Dio wrote:tufty wrote:As soon as R goes over 1, it's out of control, and the potential pool for new mutants is expanding. One or more of those new mutants will inevitably escape existing immune response, as the evolutionary pressure is for it to do so, and we're right back to step 1.
Vaccine escape is the concern. We're running a pretty big experiment here. If it works things will be great. If not... hmm.
As I suggested before, this is, in effect, an "arms race".
I'm with tufty on his correct summary of how this works. Which is why I've been saying all along: "Case numbers DO matter".
More cases means more mutations. More mutations eventually creates new variants. And the evolutionary pressure is, indeed, totally on vaccine resistance / vaccine escape - because mutations that don't do that will be killed off by the vaccine, so only those that have some resistance (or, eventually, vaccine escape) will stick around - and, if we have vaccine escape, then that puts us back into the position we were in before, with a virus and no vaccines against it.
But the "arms race" aspect is that, through vaccines and through people catching Covid, our collective immune response can stop the vaccine getting a foothold. Herd immunity. And if the virus can't get a foothold, then R can't go manage to get above 1, cases fizzle out so the chances of mutations leading to variants diminishes. And that's how we "win".
And this is the "arms race" balance. We have to reach "herd immunity" before the virus can reach "vaccine escape".
Note that we'll know if we've reached the needed herd immunity threshold because, by definition, if have it, then R can't go over 1. That's, like, the other way of phrasing what "herd immunity" is. The virus can't get R over 1, because it keeps hitting immune response dead-ends - vaccinated people or people who've already had it and have resistance, as both work - and R < 1 means that it inevitably declines and can't get a foothold.
The broken link between cases and hospitalisations and deaths is definitely good. But, yes, if cases keep exponentially exploding, that can't hold. And cases still lead to mutations and variants - and variants is how we lose this. It's natural selection. The evolutionary pressure is towards vaccine escape, so if we give it enough chances - too many cases - then it will eventually find its way out.
Cases do matter. We should be keeping them as low as possible.
(But, equally, I think I get the government's logic. They're thinking that if you keep too tight a lid on it then, come Winter, we'll get another horrible explosion in cases. They want a "dull roar" of young people catching this, with the logic that this is building up immune response. But, like, I'm of the opinion that, as we have the vaccines, that's the route to achieve this. In a sense, my logic is that we don't need to encourage it. The vaccine won't always work every time. There will be unvaccinated people. We don't have to encourage it in any way, it'll inevitably happen, despite our best efforts to the contrary. Making sure that we don't ever get anywhere near "vaccine escape" should be the priority. So keep cases as low as possible - don't worry, as we'll never get it to zero anyway. We should still be "flattening the curve". Always. Forever more.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes