Sure, wasn't doubting what Giles was saying. Just throwing something out there as I can't otherwise think why they would be thinking it's just 'average' in general.Jamesac wrote:Giles has got a CV-1 Rift and played with the Vive for a bit. He's definitely got the experience to make a good comparison. If he says PS VR is best, based on the amount of work coding to Rift and PS VR that he's done, I'm willing to believe it. I'd expect the reviewers to have the same level of experience, aside from the coding bit.
Playstation VR
Re: Playstation VR
Re: Playstation VR
Definitely software I would say.gilesgoat wrote:One thing I can surely say RIGHT NOW I have SW running on CV1 and PSVR SIDE BY SIDE and I can tell definitely "which one gives me the better feeling" ..
.. and it's the PSVR ..
Not that the CV1 is bad oh no, but "PSVR is a bit better".
So I don't know .. what to say ? "Not so good SW maybe ?" ..
Whiteball wrote:Depends maybe on what these reviewers are comparing it with?
I mean, even ok-ish VR is gob smackingly good when it's all you've experienced. My DK2 experiences blew me away when I had that, but now compared to the CV1 I can honestly say they where just 'ok'
I play Elite Dangerous Horizons on my CV1 and I can honestly say it is probably the best software out there to show off what VR can do. When I try anything else I'm almost always left feeling "meh" because the immersion and experience are not as refined as ED. In other words I've been spoilt and now have a lofty expectation of anything VR in general.
Not saying this is how the reviewers are judging things necessarily but it might be one explanation as why they think it is 'average' ? They've tried a lot of CV1 and Vive stuff and compared to all that it is 'ok' ?
Maybe. Maybe not.
Trouble is I think people are expecting to play their current 'AAA' titles but in VR. Isn't going to happen yet...
- fog
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6022
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
- PSN: DenseFog
- Location: Newcastle, England
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
It's not a software issue. As Giles says, Sony are being ridiculously strict with certifying VR titles and wouldn't let anything through that was as glitchy as the GB stream showed. Aside from the fact there are plenty of reports of those same games running perfectly.Whiteball wrote: Definitely software I would say.
Trouble is I think people are expecting to play their current 'AAA' titles but in VR. Isn't going to happen yet...
Those having problems either have setup or hardware issues. Maybe the real issue is PSVR is super sensitive to surrounding lighting, noisy backgrounds etc. or has a very small operational distance from the camera and they are falling foul of that? In many ways that would be worse for Sony as few users will have perfect operating conditions at home.
Re: Playstation VR
Seeming increasingly likely that GB and Tested may have faulty units or are not doing something right with the setup. Gamespot's stream worked flawlessly on the tracking side
Steam: SteelyDamn
Re: Playstation VR
That's definitely not where GB are sat. They've been covering VR since DK1 and they're fully aware of how janky some stuff can be but equally they know which titles are the ones that "get" itWhiteball wrote: Trouble is I think people are expecting to play their current 'AAA' titles but in VR. Isn't going to happen yet...
Steam: SteelyDamn
- fog
- Baaaaaaa!

- Posts: 6022
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
- PSN: DenseFog
- Location: Newcastle, England
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
This new Tumble VR review from Eurogamer is a good example of something that wouldn't work without reliable tracking.
It looks as accurate and reliable as anything you would need in a game to me.
It looks as accurate and reliable as anything you would need in a game to me.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
Mah ... I have lights and all in this room, we will see during the week end what is going to happen "in the real world" at the exhibition in Manchester.
We just done "yet a little more SW test" I can swear our tracking "could not be better than this" you can shake you head as a loony/move all around the things "does not loose a frame, does not glitch".
I can truly say anyway I worked my tits off to implement "all the possible strategies" going into the "Advanced Techniques" territory which means there are 4 things to be done I won't tell what
But it's all explained, well sorta, it takes a while to understand/implement it correctly.
Effectively the story of tracking on PSVR is a bit 'tricky', one mistake in the SW and shit can happen but this basically means that or you have an SW that is waaay so heavvy on the CPU or that you literally done some "mistake" in the implementation.
Also I think "may depend a lot" at what point you "stopped upgrading your SDK/libs" .. if you are working with libs "of N months ago" there could be some troubles, you have to keep your code/firmware upgraded to the latest revision.
I can't even think of/how "big engines" ( I won't name ) managed to implement some stuff, I know they really had a hard time cause the nature of their own stuff, here we ( Llamasoft ) have the advantage we designed our own engine around the PSVR and CV1 and we don't have to support/implement "N other weird things we don't need".
Also we love more and more "the minimalist approach" .. the more code you manage to throw away, the better it goes.
At some point we'll get a Vive as well, we'll see how it goes there.
I am really happy of this PSVR and CV1 title we been doing so far, not only is a truly "fantastically awesome feel good" game to play it's really "something else unique" and it works SO DAMNED WELL in VR !
I can say I am really very happy so far of the results, and of course goes without saying that Yak really found "a new element to play with" in VR, and we are both getting better in making stuff for it, the more we do, the more experience we get
It's all really good, really happy with it
We just done "yet a little more SW test" I can swear our tracking "could not be better than this" you can shake you head as a loony/move all around the things "does not loose a frame, does not glitch".
I can truly say anyway I worked my tits off to implement "all the possible strategies" going into the "Advanced Techniques" territory which means there are 4 things to be done I won't tell what
But it's all explained, well sorta, it takes a while to understand/implement it correctly.
Effectively the story of tracking on PSVR is a bit 'tricky', one mistake in the SW and shit can happen but this basically means that or you have an SW that is waaay so heavvy on the CPU or that you literally done some "mistake" in the implementation.
Also I think "may depend a lot" at what point you "stopped upgrading your SDK/libs" .. if you are working with libs "of N months ago" there could be some troubles, you have to keep your code/firmware upgraded to the latest revision.
I can't even think of/how "big engines" ( I won't name ) managed to implement some stuff, I know they really had a hard time cause the nature of their own stuff, here we ( Llamasoft ) have the advantage we designed our own engine around the PSVR and CV1 and we don't have to support/implement "N other weird things we don't need".
Also we love more and more "the minimalist approach" .. the more code you manage to throw away, the better it goes.
At some point we'll get a Vive as well, we'll see how it goes there.
I am really happy of this PSVR and CV1 title we been doing so far, not only is a truly "fantastically awesome feel good" game to play it's really "something else unique" and it works SO DAMNED WELL in VR !
I can say I am really very happy so far of the results, and of course goes without saying that Yak really found "a new element to play with" in VR, and we are both getting better in making stuff for it, the more we do, the more experience we get
It's all really good, really happy with it
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10748
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Playstation VR
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
Re: Playstation VR
the first review I saw was this one:
http://www.gamesradar.com/playstation-v ... ease-date/
which was pretty much what I expected; out of all the systems I've tried so far the actual HMD of the PSVR is the best made and most comfortable, especially for glasses wearers, and the performance seems fine compared to the Occy and Vive which although technically higher rez exhibit more screendoor and therefore actually look more grainy than PSVR in use.
Never had any problems with tracking with ours. Nor any motion sickness, I can (and do) play the thing for hours on end every day just for work.
I'll be interested to see how people get on with it on Neo when that comes out. Could be some of the more graphically demanding titles will work better in VR on that, if performance is a bottleneck. In our experience with the ps4 running at a decent rez and 120Hz everything is lovely.
http://www.gamesradar.com/playstation-v ... ease-date/
which was pretty much what I expected; out of all the systems I've tried so far the actual HMD of the PSVR is the best made and most comfortable, especially for glasses wearers, and the performance seems fine compared to the Occy and Vive which although technically higher rez exhibit more screendoor and therefore actually look more grainy than PSVR in use.
Never had any problems with tracking with ours. Nor any motion sickness, I can (and do) play the thing for hours on end every day just for work.
I'll be interested to see how people get on with it on Neo when that comes out. Could be some of the more graphically demanding titles will work better in VR on that, if performance is a bottleneck. In our experience with the ps4 running at a decent rez and 120Hz everything is lovely.
Justified and Ancient.
Re: Playstation VR
I'm watching the (6 hour...) Giant Bomb stream now. Their problems have nothing to do with expectations, the tracking is working extremely poorly. Just sitting still watching the demo disc menu the camera and controller model are jittering around.Rhythm wrote:That's definitely not where GB are sat. They've been covering VR since DK1 and they're fully aware of how janky some stuff can be but equally they know which titles are the ones that "get" itWhiteball wrote: Trouble is I think people are expecting to play their current 'AAA' titles but in VR. Isn't going to happen yet...
A hypothesis on the interwebs said that it was due to their greenscreen and studio lights, but they've had the same problems at home, and turning the lights down in the studio didn't help.
They said its worse in some games than others, which I guess is a software issue, but I'd expect Sony to at least get the menu right.
Re: Playstation VR
There's some sort of fault on the some of the versions supplied to reviewers.
Eurogamer's kit wasn't tracking properly either until Sony replaced it.
Hopefully this is just a blip and won't be an issue for retail kits.
EDIT
Good write up here.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digit ... -vr-review
Eurogamer's kit wasn't tracking properly either until Sony replaced it.
Hopefully this is just a blip and won't be an issue for retail kits.
EDIT
Good write up here.
http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digit ... -vr-review
PlayStation VR is a remarkable achievement - especially bearing in mind that it manages to outscore its much more expensive rivals in key respects, principally in terms of comfort, fit and finish. In accommodating a (relatively) fixed platform, Sony had to get this hardware right first time and by and large, it's done an excellent job.
Re: Playstation VR
I'll be keeping my psvr pre-order , looking forward to getting it on the 17th, can't play it coz my pro didn't arrive till the 11th of November.
Will the llamasoft game be out before chrimbo?
Will the llamasoft game be out before chrimbo?
- Misfit
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10454
- Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
- Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
Some of the first things I read put me off a little, but more has been positive now and LLamasoft will be on it, so no way I'm cancelling this one.
Just hoping the demos will be plentiful as there is a lot of software coming and most of it is priced rather high, and some of those that seem reasonable like Batman at £20 seem to just be an hour long ride...
