gravy wrote:silent_unicorn wrote:Amiga is basically a sample playback 4 channel DAC. ADSR = Attack Decay Sustain Release controls for the waveforms. awell as volume (all be it universal) on the C64. Pro's and con's to both but wanted effects aswell as waveform/sample definition and channel volume.
No, the ADSR on the SID only affects the volume and is easily to emulate on an Amiga as it's a DAC with volume control. Now you're saying something totally different, you're now bemoaning that lack of a programmable synthesiser. Say the wrong thing, pretend you said something else. I'm seeing a pattern.
silent_unicorn wrote:Writing and reading memory locations via c64 basic as the only way to control the chipset functions is hardly a structured language. In machine code you do exactly the same operation, only the syntax is different. Without understanding what memory locations do or why there is no way to do sprites/sound/char maps on the c64.
Anyone who's written any significant amount of assembler will still be slapping their forehead at this statement. And again, you're commenting on something you have no direct knowledge of. Honestly, if having an credible opinion about this is important to you go and write some assembler rather than wasting everyone's time pontificating about it it on here.
silent_unicorn wrote:Re:Doom quotes can see the confusion, it does what it does very well on simple fast CPU designs with no custom assistance, the game design is definately NOT geared to slow CPU+custom 2d hardware design. PC specific because of the way Doom isn't proper 3D (as opposed to polygonal Quake) in x86 assembler etc.
Please read what other people have said. The code is about 95% machine independent C with a few line scaling routines in asm and the game exists on the Jag, a machine with a slow CPU and custom hardware. A 68k in fact.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOehRSrxexk
Fuck me even Wolfenstein is on the SNES another machine with a very slow CPU and custom hardware.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4NM01Jy8di0
All slow CPU / custom hardware couplings are not equal to all tasks, including making a version of Doom. It works well on some and shit on others but you're splitting the computing world into 2 camps: fast CPU no custom HW and slow CPU custom HW. It's idiotic.
And for the record Doom is well written. The source is readily available so if you can read and understand it you can make the call. Which you can't.
Let's just cut to the chase.....
1. Simulating ADSR using the CPU to control the independant channel controls in software is NOT hardware ADSR and yes if you call that a synthesizer then yes the 6581 is indeed a genius analogue synth way ahead of it's time. Let's take this train of thought to tha absolute extreme, the 520ST/STM/STFM therefore has hardware support for sample playback using said techniques and the Amiga 20 levels of parallax by software blitting. Seriously dude, you are in no position to challenge my comments on technical things by publicly making such a stupid comment, emulating things or manipulating things via a series of logical codes in software or a program does not make them present in hardware.
2. I have written basic assembler code, including on the c64, it's called a post graduate education. Writing the same basic thing as defining and moving a sprite across the screen in CBM basic as per the C64 implementation is almost identical to machine code, you write to memory, you do a loop and update a register or two in the loop. Simple and you are reaching here, are you seriously telling me coding Visual Basic or Turbo C on windows and translating it to x86 assembler is AS EASY AS doing it from cbm basic to cbm assembler? Get a grip seriously, had I said simon's basic or laser genius (a package you yourself reviewed in zzap and obviously knew c64 built in basic's lack of anything) I would agree it is bullshit. When you code in assembler on c64 what do you need to know? What all the memory addresses do, read and write to them accordingly and stick loops round them, suprise suprise it isn't hard to write an address after having to poke it in basic first and then doing some branches
3. Again are you seriously telling me there is NO 3D HARDWARE ASSISTANCE in the Jaguar chipset pertaining to the Z dimension? and it is limited to 2D HARDWARE ASSISTANCE ONLY as per the Amiga OCS chipset as I clearly said? Even if that was the case which it isn't the Amiga is a blitter (and display lists as per Jay Miner's Atari 400/800 design which is called the copper now) that about covers it graphically in silicon but hey it is a 1984 chipset. Jaguar is a closed system, you write code on it until it works as best it can because EVERYONE has an identical machine and it will run identically on all unlike little johnny with his PC Speaker and OAK technologies EGA equipped rubbish to mr big's VGA SB16 386+387 co-pro setup. Optimisation for the host platform ring any bells?, it's quite a nice thing to do on a closed system. And anyway Doom is on just about anything between Spectrum to PS1/Saturn. And pretty iffy too on 3DO and 32x debacle which is Jaguars nearest competition I guess, let alone the poor CD32.
4. (point not made by you) How the hell are expansion cards shoved into an 8mhz ISA 16bit bus on a 386/486 PC a chipset feature? THE ONLY PC hardware assistance gauranteed on all machines IS A BIOS

No game had specifically coded hardware assistance for blitter chips, or any SPUs or GPUs at the time of Doom, which may or may not be present on the card installed within it. It's done at the hardware level not by specific instructions within the code by a CPU addressing the BPLCON type registers directly A LA Amigas or any other non PC system. If this wasn't the case there would have to be a version for EVERY combination of graphics and sound cards possible to be purchased...hmmm. As for sound same deal, just hooks for the hardware to do it's thing not writing to the Creative xxxx sound processor down the ISA bus, I can't remember ANY PC games from mid 90s that doubled the number of hardware sound channels available in the soundcard's chipset using the CPU just like on ST and Amiga games like Super Stardust or even startrakker 8 channel mod player for OCS Amigas. Hell all those echo and reverb options on emulators using shit hot sound cards like the AWE32 are simple checks and calls to the hardware once the card's presence has been checked. Saying they are a custom chipset is like saying the Amiga's with a Picasso card shoved up there arse prove that the OCS/ECS Amiga was actually an XGA+ 32bit colour chipset

whatever man. Infact no by your definition the Amiga OCS chipset has hardware direct to disk realtime broadcast video, PC emulation, MAC emulation, genlock AND chromakeying and 16 bit direct to disk CD quality sound chipset. wow no wonder PCs were so shit in the 80s, they didn't have a chance
Optimisation made to the Wolfenstein source code is clearly documented on the ST version on the site specifically linked to by Guythpe, worth checking out seriously. Search for Doom Attack or ADoom for Amiga work also if the team's sites are still up. So yes if it's so perfect in your opinion why have people tightened it up now? Obviously my point was at the time...blah blah....in hindsight though....blah blah. But one good thing is I did find some very talented ST/Amiga coders on the net thanks to your comments. And by your argument these people must be coding gods

Want their contact details for some lessons??
Keep trying to derail the thread, I don't really care, people much more knowledgeable than you are laughing their heads off at this whole sad "flaming technical dismissal" Check out the new IP addresses linking to this thread over the last 48 hours
In fact you are coined the Yarak of yakyak at this exact moment, but like I said for all the laughs being generated at your expense I would gladly host the whole site for a year. Having a few bum chums try wading in is not helping your iffy incorrect technical comments either dude. Nice try but sadly 2/10 FAIL!!
(new glasses to go with your grey hair?

)
Now like I said I'm done with your trolling. *me waits for banning or more unicorn picture threads*
But thankyou *tears of laughter prevent me typing anymore*
<off to toast you and your bum chum's comedy gold value with friends on and off yakyak now with a couple of cold brewskies and Heroes ep2>
I feel sorry for people who are getting distracted in this thread from both an apparent maturing of coding talent as getting Unreal 3 engine up and running better than gears shows in the same timeframe, and also the possibility for atleast some of our members of getting into PS3 ownership AND Blu-Ray movie platform for significantly less.
And yes for the record in the UK we probably will get screwed IMO on price, like I said could Medhi Ali of 90s Commodore fame please leave the Sony Corp marketing dept. and go fuck himself
Let the PS3 specific discussions commence (my 3rd attempt at getting this thread back on topic!)