(o)(o) wrote:Perhaps not, but the various diets Ornish or Zone or Atkins etc produce about the same net weight loss, and are equally successful in terms of drop out rate, so I think one should advocate a person finding out which works for them. Low carb isn't for everyone. It backfires for some, they get rebound weight gain when reintroducing carbs. I'm sure you won't allow that to happen in your case.

To be honest if it's a choice between personal experience and anecdotal evidence from people on here vs reading up a load of stuff on the internet then it's not a hard choice where to place trust. This thread is full of endorsements for this approach.
(o)(o) wrote:Low carb is indicated for persons who are down the metabolic syndrome road as it can reverse some of its effects.
I'll pick up on this as you've alluded to "It's great if you're sick!" a few times now. Eschewing refined carbohydrates is a good move for anyone and strongly suspected as a way preventing you going down the metabolic syndrome route in the first place. Unless you can think of good reasons for porking down HFCS? Even if you maintain weight on this diet I am convinced it's a better way to eat than unfettered consumption of highly refined carbs.
I've said a few times I'm using low carb to hit target weight but whatever happens after that won't be reintroducing processed crap back into my diet whatever happens. It's not hard to keep to when you realise they make you feel really bad.
gravy wrote:Out of interest how are you doing on this? Everyone else is posting their weight loss achievements.
(o)(o) wrote:Two close friends died in the last month. Lost focus.
I think I did pretty well to maintain the same weight.
I'm really sorry to hear that. On the other hand there's never a really good time to make a change. Absolutely not trying to play grief top trumps or anything but my nan died and my dad's been diagnosed with cancer during the same period. You just have to get on with things.
You quibble a lot on here which is fine, it's a forum and part of the cut and thrust. What is a bit niggling on this one subject is you don't have an alternate experience of sustained effort to give a credible counter story. This may be uncharitable but it's coming across as if you almost want there to be flaws in any system because it's the fault of the approach rather than the individuals own efforts.
Bottom line with this stuff, whatever approach you choose to take, if you're fat, don't want to be and not completely ignorant there's enough information out there to make a change in your life. There are loads of approaches, for those of us who're weak willed and a sucker for doing whatever our hunger tells us to do low carb is pretty effective.
And that's pretty much where this thread was born, as an counter to the point of view that weight reduction has be a hard and miserable process. For the first time It hasn't for me and a few others here are saying the same.
Pick an approach and stick with it for a bit and then tell us how it's gone. I find that sort of stuff about people's personal experiences really interesting. At it's best the mutual support in this thread has been great as well. Being told I'm just going to get fat again eventually? It's not such a great read.