ShopTo seem to have the best prices for VR games (Eg Battlezone £42.85, Driveclub £27.86) and sadly it seems cheaper to buy the disks rather than the downloadable version.
Just hoping the demos will be plentiful as there is a lot of software coming and most of it is priced rather high, and some of those that seem reasonable like Batman at £20 seem to just be an hour long ride...
ShopTo seem to have the best prices for VR games (Eg Battlezone £42.85, Driveclub £27.86) and sadly it seems cheaper to buy the disks rather than the downloadable version.
- gilesgoat
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 27259
- Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
- Location: Monfalcone, Italy
- Contact:
Re: Playstation VR
Speaking about "revelation" I am afraid we kinda bargained with Sony that we won't reveal anything before 5 PM of Fri, they really want to be "synchronized" with that Blog output ( actually they are still asking some more material for it ) but trust me you'll be very pleased when you'll hear what is all about.
This time I think we'll have a "particularly hard time" in "explaining what the game is/works" in the sense you look at a static screen you go "Mah .. " .. you look at a video you go "Hum .. really nice ..." .. it's only when you wear the headset that you go "WOW HOLY COW !" ..
I mean it's not bad on screenshots but "you don't really get where everything is at" .. "most" of which is really in the 120 Fps and the action, when you are INSIDE the thing .. then you feel cosmic all the time ...
[edit] and oh at 90 Fps on the CV1 the story is not bad at all, of course the speed is adjusted so matches the PSVR version, even on DK2 is playable but then the image is really "a bit too low res and too grainy" in some points, still playable even with DK2 ( at least you don't have God's rays in there at all ) ah yes "god's rays" are really minimal to zero there are only a few non-critical points you can see some but we'll fix that ( some game menus ).
[edit2] Oh yes I can make ONE small "revelation"
Given that now we are at the final stage(s) .. the "internal code name" for the game so far been .. "Bananaworld" .. there's a reason for that .. but that I can't explain you, it's cause "something" that is in .. also while Yak's code is totally filled with "moo" and all possible variations on the word, mine is quite full of "banana" and variations on the word.
Occasional comments ( usually in places where bugs been found and fixed ) with some italian profanities and other "colorful expressions" like "This is thre )(*)(#*#)@$ bug that made me waste 3 days" .. and stuff like that.
"Last bug that made me MAD 4 days ?" .. one the stupidest you can imagine that made me dump tons of buffers, check this and that all over the places, re-check shaders and all shit, check code thinking "I must have done something really weird somewhere but should not" .. yet the bug "one of stupidest you can imagine" yet fucking hard to really figure out what was going on ..
"Something was not looking quite similar" and it's like "WHY ??" ...
In the end after lot of despair, tears and swearwords .. turns out .. "the bug was not in the code AT ALL" .. the bug was during saving/conversions/etc. ONE of the textures came out with a wrong alpha channel and trust me it was NOT immediate to be seen/understood ...
Made me INSANE ..
This time I think we'll have a "particularly hard time" in "explaining what the game is/works" in the sense you look at a static screen you go "Mah .. " .. you look at a video you go "Hum .. really nice ..." .. it's only when you wear the headset that you go "WOW HOLY COW !" ..
I mean it's not bad on screenshots but "you don't really get where everything is at" .. "most" of which is really in the 120 Fps and the action, when you are INSIDE the thing .. then you feel cosmic all the time ...
[edit] and oh at 90 Fps on the CV1 the story is not bad at all, of course the speed is adjusted so matches the PSVR version, even on DK2 is playable but then the image is really "a bit too low res and too grainy" in some points, still playable even with DK2 ( at least you don't have God's rays in there at all ) ah yes "god's rays" are really minimal to zero there are only a few non-critical points you can see some but we'll fix that ( some game menus ).
[edit2] Oh yes I can make ONE small "revelation"
Occasional comments ( usually in places where bugs been found and fixed ) with some italian profanities and other "colorful expressions" like "This is thre )(*)(#*#)@$ bug that made me waste 3 days" .. and stuff like that.
"Last bug that made me MAD 4 days ?" .. one the stupidest you can imagine that made me dump tons of buffers, check this and that all over the places, re-check shaders and all shit, check code thinking "I must have done something really weird somewhere but should not" .. yet the bug "one of stupidest you can imagine" yet fucking hard to really figure out what was going on ..
"Something was not looking quite similar" and it's like "WHY ??" ...
In the end after lot of despair, tears and swearwords .. turns out .. "the bug was not in the code AT ALL" .. the bug was during saving/conversions/etc. ONE of the textures came out with a wrong alpha channel and trust me it was NOT immediate to be seen/understood ...
Made me INSANE ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
"Baa"
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10748
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Playstation VR
I think there are some strange tech reviews of late - see this for the Pebble 2
http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/10/ ... s-tracker/
VS
http://gizmodo.com/the-pebble-2-is-now- ... 1787368019
http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/10/ ... s-tracker/
VS
http://gizmodo.com/the-pebble-2-is-now- ... 1787368019
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !

