KlaxonCow wrote:
Vaccines can potentially invoke immune response symptoms, but they can't invoke the viral symptoms, as they are not the virus.
...
KlaxonCow wrote:
Having the vaccine is like catching Covid, in terms of immune response
Edit:
(Immune response is often what kills people - especially with Covid)
Anyway - with regard to my original statement about my lack of reaction, your assumption that it was posited as the logical negation is invalid. It was only a subset of possible negations. It was never intended to be all-encompassing, and I stand by my assertion that it is no more logical to assume I would have an asymptomatic response to a Covid infection, based solely on my reaction to the AZ vaccine.
Basically, the point I was making is that the virus and the vaccine are not the same thing, either in substance or delivery. Barney wouldn’t have had the virus injected intramuscularly, and his response to the other vaccines would likely be different in each case. We simply don’t know, and can never know.
And the point I was making was that, if you're suffering side effects, then comfort yourself that it's better to have the jab and feel a bit off for a short period, than it is to end up in hospital with Covid, or have the prolonged suffering of long Covid.
Basically, an advocacy that getting the jab is a good thing, even if, in the moment of suffering, it might not feel that way.
(With the added weight, in my case, that I actually suffered long Covid symptoms, on and off, for about 5 months and, only in the last few months, have I stopped feeling a bit wobbly and off from it all. To speak from experience, not mere theory, as I pretty much had all the symptoms over the period - except, yes, never anosmia and, obviously, not the most severe and fatal symptoms, as I'm still around - which, hopefully, adds a touch of "trust me, I know, as I've been there and done that" to the advocacy / comfort I was trying to provide.)
But, apparently, we'll never know, you say. We'll never know if someone getting the jab might have been better off - asymptomatic - from just catching Covid instead. We'll apparently never know if symptoms, hospitalisations and deaths will be reduced by the jabs, even though we have millions of points of historical data from before and after the vaccination programme, and many months of trial data that was specifically all about determining its safety and effectiveness. It's completely unknowable, apparently, so who knows if we're better off with or without the vaccination programme - even though absolutely all data says we are. But how can we know?
This is why I've found your protests here a bit odd. What are you really driving at here? I presume, from what you've said, that you're not an anti-vaxxer or anything, right?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
I wasn’t suggesting for a moment that he might have been better off without the jab. I just think that speculation about whether an individual’s vaccination reactions are an indicator of how bad a Covid infection might have been are unhelpful and ultimately meaningless.
I’m fine with speculation if it is framed as such - the way you put it was more like a statement of fact, that’s all.
Something unethical with twins could yield some pretty solid results. In theory.
The fact that (anecdotally, at least) different vaccines product distinct reactions across the population suggests that the reaction to the vaccine and reaction to COVID is not rigidly 1:1.
All I know from a layman perspective is that I'm coming around to the notion of AZ being the "cheap and nasty" of the vaccines. Horrendous side effects for some people, including in some rare cases, blood clots and death.
Still preferable to the virus itself, so still get it if it's the only option, it's better than nothing. (Albeit only just, in my age range). But if I was offered any other vaccine I'd avoid AZ like, well, Covid. It sounds like it's this adenovirus delivery method also used by Janssen which is also starting to report clots
I read the intro and the concluding remarks. To summarise the paper, everything affects the vaccine response but some things affect it less. It doesn't address the nature of the relationship between vaccine response and disease response though.
Cloudane wrote:All I know from a layman perspective is that I'm coming around to the notion of AZ being the "cheap and nasty" of the vaccines. Horrendous side effects for some people, including in some rare cases, blood clots and death.
Still preferable to the virus itself, so still get it if it's the only option, it's better than nothing. (Albeit only just, in my age range). But if I was offered any other vaccine I'd avoid AZ like, well, Covid. It sounds like it's this adenovirus delivery method also used by Janssen which is also starting to report clots
Its down to around 1 in a million to die from a clot from the AZ vaccine. You stand more chance of dying driving to the innoculation centre. Its a very safe vaccine, tragic for those who get unlucky but its vital everyone gets vaccinated to kill off a pool of unvaccinated people breeding new mutations.
Even Aspirin given to a million people has a higher danger. The press has a lot to answer for stoking fears of an exceptionally rare event.
