Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Or it could be like a copper doing a stop-and-search and getting assaulted in response. Or it could be like ramming a car off the road because its got a dodgy brake light. Or it could be like this pub where all your mates go to, but if you don't like the conversation you can go to another pub but you can't because a different bunch of people are in a stopping minibuses to see if they're smuggling in booze, cos glass bottles aren't allowed, but really it's becuase they're overcharging for alcohol except they aren't because there isn't enough booze in the pub to go around but the bouncers have got all their door certification badges so they want to look in your bag but that's the bag with your asthma inhaler in but you can't stop them because you're too wheezy and everyone else knows that someone else started it anyway.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Or just like a load of people being killed
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Except it's nothing like it. First a "copper doing a stop-and-search" is a pretty harmless act, like being breathalysed after an accident. The intention here was to stop them at all costs, not stop them and check if they were doing anything illegal. Second the aggression was on the part of the IDF, who boarded the vessel and used force to take it. The people on the boat were not the aggressors: they had days at sea but had no other weapons than what came to hand as they tried to defend their boat. Thirdly the response of the IDF was wholly disproportionate: trained soldiers shooting to kill civilians armed with bits of the ship.aureole wrote:Or it could be like a copper doing a stop-and-search and getting assaulted in response.
The fact that they felt they had to do this highlights the craziness of the blockade. If e.g. the UK government wanted to stop smuggling it could just track it until entered UK waters or landed then arrest people. Israel could not do that as on that side of Gaza it's not Israeli territory, and they have no legitimacy in the Gaza strip itself.
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Not really sure what an of this has to do with anything, nor what point you're trying to make.aureole wrote:Or it could be like a copper doing a stop-and-search and getting assaulted in response. Or it could be like ramming a car off the road because its got a dodgy brake light. Or it could be like this pub where all your mates go to, but if you don't like the conversation you can go to another pub but you can't because a different bunch of people are in a stopping minibuses to see if they're smuggling in booze, cos glass bottles aren't allowed, but really it's becuase they're overcharging for alcohol except they aren't because there isn't enough booze in the pub to go around but the bouncers have got all their door certification badges so they want to look in your bag but that's the bag with your asthma inhaler in but you can't stop them because you're too wheezy and everyone else knows that someone else started it anyway.
To reiterate my point, 20 miles or not, it was obvious to any reasonable person that their intention was to run the blockade. And since only a reasonable belief is required wasn't taking action therefore legal and justified?
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
I note that intent (known or suspected) to breach a blockade is not sufficient grounds for stopping, for boarding or, indeed, for massacring.The Beeb wrote:The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea says only if a vessel is suspected to be transporting weapons, or weapons of mass destruction, can it be boarded in international waters. Otherwise the permission of the ship's flag carrying nation must be sought.
The charter allows for naval blockades, but the effect of the blockade on civilians must be proportionate to the effect on the military element for the blockade to be legally enforceable.
A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate".
Last edited by Harlequin on Wed Jun 02, 2010 1:37 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10454
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
It's likely the soldiers shouldn't have been there, but does a 'peace' activist doesn't act like this?Harlequin wrote: or, indeed, for massacring.
And mobbing and hitting people carrying guns with metal bars is surely a sure fire way to get shot? Not condoning anything, but if you are a soldier outnumbered being attacked that way, or seeing a colleague attacked that way. How are you going to react?
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
As someone so wisely stated earlier in this thread:Misfit wrote:It's likely the soldiers shouldn't have been there, but does a 'peace' activist doesn't act like this?
Duck Turkin wrote:… when you are attacked you defend yourself. Proportionate response is a great idea but doesn't work in the real world.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10454
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
However he was referring to the soldiers!Harlequin wrote:As someone so wisely stated earlier in this thread:Misfit wrote:It's likely the soldiers shouldn't have been there, but does a 'peace' activist doesn't act like this?Duck Turkin wrote:… when you are attacked you defend yourself. Proportionate response is a great idea but doesn't work in the real world.
They weren't attacking, they were boarding.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
That most metaphors don't really bear close examination and rarely help argument.disciple wrote: Not really sure what an of this has to do with anything, nor what point you're trying to make.
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Well that's only because people ignore the actual point being made and focus on the analogy, it's a strange complaint to make given that's exactly what you did!aureole wrote:That most metaphors don't really bear close examination and rarely help argument.disciple wrote: Not really sure what an of this has to do with anything, nor what point you're trying to make.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
- Harlequin
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6505
- Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
- Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
By his use of the word 'you' I assumed that he was referring to human behaviour in general. I would expect civilians to be even less disciplined in dealing emotionally with such situations than members of one of the world's most highly trained military forces.Misfit wrote:However he was referring to the soldiers!Harlequin wrote:As someone so wisely stated earlier in this thread:Misfit wrote:It's likely the soldiers shouldn't have been there, but does a 'peace' activist doesn't act like this?Duck Turkin wrote:… when you are attacked you defend yourself. Proportionate response is a great idea but doesn't work in the real world.
