Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Support Forum: http://minotaurproject.co.uk/phpBB3/viewforum.php?f=22
Post Reply
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Dio »

Jeff - I'm not arguing that they haven't claimed some right old bollocks in there. Lawyers do that. They are bloody shocking at proof-reading on any level, from linguistically through cognitively, in any way other than that obscure legal language that only they understand. I'm pretty sure that's why so many contracts cases go wrong because the contracts are unenforceable; lawyers are rubbish at logic.

But the subleties of game design isn't what this is about. I'm sure that to you as the creator those look like huge significant things. But outside that sphere it really isn't. It is undoubtedly an extraordinarily similar product to T2K. Indeed, that's one of the reasons we like it.

Do I think you have a case? Yes. Do I think you have a strong case that you could win in court? I think there are aspects which are problematic, like the claw and the enemies, and your own description of it as a spiritual successor to T2K in publicity which I think is likely to label it as a derivative work (although I'm not a lawyer). You might win, you might lose on small points, but it's definitely not obvious it's going to go your way. Even if it did, you're unlikely to prove frivolous litigation, so you'll almost certainly lose out financially so sadly losses are better cut here in my opinion.

When it came to that bloody Sony version you had a really rather fabulous case there, but this is one of those things where the big guy wins by default because you need £100k just to mount the case in the first place.

Contrast Space Giraffe: "Space Giraffe is NOT TEMPEST". Everything except the most generic aspects of the view is original, it's very strongly defendable as same-genre rather than a derivative.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by gilesgoat »

There are various points here .. all a bit "depends how you see them".

However must be said that BEFORE to even start all this TxK project there has been quite a few talks about "what we should do, how we should do it" specifically "not to enter into problems".

Seems that "all that been not enough" unfortunately :?

Now .. this is a bit of "a strange case" strange case because there are so many things in the middle ... to begin with "Would we have been happy if we would have done this thing together with A.. in the first place or have them involved in some way ?" .. yes .. we would have been .. but we never managed to .. I think there were already "serious communication problems" since ever.

The other point of course is "Jeff loves this game" and Space Giraffe already been done for the 360 "and nobody said ANYTHING that time" .. so why this time is "so different" ?

Not to mention the "countless so similar things out there" .. and nobody ever said anything to them, I mean look around .. there isn't only one.

I mean "you should go after ALL OF THEM then" not just "at us" .. if you are "consistent".

Now it's also a fact that seems to me that 'A..' today does slot machines and all other stuff .. 'not even close' to this .. have we fucked up the "T... slot machine" ?

On certain things they said, in my pure point of view "I have absolutely no doubt about where we stand".

In others .. "I can see why they are saying so" but I also still know where we should stand.

My bottom line is that if instead of sending lawyers "barking like mad about heads that should fall and things that should be set on fire" there would have been "a more human communication" I think something should have been well sorted out by now.

But we haven't had, from our point of view, this sort of communication yet .. still looking forward to it.

Did we try to have that sort of communication, YES WE DID .. let's say "we have communication problems here".
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by merman »

It's a sad, sad situation...

If "Atari" was genuinely doing something with its old IP, then you could understand the attitude. But dating back to Pong and Centipede on the PS1, it's been churning out rubbish.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
buddh4sack
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 189
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2008 6:12 pm 0

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by buddh4sack »

so disappointed that Atari is now just an intellectual property enforcement company. Horrible.
^^^ says it all.

What makes me saddest is all the effort you guys put into developing something awesome, and now a bunch of lawyers are going to steal it all. If there's anything at all I can do (contribute to kickstarter legal fund, write letters, raise awareness, etc. ), please let me know.


edit: Atari has forums. Think I'll go let them know how I feel. http://forums.atari.com/
Last edited by buddh4sack on Thu Mar 19, 2015 5:41 pm 0, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Zeether
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 31
Joined: Sun Sep 27, 2009 2:51 am 0

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Zeether »

"Atari" made a statement on social media and as you'd expect it's regurgitating the same bullshit PR statement from the news posts.
User avatar
The Caffeine Kid
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5691
Joined: Mon Mar 01, 2004 9:24 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: TheCaffeineKid
PSN: caffeinekid
Yahoo Messenger: caffeinekid
Location: Wakefield
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by The Caffeine Kid »

Life... Don't talk to me about life...

http://www.tcksoft.co.uk
http://www.retroremakes.com
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by KlaxonCow »

Have you considered talking to the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) about this, Yak?

They're already fighting a battle against software patents and such. This is not quite that exactly, but it's not too dissimilar nor a million miles away that they might be interested in hearing about how an "undead" purchased brand name, who actually had zero to do with creating the original title, is now trying to effectively "IP troll" the developer who actually single-handedly created the original work in the first place.

The principles of "free speech" and "digital innovation" do seem to need some defending in this case and that's what these folks are all about.

They know the law. They can at least, I'm sure, discuss the matter with you to let you know the legal position (or let you know who you ought to actually be talking to).
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
Whiteball
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1812
Joined: Sat Nov 24, 2007 12:39 pm 0
Location: At the computer

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Whiteball »

Shit, this is bad :cry:

Reminds me of a few years ago when First Star Software tried handing out C&D notices to all the Boulderdash clones across the web as they where trying to cash in on the (then) new mobile market with the Boulderdash name. All they succeeded in doing was pissing everyone off, alienating possible future customers. Worst was, any products they did release where steaming piles far worse than anyone other peoples efforts had ever been.

Hope you can get something sorted somehow guys. You certainly deserve much better for all your time and efforts. Without you there wouldn't even be any memory of Tempest as it would have faded away long ago. If anything you should be rewarded for keeping it relevant.

As hard as this must be, try to stay positive and hopeful.
Soluzar
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 66
Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 4:23 pm 0

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Soluzar »

Gutted. I understand that Llamasoft can't afford a big legal battle, and as such this thing is over and done with. That is a shame though, because I'm not convinced Atari have actually got a solid case based on the merits. Since they're an American company, I'll quote American law, here.

"Once a game has been made public, nothing in the copyright law prevents others from developing another game based on similar principles."

http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl108.html

That leaves Atari with mainly the visual elements, and I'm not convinced that anything there is really enough to base a case on. Tempest is not, and never has been, a game with unique characters or visual motifs. It's an abstract game, one which looks very good of course but it does so by using basic geometric elements combined in an interesting way. You can't claim to own wireframe shapes, Atari. As for the claim that you copied the terminology of the original game, any suggestion that Atari own things like "Particle Laser" or "Collect Powerups" is beneath contempt.

I'm very sad that we won't be seeing future version of TxK. I think I'll do my best to avoid any new Atari products in the future - though I am not entirely sure what they make. There was a time that they were a games publisher. Now I'm not even sure if they are healthy enough to give me something to boycott. Maybe I can find out who owns them and deny my custom to other products under the same ownership.

I feel bad for Yak and Giles that they spent so much time working on new versions only to be denied any chance of release. Hope you can pick yourselves up and find a new project.
User avatar
Chontler
Baaaaa!
Baaaaa!
Posts: 1540
Joined: Mon Mar 07, 2011 2:21 pm 0
Location: Conwy

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Chontler »

Hang on...you didn't accidentally hand over Space Giraffe to Microsoft, did you?
User avatar
tenshi_alpha
Baaa!
Baaa!
Posts: 192
Joined: Fri Oct 17, 2014 6:00 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: tenshi alpha
PSN: tenshi_alpha
Location: Sheffield

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by tenshi_alpha »

Just read about this (through MCV http://www.mcvuk.com/news/read/atari-su ... st/0146890 )

(I noticed the site was down yesterday, I just figured Giles had finally got through to BT...!)

I am devastated. TxK is an awesome game, and the only game I actively wanted to play in VR (thanks to trying it @ play expo).

Like the EFF, there's http://www.newmediarights.org/ who are a donation-funded organisation that take on legal cases like this for devs (and other digital law things), but in the US only; I'm googling to see if there's anything like it in the UK. EDIT: I think maybe the EFF are your best bet after all.... https://www.eff.org/pages/legal-assistance

If there's anything we can do to help, let us know.

Even if it's "help us fund our next non-TxK project". Or "help cheer us up".
Soluzar
Baa!
Baa!
Posts: 66
Joined: Wed Mar 27, 2013 4:23 pm 0

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Soluzar »

tenshi_alpha wrote:Even if it's "help us fund our next non-TxK project". Or "help cheer us up".
I'm sure there are more than a few of us who'd love to chip in a bit for the next project. Whatever it may be.

I don't know if Llamasoft have any interest in running a Kickstarter...
User avatar
Markie
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8004
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 7:30 pm 0
Location: OX ford
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Markie »

Can we at the very least bombard them with ugly emails? Childish I know but I'm at my wits end!
User avatar
Yak
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 20266
Joined: Wed Apr 17, 2002 10:22 am 0
Location: Wales
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Yak »

If they just leave us alone in peace and walk away then I'll be happy to just forget about the whole thing and move on to the next project.

If they start again with the lawyer shit despite everything then who knows what we'll have to do. As I have pointed out elsewhere none of the income from TxK is left, the game is end of cycle on Vita without any significant income per month at this point, so there is nothing for them to gain by litigation; we're empty, and by denying us the ports we're far more damaged by this than they are claiming to be.
Justified and Ancient.
User avatar
Baggypants
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 5328
Joined: Sun Mar 19, 2006 12:54 pm 0
Location: Salford(UK);
Contact:

Re: Regarding the TxK persecution: a brief summary

Post by Baggypants »

Markie wrote:Can we at the very least bombard them with ugly emails? Childish I know but I'm at my wits end!
Where's Anonymous when you need them :twisted:
"The eggs, get them!"
Post Reply