Yeah I take that comment back, a cohesive universe is important. The point I was badly trying to make is when adherence to a universe or story starts to have a negative impact on the game. I really don't care about it at that stage. Halo is weird for me because the more convoluted and interwoven the story has got, the worse the games seem to have become. It should just be you and your men against the alien bastards. Everything else is flim-flam, this isn't an epic sci-fi movie. Halo:CE was immense because it was a simple premise and the complexity and subtlety was drawn from the gameplay itself. The first time I played Halo when the drop-ships drone in and you start to panic, desperate to find cover, *that* is cinematic. Does anyone prefer Halo 2's or 3's single-player game to the first? In my experience very few folks do. In some ways Halo:CE is still the benchmark, it still plays better than Resistance and Metroid and a whole slew of more modern titles.The Captain wrote:Rockstar?GeeZa wrote: And who gives a shit about a cohesive universe?
The real meat of COD4 is the multiplayer, that became more obvious as time went on. I'm not gonna argue that the campaign isn't linear and that Veteran level doesn't cheat, I complained about that here too. It doesn't have that unpredictable and improvisational nature that the Halo AI has tended to deliver. There's still some opportunity in COD4 to play how you want to and you're able to make decisions. I guess all's I'm saying is that I felt that subsequent Halo games were a missed opportunity. I think Bungie could have produced the next-gen fps that seriously differentiates them from everyone else, instead I think the games haven't moved ahead and in several respects have gone backwards.I agree in some ways about the sniper level of COD4 - but it is only a masterpiece of atmosphere and setting - the gameplay itself isn't much different from the original Medal Of Honor;you can play it the same linear way every single time, and with handholding too. The same is not true of Halo 3.
Good comment on the co-op, always a tough nut to crack. I've been interested in your arguments and it's great to see someone defend a game even if we disagree. It's all cool, I'll stop this minor thread-piss now anyway.

