The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

Dio wrote:So how do you reconcile with the above with the statement that the US system is very expensive?

Privatisation will inevitably drive up costs because the incentive will be - as in the US - to deploy treatment which is unnecessary or overzealous in order to make a profit on the provision of that treatment. If the gorvernment tries to block such excess treatment, private firms will pay for patients to sue the government for the treatment - as they do in the US with uncooperative insurers, and as is already happening here with some drugs.

As with all these sorts of things, look at the incentives that the system provides. The incentive for the private firm is much less "be efficient" - any gains made there are small potatoes - than it is "treat more people" - where the potential rise in profit is unlimited.
The system is expensive. I already tried to explain why. It's nothing to do with the provision. As you note incentives are a large part of it. One aspect of that is the legal system: things like no-win no-fee (and high fees to match), outsized jury awards, sometimes ridiculously so (just last month a jury awarded $23bn to the widow of a smoker), class-action cases and the whole expense of it (again high fees, but also the long and drawn out process). This incentivises doctors to do everything they can, whether its a battery of expensive tests or many operations, so they can't be accused of overlooking something/not trying something. It's this more than anything that leads to many medically unnecessary tests and treatments.

(it also drives up costs another way: malpractice insurance is essential for many medical professionals, because even the best doctor could have something go wrong by chance and be ruined by a lawsuit. So many doctors have expensive insurance, driving up costs further)

Our legal system is nothing like that. We don't have class action cases, jury don't play such an outsized role in determining awards, and no-win no-fee is far more limited. But mostly we don't have the expectation that wrongdoing is remedied through the courts.

I've not heard of anyone suing the govt. here on patients' behalf, over drugs for example. But that's why we have NICE. With that, and with the general difficulty suing anyone here (compared to the US) it's hard to imagine anyone using the court to force a change in treatment policy.
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Dio »

NICE is effective for some things like drugs, and regulation of care by GPs is another check on the system, but the system is easily corrupted as private enterprise takes it over, simply by adding referral fees into the mix. At some point someone has to make a judgement call to say "This treatment or investigation is necessary" and the private system will result in the person making that judgement having an incentive to say yes.
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

Do you have any examples of this? The problems in the US are well known but I know of no cases of e.g. drug companies successfully suing the govt. here to overturn a judgement not to use their drug. You wrote it's happening here but it seems very unlikely, both because we have NICE to make such decisions and because we just don't resolve things like that through the courts.
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by VNVObit »

pogo wrote:
Dio wrote:So how do you reconcile with the above with the statement that the US system is very expensive?

Privatisation will inevitably drive up costs because the incentive will be - as in the US - to deploy treatment which is unnecessary or overzealous in order to make a profit on the provision of that treatment. If the gorvernment tries to block such excess treatment, private firms will pay for patients to sue the government for the treatment - as they do in the US with uncooperative insurers, and as is already happening here with some drugs.

As with all these sorts of things, look at the incentives that the system provides. The incentive for the private firm is much less "be efficient" - any gains made there are small potatoes - than it is "treat more people" - where the potential rise in profit is unlimited.
The system is expensive. I already tried to explain why. It's nothing to do with the provision. As you note incentives are a large part of it. One aspect of that is the legal system: things like no-win no-fee (and high fees to match), outsized jury awards, sometimes ridiculously so (just last month a jury awarded $23bn to the widow of a smoker), class-action cases and the whole expense of it (again high fees, but also the long and drawn out process). This incentivises doctors to do everything they can, whether its a battery of expensive tests or many operations, so they can't be accused of overlooking something/not trying something. It's this more than anything that leads to many medically unnecessary tests and treatments.

(it also drives up costs another way: malpractice insurance is essential for many medical professionals, because even the best doctor could have something go wrong by chance and be ruined by a lawsuit. So many doctors have expensive insurance, driving up costs further)

Our legal system is nothing like that. We don't have class action cases, jury don't play such an outsized role in determining awards, and no-win no-fee is far more limited. But mostly we don't have the expectation that wrongdoing is remedied through the courts.

I've not heard of anyone suing the govt. here on patients' behalf, over drugs for example. But that's why we have NICE. With that, and with the general difficulty suing anyone here (compared to the US) it's hard to imagine anyone using the court to force a change in treatment policy.
You are talking about the present in the UK and assuming that it'll remain unchanged in the brave new world of privatisation. Yet all the causes, you site, of the expensive system are a direct result of private firms identifying ways of making money from the system.

Just so you know all doctors have professional indemnity insurance and going back many years (when I did tax returns for medical professionals, amongst others) it was already a multiple of today's average earnings so I hate to think what it is now (NHS would pay the bulk of the cost).