Choosing different words does not change the reality of what the passengers perceived.Misfit wrote:They weren't attacking, they were boarding.
The Beeb further wrote:
Eyewitness accounts from ships raided by Israeli commandos have cast doubt on Israel's version of events that led to the deaths of at least nine people.
German pro-Palestinian activist Norman Paech said he had only seen wooden sticks being brandished as troops abseiled on to the deck of the ship.
…
Speaking as he arrived back in Berlin wrapped in a blue blanket, Mr Paech, a member of a German opposition party, said Israel's operation "was not an act of self-defence".
"Personally I saw two-and-a-half wooden batons that were used... There was really nothing else. We never saw any knives.
"This was an attack in international waters on a peaceful mission... This was a clear act of piracy," he added.
Mr Paech had been a passenger on the Turkish passenger ship Mavi Marmara where most, if not all, of the deaths occurred.
Fellow German activist Inge Hoeger said they had been on the ships "for peaceful purposes".
"We wanted to transport aid to Gaza," she said. "No-one had a weapon."
She added: "We were aware that this would not be a simple cruise across the sea to deliver the goods to Gaza. But we did not count on this kind of brutality."
Activist Bayram Kalyon, arriving back in Istanbul, had also been a passenger on the Mavi Marmara.
"The captain... told us 'They are firing randomly, they are breaking the windows and entering inside. So you should get out of here as soon as possible'. That was our last conversation with him."
Meanwhile, in Nazareth, Israeli Arab MP Haneen Zuabi - who was on the flotilla - told a press conference that Israeli forces began firing while still in the helicopters hovering over the ships.
"We are calling for an international committee to investigate this tragedy," she said.
…
Further criticism of Israel came from UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon on Tuesday.
In an interview with the AFP news agency, he said Israel's blockade of Gaza was responsible for the deadly raid.
"Had Israelis heeded to my call and to the call of the international community by lifting the blockade of Gaza, this tragic incident would not have happened," he said.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Why bother with the tenuous analogy then?disciple wrote:Well that's only because people ignore the actual point being made and focus on the analogy, it's a strange complaint to make given that's exactly what you did!aureole wrote: That most metaphors don't really bear close examination and rarely help argument.
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
No point in discussing this. Israel does what it likes. Nothing is going to come of this. So it's complete pointless point out the wrongs and rights. These people should have got the BBC/CNN/CBC live on board stood there with open arms and cups of tea and sandwiches and lock block the cabin doors. Welder them shut.
.
.
.
.
....I'm the BEST thing that has ever happened to ME............I think therefore I'm a Yam.
.
.
.
....I'm the BEST thing that has ever happened to ME............I think therefore I'm a Yam.
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
I think that's arguable, at what point do you stop a vehicle unlikely to stop that's heading towards a blockade with clear intention to breach. At most it's a technicality and if this point went to some sort of court the ruling could go either way.Harlequin wrote:I note that intent (known or suspected) to breach a blockade is not sufficient grounds for stoppingThe Beeb wrote:The UN Charter on the Law of the Sea says only if a vessel is suspected to be transporting weapons, or weapons of mass destruction, can it be boarded in international waters. Otherwise the permission of the ship's flag carrying nation must be sought.
The charter allows for naval blockades, but the effect of the blockade on civilians must be proportionate to the effect on the military element for the blockade to be legally enforceable.
A ship trying to breach a blockade can be boarded and force may be used to stop it as long as it is "necessary and proportionate".
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
- disciple
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13941
- Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 11:33 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: LiberMentis
- PSN: Prime_Heretic
- Location: Greenfield
- Contact:
Re: Israel renews air strikes on Gaza
Fuck me, this is an elite Isreali unit??Misfit wrote:It's likely the soldiers shouldn't have been there, but does a 'peace' activist doesn't act like this?Harlequin wrote: or, indeed, for massacring.
And mobbing and hitting people carrying guns with metal bars is surely a sure fire way to get shot? Not condoning anything, but if you are a soldier outnumbered being attacked that way, or seeing a colleague attacked that way. How are you going to react?
Bizzarely, it does look like the soldiers *were* using paintball guns as is being claimed.
PS4 : Prime_Heretic
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
Steam: bitstorm
Elite Dangerous: Cmdr Britain