I agree but at below 30 it's more of a risk than Covid is at that age range at current incidence which is why it's been halted for under 30s. For me getting close to 40 it's borderline-ish but statistically in favour of the vaccine. Aiui. But it also sounds like an incredibly unpleasant few days for many people who've had the AZ jab so if I had the choice between that and a better vaccine that doesn't have about a 1 in 6 to 1 in 10? chance of freaking torturing me for ~2 days I'd get the better vaccine. I have not heard of these extreme "hit with a sledgehammer" reactions to Pfizer or Moderna.
However, as stated, I'd still get the AZ vaccine over nothing.
It’s worth bearing in mind that theres probably some confirmation bias going on - the people having the most severe side-effects are the ones most likely to post about them. There’s likely many more people who didn’t have them, or only mild ones. Mine wasn’t exactly pleasant but I wouldn’t describe it as like “being hit by a sledgehammer”; it was more like other times I’ve been ill (I used to get severe headaches a lot and it was about on that level of feeling unwell). The effect on me was an unusual experience but didn’t make me feel worse than other times I’ve been moderately sick.
To be clear, am not trying to diminish the experiences of those who have been hammered.
Edit: Changed “mildly sick” to “moderately sick”, probably more accurate description.
Last edited by F-ZeroOne on Fri Apr 09, 2021 8:08 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Cloudane wrote:I agree but at below 30 it's more of a risk than Covid is at that age range at current incidence which is why it's been halted for under 30s. For me getting close to 40 it's borderline-ish but statistically in favour of the vaccine. Aiui. But it also sounds like an incredibly unpleasant few days for many people who've had the AZ jab so if I had the choice between that and a better vaccine that doesn't have about a 1 in 6 to 1 in 10? chance of freaking torturing me for ~2 days I'd get the better vaccine. I have not heard of these extreme "hit with a sledgehammer" reactions to Pfizer or Moderna.
However, as stated, I'd still get the AZ vaccine over nothing.
Was listening to a podcast where one of the hosts had gotten the J&J single shot dose. He said the next couple of days really fucking sucked. Would still prefer that to having to go twice TBH though
Cloudane wrote:I agree but at below 30 it's more of a risk than Covid is at that age range at current incidence which is why it's been halted for under 30s. For me getting close to 40 it's borderline-ish but statistically in favour of the vaccine. Aiui. But it also sounds like an incredibly unpleasant few days for many people who've had the AZ jab so if I had the choice between that and a better vaccine that doesn't have about a 1 in 6 to 1 in 10? chance of freaking torturing me for ~2 days I'd get the better vaccine. I have not heard of these extreme "hit with a sledgehammer" reactions to Pfizer or Moderna.
SuperMappy wrote:I got my first dose of the Moderna vaccine today, approx 9 hrs ago, and I was feeling fine till about 30 mins ago and it finally hit me "Damn is it COLD". I'm talking serious chills. I know it's my immune system waging war, but great day in the morning is it COLD! I put a jacket on to feel less cold and thankfully it's working.
Since I had actual covid19 in November I didn't think it would hit me like this.
SuperMappy wrote:Well this is lovely, I wake up this morning in total and complete pain everywhere, my arm feels like someone belted it with a sledgehammer, i got a total of 11 hrs sleep. I feel half awake with a bad headache. I call the doctor back and he says just to alternate Tylenol and Ibuprofen for the pain and it should all be gone in 24 hrs.
Ever see the Road Runner cartoons where the gigantic boulder falls on the coyote? That's what I feel like.
The reports I have been encountering both on this forum and elsewhere suggest far, far fewer than even one in thirty feeling "tortured" to anywhere close to SuperMappy's extent, and that is without considering that people generally are more likely to report complaints than the absence of them[*][/size]. My own previously unreported experience was my arm feeling bruised on the second and third day after injection (and perhaps still a little on the fourth) with no other symptoms I noticed whatsoever.
It might also not be surprising that we read more complaints about the AZ vaccine than others over here, given both that vaccinations so far have been overwhelmingly of that type in Western Europe and that there has been a political war between EU countries and AZ.
[*][/size] EDIT: As F-ZeroOne pointed out before I had finished writing.
Last edited by Harlequin on Fri Apr 09, 2021 8:21 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.