Once new angles are created private firms will look to exploit them and invariably new legislation (primary or otherwise) tends to have unintended consequences as previous forays into privatisation have shown
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

VNVObit wrote:You are talking about the present in the UK and assuming that it'll remain unchanged in the brave new world of privatisation. Yet all the causes, you site, of the expensive system are a direct result of private firms identifying ways of making money from the system.
Privatisation is happening now and has been happening for decades. It's still only a small part of the health service here but is much larger in many other systems, not just the US. So there's no "brave new world" as privatisation enters unknown territory.

And again the problems in the US have nothing to do with the private provision there. If they one day manage to fix it with single payer they'll still almost certainly have private doctors, hospitals. I.e. they can solve their cost problems and coverage problems but still with private provision.

The legal landscape is one reason its so expensive. Perhaps the biggest is the use of insurance. You really could not devise a more expensive way. You
* Get everyone to pay individually, massively multiplying costs
* Use insurance, so every expenditure decision has to be weighed against policies, multiplying the decisions and so costs
* Also insurance is financed via the financial markets - it is a financial product - so inevitably some of it ends up on Wall St
* And once insured there's less incentive to control costs, whether extra test or non-medical ones such as hotel-like accommodation

It's also just more expensive as it's a rich country. It will probably always cost more there than the EU to get treatment.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:Privatisation is happening now and has been happening for decades. It's still only a small part of the health service here but is much larger in many other systems, not just the US. So there's no "brave new world" as privatisation enters unknown territory.
Same old guff!

Even hardcore conservatives acknowledge the exponential growth of NHS privatisation.

It's pretty difficult to deny factual evidence but pogo is doing a pretty good job of poking his own eyes out.

In the interests of full disclosure - anything to declare pogo? Any affiliation with any political parties? The tea party... muppets etc.. ?
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Dio »

pogo wrote:Do you have any examples of this? The problems in the US are well known but I know of no cases of e.g. drug companies successfully suing the govt. here to overturn a judgement not to use their drug. You wrote it's happening here but it seems very unlikely, both because we have NICE to make such decisions and because we just don't resolve things like that through the courts.
Breast cancer drug, about 2-3 years ago. There was a big stink about it when it came out the drug company were funding the legal actions.
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by VNVObit »

Privatisation may have happened but not to any great scale

pogo wrote:
VNVObit wrote:You are talking about the present in the UK and assuming that it'll remain unchanged in the brave new world of privatisation. Yet all the causes, you site, of the expensive system are a direct result of private firms identifying ways of making money from the system.
Privatisation is happening now and has been happening for decades. It's still only a small part of the health service here but is much larger in many other systems, not just the US. So there's no "brave new world" as privatisation enters unknown territory.

And again the problems in the US have nothing to do with the private provision there. If they one day manage to fix it with single payer they'll still almost certainly have private doctors, hospitals. I.e. they can solve their cost problems and coverage problems but still with private provision.

The legal landscape is one reason its so expensive. Perhaps the biggest is the use of insurance. You really could not devise a more expensive way. You
* Get everyone to pay individually, massively multiplying costs
* Use insurance, so every expenditure decision has to be weighed against policies, multiplying the decisions and so costs
* Also insurance is financed via the financial markets - it is a financial product - so inevitably some of it ends up on Wall St
* And once insured there's less incentive to control costs, whether extra test or non-medical ones such as hotel-like accommodation

It's also just more expensive as it's a rich country. It will probably always cost more there than the EU to get treatment.

I think you're the only one naive enough to think that it won't play out like that here
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

Dio wrote:Breast cancer drug, about 2-3 years ago. There was a big stink about it when it came out the drug company were funding the legal actions.
Can't recall that, and can't find anything on it. Drug name? Company? Links?

Though I'd be far less worried about someone suing NICE and losing. Given NICE's importance you'd expect their judgements to be challenged legally at some point by a firm or firms.
VNVObit wrote:think you're the only one naive enough to think that it won't play out like that here
There are a couple of hundred countries in the world. All (at least all the ones I can find info on) use more private health care than us. The US is only one country, with a badly broken system for reasons that have nothing to do with private provision, and there are no plans for us to adopt their system. So, no, it won't play out like that here.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:There are a couple of hundred countries in the world. All (at least all the ones I can find info on) use more private health care than us.
And the UK is the No.1 healthcare provider in the world.

BTW I asked you a serious question there.

Do you have any political affiliations ?
User avatar
VNVObit
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4072
Joined: Sun Jan 01, 2006 10:03 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: vnvobit
PSN: VNV_Obit
Location: London

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by VNVObit »

pogo wrote:
Dio wrote:Breast cancer drug, about 2-3 years ago. There was a big stink about it when it came out the drug company were funding the legal actions.
Can't recall that, and can't find anything on it. Drug name? Company? Links?

Though I'd be far less worried about someone suing NICE and losing. Given NICE's importance you'd expect their judgements to be challenged legally at some point by a firm or firms.
VNVObit wrote:think you're the only one naive enough to think that it won't play out like that here
There are a couple of hundred countries in the world. All (at least all the ones I can find info on) use more private health care than us. The US is only one country, with a badly broken system for reasons that have nothing to do with private provision, and there are no plans for us to adopt their system. So, no, it won't play out like that here.
And there's the naivety. There are no plans to adopt. Who said the American system was planned to be broken?

And as the recent survey pointed out there may be a couple of hundred countries that have more private health care but still the UK is considered to have the best.

I am speaking from experience of living in a mixed provision system can honestly say the NHS is a better system overall. Could it be more efficient ? yes it could (most things can) The critical point is reducing demand on the system something privatisation won't do (it'd be self defeating) and this government (and labour before them ) have shown no foresight to tackle.
"England is funny, but sometimes she scares me"
Tony Wakeford

My avatar is the cover of Tower of Babel's first single

"Sky is not roof, Earth is not bottom, the world is not yours, you are the world's" from Brown by Grotus
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

(o)(o) wrote:Do you have any political affiliations ?
Sorry, missed if you asked this earlier. No, never have had. I strongly disagree with all the parties on some things: this govt.'s immigration, housing and Europe policies are all wrong.
VNVObit wrote:And there's the naivety. There are no plans to adopt. Who said the American system was planned to be broken?
To get the US system though you don't just need private provision of NHS services. You'd need to do away with the NHS altogether: have no central purchaser and guarantor of health care. Have everyone pay for themselves, via insurance if they want (with subsidies for the old, young and poor). That's simply not going to happen here: it's part of no party's platform; even without the example of the US it's obviously a worse system.

But some people here seem to think: "oh no, privatisation ! We'll end up like America!!", which is nonsense. If we privatised all provision (there are no plans for that either though you can in theory imagine us getting there one day on the current path) we'd have a system much like Canada. Which sounds much like ours. They even have wait times:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_ca ... Criticisms

Hardly the nightmare scenario some seem to imagine and we're a long way from that anyway.
User avatar
Barney
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2131
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 7:59 pm 0
Location: UK, Broughton, Brigg

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by Barney »

VNVObit wrote: Just so you know all doctors have professional indemnity insurance and going back many years (when I did tax returns for medical professionals, amongst others) it was already a multiple of today's average earnings so I hate to think what it is now (NHS would pay the bulk of the cost).
All medical professionals are required to be registered by a governing body, and for me that means that I'm insured up to 3.5 Million pounds in damages. That won't stop me being struck off in a malpractice hearing, but it does meant that any damages are covered.
"Oh dear lord, I slightly soiled myself. Oxfam won’t be pleased."
User avatar
pogo
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14180
Joined: Tue Sep 10, 2002 8:28 pm 0
Yahoo Messenger: BrassSparrow
Location: County Durham

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by pogo »

The link I posted reminds me: there's one way the US system is demonstrably better: lack of wait times. If you're paying for your health care directly or via insurance you're not going to put up with some bureaucrat telling you when you can have your checkup/operation.

But wait times save money, lots of it. A department being able to plan and organise resources weeks and months in advance is much more efficient than having resources online all the time for whenever patients ask for it. Plus if you ask people to wait for weeks and months they are more likely to not bother. They may get better. They may realise they don't actually need that checkup/procedure and not book it. They may decide not to wait and pay to go private immediately.

The latter might seem a flaw but you can't stop rich people paying for private healthcare if they want, and it does relieve pressure on the public system.
User avatar
(o)(o)
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6885
Joined: Tue Jan 19, 2010 2:21 am 0

Re: The Wonderful NHS in the UK

Post by (o)(o) »

pogo wrote:The link I posted reminds me: there's one way the US system is demonstrably better: lack of wait times.
Agreed - if you know you can't afford treatment you can start stitching your own wounds immediately.
pogo wrote:If you're paying for your health care directly or via insurance you're not going to put up with some bureaucrat telling you when you can have your checkup/operation.
Yes - how dare they have any say in how long you have to wait! I want the entire resources of the health system at my disposal NOW.
pogo wrote:But wait times save money, lots of it... if you ask people to wait for weeks and months they are more likely to not bother.
Demoralizing people so they give up to save money - happy days! :D
Post Reply