A market segment which is a mass marketDio wrote:That's just producing a new premium product in a new market segment
The Apple thread
Re: The Apple thread
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
But it got there by not compromising. Apple's genius nowadays is getting into markets at the point where they can make something that doesn't compromise on quality and capabilities at a price where it will sell. It may be more expensive but it's seen as good value for money because of the quality. So it's both premium and mass market.Gravy wrote:That's completely irrelevant it best selling portable music player both in $$$ and units. It's a mass market device selling 220m units to the end of 2009
And they are getting better at it. A lot of other companies made MP3 players; probably most of them made a profit. Only Apple though seem to be making money out of smartphones, making over half the industry's profit. And no-one is making money selling tablets apart from Apple.
- lazerwalker
- Baaaaa!

- Posts: 1319
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 10:22 pm 0
- Location: (Very) sarf of the river
Re: The Apple thread
Prediction's looking good so far:lazerwalker wrote:Amazon will launch a Kindroid device but it'll be lower end - look at the B&N nook color in the US for the sort of thing, 7" colour device, Android based but heavily modified. This will dominate the low-end, as Amazon have distribution, and more scope to inhabit loss-leader territory as they will want to be selling lots of content on the back of it. Only as the price of larger screens drops will Amazon enter the iPad sized/quality in any meaningful way.
http://techcrunch.com/2011/09/02/amazon-kindle-tablet/
(tl;dr: 7", $250(!), forked Android)
Although the article also says a full size tablet may follow at the start of next year.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
Another cheap tablet, the 35Pad
http://product.it168.com/list/b/14161093_pricea_1.shtml
The price ¥2680 is about £250. With VAT and shipping it would cost at least £300, probably not cheap enough to really take market share off the iPad. But if this is available now then other China-made tablets will get cheaper and better over the coming months, certainly into next year.
It will be interesting to see what Apple does next year. They've got the market to themselves this year but as Amazon and others release tablets at lower prices it will bring new buyers into the market in 2012. Apple might e.g. keep the iPad 2 around when it releases the iPad 3, cutting its price to limit the price advantage of new cheaper Android devices.
http://product.it168.com/list/b/14161093_pricea_1.shtml
The price ¥2680 is about £250. With VAT and shipping it would cost at least £300, probably not cheap enough to really take market share off the iPad. But if this is available now then other China-made tablets will get cheaper and better over the coming months, certainly into next year.
It will be interesting to see what Apple does next year. They've got the market to themselves this year but as Amazon and others release tablets at lower prices it will bring new buyers into the market in 2012. Apple might e.g. keep the iPad 2 around when it releases the iPad 3, cutting its price to limit the price advantage of new cheaper Android devices.
Re: The Apple thread
The problem with the Android devices is that they are shite. Technologically, they are gems, but Android itself is horrible. Compare and contrast the user experience for Android and iOS, even on a top-of-the-range brand name Android tab, and the decision is a no-brainer. Get a low-end model, and you'll be hating it until you eventually throw it away in disgust.
Add into that the fact that the manufacturers have zero interest in producing upgrades; they are being sold as throwaway toys - if you want an upgrade either you go for some unknown hack or buy a new device. Even the major manufacturers are "reticent" about giving away enough source to build your own image, for the chinese manufacturers it's like pulling (hen's) teeth even to get the GPLed bits.
Amazon might be able to do something by forking and heavily modifying Android (modulo the upgrade issue), but otherwise Android is setting itself up to be "the OS that killed the tablet revolution".
Add into that the fact that the manufacturers have zero interest in producing upgrades; they are being sold as throwaway toys - if you want an upgrade either you go for some unknown hack or buy a new device. Even the major manufacturers are "reticent" about giving away enough source to build your own image, for the chinese manufacturers it's like pulling (hen's) teeth even to get the GPLed bits.
Amazon might be able to do something by forking and heavily modifying Android (modulo the upgrade issue), but otherwise Android is setting itself up to be "the OS that killed the tablet revolution".
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
nvm, see it's mentioned above
Re: The Apple thread
nvm?
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
nevermind
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
For some perspective on Apple's lead in e.g. tablets:
http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2011/08/steve_j ... f_eur.html

It's not luck or Job's genius, it's simply hard work. This takes place in private, not in public, so it looks easy and effortless. If other companies want to emulate Apple need to put in the same work: if they just look at what Apple's done and try and copy it they will fail.
http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2011/08/steve_j ... f_eur.html

It's not luck or Job's genius, it's simply hard work. This takes place in private, not in public, so it looks easy and effortless. If other companies want to emulate Apple need to put in the same work: if they just look at what Apple's done and try and copy it they will fail.
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
Another interesting read. This compares the experience of buying, or trying to buy, lightweight laptops from other vendors with the limited range Apple offers.
http://arstechnica.com/hardware/news/20 ... n-game.ars
The long and the short of it is that PC manufacturers have only themselves to blame for trailing Apple because of their insistence on offering far too many models and options. If only they slimmed down their product lines to a handful of models they too could make laptops as slim and attractive as the MacBook Air at a similar cost. They too have good designers, and given time could achieve the economies of scale Apple has with components.
It strikes me the same is true of phones: there's only one iPhone (unless you buy last year's model). Sony Ericsson sell 54 in the UK today, and seem to release more each week. It's only not true of tablets as Apple has such a lead. And of course there's this:
http://arstechnica.com/hardware/news/20 ... n-game.ars
The long and the short of it is that PC manufacturers have only themselves to blame for trailing Apple because of their insistence on offering far too many models and options. If only they slimmed down their product lines to a handful of models they too could make laptops as slim and attractive as the MacBook Air at a similar cost. They too have good designers, and given time could achieve the economies of scale Apple has with components.
It strikes me the same is true of phones: there's only one iPhone (unless you buy last year's model). Sony Ericsson sell 54 in the UK today, and seem to release more each week. It's only not true of tablets as Apple has such a lead. And of course there's this:
Re: The Apple thread
tufty wrote:The problem with the Android devices is that they are shite. Technologically, they are gems, but Android itself is horrible. Compare and contrast the user experience for Android and iOS, even on a top-of-the-range brand name Android tab, and the decision is a no-brainer. Get a low-end model, and you'll be hating it until you eventually throw it away in disgust.
(...)
Amazon might be able to do something by forking and heavily modifying Android (modulo the upgrade issue), but otherwise Android is setting itself up to be "the OS that killed the tablet revolution".
The more I look into the possibility of coding for Android on a Tablet, the less I want to do it. It looks like a nightmare to get multimedia stuff going and the dev environment is so crude it makes my brain recoil in horror.
The only thing going for it that it allows a very good hardware competitor to have an open system,
as opposed to Apple's walled garden, which is incredibly annoying and discourages me from even trying it out.
From what I hear, the user experience on a Motorola Xoom is better overall than an iPad, especially when you add to this the open nature of it's OS (no format restrictions for video for example and so on).
I am still waiting for someone to put up a real challenge to Apple as regards ease of development on a Tablet though. I doubt from what I see that this challenger could be Android in any near future. The Apps are just not there and no wonder. Here's hoping that someone steps up with some alternative OS (not Linux based?) that will make devs want to create stuff on a Tablet that isn't locked.
Re: The Apple thread
Speaking of getting rid of crap, one of the best things PC laptop manufacturers could do is get rid of the crap that they install on the machines.
I had the MD at work complaining earlier that his Toshiba was popping up nags, notifications, requests to do this, requests to do that (boss gave it to him as it was. I would've uninstalled all the crap first, but that's just me). I don't blame him - I expanded the notification area and it came up with this huge grid.. I think it was 5x5, so 25 icons. That's how much crap they stuff on there on a "clean" installation... it's disgusting. The out-of-box experience is basically just getting more and more pissed off at all the nags and clutter.
Am I happy to pay more for an experience that doesn't make me want to stab something? Damn right!
I had the MD at work complaining earlier that his Toshiba was popping up nags, notifications, requests to do this, requests to do that (boss gave it to him as it was. I would've uninstalled all the crap first, but that's just me). I don't blame him - I expanded the notification area and it came up with this huge grid.. I think it was 5x5, so 25 icons. That's how much crap they stuff on there on a "clean" installation... it's disgusting. The out-of-box experience is basically just getting more and more pissed off at all the nags and clutter.
Am I happy to pay more for an experience that doesn't make me want to stab something? Damn right!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: The Apple thread
The advantage of the walled garden though is it makes sure developers are paid. Without it anything good gets cracked and installed by most users without paying. So if you are a developer who wants to make money or a user who wants the best apps (developers mostly don't do their best work for free) a walled garden is essential.
