KlaxonCow wrote:Darkflame wrote:Maybe its ironic and they are really really thin?
Could be. Could be.
If so - or if it turns out to be RTD throwing a complete curveball and it has nothing to do with anyone being fat or thin in any way - then I'll gladly come back and issue RTD an apology.
Okay, I wasn't entirely wrong, as I suggested that the adipose would be "fat bastards" rather than actually literally just fat. So it wasn't ironic.
But it was a slight "curveball" from my predictions. Rather than just being fat, they actually were fat. Literally.
So, as I was only half-right, I'm half-glad to be coming back to issue a half-apology to RTD. I'm half-sorry.
In essence, I had it right that it would be about fat aliens. But, fair play, I never saw it coming that it was going to literally be fat aliens, in the sense of aliens made out of actual literal fat. So that was, indeed, a "curveball".
Although, it was ironic in another way, because the complaint I was making about RTD is that he tends to have no subtlety when writing Dr.Who and is too obvious and too literal. And the irony is that he did throw a "curveball" by being so totally and utterly literal, I didn't see that one coming. He got so "literal" and so "obvious", he actually went around full circle and came back again to being subtle once more.
Calling them "adipose" wasn't meant to be a clever subtle in-joke to show off how "clever" he was, but was slap-bang central to the plot. So I did get that bit totally wrong and, hence, that's why, RTD, you get your half-apology.
But, as I said in that earlier comment, it was a safe prediction because either he'd prove me right and I'd get "told you so" rights, or he'd prove me totally wrong, which would make for a good episode (and if the telly's good, then I don't care if I was wrong, as, you know, it's good telly - so who gives a fuck about a wrong prediction from a nobody like me on a forum on the Intracabbage?).
Either way, whatever he did, he'd keep me happy, I contended. And, sure enough, that episode did keep me happy.
I wouldn't say overjoyed, mind you.
It wasn't a work of genius (nor as good as that Torchwood finale was) - so let's not get carried away - but I watched it and was very much entertained and amused by it all.
Watched it on iPlayer just now because, like PVB, I was doing other shit and plain missed it. And I'm going to be in the shit for that, as I was supposed to be videoing it for someone else - so also a big thank you on the heads up about the repeat on BBC3, PVB, as that might just be what'll save my skin for fucking up so royally on that one. I should have put it on the timer to be sure I caught it, but I thought, as I wanted to watch it as well, I'd not bother with the timer and press record manually. And this was my fatal mistake.
Mind you, that iPlayer's pretty useful (for those who can get it and get it to work). I also watched a programme about the "Shogun" of Japan the other day, which was actually really good and very interesting. Stumbled on it while I was bored and thought I'd check out how iPlayer works. Wouldn't have watched it otherwise but I'm glad I did now.
Anyway, I'm starting to go off on one of my trademarked digressions about nothing in particular, so I'll stop now. But, well, I did say I'd be back to offer an apology to RTD if I was wrong. And, well, I wasn't entirely wrong but wasn't entirely right either. So, as i say, I guess that merits "half an apology", if I'm allowed to invent such a thing.
Edit - Ah, maybe I should have waited a bit longer before posting this. But, nah, I'm not really spoilering it with the comments above, am I? That YouTube preview already gave it away. Ah, I'm just being touchy probably. But after hitting "submit", I suddenly thought "shit, maybe I should have spoilered that". I know I really hate it when folks reveal shit before I've seen something and, well, it's still close enough to transmission that folks who're downloading it on torrents might not have seen it yet. If I have unintentionally fucked up - again, as it's not been my night at all - then you have a full apology, not just half of one, for that. Oh, shit, I'm just not operating on full power at the moment. I should probably just give up on today entirely and get some sleep or something.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes