would they be faking something that makes them look bad? So, Piers published. It seemed logical. But then, oh, the vehicle in the photo is wrong. It can't be real, and must be a fake. Well, that would then explain why the British government would fake such a photo, feed it to the over-excited puppy who's been running a ceaseless anti-war campaign in his paper, and then point out that, yes, the photo can't be real, because of this tiny little detail about the vehicle - which proves it's not one of those deployed in Iraq - which they absolutely know that someone like Piers Morgan's not going to know. Because, quite frankly, how many people can happily identify the make and model of a British army vehicle from the inside?
I'm thinking that Handelsblatt has been similarly je-baited and played like that. German official talks to them, shows them official-looking documents with 8% on it. They check the credentials of this government official and, yeah, they check out. Everything they can confirm - save the veracity of that 8% claim, which is beyond them, as they're not the ones actually testing the vaccines - seems to check out. So they publish and double-down that everything they're saying is correct. They absolutely
were told, by an anonymous German government official, that the vaccine was 8%. That is a fact. That definitely happened. But, of course, what isn't a fact is that what that German government official told them was actually true.
This stinks of political games. Mafia-like threats that "it'd be a shame if something were to happen to the demand for your vaccine", as you make them an offer they can't refuse. We want every last bit of the vaccine - and if we don't get it, then we'll ruin your international reputation, so that, if we can't have you, then no-one can. How do you threaten a corporation? Yes, you go for their profits. Heck, if they can use their "biggest trading bloc on the planet" status to seed international doubts, then orders might dry up and then, hey, no-one's in their way from getting all of the vaccine.
I strongly suspect foul play.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes