Politics Thread!
- pogo
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 14180
- Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
- Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
- Location: County Durham
Re: Politics Thread!
I think that very unlikely. First, the Tories have given no indication they want another election. I know it has been suggested, probably by me, that it would be one way to clarify the outcome of the referendum and perhaps indefinitely postpone exit. But the Tories can do that without an election. Or they can invoke Article 50 at the earliest opportunity. Given that is what their leadership contest is shaping up to be about, they are unlikely to feel the need to go to the country on the same issue.
And even if they did decide to have an election, it‘s hard to imagine the result being much different. Labour are in a mess at the moment, about to enter a far more contentious leadership contest than the Tories. The Lib Dems are done as a national party for the immediate future. UKIP without Farage will struggle to improve on their one seat. The only party looking able to do well in England is the Tories.
And even if they did decide to have an election, it‘s hard to imagine the result being much different. Labour are in a mess at the moment, about to enter a far more contentious leadership contest than the Tories. The Lib Dems are done as a national party for the immediate future. UKIP without Farage will struggle to improve on their one seat. The only party looking able to do well in England is the Tories.
Re: Politics Thread!
But with this whole Brexit mess being Cameron's and, thus, by association, the Tories' fault, the electorate who wanted to remain in the EU - which was, after all, only just less than 50% and not insignificant - might well protest vote with other parties, even if they are electorally hopeless.
Because, well, protest voting is not really about positively voting for a party and genuinely believing that it'll ever win, but is rather negative voting - often in any old direction - just to give the incumbent a bloody nose. And with such a slender majority, every seat matters. It's about denying the Tories a majority in this view, not about getting a completely different party in power so much.
Indeed, I'm not imagining Labour having a landslide victory or the Lib Dems suddenly becoming this massive party out of nowhere or anything. It's that the balance is already so fragile that even blowing on it too hard could easily tip it and deny the Tories a majority and force them into a coalition / minority government position, which seems slightly impossible to be effective. And Brexit will, of course, certainly be a new unpredictable variable in all of this, which we really can't quantify to predict accurately.
In a sense, the Brexit vote itself shows us not to underestimate how a protest vote can radically swing things.
And as to the Tories not calling an election. Yes, there is that. But there's also the more Machiavellian calculation that they might well do it deliberately, as they actually want the horrible stalemate situation, as it becomes the excuse for why they can't implement Brexit. To purposefully make things messy, so it can be postponed for even longer. In fact, if you're right that the Tories really are the only likely choice in England then that actually supports the theory better, as they can then well afford to play such games but not worry that it can't be turned around and brought back to a Tory majority government again, while Labour remain in the wilderness. That actually makes it more plausible as a strategy, not less.
Because, well, protest voting is not really about positively voting for a party and genuinely believing that it'll ever win, but is rather negative voting - often in any old direction - just to give the incumbent a bloody nose. And with such a slender majority, every seat matters. It's about denying the Tories a majority in this view, not about getting a completely different party in power so much.
Indeed, I'm not imagining Labour having a landslide victory or the Lib Dems suddenly becoming this massive party out of nowhere or anything. It's that the balance is already so fragile that even blowing on it too hard could easily tip it and deny the Tories a majority and force them into a coalition / minority government position, which seems slightly impossible to be effective. And Brexit will, of course, certainly be a new unpredictable variable in all of this, which we really can't quantify to predict accurately.
In a sense, the Brexit vote itself shows us not to underestimate how a protest vote can radically swing things.
And as to the Tories not calling an election. Yes, there is that. But there's also the more Machiavellian calculation that they might well do it deliberately, as they actually want the horrible stalemate situation, as it becomes the excuse for why they can't implement Brexit. To purposefully make things messy, so it can be postponed for even longer. In fact, if you're right that the Tories really are the only likely choice in England then that actually supports the theory better, as they can then well afford to play such games but not worry that it can't be turned around and brought back to a Tory majority government again, while Labour remain in the wilderness. That actually makes it more plausible as a strategy, not less.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Politics Thread!
If the Tory grass roots "do a Corbyn" another GE is pretty certain IMHO
Reports today of centrists from both Labour and Conservatve parties chatting about the possibility of a breakaway.
I do think Leadsom's chances are slim though then again the rise of UKIP has been a bit of a lesson in what home county twats have an appetite for
Reports today of centrists from both Labour and Conservatve parties chatting about the possibility of a breakaway.
I do think Leadsom's chances are slim though then again the rise of UKIP has been a bit of a lesson in what home county twats have an appetite for
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Politics Thread!
I should hope so. First sensible thing to happen in a long time, if so. Yesterday another Hull CLP voted strongly in support of Corbyn, against the incumbent MP. Now Alan and Diana Johnson are in disagreement with both their leadership and constituencies. Best to go.gravy wrote:Reports today of centrists from both Labour and Conservatve parties chatting about the possibility of a breakaway.
This morning Eagle says she's launching a leadership bid to 'heal' the party. Her own CLP has also voted in confidence of Corbyn. It's getting ridiculous. I don't believe the narrative from the PLP members at all, this is now a scorched earth strategy.
They are not content with leaving the UK's left-wing party, having taken it as far right as they can. They want to destroy it and leave Labour in a Lib-Dem-like state, the assumption being that voters will follow them to the middle. It's quite an assumption.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: Politics Thread!
20 Tory MPs have threatened to leave the party if Leadsom is elected as leader.


Why are you breaking my kayak?
Re: Politics Thread!
I can well believe it. The two closest political groupings in the UK right now are the right of Labour and the left of the Tories - I said before the last election that if you simply went on the policies in the manifesto then you'd have thought the most likely coalition was a Tory - Labour one since they were frankly so similar, much more so than either of the big parties and the Greens, LDs or UKIP.gravy wrote:Reports today of centrists from both Labour and Conservatve parties chatting about the possibility of a breakaway.
And bear in mind that maybe as many as half the current MPs are realising this is a real threat to them. If your parliamentary parties are voting 80% one way and the people who choose who gets to stand to be an MP are voting 80% the other way, they surely know their days are numbered, there's going to be huge pressure to reselect and replace the MPs that aren't representing the party. If they don't think they have enough contacts to keep the post, or if they see a grassroots movement against their 'friends' who keep them in power, they're going to be running scared.
So if we're left with Leadsom + Corbyn in a couple of months time - extraordinarily likely - then frankly they'd be fools not to do it. They would only need to carry 40% of the vote from both sides to create a party much bigger than the rumps or the remaining small parties.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Politics Thread!
Ally with the Lib-Dems and call themselves the Soc-Dem Lib-Dems? There was a time the Liberals actually ran the country.Dio wrote:I can well believe it. The two closest political groupings in the UK right now are the right of Labour and the left of the Tories - I said before the last election that if you simply went on the policies in the manifesto then you'd have thought the most likely coalition was a Tory - Labour one since they were frankly so similar, much more so than either of the big parties and the Greens, LDs or UKIP.gravy wrote:Reports today of centrists from both Labour and Conservatve parties chatting about the possibility of a breakaway.
And bear in mind that maybe as many as half the current MPs are realising this is a real threat to them. If your parliamentary parties are voting 80% one way and the people who choose who gets to stand to be an MP are voting 80% the other way, they surely know their days are numbered, there's going to be huge pressure to reselect and replace the MPs that aren't representing the party. If they don't think they have enough contacts to keep the post, or if they see a grassroots movement against their 'friends' who keep them in power, they're going to be running scared.
So if we're left with Leadsom + Corbyn in a couple of months time - extraordinarily likely - then frankly they'd be fools not to do it. They would only need to carry 40% of the vote from both sides to create a party much bigger than the rumps or the remaining small parties.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Politics Thread!
The LDs are well to the left of the Blairite Labour party.
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Politics Thread!
There was a time when Liberal meant in favour of freedom. I'm not sure where the Democrats stand.Dio wrote:The LDs are well to the left of the Blairite Labour party.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Politics Thread!
there's a little orange book knocking about which would suggest otherwise. I'm unsure how many of the incumbent MPs endorse it, but 1/8th of them certainly do.Dio wrote:The LDs are well to the left of the Blairite Labour party.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard
Re: Politics Thread!
The LDs don't exist on the canonical left/right spectrum. They're all over the place in terms of economic liberalism, and social liberalism. That's not to they don't have a coherent set of principles but it's not anywhere on a line between Labour and the Tories.
The "orange book" was written by the economically liberal wing and isn't anywhere near as interesting or controversial as it used to be.
The "orange book" was written by the economically liberal wing and isn't anywhere near as interesting or controversial as it used to be.
Re: Politics Thread!
Theresa May has said something that politicians aren't normally capable of saying:
Monetary policy, in the form of super-low interest rates and QE, has helped those on the property ladder at the expense of those who can't afford their own home.
It's harder than ever for young people to buy their first house. There is a growing divide between a more prosperous older generation and a struggling younger generation. And there is a gaping chasm between London and the rest of the country.
Re: Politics Thread!
I think a fair few people have said it.
Nobody has done anything about it.
She won't either.
Nobody has done anything about it.
She won't either.
- Governmentyard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 11757
- Joined: Sun Oct 31, 2004 9:41 pm 0
- XBL Gamertag: GovernmentYard
- Yahoo Messenger: governmentyard
Re: Politics Thread!
Are you fucking kidding me, bro?snaff wrote:Theresa May has said something that politicians aren't normally capable of saying:
Monetary policy, in the form of super-low interest rates and QE, has helped those on the property ladder at the expense of those who can't afford their own home.
It's harder than ever for young people to buy their first house. There is a growing divide between a more prosperous older generation and a struggling younger generation. And there is a gaping chasm between London and the rest of the country.
XBox Gamertag: GovernmentYard
Everything else: governmentyard
Everything else: governmentyard



