Here's a not terribly well-put-out "debunking" of the 2001 "prior art" claims, pointing out that nowhere in 2001 (the movie) is the "ipad" manipulated in any way like an actual modern-day tablet computer, and that in fact it behaves much more like a portable flatscreen TV.defsdoor wrote:I think you've missed the point. Apple have a patent on a particular design - not functionality or something whizz bang
http://obamapacman.com/2011/08/debunked ... -analysis/
most of which, of course, goes nowhere to debunking the patent itself, as it doesn't claim anything about device usage, and only an ornamental design for an "electronic device" (which phrase could cover anything from a tablet computer to an electronic tablemat). However, he does point out that the prop in the film has a raised lip at the front, which basically torpedos the patent - it's not the same design at all, no matter the usage.
Yep, it's a design patent, and that's what design patents are used for. See the other patents referenced in the Apple patent, and those referenced in that, and so on and so forth. The idea is that you can patent a particular embodiment of a design, and then people can't make stuff that looks close to or exactly the same without licensing your patent. Is that a good idea, when dealing with something where the design is relatively obvious (although not so obvious that there aren't thousands of similar-but-not-quite-the-same design patents out there)? Probably not, but that's pretty much all there is.defsdoor wrote:just a particular style and layout of a tablet and they are exercising that patent to prevent similar looking tablets from reaching market.
Samsung, it seems to me, would have been better off pointing out that their own design is not the same as that of the iPad (or that embodied in the patent), as it has "a plurality of buttons on the front surface", and that should be that.
<headgear class="tinfoil">Or maybe this is part of a deal with MS, who were after $15 per Android device shipped by Samsung</headgear>






