World Cup 2010, there we went!

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

Gorecki wrote:Dave, have you any experience of sports coaching/instructing? Because it really isn't as simple as that.
*sports* instructing, no. And I'm not going to claim it's a simple task (I hope I didn't imply that in prior posts).

However, we weren't talking about how simple the task is. Whilst everyone debates what/who the problem is and what/who/how it can be solved, it's clear to me that the person charged with producing the solution and guaranteeing success for our football team is the manager. Capello is accountable.

We can debate how much better/worse we could be if we were in his position - but if I *was* in his position and I'd delivered those results then I'd sure as hell feel responsible for the dismal failure. I definitely wouldn't try and pin it on underperforming players, a poor coach, lack of goal line technology, etc.

Look at it outside of football: if you used something you knew to be of poor quality, and a system failure eventually emerged, could you be in a position of shrugging and blaming the defective part?
Gorecki wrote:Good to see that in pretty much all the knock-out matches so far, the team that's played the fluid, passing, attacking football has progressed. It's nice to see the teams playing the best football winning, rather than the ones best at smothering the midfield and scoring from set-pieces or playing for penalties.
Wot you said. Fluidity in movement, playing wide and using available room, good control and possession are all recipes for win.

Annoyed that Japan went out on penalties. Spain/Porty could have gone either way, but glad Spain got through on their effort - there *was* quite an element of tactical play from them.
User avatar
Gorecki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5962
Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by Gorecki »

Dungeon-Dave wrote:Look at it outside of football: if you used something you knew to be of poor quality, and a system failure eventually emerged, could you be in a position of shrugging and blaming the defective part?
That analogy isn't even remotely comparable to managing and national football team. A group of people aren't a machine, and individuals aren't 'parts'. If you're thinking along those lines then I can see how you're getting to those conclusions.

There was a nice quote from someone (Motson?) on MotD about a week ago who said that the manager is responsible for the results, the players are responsible for their (as in individual) performance. And whilst that's a gross simplification it does have a certain elegance to it. And the result in this case is being knocked out in the last sixteen, when we're a team that traditionally can be expected to get to the last sixteen and yet two years ago couldn't even qualify for European Championship. The result is hardly a disaster. The performance was though.
Tang Sou!
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

Gorecki wrote:That analogy isn't even remotely comparable to managing and national football team. A group of people aren't a machine, and individuals aren't 'parts'. If you're thinking along those lines then I can see how you're getting to those conclusions.
If I put it in the context of managing a music band, managing a sales team, managing a troop of soldiers then I'd still arrive at the same conclusion. Leadership and managerial ability should shape and focus individuals into a team, and should identify dynamics that strengthen or weaken that team's potential - then address them in some way.
Gorecki wrote:The result is hardly a disaster. The performance was though.
If you put it in terms of attainment and advancement from prior performance, then comparably it's a good result. If you put it in terms of taking the cream of England's players and putting them into what should be the best we can produce and they play dire - to the point that commentators keep expressing bewilderment at how those that produce results at weekend matches seem different characters entirely when in the world cup - then I feel that's a poor result.

Let's get this clear: I'm not a footy fanatic by any means of the imagination. If I took 11 people out of the comfort of their own teams and threw them together without any direction from me - just hoped for the best - then I'd possibly get what England produced against Germany. My role, as a manager, should be about getting those to gel as a team to coax the best performance out of them. Can you honestly say that's what Capello did? Can you say that's what he ought to have done? It honestly didn't look like just one or two letting the side down, it seemed as though quite a number were hopelessly floundering. At best, I would describe the team as "lacklustre and direction-less, as though they lacked a decent leader or proper management".
User avatar
Guru-Meditation
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4093
Joined: Mon Jun 16, 2003 10:46 am 0
Location: Bellevue near Seattle
Contact:

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by Guru-Meditation »

Checklist for Nike's "Write the Future" advert - Starring roles:

Drogba: Broke his arm before the tournament. Knocked out in group stages. Scored one goal in a 1-3 defeat to Brazil.
Cannavaro: Outclassed as Italy crash out in the group stage. Cited as one of the reasons Italy flopped.
Rooney: 0 goals, out of sorts, knocked out by Germany in round of 16. Cussed out booing fans on live TV.
Ribery: 0 goals for France, arguably the worst team of the tournament on and off the pitch, knocked out in group phase.
Ronaldinhio: Wasn’t picked for the squad.
Ronaldo: Knocked out in the round of 16 after scoring one goal. Against North Korea. After accidentally knocking it forward with the back of his head.
passplay> is anyone else sitting with their balls gently nestled in a bowl of red jello?
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

Guru-Meditation wrote:After accidentally knocking it forward with the back of his head.
It's big enough...

Don't Nike have a "curse of Hello magazine" touch about footy players? Private Eye did an article a number of years back about how players featured in Nike adverts sometimes never feature in the actual games, due to last-minute injury or crashing out early.

Remember this? (or Cantona v The Devil)
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by GeeZa »

Dungeon-Dave wrote:My role, as a manager, should be about getting those to gel as a team to coax the best performance out of them. Can you honestly say that's what Capello did? Can you say that's what he ought to have done? It honestly didn't look like just one or two letting the side down, it seemed as though quite a number were hopelessly floundering.
Look, I'm definitely inclined to think Capello's job should be appraised in the wake of this, his squad selection didn't fill me with joy but upon reflection he's not got much to pick from. I would say perhaps only Dawson, Milner, Rooney and Defoe had good enough club seasons to justify their places. Everyone else, particularly the midfield, back four and the keepers, were either injured or suffered from major inconsistency. But then who else is out there? He brought Michael Carrick for goodness sake, that's how slim the pickings are.

I've just re-watched the Germany goals again and they're all basic defensive mistakes, the sorts of things you're coached about at age nine. Not letting the ball bounce, following the runners, staying goal side, basic simple stuff. In the wake of all the hooha people forgot about that first goal. God almighty it was bad and the others weren't far behind. The one thing I am tired of is the players shifting responsibility when things go wrong.

Spain were pure class.
"Chrome plated stars on a black leather sky"
User avatar
Misfit
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10456
Joined: Sat Sep 28, 2002 2:43 pm 0
Location: Nottingham UK
Contact:

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by Misfit »

I think Geeza may be Roy Keane!

Here is a great interview with him (Keane) at one point he basically goes through the team saying they all had rubbish seasons...
Ipswich boss Roy Keane says it is "crazy" to criticise Fabio Capello after England's World Cup debacle and declares that the players "get away with murder" and need to look at themselves.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/footbal ... 773716.stm
User avatar
PFVA
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14996
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 1:40 am 0
Location: Paralel 38

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by PFVA »

Guru-Meditation wrote:Checklist for Nike's "Write the Future" advert - Starring roles:

Drogba: Broke his arm before the tournament. Knocked out in group stages. Scored one goal in a 1-3 defeat to Brazil.
Cannavaro: Outclassed as Italy crash out in the group stage. Cited as one of the reasons Italy flopped.
Rooney: 0 goals, out of sorts, knocked out by Germany in round of 16. Cussed out booing fans on live TV.
Ribery: 0 goals for France, arguably the worst team of the tournament on and off the pitch, knocked out in group phase.
Ronaldinhio: Wasn’t picked for the squad.
Ronaldo: Knocked out in the round of 16 after scoring one goal. Against North Korea. After accidentally knocking it forward with the back of his head.
There has been a lot of fuss about Ronaldinho Gaúcho not being picked for the team. What i understand of the explanations is that he can't any longer play as he was used to, age, physical problems, etc. If he were to play, his role would have to be different from what it was due to that. Sometimes big famous players don't adapt well to that change. The decision was picking up a newer team. Brazil as an immense pool of players to choose from and it can afford to make these decisions. Of course, if it doesn't work the media will finish crucifying the coach. There is already a big fuss going between the media and him.

Having seen Portugal's performance in this Cup i have a tendency to see the point of the Brazilian couch. Yesterday the will to win wasn't showing in the Portuguese team. It wasn't showing against Yvory Coast and Brazil either. Besides the goal keeper and the defense one of the few playing was Fabio which comes from a national team. All those alledgelly "good players", some of them playing in Spain (Cristiano is not the only one), others in other European countries weren't showing a will to play and even less a will to win.

There was a lot of fuss here even before we got to the South African stage that the naturalized players didn't show the will to play for the country (and there was even a fuss about how they sang the national anthem before the games), some of those were kept out and quite frankly our native players that have better paid jobs elsewhere in Europe seemed to even have less will to play.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by merman »

At half-time Portugal should have been pleased with their performance. They had restricted Spain to long range shots (which had, admittedly, forced Eduardo into making three good saves) and had a couple of decent chances themselves (Almeida's header in particular).

But after that, there was no Plan B. Spain were playing nice flowing football and got the goal. And Portugal had nothing in response. Ronaldo looked lost, with very little support (although the left back did look good, until he was forced onto the back foot and his confidence went).

The real shame was the late elbow, up until then the ref had coped well with what could have been a niggly, nasty game with lots of fouls. But he'd let play flow and wasn't fooled by falling over.



I know it's not football, but I always remember a quote from Will Carling, talking about captaining the England side. "Once we go over that white line, it's up to the players to do the job."
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
fog
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6022
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 1:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dense Fog
PSN: DenseFog
Location: Newcastle, England
Contact:

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by fog »

GeeZa wrote:Look, I'm definitely inclined to think Capello's job should be appraised in the wake of this, his squad selection didn't fill me with joy but upon reflection he's not got much to pick from. I would say perhaps only Dawson, Milner, Rooney and Defoe had good enough club seasons to justify their places. Everyone else, particularly the midfield, back four and the keepers, were either injured or suffered from major inconsistency. But then who else is out there? He brought Michael Carrick for goodness sake, that's how slim the pickings are.

I've just re-watched the Germany goals again and they're all basic defensive mistakes, the sorts of things you're coached about at age nine. Not letting the ball bounce, following the runners, staying goal side, basic simple stuff. In the wake of all the hooha people forgot about that first goal. God almighty it was bad and the others weren't far behind. The one thing I am tired of is the players shifting responsibility when things go wrong.
Bang on.
User avatar
PFVA
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14996
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 1:40 am 0
Location: Paralel 38

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by PFVA »

merman wrote:At half-time Portugal should have been pleased with their performance. They had restricted Spain to long range shots (which had, admittedly, forced Eduardo into making three good saves) and had a couple of decent chances themselves (Almeida's header in particular).

But after that, there was no Plan B. Spain were playing nice flowing football and got the goal. And Portugal had nothing in response. Ronaldo looked lost, with very little support (although the left back did look good, until he was forced onto the back foot and his confidence went).

The real shame was the late elbow, up until then the ref had coped well with what could have been a niggly, nasty game with lots of fouls. But he'd let play flow and wasn't fooled by falling over.



I know it's not football, but I always remember a quote from Will Carling, talking about captaining the England side. "Once we go over that white line, it's up to the players to do the job."
The coach said, right after the game, that the plan was to tire Spain during the first half, and then go to the attack on the second one and that's why they replaced some players and intentionally change strategy. He also said that Villa's goal messed up the plan. I gather he wasn't as tired as he was expected to be.

Some of the telly experts think they should have continued playing the same way even holding to a 0-0 and then going into the penalties at the end, there was a good chance than Eduardo would defend more of them than Casillas. Not exactly exciting football but an option.

At the end of the game when asked about what went wrong Cristiano told the media they should ask Queiroz. Then someone in the technical stuff accused Cristiano of not having performed what was expected of him as captain of the team. This morning Cristiano was saying that Queiroz was not at fault and he only said that because he was deeply suffering inside with the defeat at the end of the game and that he didn't know anything about underperforming as captain. I'm sure this will keep going for a while.

The media is mostly blaming Queiroz, the people are praying for Saint Mourinho to be done with Real de Madrid soon to come over as coach and save the national team finally leading it to World Cup finals, something that has han't happen since 1966.
User avatar
GeeZa
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7156
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2003 5:04 pm 0
Location: Taghazout.

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by GeeZa »

Misfit wrote:I think Geeza may be Roy Keane!
Love him or loathe him he does tend to cut through the bullshit in this game. I liked it when he was asked whether he thought Henry was cheat when Ireland got knocked out of qualification and his answer went something like "The Irish defenders let the ball bounce, there's only one ball, get your head on it". :)
"Chrome plated stars on a black leather sky"
User avatar
Gorecki
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5962
Joined: Sat Aug 31, 2002 1:39 am 0
Location: Essex, home of the Boy Racer

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by Gorecki »

Dungeon-Dave wrote:Don't Nike have a "curse of Hello magazine" touch about footy players? Private Eye did an article a number of years back about how players featured in Nike adverts sometimes never feature in the actual games, due to last-minute injury or crashing out early.
I've known about the curse of Sports Illustrated for a long, long time. Basically, anyone who gets on to the front cover of said periodical is supposed to suffer a fall from grace swiftly afterwards.

It's actually a real phenomenon. To get on the front cover of SI or get a multi-million contract with Nike you have to be at the very top of your game. And when you're at the top the only way to go is down.


And on the subject of 'star' players, here's an amazing interview with John Barnes on the trouble with the current England team that chimes superbly with GeeZa's argument above.
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/standard- ... m-ethic.do
"Football is a socialist sport," he explains. "Financially, some may receive more rewards than others but, from a footballing perspective, for 90 minutes, regardless of whether you are Lionel Messi or the substitute right-back for Argentina, you are all working to the same end.

"The teams which embrace the socialist ideology rather than having superstars, are the teams that are successful. Or if there are superstars they don't perceive themselves to be that. That's why I use Messi as an example. As much as he's a superstar he respects his team-mates and their collective efforts."
"I don't blame the players. If I was a player now and they were going to treat me as if I was some kind of God, maybe I would act that way. I blame the football fraternity - the media, the fans, everybody who has said, 'Look how great they are'. The result is that these players now feel subconsciously that they are the biggest part of the solution when we do well. But when we do badly they're not a part of the problem.

"Look at John Terry after the Algeria match. He comes out and tells you what the problem is. But he doesn't see himself as part of the problem."
Tang Sou!
User avatar
PFVA
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14996
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 1:40 am 0
Location: Paralel 38

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by PFVA »

Manwhile you discuss the problems and solutions of the English team here is a summary of the soap opera i read in the papers at the cafe this morning.

Things are going worse between CR and Queiroz after loosing to Spain. Luis Figo came out joining the group of those criticizing Cristiano stating he didn't fullfill his role as captain. He said when he was the captain sometimes he had to sacrifice himself as player for the good and incentivation of the team. Mourinho came out to defend Cristiano stating they can't put the blame on just him and saying that what he needs now is a vacation before returning to the Real. During the intermission at the first game against the Yvory Coast, Queiroz would have told Ronaldo to incentivate and push the other players to improve performance and CR would have answered that he wasn't the one who choose those players.

Deco who also criticized Queiroz at the end of that game and didn't get to play again after that, left straight to Brazil after the last game. He's a double citizen of both countries.

Several, apparently including at least some of the players want Queiroz to be fired before the Euro 2012 season starts in September. Queiroz makes 1.6 million a year and his contract is untill 2012. If he would be fired they would have to pay him over 2 million indemnization which would double the costs of the national team since they would have to hire another coach having paying another 1.6 million/year. Queiroz doesn't seem to be succumbing to the pressure for resigning. So far the man who makes the final decision hasn't made any comments.

(This kind of situation probably can explain how things got to the point they got in France)

The players themselves get paid 800.00/day when at the service of the national team. And they got a 50,000 bonus for making it to the 1/8 finals. In a country where minimum wage is 400 Euros/month and with the crisis people are struggling to even find jobs, unemployment benefits being cut, etc i can see why so many defend the option of not having a national team and save the money untill the crisis is over or at least slash their benefits.

Eduardo's fan club is on the rise specially on the female side with tons of females waiting for him when he returned home offering to cheer him up. It seems that at least nationally Cristiano's large female fan club is giving away to Eduardo's one.

I don't know if it is a reflexion of all these but Cristiano's store, CR7, is offering 40% disccount on the products and claiming even higher ones at the stores itselves:

http://www.cr7bycristiano.com/epages/230476.sf
User avatar
Dungeon-Dave
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3925
Joined: Thu Aug 04, 2005 12:01 pm 0
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: World Cup 2010, there we went!

Post by Dungeon-Dave »

fog wrote:
GeeZa wrote:Look, I'm definitely inclined to think Capello's job should be appraised in the wake of this...

The one thing I am tired of is the players shifting responsibility when things go wrong.
Bang on.
Gets my vote.
PFVA wrote:The coach said, right after the game, that the plan was to tire Spain during the first half, and then go to the attack on the second one and that's why they replaced some players and intentionally change strategy. He also said that Villa's goal messed up the plan. I gather he wasn't as tired as he was expected to be.
A strategy reliant upon a single plan (and lacking a fallback plan) is fundamentally a flawed strategy. "He scored? He can't do THAT! It's not part of the plan!"
PFVA wrote:Luis Figo came out joining the group of those criticizing Cristiano stating he didn't fullfill his role as captain.
During the intermission at the first game against the Yvory Coast, Queiroz would have told Ronaldo to incentivate and push the other players to improve performance and CR would have answered that he wasn't the one who choose those players.
CR may have answered correctly, but that wasn't the question posed to him. I'd have expected the captain to rouse and incentivise players - the manager directs, the captain ensures it gets carried out.

There has been a lot of talk about just how selfish and self-centred CR is, so placing him as Captain is a real test of the many outweighing the needs of the one, and I think he failed somewhat. I don't take an interest in him so can't comment.
PFVA wrote:Eduardo's fan club is on the rise specially on the female side with tons of females waiting for him when he returned home offering to cheer him up. It seems that at least nationally Cristiano's large female fan club is giving away to Eduardo's one.
Oh, justice!

Good summary there, PFVA - nice.
Post Reply