Rhythm wrote:instead of the wider point of this being a completely fucking mental policy
What's most insane about this "massive gamble" policy is, well, what's the reward if it pays off?
If it pays off, then we have a population that's double-jabbed, catches its "third dose" of Delta and then we move into the Autumn "booster" shots.
But, presumably, the Autumn booster shots have already been adapted to the Alpha and Delta variants.
So, we're going to expose everyone to Delta now - the wild herd immunity way - when, umm, in a few months, we're going to be jabbing everyone for it anyway?
Remind me, what's the point of doing this again?
Seriously, in terms of immunity, don't we end up in more or less the same place anyway? Therefore, we're taking this wild gamble for the reward of... what exactly? We don't, in the long term, end up in any better position in terms of collective immunity.
And, remember, letting cases explode is letting mutations explode, which is brewing up new variants. This is random, so we don't know if it will or won't happen, or when exactly, but the higher and higher we let cases rise, the more and more this heads towards "inevitable" at the limit.
So, we have a double-jabbed population. We let them catch Delta. In the midst of this, then the "Omnicron" variant emerges - and, per evolutionary pressure, this variant will be hardy against our vaccines (reducing their efficacy) and it'll drift towards being more transmissible.
Then we have our Autumn "booster" shots, which have been tweaked for the Alpha / Delta variants... but not "Omnicron", as that one's only just emerged, thanks to our "wild gamble" strategy, so of course the "booster" is not actually going to be good for that.
Whereas, if we don't do this insane thing, then we have a double-jabbed population. We keep numbers down until Autumn, then give folks the "booster" for Alpha / Delta. The "Omnicron" variant does not exist, as we didn't let shit get out of control to brew up yet a new variant.
Well, the "reward" might simply be economic. This is the faster way out to "normality" would be the claim. But, again, that only works if we're lucky in not brewing up that "Omnicron" variant in the meantime.
Because then we're being threatened by "Omnicron" and if the vaccines aren't good for that - not effective enough - then we could be threatened to bring restrictions back again as the only way to keep it in check. And the thing is that we can know, in advance, due to evolutionary pressure, that any new variant will be even more vaccine-resistant than the last ones.
It
will - inevitably so - be chipping away at our vaccine efficacy. The only question that would be up in the air is by how much?
And the big roll of that dice is that it's only chipping away, say, 5 to 10% of vaccine efficacy. But if a new variant is actually chipping away more like 30%, 40%, 50% of vaccine efficacy then, basically, "oh shit". Or it might even hit the magical "winning formula" of vaccine escape and it actually reduces efficacy to 0% - at which point, our vaccines do nothing and we're back to square one again.
And then where will your precious economy be then, eh? As that scenario means the only thing we can do - no choice - is lock back down again. "Where is your god now?".
In fairness, there is a dice roll in the midst of this. We could roll good numbers. The plan actually works and Boris is hailed as a "hero" to all the "Freedom Day" Tory backbenchers egging him on.
But it's purely by luck and not an inch of design.
Although, due to what's at stake, I wish Boris good luck at the craps table because, if this is happening, then roll those lucky dice. Even though I'm fucking fuming internally that this insanity should never be rewarded, as it'll make people erroneously think that being totally mental is a good idea. And we'll suffer through the headlines, praising a mad man who just pushed us out of a plane without a parachute because, by a lucky roll of the dice, we somehow landed safely.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes