A petition to change the rules, and the response is "the rules say it's not done like that".
Could only have done worse if it'd been posted on stack overflow.
24,000 people want to overturn the democratic system we’ve had for generations, what more would you expect? Essentially they want a presidential system, where you vote for a prime minister not a party, and if they quit or are forced out then an election is needed to choose another. That is truly radical and not a small change.
If there really were popular support for this then one or more of the political parties would get behind it. But none are, in part as they all benefit from the current system of being able to kick out their leader mid-term. In fact the last four leaders who started their prime ministership by winning an election (Wilson, Thatcher, Blair, Cameron) were all replaced mid-term without it triggering an election. Two Labour and two Conservatives, which perhaps explains why there is no support among the major parties for such constitutional innovation.
A petition to change the rules, and the response is "the rules say it's not done like that".
Could only have done worse if it'd been posted on stack overflow.
24,000 people want to overturn the democratic system we’ve had for generations, what more would you expect? Essentially they want a presidential system, where you vote for a prime minister not a party, and if they quit or are forced out then an election is needed to choose another. That is truly radical and not a small change.
If there really were popular support for this then one or more of the political parties would get behind it. But none are, in part as they all benefit from the current system of being able to kick out their leader mid-term. In fact the last four leaders who started their prime ministership by winning an election (Wilson, Thatcher, Blair, Cameron) were all replaced mid-term without it triggering an election. Two Labour and two Conservatives, which perhaps explains why there is no support among the major parties for such constitutional innovation.
Ted Heath started by winning an election too. There may well be others, but he's definitely in your timeframe since he came between Wilson and Thatcher.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
I was thinking of 1974, when he became PM by beating Heath, then quit and Callaghan took over. Since then, so since 1974, every government has changed their leader during their time in power. It has never triggered a general election.
It should be harder now, too, with the fixed term parliament acts. No government can simply choose to go to the country now (although in practice with the cooperation of the opposition they could make it happen).
A petition to change the rules, and the response is "the rules say it's not done like that".
Could only have done worse if it'd been posted on stack overflow.
24,000 people want to overturn the democratic system we’ve had for generations
Britain has features of democracy, but is so compromised that it more closely resembles totalitarianism.
Thus the frenzy in Westminster, Fleet Street, City of London Corporation and beyond when true democratic principle was allowed to give rise to a true man of the people - Jeremy Corbyn. The establishment is so alarmed that the two Tory parties might be challenged by rational argument that they reflexively engage in political repression.
Guardian letter ....
The leadership of Jeremy Corbyn has been subject to the most savage campaign of falsehood and misrepresentation in some of our most popular media outlets. He has, at different times, been derided, ignored, vilified and condemned. Few journalists attempted to fathom the reason for his overwhelming victory in the Labour leadership contest in 2015 and few have sought systematically and impartially to explore the policies he has promoted as leader. We do not expect journalists to give any elected leader an easy ride but Corbyn has been treated from the start as a problem to be solved rather than as a politician to be taken seriously. The reason is that he has never been part of the Westminster village or the media bubble and that he has never hidden his commitment to socialist politics. At a time when austerity, insecurity and racism remain real threats to the lives of many people in the UK, we believe that Jeremy Corbyn can help to provide a way out of the mess we are in. We condemn the unwarranted attacks on his leadership by an unelected media and call on those who want to see meaningful and progressive social change to stand behind Jeremy Corbyn.
Prof Greg Philo, Glasgow University
Prof Des Freedman, Goldsmiths, University of London
Prof Noam Chomsky, MIT
Prof Ed Herman, University of Pennsylvania
Prof Mica Nava, University of East London
Prof Robert McChesney, Southern Illinois University
Prof David Buckingham, Loughborough University
Prof Joanna Zylinska, Goldsmiths, University of London
Prof Peter Golding, Northumbria University
Prof Sue Clayton, Goldsmiths, University of London
Prof Michael Chanan, University of Roehampton
Prof Máire Messenger Davies, University of Ulster
Prof Andrew Chadwick, Royal Holloway, University of London
Prof Julian Petley, Brunel University
Prof Christian Fuchs, University of Westminster
Prof Michael Pickering, Loughborough University
Prof John Storey, University of Sunderland
Prof David Miller, University of Bath
Prof Geoff King, Brunel University
A further 100 senior professors signed that letter - which is backed by academic research into the media treatment of Corbyn.
pogo wrote:Essentially they want a presidential system, where you vote for a prime minister not a party
I think what "they" want is for the system not to simply instate another leader without public mandate.
pogo wrote:24,000 people want to overturn the democratic system we’ve had for generations, what more would you expect? Essentially they want a presidential system, where you vote for a prime minister not a party, and if they quit or are forced out then an election is needed to choose another. That is truly radical and not a small change.
Sure, but the answer you need to give is "no, that's stupid", not "we don't do it that way".
Bait-and-switch has always been fundamental to politics the world over. Nothing is going to change that.
(o)(o) wrote:Thus the frenzy in Westminster, Fleet Street, City of London Corporation and beyond when true democratic principle was allowed to give rise to a true man of the people - Jeremy Corbyn. The establishment is so alarmed that the two Tory parties might be challenged by rational argument that they reflexively engage in political repression.
FFS, drop this loopy conspiracy theory, that Corbyn is only doing badly as the establishment, including all of the media and most Labour MPs, are ganging up on him. Corbyn is doing badly as he’s a bad leader. Just watch the VICE documentary again. Or Wednesday’s PMQ when at May’s first ever PMQ he looked like the inexperienced and unprepared one, just asking a series of unconnected questions, not using his time to respond or follow up. He will I think find May a much tougher debating opponent than Cameron.
Most importantly it’s his own MPs who overwhelmingly say he is not up to the job and they want him out. They are not all deluded or part of some conspiracy. They are doing it as they know they can’t win an election, and so do what they were elected for, with Corbyn in charge. Probably even if he’s replaced Labour will find it hard to win in 2020, but they need a new leader to start the process of healing the party and devising a platform that the whole party can get behind.
(o)(o) wrote:Thus the frenzy in Westminster, Fleet Street, City of London Corporation and beyond when true democratic principle was allowed to give rise to a true man of the people - Jeremy Corbyn. The establishment is so alarmed that the two Tory parties might be challenged by rational argument that they reflexively engage in political repression.
FFS, drop this loopy conspiracy theory, that Corbyn is only doing badly as the establishment, including all of the media and most Labour MPs, are ganging up on him. Corbyn is doing badly as he’s a bad leader. Just watch the VICE documentary again. Or Wednesday’s PMQ when at May’s first ever PMQ he looked like the inexperienced and unprepared one, just asking a series of unconnected questions, not using his time to respond or follow up. He will I think find May a much tougher debating opponent than Cameron.
Most importantly it’s his own MPs who overwhelmingly say he is not up to the job and they want him out. They are not all deluded or part of some conspiracy. They are doing it as they know they can’t win an election, and so do what they were elected for, with Corbyn in charge. Probably even if he’s replaced Labour will find it hard to win in 2020, but they need a new leader to start the process of healing the party and devising a platform that the whole party can get behind.
Do you pray to Laura Kunsberg every night as you snuggle down under your Daily Mail duvet?
Maggie May's PMQs performance was horrible.
She dodged multiple questions and came out with an achingly poor joke about Corbyn that had the Tory backbenchers braying like donkeys.
She goes on about social justice and the country working for everyone - as her administration confirms it is cutting student bursaries for nurses (when we already have a massive shortage and a worrying number of senior nurses about to retire) and allowing universities to raise tuition fees above £9000 per year (meaning higher levels of debt - now being administered and collected by private companies - and fewer students from state schools able to afford university).
As Parliament goes on recess, you better hope she has some Road to Damascus style conversion and actually starts acting on the rhetoric.
It wasn’t so much that she was good, but Corbyn was bad. His first question was on the Miners Strike, ffs. A vitally important issue to him clearly but most everyone else has moved on from what happened in the 1980s, if they were even politically aware then. Certainly voters don’t care.
It was May’s first PMQs, so she can only get better. Corbyn seemingly can’t. He will find it harder too to level the charge at her that she is posh and elitist (not that attacking Cameron like that was a good idea either), as she far from it. Nor is she much like Thatcher, except in the obvious way of being a woman PM.
Not sure why so much stock is being put on this. Every PM and opposition leader has had good and bad PMQs.
May's pretty robust but it's going to be hard work for her when parliament reconvenes. I suspect she'll get less problems from Corbyn that from her own cabinet.
pogo wrote:
It wasn’t so much that she was good, but Corbyn was bad. His first question was on the Miners Strike, ffs. A vitally important issue to him clearly but most everyone else has moved on from what happened in the 1980s, if they were even politically aware then. Certainly voters don’t care.
.
The miners strike still to this day is relevant.
If it isn't, then why am I in a shit job to this day as a result of Thatcher breaking the unions?
It may not be relevant to you, it may not be in the electorate conscience but it's every bit as relevant now as it was then and thank fuck someone with a voice is sticking with it.
It's time the people weren't fooled into the political class mind set that 'dictates' there's some middle to right ideology that's the only possible workable politics there is....you can thank cunt blair for perpetuating that and you can thank Corbyn for pulling the working classes back to reality instead of having full faith in their overlords!
I'd vote Labour again under corbyn, if it wasn't for the pathetic mess that is Scottish Labour.
Merthyr Tydfil - a former mining town, once the largest in Wales and the centre of coal mining in South Wales - is, by ONS figures, the worst place in the entire UK for employment.
It's been like that since the coal mines were closed and there's simply nothing there to replace it, so its fortunes have never improved.
The Miners' Strike might have been some 30 years ago, but it all remains perfectly current in Merthyr because as there has been no recovery since then, in effect, time has stood still for those communities ever since.
You see, when you talked before, pogo, about the service industry replacing industry, you failed to take one simple thing into consideration. Namely, geography.
The point about the service industry, as you yourself indirectly noted when talking about how the EU's free movement of people is vital to a service economy, is that it's about people. Merthyr's location made perfect sense when the industry was coal. Most simply, that's where the coal was. Also, the valley's river was a "highway" for transporting the coal down to the city of Cardiff, with its docks, for transport and trade to the rest of the world.
For industrial purposes, Merthyr's location made abundant sense. How it once grew to be the largest town in Wales, as its geography made it the focal point of the coal mining industry.
But the service industry is about people. Being halfway up a valley in the middle of nowhere provides no such advantage. Indeed, it's a horrible detriment.
Who builds office tower blocks on the mountainous sides of an otherwise rural Welsh valley? Well, yeah, no-one. Because that would be very silly.
Where it was once geographically perfect for coal mining, it's perfectly imperfect for much of anything else. And, thus, nothing much of anything else has come to pass in the 30 years since. Nothing's come to replace it. Nothing likely ever will.
It must be understood that when we say that these South Wales valleys are an industrial landscape, we don't just mean that it is, as a point of fact, littered with industry, but that it also is intrinsically so. It's an industrial landscape from the perspective that that's pretty much the only thing that naturally fits in there geographically.
Merthyr was the centre of coal mining. The coal was transported down the river valley to Cardiff, the port who traded it with the world. One valley over, the port of Port Talbot taking in some of that coal for steel production at its steel works - carbon, in the form of coal, along with iron, is needed for the production of steel, in case you didn't know that - and using its own deep water harbour to trade it with the world. It was fed by Merthyr's coal.
Swansea used to have the nickname "Copperopolis". It had the largest copperworks and it was rather integral to why "Britannia ruled the waves" back in the day.
Nelson's fleet that won at Trafalgar were all copper-bottomed ships - this was Britain's "secret sauce" in that if you clad the bottom of these wooden ships with copper, they would move through the waters much faster and be much more manoeuvrable, giving the British fleets the advantage over their enemies, who didn't yet know to do this - and the "Copperopolis" of Swansea was where they did all that.
Carmarthen is a Roman town and its gold mines were the reason why the Romans bothered to push their way along the South Wales coast - building defensive forts along the way (the Welsh word "caer" means fort - hence Caerfyrddin (Carmarthen's Welsh name), Caerdydd (Cardiff's Welsh name), Caerphilly, etc. which is a neat indication of where the Romans set up their forts, just look for "caer-" in their Welsh names) to secure their route to and from the gold. Welsh gold fed the Roman Empire. But, yeah, that's also why there's pretty much fuck all gold left there now. The Romans mined it all up.
It's an industrial landscape. For heavy industry, the mountainous terrain is not a problem. It's actually the contrary. As, of course, it's geographically the source of all their resources in the first place. The forces of nature that pushed the hills and mountains up, also pushed up the natural resources nearer the surface to be mined. The valleys gouged out by the rivers that run down them were convenient "highways" for transporting resources down to the ports and harbours at the rivers' mouths.
I don't disagree with you in theory, pogo. In the sense that such industry was always intrinsically destined to die one day, anyway. Even if we really, really gave a shit about heavy industry and massively invested in it and all that jazz, it would naturally die off, because there's only so much coal and copper and gold in the ground.
(Though the story of Tower Colliery shows that it was all killed off prematurely. When Maggie shut the mines, the workers of Tower Colliery used their redundancy pay to buy the mine and they continued to work it - making a profit every single year of operation, in stark contrast to what the National Coal Board suggested was "unprofitable". But even this success story has a sad ending. Tower is now closed. But not because the National Coal Board were right - not at all, the employees profited and remained in work all along - but simply because the coal ran out. So Maggie and the Coal Board were wrong, as these guys kept going, profitably, until 2008. But it had to end eventually. There's only so much coal in the ground to be mined.)
The service industry, though, is about people and that never runs out while human beings continue to exist. People are a renewable resource.
But the grand missing bit in your and the government's calculations is that of geography. There can't be a simple transfer from heavy industry to the service sector and other industries. The geography that heavy industry loves is absolutely horribly unsuitable for pretty much everything else.
(Yes, even farming, in truth, despite being rural. The mountains and hills means that there's actually not that much arable land in Wales. There is a reason why the Welsh are associated with sheep farming. Like New Zealand - also famous for its lamb and being an answer to the pub quiz question of "which countries have more sheep than people?" - whilst its dramatic landscape is awesome as a backdrop to Lord of the Rings, you can appreciate that it's also rather useless for planting big fields of crops. The useful thing about sheep is that you can pretty much stick them anywhere. As long as there's grass, sheep are happy, just like goats, to amble about on the steepest of inclines and not care in the slightest.)
Put it this way, even if the people of Merthyr and Port Talbot will eventually find other work, they won't find it in those towns themselves. They'll have to "get on their bikes" and commute and move away. Move to the cities. The service industry is about people, so large population centres - the cities - is where that industry finds its place in the geographical landscape.
But the towns themselves are fucked. Nothing will come to replace the heavy industry, because nothing else suitability fits into the geographical landscape of where they are.
Things like the Miners' Strikes are still relevant in a community like Merthyr Tydfil and those in the North of England too, because those communities simply haven't recovered in the 30 years since, as nothing significant has come to replace any of it. Because, after all, in geographical terms, why the hell would it? This is also what, rather inevitably, faces Port Talbot, if Tata Steel does decide to pack up and leave.
Merthyr is the worst place in the whole UK for employment. The Miners' Strike remains relevant there, because nothing has happened since, so this remains the "latest news" for these communities. Even though, yeah, it's more than 30 year old news now.
There is good reason why, for some, Maggie's death was greeted as a moment of celebration. It's a horrible thing - I can't approve of that, as a human being is a human being and life is precious regardless - but I do perfectly understand where all that bad feeling comes from.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
A petition to change the rules, and the response is "the rules say it's not done like that".
Could only have done worse if it'd been posted on stack overflow.
24,000 people want to overturn the democratic system we’ve had for generations, what more would you expect? Essentially they want a presidential system, where you vote for a prime minister not a party, and if they quit or are forced out then an election is needed to choose another. That is truly radical and not a small change.
If there really were popular support for this then one or more of the political parties would get behind it. But none are, in part as they all benefit from the current system of being able to kick out their leader mid-term. In fact the last four leaders who started their prime ministership by winning an election (Wilson, Thatcher, Blair, Cameron) were all replaced mid-term without it triggering an election. Two Labour and two Conservatives, which perhaps explains why there is no support among the major parties for such constitutional innovation.
Not true.
It's only recently that fixed term has to be fulfilled, prior to this as recent as Brown a PM/Government could call a GE whenever they wanted. So that "system we've had for generations" has only existed for a brief time, since 2011, not exactly generations.