Re: The Apple thread
Coding for Android really is awful, especially if you want performance. The choice of a poorly optimised Java clone as a systems programming language for "limited" CPU devices is possibly one of the daftest I've ever come across. But I've railed on about that repeatedly, and it's unlikely Google are gonna listen to me... Dropping down to "native" code is, of course, do-able (but painful and woefully underdocumented, like most things about Android).noodles wrote:The more I look into the possibility of coding for Android on a Tablet, the less I want to do it. It looks like a nightmare to get multimedia stuff going and the dev environment is so crude it makes my brain recoil in horror.
This makes your life as a developer very hard and very annoying, however - devices have massively differing capabilities, versions of (and modifications to) the underlying OS, even the bits of hardware you might expect to have similar performance don't necessarily depending on the chipset (touchscreen / sensor response times, for example, can be a horrible headache, especially if you need high performance)noodles wrote:The only thing going for it that it allows a very good hardware competitor to have an open system,
Annoying in what way? Sure, it's "pay to enter" for devs, you have to have an OSX box to develop on, and there are restrictions as to what you are "allowed" to develop if you want to distribute through Apple, but otherwise, the "walled garden" is a massive boon - a small and strictly defined set of hardware to develop for, decent dev tools, proper (and in depth) documentation and useful sample code, etc etc.noodles wrote:as opposed to Apple's walled garden, which is incredibly annoying and discourages me from even trying it out.
There's only one way to decide if that's true, and that's to try and live with an Android tablet and an iPad. My experience has been that the Android "user experience" is one of frustration, irritation, random crashes and lockups, half the apps on the market not working properly on a tablet with its "big screen", rogue bash shells using 100% CPU and requiring either a reboot or a terminal emulator and a rooted tablet to fix, being forced into being part of Google's "sell my personal details" advertising funded empire (TANSTAAFL), and finally that there's precious few games worth playing. Plus, of course, "you are out of space, please uninstall some applications" when I have an 8GB CF card which is mostly empty.noodles wrote:From what I hear, the user experience on a Motorola Xoom is better overall than an iPad,
Ain't nothing particularly wrong with using Linux as a kernel - after all, the kernel of iOS isn't so far from Linux in many respects. It's (mostly) the userland layer of Android that's fucked by design. In fact, it feels fucked more by lack of design, but it's a tradeoff - usability vs advertising revenue.noodles wrote:Here's hoping that someone steps up with some alternative OS (not Linux based?) that will make devs want to create stuff on a Tablet that isn't locked.
A small realtime microkernel might be a "better" option than Linux's monolithic monstrosity, but there's a lot of work to turn a microkernel into an OS.
The main problem is that nobody else seems to have anything approaching market readiness. WebOS seems to have been binned (it could probably have been a contender), MS seem to be pinning their hopes on Win8 but are so far behind the market I doubt if they will catch up before the scene has moved on massively, and I haven't heard anything much about crackberry's OS since the playbook was announced. The various other linux-based options are basically a (not very good) joke.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10456
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: The Apple thread
Everything Tufty said is true.
On the Crackberry front, the Playbook OS is very nice to use, but quite limited as it's lacking key apps (like Email!). I hear a V2 version is expected in the next few weeks though so hopefully it will get better.
However it's still a wall garden, so Android lovers will hate it! Saying that I don't see the hate, possibly because it's not Apple's garden or there are just too few of the?
No real idea what it's like from a dev point of view, but at least it's just one bit of hardware to program for, and haven't really delved into their app store to see the quality, just use it as an altertive browser to my iPad sometimes.
In general a nice bit of kit, prefer it to any Android device I've played with, but would never have it instead of my iPad.
I would like Apple to go rubber backed like on the Playbook.
On the Crackberry front, the Playbook OS is very nice to use, but quite limited as it's lacking key apps (like Email!). I hear a V2 version is expected in the next few weeks though so hopefully it will get better.
However it's still a wall garden, so Android lovers will hate it! Saying that I don't see the hate, possibly because it's not Apple's garden or there are just too few of the?
No real idea what it's like from a dev point of view, but at least it's just one bit of hardware to program for, and haven't really delved into their app store to see the quality, just use it as an altertive browser to my iPad sometimes.
In general a nice bit of kit, prefer it to any Android device I've played with, but would never have it instead of my iPad.
I would like Apple to go rubber backed like on the Playbook.

