The system is expensive. I already tried to explain why. It's nothing to do with the provision. As you note incentives are a large part of it. One aspect of that is the legal system: things like no-win no-fee (and high fees to match), outsized jury awards, sometimes ridiculously so (just last month a jury awarded $23bn to the widow of a smoker), class-action cases and the whole expense of it (again high fees, but also the long and drawn out process). This incentivises doctors to do everything they can, whether its a battery of expensive tests or many operations, so they can't be accused of overlooking something/not trying something. It's this more than anything that leads to many medically unnecessary tests and treatments.Dio wrote:So how do you reconcile with the above with the statement that the US system is very expensive?
Privatisation will inevitably drive up costs because the incentive will be - as in the US - to deploy treatment which is unnecessary or overzealous in order to make a profit on the provision of that treatment. If the gorvernment tries to block such excess treatment, private firms will pay for patients to sue the government for the treatment - as they do in the US with uncooperative insurers, and as is already happening here with some drugs.
As with all these sorts of things, look at the incentives that the system provides. The incentive for the private firm is much less "be efficient" - any gains made there are small potatoes - than it is "treat more people" - where the potential rise in profit is unlimited.
(it also drives up costs another way: malpractice insurance is essential for many medical professionals, because even the best doctor could have something go wrong by chance and be ruined by a lawsuit. So many doctors have expensive insurance, driving up costs further)
Our legal system is nothing like that. We don't have class action cases, jury don't play such an outsized role in determining awards, and no-win no-fee is far more limited. But mostly we don't have the expectation that wrongdoing is remedied through the courts.
I've not heard of anyone suing the govt. here on patients' behalf, over drugs for example. But that's why we have NICE. With that, and with the general difficulty suing anyone here (compared to the US) it's hard to imagine anyone using the court to force a change in treatment policy.



