I absolutely did concede that point in the sentences just before those you quoted:Dio wrote:That's not the case. As I clearly pointed out a few days ago, exponential functions are totally controllable on low exponents and/or long cycle times.KlaxonCow wrote:When R > 1.0 then you must pretty much immediately give up on your "experiments". If you've reached R > 1.0, then your experiments have, by definition, failed.
And, truth is, though we might phrase it differently, I do think we're on the same page, by you saying this:KlaxonCow wrote:I remain optimistic in that, yes, the numbers do suggest that it would take one hell of an almighty cock-up to screw this one up. Dio's right that, while the exponent is low, there is leeway and wiggle room there - but there's not an infinite amount of it.
Different ways of saying it.Dio wrote:As of today we are indeed close to cocking that up, but we are not there yet.
But the gist of what I meant by "there is leeway and wiggle room there - but there's not an infinite amount of it" is the same idea. We're not there yet, as there is some leeway and wiggle room there, but there isn't an infinite amount of it. It will run out.
Though I would logically dispute your objection to this statement:
Because R > 1.0, by definition, means exponential growth so your "let's see if we can control this" experiment has, by definition, failed.KlaxonCow wrote:If you've reached R > 1.0, then your experiments have, by definition, failed.
You can dispute whether there is some leeway to tolerate up to R >= 1.2 - that you don't need to instantly call another lockdown - but that's really another separate matter about how much "going wrong" we can tolerate before we refuse to tolerate it anymore. I would still hold that, logically, by definition, R > 1.0 is the very metric of failure, if your experimental intent is trying to control the outbreak.
No, it is now increasing. Your "control" experiment has failed, as R > 1.0 is the very metric of whether we do or don't have control.
And, as you know, R = 1.1 eventually becomes R = 1.2, with sufficient time. We can validly disagree on this - personally, I don't see the value in pissing about for a few weeks, awaiting the inevitable, and letting things get worse in that time, as I fail to see that these "experiments" are worth that cost. But that's an ethical / judgement call kind of thing, so I'm fine for us to take different perspectives on this.
Indeed, truth is, we've also had this same argument on "the future of energy" thread, in that I suggested that, knowing fossil fuels are going to run out, as an inevitable outcome, we should start making the change right now. But you, again, felt we had the leeway to piss-fart about for a little while longer. My real underlying objection to that amounts to, well, "why?". Why fuck around for a while, with something that we already know - as an inevitable, unavoidable outcome - is inherently doomed anyway?
Why wait for case numbers to get out of control, and the NHS to start to become overwhelmed, and for all the misery that will rain down on people's lives? When we know exactly where the R is going. It is, without remedial action, going to hit R > 1.2, isn't it? Why pile on another 0.5 degrees of warming to the planet, before we do the thing that we know we've got to do anyway?
I don't see the value in just watching things go wrong, before acting, when we knew - for mathematical fact - that it was inevitably going to go wrong. If R > 1.0, then you tried but it didn't work. Please cancel this "experiment" now, as the metrics directly tells us that it has, by definition, failed. You were attempting "control", but R > 1.0 is the metric that you've lost it, as the virus is now returning to exponential growth.
What is the value in fucking about for a few weeks - watching things get worse - when, being arithmetically literate, we already know for a fact what is coming and what we're going to see?
Like, if you can see the brick wall coming, then turn the steering wheel and slam on the brakes now. You might, perhaps, be able to avoid it. If you wait until the last possible millisecond - in the hopes of what? That the brick wall will magically disappear? - before you do anything, then the odds of avoidance are greatly reduced. You are, in fact, pushing it right up to the edge. And I see no value whatsoever in doing that. Hit the brakes now, and you stand the greatest possible chance of perhaps never hitting that brick wall at all.
It's a judgement call, I guess. But I thoroughly disagree with your approach to risk management. I can concede a little - that it's not instantly disaster, if we delay a little - but it will be disaster if we delay too much... and, simply, I don't see the value of delay at all? Why? What's the pragmatic pay off here? If it's there, I don't see it. But I'm open to you showing me what I'm missing, if there is something being missed here.

